The blaze occurred just past midnight in Arpora in North Goa, a party hub.

Sultana says Labour party has ‘left the scene’ as she says she ‘gets on really well’ with Greens’ Polanski

Rounding up his interview, Trevor Phillips asked Helen Whately about the Guardian’s investigation into Nigel Farage’s alleged racist and antisemitic behaviour as a teenager towards fellow Dulwich college pupils. She suggested that the Reform leader appears not to be giving “straight answers” when asked about his past behaviour, and ruled out any pact with Farage’s party at the next general election.

“He needs to give people a straight answer,” Whately said.

The number one reason why people, young people, are becoming Neet – not in employment, education or training – is because they’re moving on to sickness benefits.

Yet we just saw a few months ago where Labour was attempting to make some reforms to this problem (people going on to sickness benefits). They u-turned, they abandoned their reforms.

About 350,000 new places to be offered to ‘neets’ with ‘sanctions’ levied for those who do not engage, says DWP

Young unemployed people will be offered training or job opportunities in construction, care and hospitality as part of a UK government scheme, but could have their benefits cut if they do not take up offers.

Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, announced on Sunday that 350,000 new training or workplace opportunities would be offered to young people on universal credit, but added there would be “sanctions” for claimants who did not engage.

Today America's college professors "struggle to accommodate the many students with an official disability designation," reports the Atlantic, "which may entitle them to extra time, a distraction-free environment, or the use of otherwise-prohibited technology." Their staff writer argues these accommodations "have become another way for the most privileged students to press their advantage." [Over the past decade and a half] the share of students at selective universities who qualify for accommodations — often, extra time on tests — has grown at a breathtaking pace. At the University of Chicago, the number has more than tripled over the past eight years; at UC Berkeley, it has nearly quintupled over the past 15 years. The increase is driven by more young people getting diagnosed with conditions such as ADHD, anxiety, and depression, and by universities making the process of getting accommodations easier. The change has occurred disproportionately at the most prestigious and expensive institutions. At Brown and Harvard, more than 20 percent of undergraduates are registered as disabled. At Amherst, that figure is 34 percent. Not all of those students receive accommodations, but researchers told me that most do. The schools that enroll the most academically successful students, in other words, also have the largest share of students with a disability that could prevent them from succeeding academically. "You hear 'students with disabilities' and it's not kids in wheelchairs," one professor at a selective university, who requested anonymity because he doesn't have tenure, told me. "It's just not. It's rich kids getting extra time on tests...." Recently, mental-health issues have joined ADHD as a primary driver of the accommodations boom. Over the past decade, the number of young people diagnosed with depression or anxiety has exploded. L. Scott Lissner, the ADA coordinator at Ohio State University, told me that 36 percent of the students registered with OSU's disability office have accommodations for mental-health issues, making them the largest group of students his office serves. Many receive testing accommodations, extensions on take-home assignments, or permission to miss class. Students at Carnegie Mellon University whose severe anxiety makes concentration difficult might get extra time on tests or permission to record class sessions, Catherine Samuel, the school's director of disability resources, told me. Students with social-anxiety disorder can get a note so the professor doesn't call on them without warning... Some students get approved for housing accommodations, including single rooms and emotional-support animals. Other accommodations risk putting the needs of one student over the experience of their peers. One administrator told me that a student at a public college in California had permission to bring their mother to class. This became a problem, because the mom turned out to be an enthusiastic class participant. Professors told me that the most common — and most contentious — accommodation is the granting of extra time on exams... Several of the college students I spoke with for this story said they knew someone who had obtained a dubious diagnosis... The surge itself is undeniable. Soon, some schools may have more students receiving accommodations than not, a scenario that would have seemed absurd just a decade ago. Already, at one law school, 45 percent of students receive academic accommodations. Paul Graham Fisher, a Stanford professor who served as co-chair of the university's disability task force, told me, "I have had conversations with people in the Stanford administration. They've talked about at what point can we say no? What if it hits 50 or 60 percent? At what point do you just say 'We can't do this'?" This year, 38 percent of Stanford undergraduates are registered as having a disability; in the fall quarter, 24 percent of undergraduates were receiving academic or housing accommodations.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Nearly three decades after 15-year-old Danielle Houchins was found dead, authorities say DNA finally led them to her killer.

Danni Houchins was found dead in a swamp in Montana. Decades later, a friend of Danni's sister realized she'd been alone with Danni's killer in the wilderness.

For years, the death of 15-year-old Danielle "Danni" Houchins had been shrouded in mystery. Montana investigators initially said it could have been a tragic accident, but her family always suspected something more sinister.

With her posts and pleas on TikTok, Molly Bish's sister Jennifer hopes she will generate new tips that will finally solve her sister's Massachusetts murder case and put an end to a painful decades-old mystery.

Actor speaks out over controversy around American Eagle advert in the summer that critics say flirted with eugenics

The actor Sydney Sweeney has said she should have addressed the controversy surrounding her American Eagle jeans advert, which was accused by critics of flirting with eugenics, saying not doing so “widened the divide” between people.

Sweeney, who made her name in HBO’s Euphoria and has since become a leading Hollywood star, told People magazine she regretted staying silent during the row, in which Donald Trump at one point intervened.

PM gives clearest indication yet of comeback, calling former deputy ‘the best social mobility story’ the country has seen

• UK politics live – latest updates

Keir Starmer has predicted that Angela Rayner will return to the cabinet, calling his former deputy, who resigned in September after underpaying stamp duty on a property purchase, “hugely talented”.

In an interview with the Observer, the prime minister described Rayner, who left school aged 16 without any qualifications, as “the best social mobility story this country has ever seen”.

The movement’s success was never a given. It took much longer and required repeated action and tremendous sacrifice, without any certainty it would work

The Montgomery bus boycott, which began 70 years ago on 5 December 1955, is now understood as one of the most successful American social movements. And yet, much of how it is remembered is romanticized, inaccurate and even dangerous – distorting how we imagine social change happens.

In the fable, Rosa Parks refuses to give up her seat, Black Montgomery residents rise up, a young Martin Luther King Jr is introduced to the world, and injustice is vanquished. The right action is all it takes – furthering a mythology that, without deep preparation or sacrifice, Americans can make great change with a single act. Today, in the face of rising injustice, many criticize young activists for being too disruptive, too disorganized, too impractical. But, in fact, the Montgomery movement began much earlier and took much longer than we imagine and entailed tremendous sacrifice. It required hard choice after hard choice without evidence these actions would matter, and was considered too disruptive by many at the time – all of which gives us important lessons for how to challenge injustice today.

Jeanne Theoharis is a distinguished professor of political science at Brooklyn College and the author of King of the North: Martin Luther King Jr’s Life of Struggle Outside the South and The Rebellious Life of Mrs Rosa Parks.

Heather Jones, now 33, went public with allegations after Robert Sullivan continued to work with children

The woman who publicly alleged that she was 17 when a longtime Roman Catholic priest in Alabama successfully offered her financial support in exchange for sex and other forms of private companionship – recently prompting him to resign from the clergy – says “there is no real winner in this situation”.

In her first remarks since Robert “Bob” Sullivan’s self-imposed removal from the priesthood was announced by his church superiors, Heather Jones wrote in a statement that the only thing she gained was “truth finally coming to light after years of gaslighting myself into thinking it wasn’t a big deal”.

National guard shooting prompts extraordinary outburst and targeting of people from startling range of countries

When the history of Donald Trump’s second presidency is written, 26 November 2025 may well go down as a particular landmark.

On the eve of Thanksgiving, a lone gunman shot two West Virginia national guards, Sarah Beckstrom, and Andrew Wolfe, as they were on patrol outside Washington DC’s Farragut West metro station, a short walk from the White House – and thereby opened the floodgates to a wave of racist and anti-immigrant invective that seemed extreme even for Trump.

Get yourself a massage gun to fit to your budget with help from this list of the top options tested by CNET experts.

I didn't expect Apple's best phone to struggle so much against the Oppo Find X9 Pro.

Google's new AI image model erases what's left of the line between reality and AI. It's unnervingly excellent at its job.

President Trump's efforts to reshape the executive branch and flex his presidential power are set to be tested at the Supreme Court on Monday.

Rheinmettal shares have nearly tripled since President Donald Trump’s military spending demands, making CEO Armin Papperger the face of Europe’s rearmament.

Kishwer Falkner says Reform leader should apologise to people who say he targeted them at school, even if he rejects being deliberately racist

Nigel Farage should offer an unreserved apology to people who allege he targeted them with racist or antisemitic behaviour while at school, the outgoing head of the government’s equalities watchdog has said.

Kishwer Falkner, a crossbench peer who has just completed five years as chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission, said that even if the Reform UK leader rejected the allegation that he had been deliberately racist, he could nonetheless apologise to people who said they had been deeply hurt by his actions.

A soaring stock market rewards the already well-off but Trump’s handling of the economy has caused his approval ratings to plunge

Entering Printemps in downtown New York City feels like an escape. A slight smell of musk hangs in the air as shoppers weave carefully around racks of coats and shelves of handbags and shoes. For the holidays, the store set up a small ice rink on its second floor where skaters perform on weekends.

The French luxury retail emporium opened its first New York outlet earlier this year and has said it wants shoppers to feel so comfortable that it feels like their own chic “French apartment”. The store has a bar upstairs, along with a roving champagne cart, and encourages shoppers to sip on their drinks while they browse. Plush carpeting in the dressing room, full of orange and reds, is reminiscent of a Wes Anderson movie set.

In February 2024, without warning, YouTube deleted the account of independent British journalist Robert Inlakesh.

His YouTube page featured dozens of videos, including numerous livestreams documenting Israel’s military occupation of the West Bank. In a decade covering Palestine and Israel, he had captured video of Israeli authorities demolishing Palestinian homes, police harassing Palestinian drivers, and Israeli soldiers shooting at Palestinian civilians and journalists during protests in front of illegal Israeli settlements. In an instant, all of that footage was gone.

In July, YouTube deleted Inlakesh’s private backup account. And in August, Google, YouTube’s parent company, deleted his Google account, including his Gmail and his archive of documents and writings.

The tech giant initially claimed Inlakesh’s account violated YouTube’s community guidelines. Months later, the company justified his account termination by alleging his page contained spam or scam content.

However, when The Intercept inquired further about Inlakesh’s case, nearly two years after his account was deleted, YouTube provided a separate and wholly different explanation for the termination: a connection to an Iranian influence campaign.

YouTube declined to provide evidence to support this claim, stating that the company doesn’t discuss how it detects influence operations. Inlakesh remains unable to make new Google accounts, preventing him from sharing his video journalism on the largest English language video platform.

Inlakesh, now a freelance journalist, acknowledged that from 2019 to 2021 he worked from the London office of the Iranian state-owned media organization Press TV, which is under U.S. sanctions. Even so, Inlakesh said that should not have led to the erasure of his entire YouTube account, the vast majority of which was his own independent content that was posted before or after his time at Press TV.

A public Google document from the month Inlakesh’s account was deleted notes that the company had recently closed more than 30 accounts it alleged were linked to Iran that had posted content critical of Israel and its war on Gaza. The company did not respond when asked specifically if Inlakesh’s account was among those mentioned in the document.

Inlakesh said he felt like he was targeted not due to his former employer but because of his journalism about Palestine, especially amid the increasingly common trend of pro-Israeli censorship among Big Tech companies.

“What are the implications of this, not just for me, but for other journalists?” Inlakesh told The Intercept. “To do this and not to provide me with any information — you’re basically saying I’m a foreign agent of Iran for working with an outlet; that’s the implication. You have to provide some evidence for that. Where’s your documentation?”

Misdirection and Lack of Answers

Over the past couple years, YouTube and Google’s explanations given for the terminations of Inlakesh’s accounts have been inconsistent and vague.

YouTube first accused Inlakesh of “severe or repeated violations of our Community Guidelines.” When a Google employee, Marc Cohen, noticed Inlakesh’s public outcry about his account termination in February 2024, he decided to get involved. Cohen filed a support ticket on Google’s internal issue tracker system, “the Buganizer,” asking why a journalist’s account was deleted. Failing to get an answer internally, Cohen went public with his questions that March. After drawing the attention of the YouTube team on Twitter, he said he eventually received an internal response from Google which claimed that Inlakesh’s account had been terminated owing to “scam, deceptive or spam content.”

Cohen, who resigned from Google later that year over its support of the Israeli government’s genocide in Gaza, said had he not gotten involved, Inlakesh would have been left with even less information.

“They get away with that because they’re Google,” Cohen said. “What are you going to do? Go hire a lawyer and sue Google? You have no choice.”

When Inlakesh’s Gmail account was deleted this year, Google said his account had been “used to impersonate someone or misrepresent yourself,” which Google said is a violation of its policies. Inlakesh appealed three times but was given no response.

Only after The Intercept’s inquiry into Inlakesh’s case did Google shift its response to alleged Iranian influence.

“This creator’s channel was terminated in February 2024 as part of our ongoing investigations into coordinated influence operations backed by the Iranian state,” a YouTube spokesperson told The Intercept. The termination of his channel meant all other accounts associated with Inlakesh, including his backup account, were also deleted, YouTube said.

When The Intercept asked YouTube to elaborate on the reason behind the account deletions, such as which specific content may have flagged the account as being linked to an Iranian state influence operation, a YouTube spokesperson replied that YouTube doesn’t “disclose specifics of how we detect coordinated influence operations,” and instead referred The Intercept to Google’s Threat Analysis Group’s quarterly bulletins. TAG is a team within Google that describes itself as working “to counter government-backed hacking and attacks against Google and our users.”

Google’s Threat Analysis Group’s bulletin from when Inlakesh’s account was first terminated states that in February 2024, a total of 37 YouTube channels were deleted as a result of an “investigation into coordinated influence operations linked to Iran.” Four of these accounts, the document notes, were sharing content which “was critical of the Israeli government and its actions in the ongoing Israel-Gaza war” and had “shared content depicting alleged cyber attacks targeting Israeli organizations.” Google said in the document that the other 33 terminated YouTube channels had shown content “supportive of Iran, Yemen, and Palestine and critical of the US and Israel.”

A Pattern of Censorship

Google has a long-standing and well-documented practice of censoring Palestinian content or content critical of the Israeli government, in addition to evidence of human rights abuses in other conflicts. Such censorship has only exacerbated during Israel’s genocidal war on Gaza,

The company deploys various methods to censor content, such as teams of experts who manually review content, automated systems that flag content, reviews of U.S. sanction and foreign terror organization lists, as well as takedown requests from governments.

For the past decade, Israel’s Cyber Unit has openly run operations to convince companies to delete Palestine-related content from platforms such as YouTube.

Related

Israeli Group Claims It’s Working With Big Tech Insiders to Censor “Inflammatory” Wartime Content

Among U.S. allies, Israel had the highest percentage of requests resulting in takedowns on Google platforms, with a nearly 90 percent takedown rate, according to Google’s data since 2011. This rate outpaces countries like France, Germany, the United Kingdom, and Google’s home country, the United States. Absent from Google’s public reports, however, are takedown requests made by individual users, a route often weaponized by the Israeli cyber unit and internally by pro-Israel employees.

The scale of content deleted specifically due to U.S. sanctions is also difficult to quantify since such decisions happen without transparency. A recent investigation by The Intercept revealed that YouTube quietly deleted the accounts of three prominent Palestinian human rights organizations due to the Trump administration’s sanctions against the groups for assisting the International Criminal Court’s war crimes case against Israeli officials. The terminated pages accounted for at least 700 videos erased, many of which spotlighted alleged human rights abuses by the Israeli government.

Dia Kayyali, a technology and human rights consultant, said that in the past several years, as Big Tech platforms have relied more on automated systems that are fed U.S. sanction and terror lists, rights groups have seen an increase in the number of journalists within the Middle East and North Africa region who have had their content related to Palestine removed from YouTube, even when the content they post does not violate the company’s policies. The same could have happened with Inlakesh’s account, Kayyali said.

“And that’s part of the problem with automation — because it just does a really bad job of parsing content — content that could be graphic, anything that has any reference to Hamas,” Kayyali said. Hamas is included within the U.S. foreign terror organization list and Iran remains one of the most sanctioned countries by the U.S. government.

Google and other Big Tech platforms rely heavily on U.S. sanction lists in part to avoid potential liability from the State Department. But such caution is not always warranted, said Mohsen Farshneshani, principal attorney at the Washington, D.C.-based Sanctions Law Center.

Related

YouTube Quietly Erased More Than 700 Videos Documenting Israeli Human Rights Violations

Multinational corporations like Google tend to lean toward “overcompliance” with sanction regulations, often deleting content even when it legally is not required to do so, harming journalists and human rights groups, said Farshneshani.

Under U.S. law, in the Berman Amendment to the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, informational materials — in this case, reporting and journalism — are exempt from being subject to sanctions.

Such a carveout should have protected Inlakesh’s page from being deleted, Farshneshani said. Google likely could have taken down specific videos that raised concern, or demonetized specific videos or the entire account, he said. (Inlakesh said that years before terminating his videos and account, YouTube had demonetized some of his content depicting Israeli military violence.)

“Deleting an entire account is far from what the statutes or the regulations ask of U.S. entities,” Farshneshani said. “The exemption is meant for situations like this. And if these companies are to uphold their part of the bargain as brokers of information for the greater global community, they would do the extra leg work to make sure the stuff stays up.”

State-Sponsored Media

While YouTube and Google have not stated whether Inlakesh’s history with Press TV played a factor in the deletion, the Iranian state-funded outlet has long been under Google’s scrutiny. In 2013, Google temporarily deleted Press TV’s YouTube account before permanently deleting the channel in 2019 along with its Gmail account amid the first Trump administration’s sanctions campaign against Iran. The Biden administration in 2021 seized and censored dozens of websites tied to Iran, and in 2023 placed sanctions on Press TV due to Iran’s violent crackdown on anti-government protesters after the in-custody death of Mahsa Amini.

Press TV also has been accused by rights groups and journalists for filming and airing propaganda videos in which individuals detained by Iran are coerced to “confess” to alleged crimes in recorded interviews, as a part of the government’s attempts to justify their imprisonment or execution.

Press TV did not respond to The Intercept’s request for comment.

Out of the many videos on his YouTube account, Inlakesh recalled only two being associated with his work for Press TV: a documentary critical of the 2020 Trump deal on Israel–Palestine and a short clip about Republicans’ Islamophobic attacks on Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., in 2019. The rest either predate or postdate his stint at Press TV.

Press TV’s U.K. YouTube channel at times appears listed as an “associated channel” in archival versions of Inlakesh’s personal YouTube page. A YouTube spokesperson stated that YouTube uses “various signals to determine the relationship between channels linked by ownership for enforcement purposes,” but did not clarify what the specific signals were.

Inlakesh maintained that he had editorial independence while at Press TV and was never directed to post to his personal YouTube page.

Jillian York, the director for international freedom of expression at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, said she understood Google’s need to moderate content, but questioned why it deleted Inlakesh’s account rather than using its policy of labeling state-sponsored content, a system that itself has been plagued with problems. “More labels, more warnings, less censorship,” York said.

“The political climate around Palestine has made it such that a lot of the Silicon Valley-based social media platforms don’t seem particularly willing to ensure that Palestinian content can stay up,” she said.

Killing the Narrative

Inlakesh said he lost several documentaries about Israel and Palestine that were hosted exclusively on YouTube. However, what he lamented most was the loss of footage of his independent coverage from the West Bank, including livestreams that document alleged Israeli military abuses and were not backed up elsewhere.

One such video, he said, was a livestream from a protest at the major Israeli settlement of Beit El on February 11, 2020, against President Donald Trump’s lopsided annexation plan for Israel and Palestine.

Through the haze of tear gas, Inlakesh filmed Israeli soldiers camped out at a nearby hill, aiming their guns at the crowd of mostly children throwing rocks.

“And then you see the children drop,” Inlakesh recalled, followed by the bang of a gunshot. Paramedics rushed over to retrieve the children as Inlakesh followed behind. In all, Inlakesh said he filmed Israeli military gunfire hit three Palestinian children, a likely war crime violation, leaving them with wounds to the arms, legs and torso.

“You’re killing part of the narrative,” Inlakesh said. “You’re actively taking away the public’s ability to assess what happened at a critical moment during the history of the conflict.”

The post A Journalist Reported From Palestine. YouTube Deleted His Account Claiming He’s an Iranian Agent appeared first on The Intercept.

The latest Harvard Youth Poll found that few young Americans feel the country is heading in the right direction, with AI driving fears about job security.

I spoke with experts to discover how, when and why wellness influencers have gained the ability to spread health misinformation on social media.

Read this series on ProPublica.org.

The post Sick in a Hospital Town appeared first on ProPublica.

Read the full article on ProPublica.org.

The post Sick in a Hospital Town, Part 5: Too Big to Fight appeared first on ProPublica.

Read the full article on ProPublica.org.

The post Sick in a Hospital Town, Part 4: The Last Safety Net appeared first on ProPublica.

Read the full article on ProPublica.org.

The post Sick in a Hospital Town, Part 3: Poor Grades, Poor Outcomes appeared first on ProPublica.

Read the full article on ProPublica.org.

The post Sick in a Hospital Town, Part 2: The Making of a Monopoly appeared first on ProPublica.

Read the full article on ProPublica.org.

The post Sick in a Hospital Town, Part 1: The Business of Care appeared first on ProPublica.

Early morning, May 26, 2022

Anthony Parker was tired of feeling tired. He was approaching his 70th birthday and his third decade as president of Albany Technical College in southwest Georgia. He was close to accomplishing the professional project of his dreams, a brand-new center for training nurses, when his heart began to give him trouble. He’d found that it was hard to walk short stretches across campus without getting winded. He’d stopped using the pedestrian bridge that connected the east and west sides of the college because it had become too difficult to climb the stairs. His wife and three adult children were struck by his sudden urge to take afternoon naps, something he’d once ribbed them about, saying they were sleeping their lives away. 

But perhaps what most bothered Dr. Parker — which is what everyone called him because he’d earned a Ph.D. and because honorifics are considered good manners in the South — was that his severely irregular heartbeat had begun to affect his golf game. So, on the day before he checked into Phoebe Putney Memorial, Albany’s only hospital, Dr. Parker was anxious to get his stamina back.

His cardiologist, Dr. José Ernesto Betancourt, recommended a procedure called an ablation. It involved running a catheter through a blood vessel from his groin to his heart and applying extreme heat or cold to create tiny patches of scar tissue on the outer walls of the organ, blocking the electrical signals that were causing his arrhythmia. Betancourt told Dr. Parker the procedure was minimally invasive and had a high success rate in men his age. In most cases, patients were sent home the day after the procedure and able to return to normal activities in a day or two.

Because Betancourt was relatively new to Phoebe, the Parkers sought a second opinion from a close friend, a cardiologist who was godfather to their second child. After he heard what other measures had been taken to try to address Dr. Parker’s condition, he agreed that an ablation was an appropriate next step. 

Next came the decision about whether to have the procedure at Phoebe. The Parkers had heard horror stories about the hospital from friends and colleagues over the years. But every hospital had stories like that — as far as they were concerned, those were isolated incidents. Dr. Parker was confident that what might have happened to other people would never happen to him. If there’d been anything serious to worry about, some systemic problem, he would have heard about it. For much of the time the Parkers had lived in Albany, he’d served on Phoebe’s board of directors, one of the few African Americans invited to do so. He was a member of what the hospital called the “Phoebe Family.”

He scheduled the ablation for the Thursday before Memorial Day in 2022. He assured his staff he’d be back at work by the following Tuesday and even half-joked about getting out to hit a few golf balls during the break.

When the day arrived, Sandra, Dr. Parker’s wife of nearly 50 years, drove him the 15 minutes to Phoebe. By 7:30 a.m., he had checked into the surgery center. A nurse arrived to wheel him to the catheter lab, where the procedure would take place. Mrs. Parker walked alongside them as far as the entrance. Before saying goodbye, Dr. Parker pulled off his wedding ring and handed it to her for safekeeping. She slipped it on top of her own ring. Then she kissed her husband and told him she loved him as the nurse rolled him away.

One of her younger daughter’s best friends from high school called to check on Mrs. Parker. 

“Phoebe better not mess up,” she said.

CHAPTER 1

Albany, Georgia, is a sleepy, majority African American city of some 67,000 that sits along the banks of the Flint River, more than a three-hour drive south from Atlanta. It’s not on any major interstate. Getting there isn’t easy, though there’s not much reason to go without family ties. It’s one of the state’s poorest cities in one of its poorest counties, Dougherty. It’s so isolated and so untouched by time that its own residents like to joke that when the world ends, Albany is the place to be because it will take another 20 years for the end to arrive there.

COVID-19 upended that way of thinking. In early March 2020, Albany became one of the country’s first hot spots. It had the fourth-highest per capita case rate in the world (after Wuhan, China, the Lombardy region of Italy and New York), and the virus was taking a disproportionate toll on neighborhoods with the highest concentrations of poor, Black residents. Suddenly a city that most Americans couldn’t place on a map had become a harbinger of doom: If the virus could strike Albany, nowhere was safe. Phoebe Putney Memorial, the primary command center for the regional COVID-19 response, was inundated with calls from journalists seeking to make sense of how the virus was being transmitted, who was most affected and whether our health care system could save us.

The storylines that were drawn tended to cast American hospitals as national heroes, and Phoebe, like its counterparts elsewhere, embraced the role. Its doctors, nurses and chaplains appeared on magazine covers and morning news shows. They testified at congressional hearings, hosted delegations of state and federal elected officials, were honored at area military ceremonies and virtually presided at the opening bell of the New York Stock Exchange. Phoebe’s executives used daily livestreamed press briefings to appeal for calm and answer questions about whatever new federal guidelines were being issued for preventing the virus from spreading. 

Sometimes the executives tripped over the color line, like when the hospital’s chief medical officer, Dr. Steven Kitchen, who is white, announced that thanks to “prudent medical history-taking,” Phoebe had discovered that the outbreak was touched off by an infected visitor from Atlanta who came to attend a service with more than 100 other mourners at a Black funeral home. Many of them went to a second funeral the following weekend. The assertion was so clearly loaded in a town once considered a bulwark of the Confederacy that the chair of the Dougherty County government, who was also white, quickly chimed in, saying, “This is not to besmirch anyone’s reputation,” adding, “No one did anything wrong by going to any of these funerals.”

Most of the messaging, though, celebrated the miracles happening inside the hospital’s COVID-19 wards. One video that the press office circulated featured a 99-year-old patient named Maude Burke, who Phoebe had determined was well enough to be discharged from the hospital. In her honor, nurses and doctors had staged their own version of a ticker-tape parade. Burke, peeking out from beneath a poofy hair bonnet, was propped up on a gurney that orderlies pushed through hallways thronged with staff who cheered and waved balloons as it, and she, glided by. 

“We continue to celebrate with our COVID-19 patients when they get well enough to go home,” Phoebe wrote in a statement that was released along with the video. The statement noted that Burke was a few months shy of her 100th birthday, which made her the oldest COVID-19 patient it had been able to discharge. “Her strength and determination are amazing,” the statement read, adding, “Thank you for being an inspiration Ms. Maude!”

I was among the throng of journalists who rushed to report about what was happening in Albany. I thought, at first, that it was a compelling place to tell a story about a small town facing a mammoth crisis: David versus Goliath. I interviewed intensive care doctors and emergency room nurses who would call to update me on conditions at the hospital at the end of their shifts. I monitored livestreams of city council meetings and church services. I gathered data about the identities and comorbidities of people who were dying of COVID-19. As I watched the pandemic unfold, I realized I was chasing the wrong story.

COVID-19 was just the latest in a long list of health crises to hit the city. Since the 1990s, its residents had suffered some of Georgia’s highest death rates from heart and kidney disease, according to the state’s Department of Public Health. Data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention showed that they’d also suffered some of the highest rates of diabetes in the country. Life expectancy rates in the census tracts immediately adjacent to the hospital were lower than the state average. Teen pregnancy rates were higher. And the indicators that affect a community’s well-being, known as the social determinants of health — such as poverty, unemployment, educational attainment, violent crime and food insecurity — had been going in negative directions for the previous two decades.

Perhaps the most important determinant of a community’s health, however, is access to care. In this, Albany seemed more fortunate than other cities its size because it has Phoebe, a self-described world-class health system that is so intimately woven into residents’ lives that they call it by its first name. Its main hospital in Albany is licensed to operate 691 beds, and it owns two other area hospitals, a cancer center, a hospice, as well as numerous outpatient clinics, urgent care facilities and medical practices covering specialties, including bariatrics, cardiology, anesthesiology, gastroenterology, neurology, urology and sports medicine. It has long run training programs for specialists in family medicine and pharmacists. Over the past three decades, the system has not only grown into the largest provider of health care in southwest Georgia, but it has also become the region’s largest employer with more than 5,500 employees and a footprint that covers a large swath of the center of town.

I began to focus on the relationship between Phoebe’s breakneck growth and the rates of chronic illnesses among Albany’s residents and wondered whether the city was more of a microcosm than a hot spot. It wasn’t the only place where the poorest among us are also the sickest. The United States is blessed with one of the most scientifically and technologically advanced health care systems in the world, a sprawling industry so vast and lucrative that it is now one of the largest drivers of the economy, accounting for more jobs and revenue than manufacturing. But for all the money flowing in and out, Americans have more chronic illnesses and shorter lifespans than people in other wealthy nations. When it comes to health outcomes among those countries, the United States ranks last. 

I set out to answer a question I hoped would resonate with anyone who’s ever struggled to get the health care they need. Why are people in Albany — and, for that matter, the city of Albany itself — so sick when its most powerful institution is a hospital?

I started by speaking to dozens of people whose loved ones had died at Phoebe during COVID-19. It didn’t surprise me to learn that not all the miracles posted on Phoebe’s Facebook page were true. Maude Burke’s relatives told me she hadn’t fully recovered from COVID-19. She’d been readmitted to the hospital a couple days after she was discharged and died shortly thereafter. Nor did it surprise me that relatives like hers were bitter about their loss and that some blamed Phoebe for mishandling their loved ones’ cases. (A Phoebe spokesperson said, “We are confident that Ms. Burke received quality, compassionate care during her stay at Phoebe and that she was appropriately discharged.”) 

What I didn’t expect was how fearful people were to criticize Phoebe on the record and how powerless they were to hold the hospital to account. The same was true of many of the current and former employees of the hospital.

Still, people encouraged me to keep digging. Among them was Pastor Daniel Simmons at Mt. Zion Baptist Church, home to one of the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.’s earliest and least successful civil rights campaigns. He told me that he had serious doubts about Phoebe’s account of the outbreak’s origins and that rather than bringing the community together it had cast African Americans as culprits. Even Georgia’s governor, Brian Kemp, picked up the explanation, telling the press, “We had an infected person do the wrong thing and go to a funeral service.” The funerals, Simmons said, were not the only potential superspreader events to have occurred in the weeks leading up to the outbreak. The city had also hosted a marathon to raise money for Phoebe that drew runners from across the country.

I later learned that Simmons was on to something when I met an epidemiologist named Daniel Pollock, who’d retired from the CDC and was researching a paper that examined the origins of Albany’s outbreak. He told me that Phoebe’s assertions were, at best, “highly speculative” and, at worst, “deliberately misleading.” Phoebe’s COVID-19 narrative, he told me, was “deeply flawed from an epidemiological perspective, stigmatizing from a health communications perspective and unjust from an ethical perspective.”

There was no conclusive scientific evidence linking the virus’s introduction in Albany to a single person, Pollock said. Yes, he told me, Patient Zero, as he came to be called, could have carried the virus to the city. But there’s compelling evidence that the virus was circulating widely and undetected in Georgia, including in Albany, weeks before the patient arrived at Phoebe. Doctors there mistakenly thought his rapidly deteriorating condition was connected to a previous and long-standing respiratory illness, not a new one. They never tested him for COVID-19, which Pollock said went against the CDC’s recommendations at the time. 

That patient spent seven days at Phoebe before he was transferred to a hospital back in the Atlanta area, where he could be closer to home. That hospital notified Phoebe that the patient was COVID-19 positive.

Because Phoebe failed to test the patient, it’s impossible, Pollock told me, to know for sure whether he carried the virus into the hospital or contracted it there. What’s certain, though, is that the phone call from Atlanta was the first time Phoebe understood that dozens of its staff had been exposed to the virus. At the minimum, the hospital was as much a superspreader location for Albany’s outbreak, Pollock said, as the two Black funerals that Phoebe officials had called out in that March 2020 press briefing.

“It was an abject failure on Phoebe’s part not to test him and isolate him as soon as he entered the hospital,” Pollock said. He pointed out that although tests were hard to come by at the time, the Atlanta-area hospital tested the patient as soon as he arrived. Phoebe’s failure to do so, he said, “made it difficult to pinpoint when and where the first case occurred. Instead of admitting as much, Phoebe wanted to find an explanation that omitted their medical mishaps. It amounted to a cover up.”

Kitchen agreed that without having tested Patient Zero for COVID-19, it was “impossible to definitively say” that he was the source of the outbreak. However, he added, “I think it’s very likely that he was.” His conclusions, he said, were based on the best information he had at an extraordinarily chaotic time. Pollock has had the luxury of investigating the matter long after the crisis ended.

A Phoebe spokesperson echoed Kitchen’s views. He said: “It is a fact that the first confirmed COVID patient treated at Phoebe was visiting Albany for a funeral. It is also true that most of the sickest patients who filled our critical care units in the first days of our COVID battle were connected to several gatherings in the community.” 

When I asked Kitchen about the stigmatizing effect of Phoebe’s initial assertions about the origins of the outbreak, he seemed taken aback. How could telling the public what he knew as soon as he knew it be stigmatizing? He hadn’t said anything in any way that had blamed anyone. Why would Black people feel that he had? 

“There was no suggestion or tone of judgment or blame,” he said. “I was simply conveying information factually and with great sensitivity and compassion for everyone who was affected.”

Simmons didn’t know about Pollock’s paper. His skepticism about Phoebe’s funeral explanation came from what he’d learned during his years living in Albany about how power works there. It was part of a familiar pattern, he said, and with time, I would see it, too.

“If Albany, Georgia, had done things differently over the years, our community wouldn’t have been as vulnerable as it was,” he told me. “If the health care system was different, if it had a different relationship with poor people and people of color, the outcome would have been different.”

The main lesson he said that he hoped I and other people would take from Albany’s COVID-19 crisis was, “It didn’t have to be this way.” 

Late afternoon, May 26, 2022

Mrs. Parker felt her eyes well up as she arrived at the waiting room. Sixty-seven years old, compact, with a dark complexion and close-cropped hair, she had been a high school assistant principal for many years and had a lot of practice projecting confidence under pressure. But her wide, expressive eyes gave her away. The clerk took Mrs. Parker by the hand and promised to pass on any and every update she received about her husband.

Mrs. Parker took a seat in a less-crowded corner of the waiting room and pulled a bag of peppermints and her iPad from her purse, hoping she’d find enough reading to distract her. On the wall above her, she caught sight of a portrait of the late Dr. Carl Gordon, a towering figure in the hospital’s history and a friend of the Parkers.

Gordon had left Albany after high school in the mid-1940s to attend college. Afterward he joined the military, served in Korea and Vietnam, then returned to Albany in 1968 because there were no Black surgeons in the city. He told people that conditions at Phoebe had “improved 100%” since he’d left — by which he meant they were still bad, but less bad. Federal law had forced Phoebe to integrate its staff and patient wings. Dr. Gordon became the second Black physician granted privileges at Phoebe and, in 1993, its first Black chief of staff. 

The Parkers moved to Albany two years later when Dr. Parker took over running Albany Tech. The two families became close, partly because they were among the handful of African Americans in high positions at major institutions, who’d bought homes in neighborhoods next to country clubs, and moved easily — or knew how to make it look like they moved easily — across the color line.

Looking up at the portrait, Mrs. Parker tapped out a text to Dr. Gordon’s son. “Your Dad,” she wrote, “is keeping me company and giving me comfort.”

Relationships like that made Phoebe feel like more than a hospital to the Parkers. In the weeks leading up to the procedure, they’d received well wishes from the hospital’s president and the health system’s CEO and chief medical officer, along with nurses who’d been students of hers and her husband. Phoebe had recently hired the Parkers’ elder daughter, Kim, who has a Ph.D. in public health, and had agreed to a $40 million deal with Albany Tech to significantly expand its nursing program. It was a project that Dr. Parker for years had pressed Phoebe to support. He believed it would create good jobs for a community badly in need of them, revitalize the school and address critical staffing shortages at the hospital.

The morning and afternoon passed with no word, except that the procedure was still underway. Around 4 p.m., Mrs. Parker asked for the umpteenth time about her husband. A nurse arrived from the catheter lab to tell her that there was nothing to worry about. It was not unusual for an ablation to take longer than expected because of the time required to map the arteries of a patient’s heart. The receptionist told Mrs. Parker that the waiting room would close soon, but that she could stay there as long as she needed.

Around 4:30, Betancourt arrived. He seemed a bit out of breath, but he was smiling. The procedure had gone well, he told Mrs. Parker. Her husband’s blood pressure was running low, but they were giving him some medication to stabilize it, and they were going to have him spend a night in the ICU so that he could be closely monitored. 

He told her that her husband might be out of it for the next six to 12 hours but that he believed they had accomplished what they wanted. He asked Mrs. Parker to give him an hour to get her husband ready for transfer and then he’d take her back to see him. She could stay with him for a while, if she liked, but he said she should go home and get a good night’s sleep since Dr. Parker was unlikely to be awake before morning.

Relieved, Mrs. Parker dashed off texts to her three kids and eight siblings. She packed her iPad and sat back down to wait for Betancourt to return. When Betancourt reappeared, she thought he looked pale and panicked.

He pulled up a chair and told her there had been some complications. Her husband had gone into cardiac arrest.

Mrs. Parker felt the room spin and blinked hard to try to keep herself focused. Maybe she misunderstood the doctor. He was Cuban-born and -trained and spoke with a thick accent.

She thought to herself, “Did he just say Anthony had a heart attack?”

Before she could open her mouth to ask, Betancourt told her that he’d responded to the arrest as soon as it happened. As for how long her husband’s heart had stopped beating, it couldn’t have been more than five or six minutes. 

“That’s not a lot of time,” she thought. “Is it?”

CHAPTER 2

In May 2020, after the first wave of the pandemic had subsided, Albany’s mayor, Kermit “Bo” Dorough, discussed the city’s response to the crisis in an interview with a monthly current affairs program called “The Buzz” on Queen Bee radio station.

Video of the show was livestreamed, so I was able to watch it. Queen Bee’s studios were inside a downtown brewpub. Like the mayor, the two hosts were white and had long been fixtures on the local political scene: Carlton Fletcher, the longtime editor of the Albany Herald, the area’s one daily newspaper, and B.J. Fletcher, no relation, a rare Republican member of the City Commission, what Albany calls its city council.

The mayor, a workers’ compensation lawyer in his early 60s, had only been in office for four months, a tenure that had been consumed entirely by COVID-19. He’d long been an opponent of the city’s establishment, especially Phoebe. His election had been attributed more to abysmally low turnout among Black voters rather than a surge among whites. 

After opening the conversation on a congratulatory note, the hosts turned quickly to the crisis at hand, and Carlton Fletcher asked his co-host and guest to share their thoughts about Phoebe’s performance.

B.J. Fletcher answered first. Just as she’d been raised to show respect to military officers and preachers by standing up when they walked into a room, she said, she now felt compelled to do the same for health care workers. “I can’t see Albany without Phoebe,” she said, and called the hospital’s response to the pandemic “top of the line.”

When she finished speaking, Dorough pounced like a dog on a rib eye. “That’s a juvenile statement,” he said. Then he cleaved his hands to his chest and reminded those listeners living in Albany, or anywhere else in Dougherty County, that the hospital belonged to them. 

“We own Phoebe Putney,” he huffed.

Dorough wasn’t just spouting a political talking point. Founded in 1911, Phoebe Putney Memorial was operated by the county government from 1941 until the early 1990s. But then, in a move that allowed the hospital to expand its services beyond the county limits, Dougherty officials agreed to lease the facility to a private nonprofit entity with the same name. That’s when Phoebe Putney Health System was born. Under the new arrangement, the county kept ownership of the building in which the main hospital operated, but it lost control of the day-to-day management of the hospital, including, to Dorough’s chagrin, how much it charges its patients.

Dorough told Queen Bee listeners that he was convinced Phoebe’s patients paid way too much. “Just because Phoebe Putney has made such valiant contributions to our community in the last few months,” he said, “doesn’t change the fact that health care costs are higher here than anywhere else in the southeast United States.”

Cost is one of the great mysteries of American health care, and few communities have fought over the issue more vigorously than Albany. Phoebe hasn’t always been Albany’s only hospital. It became so after a long and highly contentious fight that was the subject of countless newspaper articles, a feature-length documentary and a lawsuit by the Federal Trade Commission that went all the way to the Supreme Court. Throughout that fight, Phoebe had denied that its prices were out of line, but, like most hospitals, it refused to divulge them for competitive reasons. 

Dorough reminded listeners that on the night he became mayor he pledged to find a way to get an independent study of health care costs across the region to determine how Phoebe’s fees compared with those of other hospitals, something he’d been demanding for years. Now that he was mayor he felt confident he was in a position to get it done, and he challenged his colleagues on the city and county commissions to join him, saying that Albany’s future was at stake. 

“I don’t think it’s a community hospital that first and foremost benefits the community,” he said of Phoebe. “I think it is a business model where you’re driven by profits.”

A few weeks later, I met a young Black man named Clifford Alexander Thomas. We met at a sandwich shop downtown. He’d lost his 61-year-old mother, Beverly “Kay” Thomas, to COVID-19 not long after the outbreak and was still grieving. It was hard enough, he told me, to make peace with the fact that a virus from China had made its way to “Small-bany,” as he called his hometown, and took away his favorite person in the world. But he doubted he’d ever be able to make peace with Phoebe, not because it didn’t know how to save her but because of the way it had treated her, and him, after she died.

Thomas, tall and thick through the middle, pulled out his cellphone and showed the last photo he’d taken of his mother. She was lying on her bed at the hospital, her mouth caked in mucus, her torso half-exposed and tangled in tubes and tape. Judging from the way his mother looked and by the gowns and sheets that littered the floor, Thomas guessed that his mother’s final moments had caused some commotion. But what he couldn’t understand was why the hospital staff hadn’t taken the time to clean her and her room, even though he’d told them that he and his sister were on their way to the hospital to say their goodbyes.

“Why would they leave her like that?” Thomas asked. “Is that what they call taking care of someone? Did they really do everything they could to save her life? Did they think about how it would feel if that was their momma left like a lab rat?” 

I suggested there might be an explanation. Hospital staffers were probably so busy handling the crush of COVID-19 cases that they couldn’t clean his mother up as quickly as they should have. Perhaps they’d had to rush away to try to save other lives?

Thomas didn’t budge. He told me that while he and his sister were standing over their mother’s body, a white nurse walked into the room and, without saying a word, began disconnecting the IV. He said he broke the awkward silence by asking her whether he could retrieve his mother’s belongings. The nurse, he told me, looked over at him and said, “This one didn’t have any belongings.”

He said he struggled to keep his composure because that’s what his mother would have wanted. She’d been born at Phoebe, delivered by an obstetrician who used forceps to pull her into the world, leaving her with a permanently disfigured right limb. Her parents sent her to Atlanta for surgeries to try to repair the damage. But they never filed a complaint against Phoebe or its obstetrician because Black people didn’t sue white doctors in those times, and no one, particularly poor African Americans, dared get on the wrong side of the only hospital in town.

Watching that nurse removing tubes from his mother without acknowledging his and his sister’s loss, Thomas said, his anguish got the best of him. He told the nurse, “Be mindful of the next words that come out of your mouth.” Then he asked her to get out of his mother’s room altogether.

He said the nurse left and came back with a security guard who ordered him to leave.

“That definitely tore me with Phoebe,” he said.

Remembering Beverly “Kay” Thomas 
1958-2020

A Phoebe spokesperson said that while the hospital could not confirm Thomas’ encounter with the nurse, “his perception indicates that she — and we as an organization — could have done better.”

All across Albany, I found evidence of tattered relations between the hospital and the city. Those with insurance — many of them white or well-off — were critical of the hospital in the same ways as Dorough. They described Phoebe as a behemoth that had unfairly driven off its competition, jacked up its prices and pumped more money into executive salaries than into improving its services. They complained that the hospital’s nonprofit status created a drain on the county’s tax base, and they blamed the hospital’s high fees for their exorbitant health insurance rates.

Those without insurance or on Medicaid — many of them Black and employed in low-wage jobs — complained about the quality of care. They described everything from long waits in the emergency room and dismissive attitudes among nurses and doctors to lapses that cost them or their relatives life and limb. They almost never claimed ownership of the hospital but instead described its leadership and their own stubbornly high rates of disease as vestiges of the institution’s history, throughout which whites set the hospital’s priorities and expected African Americans to go along or go elsewhere, knowing there wasn’t anywhere else.

Both critiques were not only commentaries on Phoebe’s economic and political power but echo American sentiments about our health care system as a whole. That’s largely because most people don’t think of hospitals the way they think of themselves. Although the United States is the only industrialized country without universal health insurance, we cling to the notion of our health care system as a public service because that’s often how hospitals portray themselves. 

The reality, however, is that hospitals are businesses, first and foremost. The decisions they make about the kinds of services they provide, the staffing they need to provide them and even the amount of financial assistance they offer to the poor are not driven first by the health needs of a community but by what the hospital needs to maintain its bottom line. That’s even true at the nearly 60% of hospitals that are nonprofits, which enjoy tax exemptions worth $37.4 billion a year.

Nearly 1,600 mergers over the past two decades have made hospitals some of the biggest companies in the country. They have played leading roles in the redevelopment of old industrial capitals like Cleveland, Buffalo, Baltimore and Pittsburgh and turned their downtrodden centers into gleaming, glass-encased landscapes. All this consolidation, however, has its pernicious effects. It’s not the pharmaceutical industry that is most responsible for driving up the nation’s health care costs; it’s the hospital industry. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services recently reported that hospitals account for nearly one-third of the $4.9 trillion the nation spends on health care. Retail and prescription drugs, according to the report, account for only 9% of spending.

Just like any other industry, the more concentrated the money becomes, the fewer incentives there are to lower costs or improve quality and the less communities can do about either. The imbalance is most acute in small cities like Bryan, Ohio; Beatrice, Nebraska; St. Joseph, Missouri; Owensboro, Kentucky — and Albany, Georgia. Their survival is hitched to the fates of oligopoly health systems the way towns in West Virginia and Kentucky once were to coal. They’ve become hospital towns.

Early evening, May 26, 2022

Kim, the Parkers’ elder daughter, was the first to show up at the hospital after her mother alerted the family about Dr. Parker’s cardiac arrest. The two of them had barely stepped off the elevator on their way to one of Phoebe’s intensive care units when his cardiologist, Dr. José Ernesto Betancourt, and three other physicians rounded the corner. For Mrs. Parker, the sight of them, shoulder to shoulder, all in white coats, conjured the image of the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. “This isn’t good,” she whispered to Kim.

Dr. Jyotir Mehta, the chief of Phoebe’s critical care team, stepped ahead of the pack to take Mrs. Parker’s hand and asked whether she knew who he was. Of course she did, Mrs. Parker thought to herself. She’d known Dr. Mehta for years. He’d served on the health system’s board with her husband. What he was really asking, Mrs. Parker thought, was whether she had her wits about her; whether she was mentally capable of understanding what he was about to tell her; that if she wanted to fall apart, now was not the time. 

“Yes, Dr. Mehta,” she nodded, thanking him for being there.

Dr. Dianna Grant, the health system’s chief medical officer and a friend — she’d been the one who’d hired Kim — arrived shortly after. She told Mrs. Parker that the health system’s entire executive team had been notified about what had happened. Your Phoebe family is here, she said, and we love you.

This was the embrace Mrs. Parker had hoped for — the one Phoebe reserved for its inner circle. Whether Grant intended it, her words felt to Mrs. Parker like a secret handshake, an invitation to let down her guard and cry, and she did, falling into Grant’s arms sobbing.

Friends and colleagues from Albany Tech began arriving. Betancourt pulled Mrs. Parker and her daughter aside and began going over what he’d said before: how he’d been right there when the cardiac arrest occurred and how quickly he’d gotten Dr. Parker’s heart beating again. It couldn’t have been more than five minutes. It appeared the cardiac arrest hadn’t caused any significant harm to Dr. Parker’s heart. It was functioning well. What worried Betancourt and the rest of the critical care team was the extent of damage to their patient’s brain, which had been starved of oxygen when his heart had stopped beating.

He told her that Dr. Parker had not awakened. Another doctor, whom Mrs. Parker didn’t recognize, joined the conversation and told her that the medical team wanted to try a treatment that would involve cooling her husband’s body below normal to slow his metabolism and reduce his brain’s need for oxygen, giving it time to rest and restore. The cure is a little R&R, she thought to herself. 

The doctor explained that therapeutic hypothermia had been developed by doctors who’d found that they could revive skiers who’d fallen unconscious below sheets of snow and ice for long periods. Betancourt assured Mrs. Parker that her husband would be kept comfortable throughout the treatment, which he estimated would last 72 hours. In the final phase, he told her, they’d slowly return Dr. Parker’s temperature to normal and wake him. 

Mrs. Parker took the doctor’s plans to wake him as a promise. The sooner the doctors got started, the sooner she’d have her husband back. “That’s no time at all,” she said to Kim. “Hell, we can stand on our heads for 72 hours if we need to.”

CHAPTER 3

More than a century ago, the great sociologist and civil rights activist W.E.B. Du Bois wrote about Albany in his landmark “The Souls of Black Folk,” and the city still looks and feels a lot like the place he described: “wide-streeted” and “placid.” The Flint River, which once separated Black neighborhoods from white ones, still serves as an economic dividing line, with wealth concentrated on its far west side and poverty on the east. The town, Du Bois wrote, “takes frequent and prolonged naps.” There were many afternoons when I drove through Albany and felt as if I were the only one there — except for Phoebe.

Phoebe’s everywhere. Its logo and advertising can be found on the sides of high school sports stadiums and on billboards rising above the fast-food restaurants, Dollar Generals, discount strip malls and liquor stores that line commercial thoroughfares. There are Phoebe golf tees. Phoebe pens find their way into glove compartments and purses. I went to the beach with Clifford Thomas’ family, and he offered me a Phoebe beach chair. At almost every community event I attended, at least one person wore a Phoebe T-shirt, cap or jacket. 

The hospital itself isn’t much to look at. It’s a blond brick-and-concrete structure with a spearmint-colored roof, made up of a main building with nine patient floors and two adjoining wings for outpatient services and a new trauma tower. Those facilities occupy more than five square blocks at the center of the city.. The hospital towers over the properties that surround it, including nearly 100 that Phoebe had acquired over the years. It has turned a bit more than half of those properties into facilities for its own use — an energy plant, parking lots, housing for cancer patients, a day care center for its employees. It has left many vacant and unattended.

A block from Phoebe, on one of my solitary drives through town, I spotted an elderly man watering a rose bush with deep fuschia blooms outside a red brick Craftsman-style home. His name was Nathaniel Smith. He and his wife, Mary, seemed happy to have some company, and they invited me up to their porch to talk.

“Are you the only people living on this block?” I asked.

He smiled, and nodded yes, as if he’d heard that question before. Then he asked whether I worked for Phoebe and was interested in buying his place. The hospital began acquiring the other houses on his block in 1986. It now owned all but one, he told me. I looked around — roofs had fallen in, lawns were littered with empty liquor bottles and fast-food wrappers, there were holes in walls where windows used to be.

The Smiths asked me if I had any idea whether the hospital had a plan for the houses. I told them that I did not. Then Mr. Smith shook his head and scowled, “It don’t make sense for a nonprofit hospital to buy up all these houses and let them go to waste like that.”

Nathaniel and Mary Smith were in their 80s. When they moved into their home in 1987, he worked as a peanut sorter at the M&M Mars plant. They paid $46,000 for the house. They told me they put down all the money they had, but they saw it as a smart investment in a home where they could comfortably live out their days and then pass on to their daughter. When they arrived in the neighborhood, it was filled with working families like theirs. Their daughter was able to walk to school. Mary, a seamstress, converted the shed out back into her sewing studio. Nathaniel doted on his flowers. “It was a real nice place to live,” he told me.

By the time I showed up, Phoebe and Mr. Smith’s rosebush seemed about the only thing flourishing in his neighborhood. The Smiths had stayed put all those years because they couldn’t afford to leave. Phoebe, they said, had been the only buyer to express interest in their property, but the hospital had only offered a little more than what they’d paid for it, which wasn’t enough to cover their mortgage and the cost of settling elsewhere.

When I first told Mr. Smith that I was a reporter, his eyes lit up and he asked whether I’d ever met Oprah. I shook my head and told him that I’d spent the bulk of my career reporting from Latin America. Then he said something that made me think he was reading my mind.

“I bet you ain’t never seen a place like Albany.”

One of the many ironies about Albany, a city where Confederate flags still fly, is that its most important institution was founded with money from a man who fought for the North. Francis Flagg Putney, a New Hampshire native and a veteran of the Union Army, arrived in Albany shortly after the Civil War. A supporter of Black civil rights, he was shot in the shoulder in 1868 in what became known as the Camilla Massacre when whites opened fire on a political rally he helped lead in a nearby town, leaving 12 dead and dozens injured.

Putney abandoned politics soon after; instead, he devoted his energy to building the region’s largest and most profitable cotton farm. In 1909, a women’s association asked his support for the construction of the city’s first hospital. He agreed to donate $25,000 on three conditions: that the hospital be made of bricks, so that it was fire resistant; that it bear his mother’s name; and that it serve both Blacks and whites.

The women agreed, which set the hospital apart from most others in the country. But just because Phoebe admitted Blacks, it didn’t mean they received the same treatment as whites. There were only a small number of Black nurses until the mid-1950s, and they were almost exclusively assigned to Black patients or to night shifts. White nurses were addressed by their last names; Black nurses were just called “nurse.” The cafeteria had white-only counters. Until at least 1960, Black patients were housed in the basement, alongside the furnace, steam pipes and laundry machines. Black doctors were denied privileges until 1965. 

Phoebe acknowledges its segregated past in a 230-page book it published called “A History from the Heart,” but it makes few mentions of how Black patients and doctors were treated, and even those minimize the nature and effects of the indignities Blacks endured. Here’s one passage:

“Queen Jenkins, R.N., Phoebe’s only African American registered nurse in 1960, remembers some difficulties with patients, black and white, and co-workers. White patients often asked for a white nurse, and so did some black patients. LPNs and nurses aides sometimes did not want to take orders from her. Remembering her mother’s advice, ‘let your work speak for you,’ Mrs. Jenkins tried to ignore the racial prejudice.”

Before World War II, Albany was an impoverished agricultural town, its majority black population working mostly in the surrounding cotton and pecan fields. After the war, thanks largely to the opening of a nearby B-52 bomber base and, later, a Marine logistics base, it experienced an economic boom. In 1952, Merck opened a pharmaceutical factory on a 640-acre lot, drawing hundreds of chemists and their families. 

The influx of money and educated workers contributed to changing Albany to a majority white town but also to making race relations there different from the poorer, rural counties around it. Although the Ku Klux Klan openly held meetings around the city, Albany did not experience the lynchings and other forms of terrorism that raged elsewhere. Amid the relative calm grew a small, but notable Black elite, made up of doctors, lawyers, business owners, ministers and educators, who held onto their gains, as nurse Jenkins did, by not openly challenging the racial status quo — mostly because they knew things could be much worse.

The quiescence was disrupted in 1961, when the city’s Black high school and college students, emboldened by the sit-ins and Freedom Rides challenging segregation throughout the South, launched a series of protests at the Trailways bus station. Administrators at the historically Black Albany State University attempted to quell the demonstrations by suspending protesters. There were discussions among ministers about driving the organizers out of Albany, though no one acted on them. When the students pressed on, and the police chief began sending them en masse to jail, the elders rushed to take control of the movement, hoping to stop the tensions from turning violent.

They turned for leadership to the 32-year-old Rev. Martin Luther King Jr., who had gained renown five years earlier for organizing the Montgomery bus boycott in Alabama. Albany became his second major civil rights campaign and is widely considered the only one that failed. The city was seized by demonstrations and arrests, with at least 1,000 people following King to jail. But the resentments between the older and younger factions of the movement never mended. They were unable to agree on the goals of their campaign, much less the tactics for winning them. In the end, the movement ran out of money and foot soldiers before the police chief ran out of jail cells.

King left Albany defeated. Managers at the public library closed its doors when Blacks attempted to check out books. Public transit administrators shut down service rather than allow Blacks to occupy any seats on buses that they wanted. Park supervisors took down nets at an African American tennis court when integrated doubles attempted to play there. After Congress passed the Civil Rights Act in 1964, whites established private schools or moved to surrounding counties to keep their kids out of integrated classrooms. And in 1970, a group of white neurosurgeons opened a new medical center, less than 2 miles from Phoebe, called Palmyra Park.

The neurosurgeons had joined forces with what would become the largest for-profit hospital chain in the country — the Hospital Corporation of America. Its founders patterned the company after fast-food franchises, seizing on the fact that the newly enacted Medicare bill essentially allowed hospitals and doctors to charge the federal government what they wanted. With its manicured gardens, high-end meals and private rooms, the 223-bed Palmyra quickly became the hospital for people with means. 

The Phoebe swag that blankets the region today? No one went near it back then, according to Duncan Moore, who ran Phoebe in the mid-1980s. Throughout his time in Albany, Moore told me, white people referred to Phoebe as “the nigger hospital.” He said he had a hard time getting doctors to stop sending all their well-insured patients to Palmyra and all their underinsured patients to Phoebe. He would wander the hospital floors, scanning daily admissions sheets and engaging in hallway shouting matches with offending doctors. “It got to be like hand-to-hand combat,” he said.

Late evening, May 26, 2022

After giving Phoebe’s doctors permission to begin the hypothermia, Mrs. Parker asked to go see her husband. When she got to his room, she barely recognized him. He looked nothing like the person she’d kissed that morning. That man was vibrant, upbeat and indomitable. This one — prone, pale, cold to the touch — was at the mercy of others. 

“That’s so not Anthony,” she thought, not the man who in most crises during their 50 years of marriage had taken charge. 

She started talking to him with all the confidence she could gather, hoping that he was able to hear her. “I love you. I’m here. I’m not going anywhere. I know you’re going to pull through this. You always do. This will be one more thing we’ll have to talk about.”

From the moment he escorted her to the junior prom in Orangeburg, South Carolina, she and Anthony talked about everything. Like so many teenage love affairs, their attraction was primarily physical at first. He was tall and had a mustache. She had curves and a blinding smile. His parents were friends with her grandparents. She’d been raised in a big, raucous family by a father who was a truck driver and a mother who was a cosmetologist. He’d been the sheltered only child of an elementary school teacher and the principal at a nearby high school that was segregated like hers. But their different temperaments complemented each other. “She’s the nicest girl I’ve ever met,” he wrote in his senior memory book. “And somehow I’m going to get it through her thick head that I love her.”

Two years later, when she was a freshman and Anthony a sophomore at the historically Black South Carolina State University, he asked her to marry him. She skipped gym class and he took the night off from his job as an orderly at the campus hospital to elope. His mother swore she’d never forgive her new daughter-in-law for denying her the joy of a big wedding, but then Kim was born and any hard feelings were forgotten.

Mrs. Parker wasn’t worried that Anthony lacked a clear plan when he earned his business degree. They would figure it out. After getting laid off from an administrative job in a nearby factory, he went back to South Carolina State for a master’s in rehabilitation counseling and landed a job in the marketing department of Augusta Technical Institute, which was part of Georgia’s system of technical colleges. It was there that he found his calling. He’d run a school, like his father. 

He received a Ph.D. in education administration at the University of South Carolina. Few of the white administrators at Georgia’s technical colleges had doctorates. They also didn’t have to get over the same hurdles he did. Still, that awareness didn’t prevent him from being deeply wounded when he was passed over for president of the technical college in Statesboro in favor of a white man. He declared himself done with Georgia and took a job at a trade school in South Carolina. Then in 1995, one of his former colleagues called to tell him that the president’s position was open at Albany Tech and that the commissioner of the state’s trade schools wanted him to apply.

A nurse tapped on the door of Dr. Parker’s room. She gently mentioned to Mrs. Parker that it was getting late and offered to take her to a place where she and her children could make themselves comfortable during the 72-hour cooling period. It wasn’t going to be necessary for them to contort themselves into rigid chairs. Phoebe had set them up in what it called its “hospit-el” — hotel rooms in a hospital — that it offered to VIPs. The nurse said that Mrs. Parker’s family had been assigned one of the nicest rooms. 

It had two double beds, a flat-screen television and a desk. Not at all plush, Mrs. Parker thought, but it was comfortable, and she was grateful for it. Her water aerobics bag with a change of clothes was in the trunk of her car, and after she’d unpacked, the nurse returned with a goodie basket, filled with snacks and soft drinks, wrapped in colored cellophane.

CHAPTER 4

Moore didn’t stay long in Albany. He knew the fight to overcome the competition from Palmyra would always be ugly. Closer to the end of his career than the beginning, he didn’t have the energy for it. But he knew someone who did, his 34-year-old protégé, Joel Wernick. The two men had met when Wernick was a star right guard on his high school football team in Fort Smith, Arkansas, and worked as a groundskeeper at the hospital that Moore ran. Wernick was brash and competitive, Moore told me, and he encouraged him to go to business school and pursue a job like his.

Wernick took Moore’s advice and became part of a growing number of hospital administrators who’d been trained in business, not medicine. “They were the kind of men — and the vast majority of them were men — who would walk into a room with a pregnant woman and immediately know how much her care was going to cost, rather than the kind of person who could walk into that same room and know immediately what care that woman would need for a safe delivery,” said Richard Ray, a former Phoebe vice president. “They’re both important, but they have different priorities.”

In 1988, Moore recommended Wernick to the Hospital Authority of Albany-Dougherty County, whose nine members approved Phoebe’s spending and operations. From the moment Wernick arrived in Albany, his No. 1 priority was to get rid of Palmyra. He had a powerful ally in the chair of the authority, William Harry Willson, who would hold the position for 31 years. A Harvard Business School graduate, Willson had converted his family’s pecan farm into a successful mail-order business, helped found a local bank and became the city’s leading philanthropist. 

Albany’s economy had shifted from agriculture to industry. In 1968, Firestone had opened a factory that employed some 1,600 workers. Procter & Gamble had built a paper products plant in 1973. Within the city’s white establishment, old and new money were vying for influence. Willson and Phoebe represented the old, Palmyra the new. To hear Phoebe’s supporters explain it, Palmyra was driven by racism and greed. Not only did it provide scant care to the poor, but it had no obligations to invest any of the money it was making off of Albany into Albany. Meanwhile, as a public hospital, Phoebe was legally obligated to serve the poor, and in the years when the hospital ran a deficit, the county’s taxpayers were on the hook to make up the difference.

Willson moved to make Phoebe a business, too. Among his first instructions to Wernick was to reach out to Palmyra’s parent company and offer to buy it out. When the Hospital Corporation of America turned him down, they decided that the only way Phoebe could compete was to expand, and the only way it could expand was to change its governance. 

The two persuaded Dougherty County to relinquish oversight of Phoebe and transfer it to a private management company that would also finance its operations. Under the new structure, the county would retain ownership of the actual building but lease it to the new entity for $1 a year. 

That lease still stands as the county’s only leverage over how the hospital is run. County officials can revoke it without warning, although the conditions of the lease leave a lot to Phoebe’s discretion. It broadly requires that Phoebe provide quality care to the community at a reasonable cost — without defining what that means — that it spend 3% of its revenue on free and subsidized care for the poor and that it uphold Phoebe’s founding promise to treat all people, no matter their ability to pay.

With that move, Phoebe Putney Memorial Hospital became the centerpiece of the Phoebe Putney Health System. Controlled by Wernick, the health system was now free to pursue business ventures in the wealthier suburbs outside the county limits with the same tax-free status as before but without the same burden of public scrutiny. 

Under Wernick and Willson’s leadership, the hospital authority approved hundreds of millions of dollars in bonds for the construction of new clinics, office towers and medical wings, including some that weren’t in Dougherty County. Rather than staging hallway tirades to get doctors to refer their paying patients to Phoebe, Wernick bought their practices. He lobbied to prevent Palmyra from obtaining a state license to deliver babies by using Georgia’s strict certificate-of-need provisions, which put limits on the kinds of health care services that can be provided in any one market.

The laws are meant to prevent massive chains from squeezing out smaller hospitals, but in practice they often stifle the competition. Wernick refused to negotiate rates with managers of factories who complained that the costs to insure their workers in Albany were higher than in other cities. When Blue Cross, Georgia’s largest health insurer, moved to include Palmyra in its health care plans, Wernick threatened to withdraw from the network if it went ahead with the deal. It did not.

In 10 years, Wernick dramatically reshaped Phoebe from a small community hospital in a small city to a behemoth hospital system spread across the state. In 1998, a decade after Wernick arrived,  The Wall Street Journal reported that the hospital’s profit margins were double the national industry average. Along the way, though, he had made enemies. In 2003, Phoebe’s chief of surgery and a local health care accountant started sending a series of anonymous faxes to businesses, accusing Phoebe and Wernick of an array of excessive and predatory behavior. The faxes, called Phoebe Factoids, were drawn from public records and leaks. A lot of the allegations they made were true — that Phoebe paid its executives high six-figure salaries; that it treated the members of its board of directors to all-expenses-paid trips to Europe and the Caribbean; and that it employed aggressive measures to collect medical debts from the poor. But the information was couched in so much spin and crude innuendo that it wasn’t easy to tell what was accurate and what wasn’t.

For months, the Factoids held Albany in thrall. Wernick used his connections in the district attorney’s office — led by a Putney descendant — and a former FBI agent to help him investigate who was behind them. Once he knew who the authors were, Phoebe sued one of them for defamation. They brought their own suits against Wernick and Phoebe, accusing them of retaliation. Each side denied the allegations. 

Eventually the faxes stopped, and the lawsuits were dismissed or dropped, but not before attracting attention from state and national media, which, in turn, got the attention of Iowa Republican Sen. Charles E. Grassley. The chair of the Senate Finance Committee, he was launching an investigation into whether nonprofit hospitals like Phoebe were giving enough back to their communities to justify what they were receiving in tax breaks.

The committee released its findings in 2006, and they were devastating. Among the 10 hospitals that answered the senator’s questions, eight of them submitted information about the amount of free and discounted care they provide to the poor. According to the committee, Phoebe’s terms were the least generous. It offered free services only to people whose income was under 125% of the poverty line and discounted care to those below 200%. Under those terms, a single mother with two dependent children who earned more than $21,000 a year would not qualify for free care. The other seven hospitals covered patients whose income was at least one and a half times that much.

Even more damning was how aggressively Phoebe pursued patients with medical debt. The hospital told the committee that it had filed lawsuits against more than 1,000 people during the previous five years and that nearly 40% of those suits involved people who owed less than $500.

Decades later, when I spoke with Dean Zerbe, who led the Grassley investigation, he got worked up again about Phoebe’s debt collection practices. “They weren’t doing that because they genuinely expected to collect $500,” he said. “When hospitals go after people like that, it’s because they don’t want them to come back.”

Three former executives at Phoebe told me that the Grassley report rattled Wernick, because he couldn’t disparage the findings as a “terrorist conspiracy” the way he had done with the Factoids. It wasn’t the only public relations hit. The Albany Herald published an accounting of the properties the hospital was acquiring in the downtown historic district, raising questions about the drain on the county’s property tax base. In 2006, The Associated Press reported that Phoebe had used its relationship with the county government, which has the power of eminent domain, to force a 93-year-old retired domestic worker named Julia Lemon out of her home. The hospital wanted to raze the house so that it could expand a day care center for its employees. A jury ruled in Lemon’s favor. 

That same year, the Albany Herald obtained a deposition in which the hospital’s chief financial officer revealed that Wernick’s compensation came with a long list of perks, including a country club membership, six-figure bonuses, an automobile of his choice every three years and a termination agreement guaranteeing that if he was fired for cause, he’d receive three years pay unless he was convicted of a felony. This was on top of a $650,000 salary.

If all that wasn’t enough, in 2009, the battle between Wernick and the authors of the Factoids became the subject of a feature-length documentary. The timing of all the coverage couldn’t have been worse. Plants in Albany had begun to shut down, and thousands of people were being thrown out of work: Bob’s Candies (236 employees); Merck (273 employees); MacGregor Golf (200 employees); Flint River Textiles (230 employees); and, the biggest hit, Cooper Tire, which had replaced Firestone (1,268 employees). On their way out of town, plant managers complained that one of the reasons for the closures was the high cost of health care.

Sandra Morris was a human resources manager at the Procter & Gamble plant, which didn’t close but whose workforce has shrunk over the years. “I was trying to do everything I could to lower our costs,” she told me. But, she added, “I was fighting a monstrosity of a hospital.”

The battle with Palmyra ended when Phoebe least expected it — when it looked like it had lost. Palmyra applied in 2008 for a license to deliver babies. Phoebe spent millions of dollars, including $8.8 million to the firm of its lead attorney, Robert Baudino, to challenge the request. Palmyra took its case to court, charging Phoebe with a host of antitrust violations, and it won. In April 2010, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against Phoebe and, in remanding the case, recommended that the health system could be held liable for damages amounting to three times the value of any provable harm.

Those who worked with Wernick told me that he saw the ruling as a matter of life and death. The damages Phoebe might have to pay would gut its finances. Just as troubling was that Palmyra’s ability to begin delivering babies would have dealt a significant blow to Phoebe’s ability to compete for patients. I’ve spoken to numerous people about Wernick, and the one quality that both his allies and detractors agree on is that his determination to win was extreme. Where they disagree is about his motives. His supporters say that he operated on the belief that what was good for Phoebe was good for Albany and that it was his commitment to doing right by the community that compelled him to fight as hard as he did. To his critics, he was only interested in building a health care empire, whether that was what Albany needed or not. Lynda Hammond, a former Phoebe vice president, told me that for Wernick “it was all about being the only hospital, not the better hospital.”

Three months after the 11th Circuit’s ruling, Wernick dispatched Baudino to Hospital Corporation of America’s headquarters to discuss, again, Phoebe’s interest in buying Palmyra. The only public records of how the deal was consummated come from the filings made by the Federal Trade Commission, which mounted a legal battle to undo it. 

According to those records, HCA seized on Phoebe’s vulnerability and asked for $195 million in cash, which was more than twice Palmyra’s net revenue for the previous 12 months and which the FTC said “far exceeded” other recent hospital deals. HCA demanded that the agreement be kept confidential until it was signed. Also, if the acquisition failed to go through, either because of antitrust challenges or opposition from the hospital authority, Phoebe would have to pay the chain a breakup fee of some $52.5 million.

Wernick presented the terms to the hospital authority a week before Christmas. Baudino, Phoebe’s lawyer, was assigned to represent the authority. As the FTC would later point out in a legal complaint, this put him in the position of both pitching the merger and weighing its merits. He recommended that the authority approve the deal. Seven of its nine members attended the meeting, and they voted unanimously in favor. 

Feelings among the residents of Albany, who didn’t learn about the purchase until after it was signed, ranged from confusion to outrage. The Albany Herald quoted opponents to the deal saying that it was “mind-boggling” that the hospital authority would agree to a merger of this magnitude without taking time to do an independent assessment of its potential impact on the cost and quality of care. They accused the members of the authority of conducting themselves as “agents of the hospital” rather than representatives of the public good.

Within months, the FTC sued Phoebe, describing the hospital authority as a “rubber stamp” and the deal as a “merger to monopoly” that would “cause consumers and employers in the Albany region to pay dramatically higher rates for vital health care services.” The agency pointed out that many people in the city were “already struggling to keep up with rising medical expenses.” It added that the merger was also likely to “reduce the quality and choice of services available.”

Over the years Phoebe had done many things to lose the confidence of the community it was supposed to serve, but the purchase of Palmyra — at a huge cost, revealed only at the last minute, without public input or any assessment of its repercussions — was a turning point for many residents.

The hospital authority didn’t call a public hearing on the merger until May 2012, some 17 months after the deal was announced. It attracted an overflow crowd and lasted more than three hours, as one impassioned speaker after another shared their views. “Why did it take the FTC to recognize what you did not — the need to protect our citizens from an overreaching hospital,” asked a resident named Hope Campbell, speaking for many in the room. 

In response, Wernick promised that, in order to keep the merger from draining revenue from the county, Phoebe would voluntarily continue to pay what had been Palmyra’s property taxes. Not only would there be no increases in the cost of care, Wernick said, but ending the rivalry between two hospitals would allow Phoebe to streamline services in a way that would reduce costs and broaden its ability to provide the region with “high-quality, affordable and accessible health care.”

He explained that Phoebe Putney Health System had grown to cover 35 counties. As a result, it had to expand to keep up with the demand, and buying a facility was much cheaper and much less disruptive than building one. Phoebe would finally have the space and resources, he said, to address some of the region’s most pressing needs, including establishing a trauma center. And he pledged to convert Palmyra into a medical facility that focused on care for women and children.

The matter of the merger was not settled for five years, and although Phoebe lost the legal battle, it ultimately won. The Supreme Court ruled against the merger, but by then Phoebe had taken control of Palmyra, combining its services and staff and even giving the facility a new name, Phoebe North. The FTC fought another couple of years to find a way to separate the two entities, but it eventually decided that Georgia’s strict certificate-of-need provisions would make it almost impossible for an outside health system to sustainably take over Phoebe North.

Richard Ray, the former Phoebe vice president, recalled being summoned to an executive meeting shortly after the settlement with the FTC was announced. He said that the mood at the meeting was anything but celebratory. The purchase had thrust Phoebe deep into debt. Nobody was sure how the hospital was going to keep its doors open. 

Wasn’t the plan to turn Phoebe North into a women and children’s facility? I asked.

“It was clear that no real due diligence on the idea had ever been done,” he said. “We had bought this facility that we couldn’t use.”

How did Phoebe explain that to the public? I asked.

“We knew we couldn’t say that to the public,” he said, “so we really didn’t say anything.”

May 27-29, 2022

Just a little more than 24 hours had passed when Mrs. Parker realized that word about her husband’s condition had gotten out. She received a text from someone she and Anthony barely knew, a middle manager in Phoebe’s human resources department. But somehow the woman had heard he was in critical condition and messaged to say that she was praying for him. 

“How does she know?” Mrs. Parker wondered. “Had news about Anthony gotten out?

If that wasn’t intrusive enough, the woman stopped by the room. You don’t want to move him to Emory or somewhere? she whispered. Shouldn’t you get him out of here?

It seemed an inappropriate question on so many levels, not the least of which was how little they knew each other. Still, Mrs. Parker was polite. “We’re good,” she responded. “I appreciate your concern, but we’re good.”

Other people might not have a high opinion of Phoebe, but Mrs. Parker did. She was confident its staff was going to save Anthony. She compared it in her mind to when President Donald Trump came down with COVID-19 and had to be rushed to Walter Reed National Military Medical Center. That was an all-hands-on-deck emergency, and the staff at Phoebe, whose senior executives milled in and out of Anthony’s room, had made it clear that this was an all-hands-on-deck emergency, too.

Andrea, the Parkers’ middle child, who was 43 and served as a commander in the Coast Guard, had arrived from suburban Washington, D.C., late the previous evening. So had Richard, a UPS long-haul driver, based in Atlanta, who was 39 and the youngest sibling. None of them doubted that their father was in good hands. They supported their mother, and their mother was going to stick with Phoebe.

That’s what Anthony had always done when others raised questions about the hospital. When doctors shared concerns about staffing issues that were leading to poor patient outcomes, Anthony questioned the propriety of their actions, not Phoebe’s. When friends complained about loved ones dying in Phoebe’s care, he didn’t use his position on the board to press the hospital for an inquiry. He would say he was confident Phoebe had acted appropriately. When he asked Phoebe to invest in Albany Tech’s nursing program and instead it gave money to the predominantly white community college, he stewed privately, but he didn’t raise a ruckus. “They just don’t know they need us yet,” he’d say to his staff. “We’ll be here when they do.”

Mrs. Parker’s loyalties also ran deep. When the spouse of a co-worker had nearly died from an infection she’d gotten after a hysterectomy at Phoebe, she asked Mrs. Parker to help get a letter to CEO Joel Wernick. Mrs. Parker didn’t do it. Who knew whether Phoebe was responsible? she reasoned. It didn’t feel like something she should take to Anthony, much less for Anthony to take to Wernick. 

Yes, there was the time years earlier when he was being treated for lymphoma and had been admitted for what was supposed to be a laparoscopic biopsy of a spot that had been detected on one of his lungs. The doctor emerged from the biopsy saying he’d ended up performing major surgery. “Did he just tell me he opened Anthony’s chest?” she said to herself, feeling a lot like she would when Dr. José Ernesto Betancourt told her that her husband had gone into cardiac arrest. The surgeon back then explained that he’d changed plans because he’d had a hard time reaching the section of the lung that he’d wanted to check for cancer and that fortunately he’d found no signs of disease. But afterward, Dr. Parker’s radiation oncologist complained that the biopsy hadn’t been necessary. 

Why hadn’t her husband’s doctors communicated with one another? Mrs. Parker wondered. A lawsuit certainly crossed her mind but not her husband’s. He would have never considered such a thing. Not when it came to Phoebe. He’d have a longer recovery, but he’d be fine. His thinking was, “Let’s move on.”

She was praying that her husband would be fine this time, too, that his faith in Phoebe would be vindicated. On Sunday, three days after the ablation, it seemed that might be the case. The cooling period had ended. Dr. Parker’s body was being returned to normal temperature. His three children were in his room, singing along with a recording of the South Carolina State fight song — “Get up for the Bulldogs. Everybody, get up!” — hoping their father could hear them, when suddenly he opened his eyes.

CHAPTER 5

Phoebe spending nearly $200 million to buy and then mothball most of Palmyra while so many Albany residents were struggling to pay their medical bills was disastrous for its reputation and its finances. The hospital had paid cash for Palmyra, cobbling together the financing afterward, including arranging for the hospital authority to issue yet another bond — this one for $108 million. The additional debt helped send Phoebe’s expenses soaring from $508 million in 2012 to $576 million the next year. 

I spoke with several former Phoebe executives about what things were like during that time. They told me that conditions were bleak. One recalled Joel Wernick, who’d now run the health system for 25 years, spending millions of dollars on a communications expert to come up with a branding campaign. “We had soiled beds, waiting rooms with holes in the chairs, mounting sepsis issues and had just laid off 200 qualified nurses,” he recalled, “but we had a new logo.”

A former vice president at Phoebe showed me an email chain that she’d saved from around that time. It had been written under the subject line “ICU Morale.” The emails captured a conversation among a group of intensive care nurses who were encouraging one another to try to make the best of the conditions because there wasn’t much else they could do.

“Money problems in the hospital (despite all of our opinions) have dictated that cutbacks are necessary,” one of the nurses wrote. “People and family are going to die, our patients are going to die, sometimes quick… sometimes not … sometimes despite everything we do.” The nurse went on. “People are going to be treated wrong, people will suffer, work will not be the best at times,” he wrote. “We will continue to feel underpaid no matter what job, company or title we attain.”

One of the nurse’s colleagues thanked him for speaking up. A supervisor encouraged everyone on the email chain to try to make the best of a bad situation. However, there was a long response from a nurse whose positivity was spent. 

She wrote that during a typical shift in the ICU, it wasn’t unusual for a single nurse to manage three critically ill patients at a time, while guidelines advise only being responsible for one to two. She described how doctors ignored late-night calls, leaving her and her colleagues scurrying on their own to figure out how to save patients whose vital signs were crashing. She recalled running out of essential supplies and having to spend hours on the phone — and away from her patients — to get them restocked. 

She despaired about having to answer questions from patients and families about “why something wasn’t done or checked, when you’ve been doing your best just to stay afloat.” 

It’s easy to talk about keeping a positive attitude, she wrote. “But when you’re hit with tidal wave after tidal wave, night after night, even the most faithful, positive person will start to waver.”

A Phoebe spokesperson said the emails “represent the opinions of a few individuals, not facts.” At the time, he said, Phoebe “was not under undue financial strain and never prioritized financial considerations over quality and safety.”  

The conversation in those emails resonated because I’d pored over hundreds of pages of Phoebe’s financial records. Revenue from patient stays was flat. The former Phoebe vice president told me that Palmyra’s patients were so upset by the merger that those who could afford to travel for health care, which often included people with decent insurance, went out of their way not to go to Phoebe. Providing care for the poor and uninsured became an even bigger burden. The amount of bad debt that Phoebe accumulated because patients weren’t paying their bills increased from $16.5 million in 2012 to more than $121.7 million in 2018.

Despite Wernick’s promises, the cost of care at Phoebe increased immediately after the merger, and, a year later, so did the cost of health insurance. An Atlanta Journal-Constitution examination in 2013 of the online market that had been established by the Affordable Care Act found that a middle-tier insurance plan for a typical 30-year-old consumer in Albany was the highest in the state.

The following year, The Washington Post published a national study of the online marketplace. It found that southwest Georgia was one of the most expensive health insurance regions in the country. The only places with higher premiums were in the areas around the Colorado resort towns of Vail and Aspen.

“If Lee Mullins lived in Pittsburgh, he could buy mid-level health coverage for his family for $940 a month,” the Post story opened. “If he lived in Beverly Hills, he would pay $1,405. But Mullins, who builds custom swimming pools, lives in southwest Georgia. Here, a similar health plan for his family of four costs $2,654 a month.”

What that meant, I was told over and over again in Albany, was that the poor and uninsured stopped seeking routine care, and the rates of treatable illnesses began to climb.

I sought out Wesley James, a sociologist at the University of Memphis, whose research focuses on health, mortality and life expectancy in rural parts of the country, and asked him to analyze mortality rates for Dougherty County over the past 50 years. Drawing on Centers for Disease Control and Prevention data, he found that for most of that time, the county’s diabetes mortality rate had tracked closely with the rates for the state and nation. In the decade after the merger, however, it leaps off the charts like rocket trails, going from 36 to 76 per 100,000 people. 

James told me that it wasn’t unusual to see modest upticks in poor, rural communities that have experienced steep population decreases and been hit by economic turmoil but that he’d rarely seen spikes as high as the ones he’d recorded in Dougherty County.

None of this affected Wernick’s compensation. In 2017, the year he turned 63, the health system provided him with a $6 million retirement package, in addition to his more than $1.1 million in salary and deferred pay. In 2018, Wernick’s last full year as CEO, his earnings per bed were more than twice as much as that of the CEO at the Mayo Clinic, one of the top-rated health systems in the country. In the two years following his departure, Wernick was paid almost $2.8 million, because the board had extended his contract in case it wasn’t able to find a replacement.

If Wernick had made peace with his opponents by the time he left, he gave no sign of it in the exit profile that the Albany Herald published. “The kind of unwarranted criticism I was subjected to never really hurt my pride, as it was intended to do,” he told the paper. Nor, he said, did it diminish his commitment to Albany. “This is a place where thousands live, and millions wish they could,” he said. “I intend to continue contributing to it.” 

Eight months later, he moved to the other side of the state.

May 29, 2022

When Dr. Parker opened his eyes, his pupils rolled upward. He didn’t say anything. His body was clenched and trembling as if he’d felt a jolt of electricity. The entire episode only lasted a few seconds, but that was the signal Mrs. Parker and her family had been praying for — the “‘Grey’s Anatomy’ moment” she had told everyone was going to happen. Anthony was coming back. He would wake up. He might not remember who they were right away, but he’d wake up. 

There were so many big things ahead for him. His and Mrs. Parker’s 50th wedding anniversary. Andrea’s retirement from the Coast Guard. His newly elected position on the Rotary Club board. And the launch of Albany Tech’s partnership with Phoebe that would double the college’s nursing enrollment. The project marked the culmination of Dr. Parker’s effort to transform the image of his school from one that gave students manual skills to one that turned them into professionals. 

Mrs. Parker remembered the naysayers — people who never believed it would happen or believed it shouldn’t. At lunch one day, William Harry Willson’s wife, like her husband, a major benefactor of the hospital and community, took Dr. Parker playfully by the hand and cautioned him against trying to turn the school into something for which it was not intended. Willson didn’t say it in so many words, but the message Dr. Parker took from her was: “Don’t forget what your school is there for. Teach those kids to use their hands, not their brains.”

She remembered her husband repeatedly asking the hospital to support Albany Tech’s nursing program and Wernick regularly turning him down. The one time Phoebe did give a large donation, Wernick insisted that Dr. Parker keep it anonymous. It ticked Dr. Parker off. It felt to him like the same kind of hush money that Strom Thurmond, the segregationist senator from South Carolina, had secretly sent to the Black child he’d fathered but never publicly acknowledged.

Dr. Parker never let on publicly how he really felt about Wernick’s request, and he told his wife not to do so either. He did what he’d always done: accepted the gift, privately thanked the hospital and made the most of the money without saying where it came from.

CHAPTER 6

Before coming down with COVID-19, LaTosha Almond earned about $9 an hour working for a company that laundered the hospital’s linens. Her health habits were typical of the poor and uninsured. She couldn’t afford regular checkups. She sought medical help — usually by going to the emergency room — only when she was sick, which was a lot. She was raised in the tiny town of Cotton, where her mother, grandmother and great-grandmother had worked on a farm, both in the fields and in the kitchen. 

Almond was the youngest of six children, raised by a mother who struggled with mental health and a father with a violent temper. She spent her childhood bouncing between a troubled home and foster care and her adulthood bouncing between dead-end jobs. 

By the time she was about to turn 42, she was morbidly obese, diabetic and in the early stages of congestive heart failure. If that wasn’t enough to make her a perfect target for COVID-19, she’d been hospitalized with the flu just months before the start of the pandemic.

But it wasn’t COVID-19 that killed Almond. Her medical records show that she died from cardiac arrest and severe brain damage, which her family believes was caused by a series of alarming and inexplicable lapses by medical staff at Phoebe. Three nurses, who were either involved in Almond’s care or had detailed knowledge of it, agreed.

According to her medical records, Almond was admitted to Phoebe with COVID-19 in early April 2020 and was hospitalized there until June 1. She announced that she was being discharged on Facebook. Her voice was weak and raspy, but her mood was upbeat. She’d not only beaten COVID-19, she’d shed 100 pounds. “I’m getting fine, girl,” she said to one friend who typed a comment congratulating her. “Fine, fine, fine.” 

That wasn’t all. “My life has changed,” she went on. “I feel better about myself. No matter what nobody say, you can’t bring me down.”

The day after Almond arrived home, her mother, Tersas Laster, detected an awful stench coming from her daughter’s bedroom. 

“I went in and asked Tosha, ‘What’s that smell, baby?’” Laster said. “She told me, ‘Ma, it’s that wound.’” Almond had a severe bedsore on her lower back. Laster described it as big as a dinner plate and so deep that she could see her daughter’s bone. “It was pouring out yellow and gray pus,” she said. “Smelling like a dead carcass on the side of the road — that’s how they sent my baby home.”

A home health nurse whom Phoebe had assigned to follow up with Almond instructed Laster to get Almond back to the hospital. “The nurse told me they should have never discharged my baby with that wound,” Laster said. Almond’s medical records indicate that she underwent emergency surgery to debride the wound. The surgeons also performed a tracheotomy because her airway had narrowed, making it hard for her to breathe. 

Almond spent an additional three weeks at Phoebe and was discharged on June 25 with a tracheostomy tube that required regular cleaning to keep her airway open. Laster only attended school until the eighth grade and acknowledged to me that she doesn’t read or write well. She said that Phoebe did not teach her or her daughter how to manage the trach, as required for discharge. According to Almond’s medical records, she was rushed back to the emergency room three times after the trach became clogged.

The first time was on June 27. Records indicate that doctors in Phoebe’s emergency room removed “a large mucus plug” and sent her home. She was back in the ER again on July 12, with another plug, which doctors removed. A few minutes before noon the next day Almond was back at Phoebe for the third and final time. 

“Patient arrived in cardiac arrest, which seemed secondary to respiratory arrest,” her medical records said. Her heart had stopped beating for nearly 15 minutes before doctors were able to revive her, according to the records. They removed her trach and put her on a ventilator and tried treating her with hypothermia — cooling her body to give her brain time to recover. However, the records said, the heart attack had caused too much damage. Almond was not exhibiting “any purposeful activity or signs of brain activity.”

She was pronounced dead shortly before 10 a.m. on July 15. Her sister Rosalynn Almond said the way Phoebe had treated Almond was “inhumane,” adding, “What kind of doctor sends a person home with an open wound like that?”

Citing privacy protections, a Phoebe spokesperson said he could not comment on the specifics of Almond’s case but added “we believe Phoebe provided appropriate care.”

She and her mother attempted to find a lawyer who would represent them against Phoebe, but no one would take their case. Georgia, like many other states, enacted an emergency immunity law that shielded health care providers from civil liability in COVID-19 cases, except when plaintiffs could meet the nearly unattainable standard of proving gross negligence or willful misconduct. Almond was classified as a COVID-19 death, even though that wasn’t what killed her.

“I feel like if they’d have done what they were supposed to, my child would be here now,” Laster said. “I wouldn’t have had to bury my baby.”

Two of Almond’s home health nurses told me that in the chaos of COVID-19 families were not always getting the supplies and the training they needed to properly manage trach patients, because Phoebe either didn’t have the resources or didn’t provide them. Another nurse, who knew of Almond’s case but was not assigned to it, said she scoured Amazon every day looking to buy inner cannulas, the tubes that are placed inside the trach, that were the right sizes for her patients’ needs. She said that cannulas were so hard to find that she asked patients to reuse them more times than standards advised, and she reluctantly asked for them back from patients who had recovered. 

A Phoebe spokesperson said the hospital had “no recollection of anyone ever reaching out to complain about a lack of home health supplies or to indicate they were scouring Amazon in search of proper supplies.”

Cases like Almond’s had me wondering how well Phoebe had tended to its patients before the pandemic. In 2012, the year after it acquired Palmyra, Phoebe was rated one of the worst hospitals in the country by a coalition of large health insurers and leading patient safety experts known as the Leapfrog Group. The group’s members had been alarmed by reports that across the country 200,000 people were being killed or injured each year by medical mistakes and wanted to provide patients a way to evaluate their health care options. 

The Leapfrog Group began giving letter grades to hospitals based on information it gathered from the institutions themselves and on an analysis of public data from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. The Albany Herald reported that part of the reason for Phoebe’s poor first grade — it got an F — was that Leapfrog gave the hospital only 5 points out of 100 for ICU physician staffing. The hospital’s senior vice president of medical affairs told Georgia Health News that he was “troubled” by Leapfrog’s methodology, which he described as “inaccurate and misleading.”  The score resonated with me because it tracked with what I’d read in the email exchange I’d obtained and with what I’d been told by several nurses who worked at Phoebe during that time. They said that the ICUs back then were not staffed 24 hours and that getting critical care physicians to respond to emergencies was hit or miss. 

In 2015, CMS developed a star system to rate the quality of care at the nation’s hospitals, based on reports of hospital-acquired illnesses, readmissions, emergency room wait times and overall patient satisfaction. The ratings, while imperfect, are widely cited among industry analysts because of the agency’s regulatory authority.

According to the system, one star indicates poor performance, and five indicates excellence. Phoebe received one star when the first reports were published in 2016. CMS rated Phoebe below national averages in the most crucial categories, including hospital mortality rates, the rigor of the safety measures practiced by its staff, the numbers of preventable readmissions and general patient satisfaction. The hospital’s Medicare reimbursements were docked because of high rates of hospital-acquired infections and rates of readmission. 

Phoebe responded by pointing to one of the glaring weaknesses in the CMS rating system, which is that it puts hospitals that serve predominantly poor and uninsured populations on equal footing with hospitals in wealthier communities. Dr. Steven Kitchen, the chief medical officer, said, “The ratings given to hospitals like Phoebe show that this simple star system does not accurately represent the quality or complexity of care provided by teaching hospitals.” However, to put Phoebe’s score in context, 96% of the nation’s hospitals rated by the agency scored higher. All the other hospitals within a 100-mile radius of Albany received three or four stars. Only four other hospitals in Georgia received one star, including Grady Memorial Hospital, a publicly run, 634-bed safety-net hospital in Atlanta.

The Georgia Department of Community Health examined Phoebe’s surgical records. It found two separate incidents of surgeons who operated on the wrong section of a patient’s spine and another where doctors operated on the wrong hip. Home health nurses, according to the inspection reports, were not keeping adequate service records, making it hard to scrutinize whether patients were receiving the medications and therapy they needed. Inspectors obtained audio recordings that showed Phoebe’s physicians refusing to accept critically ill and injured patients who had been referred by emergency rooms at smaller facilities. One case involved a patient with a serious head injury, whom Phoebe’s neurosurgeon dismissed as a serial drunk. 

CMS gave the hospital a two-star rating in 2017. Then in 2018, under enormous pressure from the American Hospital Association, one of the most powerful lobbies in Washington, CMS paused its rating system to adjust its metrics. That year, state officials inspected the death of a Phoebe patient who’d arrived at the emergency room complaining of weakness and persistent diarrhea. The hospital had initially reported the death as a freak incident. However, the state’s investigation revealed that staff either ignored or silenced alarms that indicated the patient was in distress 19 times until relatives discovered the patient unresponsive. Inspectors found that the patient was “down for possibly thirty (30) minutes before CPR was initiated.” 

A Phoebe spokesperson said any health system of its size “will sometimes have patient outcomes that are not optimal. It is the responsibility of every hospital to learn from those cases and do everything in their power to do better the next time.”

When the results of the new CMS system were back online in 2019, Phoebe received one star again. It had a one-star rating in 2020, when Albany was hit by COVID-19 and patients like Almond flooded in for care. Phoebe is still struggling to address the issues raised by Almond’s case. In 2023, it was penalized for a high readmission rate, which tracks patients who return to a hospital within 30 days after their discharge. That metric can serve as an indication that they may have been released too early or without proper instructions. According to that data, Phoebe also continued to have a problem with bedsores in 2023. The hospital has two stars today, which places it among the bottom 30% of all CMS-rated hospitals in the country.

An email sent this year from an ICU nurse to hospital leaders suggests that some of the same staffing issues nurses complained about more than a decade ago persist.

The nurse described staffing levels at Phoebe’s ICUs as a “crisis.” She wrote that charge nurses, who supervise their units and therefore are not supposed to participate directly in patient care, routinely manage two patients. Nurses who should be handling no more than two patients were often assigned three. “This is not only unsafe for patient care, but also unsustainable for staff morale and retention,” the nurse wrote.

“If immediate action is not taken to correct the staffing crisis, the hospital will not only see a decline in patient outcomes,” she continued, “but also a significant loss of experienced ICU nurses who cannot continue to work under these unsafe conditions.”

A Phoebe spokesperson disputed the nurse’s charge, saying, “We have not had a staffing crisis in our ICUs.” He added, “We staff for the volume and acuity of our patients and currently do not have any issues with staffing in our critical care unit.”

June 1, 2022

On Wednesday, Mrs. Parker’s sixth day sitting vigil, Dr. James Palazzolo introduced himself, explaining that he was now the critical care specialist on call. Mrs. Parker had seen Palazzolo around the hospital over the years. She’d been put off a bit by his formal bearing until a close friend who had been Palazzolo’s patient told her how much she liked him. Palazzolo, in fact, was warm, but he hadn’t come to bring Mrs. Parker good news. He wanted to know whether Dr. Parker had signed a living will that explained how he wanted her and his doctors to manage the end of his life, in the event that he was unable to tell them himself.

Mrs. Parker froze for a second and then asked Palazzolo what he meant. She hadn’t been preparing for the end of her husband’s life. She’d been preparing for a “Grey’s Anatomy” moment. He seemed so close. He’d already opened his eyes.

Palazzolo asked her if she had spoken with a neurologist.

Mrs. Parker shook her head. Should she have? she wondered to herself. How was she supposed to know that? Palazzolo said that her husband was being seen by a neurologist and that he’d arrange for her to meet with him. She didn’t even know a neurologist had been involved in her husband’s care. Palazzolo explained that he wanted her to get a specialist’s opinion of her husband’s condition, but his reading of the medical records suggested that Dr. Parker’s brain damage was extensive. He wasn’t getting progressively better, and it seemed unlikely that he would. 

Mrs. Parker suddenly didn’t know whom to believe. The previous doctors had told her that they were going to give her husband’s brain time to rest and recover and then would wake him. No one had raised the possibility that he wouldn’t recover. “Anthony opened his eyes,” she reminded Palazzolo.

That was a reflex, a spasm, the doctor said. It wasn’t a sign of brain activity. There hadn’t been any meaningful sign of brain activity since the surgery, he told her. 

Mrs. Parker stood in stunned silence. Why hadn’t anyone told her that? She didn’t want to think the worst of Phoebe, that the hospital had been deliberately keeping the truth from her, but she couldn’t help herself. 

Palazzolo asked her whether she and her husband had ever discussed what they would want the other to do under these kinds of circumstances. He encouraged her to summon her children to discuss next steps, and he repeated that he would make sure to have a neurologist meet with her before the end of the day. 

Andrea, the Parkers’ middle child, arrived at the hospital soon after. They were sitting in a waiting area outside of Dr. Parker’s room when Dr. William Garrett, the neurologist on call, appeared in a white lab coat and bow tie. He invited the Parkers to talk in his office. The space, little bigger than a closet, was cramped and cluttered. Garrett sat behind a desk and turned his computer monitor toward them, calling up different models of the brain, and proceeded to show images and charts that explained the various kinds of damage that could have been caused during the four to 14 minutes Dr. Parker’s heart had stopped beating.

Andrea, taking notes, wrote, “4-14,” and then looked up. “We thought it had only been a few minutes, five at the most,” she said. “Now you’re saying it could have been 14?” 

The neurologist told her that the records he’d seen from the day of the procedure weren’t clear, so he couldn’t be sure, but it looked to him like it might have taken much longer than five minutes to restore her dad’s heartbeat. Then he turned back to his models, describing something about inconclusive clinical trials, which made it hard to assess certain kinds of damage to the brain and the chances for recovery. 

Mrs. Parker’s face went blank again. She was unable to absorb most of what Garrett was saying. What did those images on his computer have to do with Anthony? she thought to herself. Why is this man speaking to me like I’m one of his med students?

Andrea was also losing patience. She was scribbling the doctor’s words — “extensive posturing in all extremities,” “flexor response at day six,” “reminiscent of diffuse expression” — but she had no idea what they meant. When he told her that there was no single data point that he could use to provide a conclusive prognosis, she stopped him. “I know neurology isn’t an exact science,” she said, “but I don’t want to talk about models.” 

Pointing at herself and then at her mother, she went on, “I want to talk about this case — about my dad, her husband.”

The doctor said he wished he knew more about the extent and severity of the brain damage, but he hadn’t been able to perform a scan because Phoebe didn’t have a mobile MRI machine and her dad was too unstable to be moved. 

Based on the little he knew, Andrea asked, what would he do if this was his loved one?

Garrett turned away from his computer and toward Mrs. Parker. He told her that he was married to a sweet, beautiful woman whom he loved dearly, but that he didn’t think it would be useful to speculate on what he’d do in Mrs. Parker’s shoes. He told her that his clinical assessment of her husband’s condition was the same as Palazzolo’s. It wasn’t getting progressively better. As for what she should do, he said perhaps she wouldn’t have to do anything. Sometimes, he told her, God makes the decision for us.

The room went silent. Mrs. Parker could feel her daughter about to explode. Why was this doctor talking in circles? Was he hiding something? Was Phoebe hiding something? Suddenly its embrace seemed more like a trap. 

CHAPTER 7

Scott Steiner, who succeeded Joel Wernick as the CEO at Phoebe, was happy to cooperate with my reporting when I was focused on the hospital’s response to COVID-19. But he was less enthusiastic when I told him that my focus had shifted to the health system’s relationship with Albany. He explained why when I met with him in his office, and he told me about the first time he sat with Wernick.

It was 2018, and the office looked different back then. Wernick, he said, kept it like a bunker — dimly lit with a dark carpet, hunter-green furniture and thick velvet drapes that were drawn shut. Steiner had been told that Wernick barely left the office during work hours anymore and that he never opened the drapes. According to Steiner, when he asked Wernick why not, the CEO looked at him with a “little wily smile” and said, “For fear of being shot.” 

Leading Phoebe during COVID-19 hadn’t been easy, Steiner said, but distancing himself from his predecessor was even more challenging. In his first year, he’d held 570 meetings with community groups, churches and medical practices, many of them taken up with decades-old grievances — what Steiner described as the “ghosts that will outlast me.”

Steiner, who is 57, grew up in St. Louis. His mother was an intensive care unit nurse, his father an executive at a printing company. He received his MBA from nearby Webster University. Before joining Phoebe he had been the CEO for a group of Detroit hospitals, owned by Tenet Healthcare, the second-largest for-profit health system in the country. It was a miserable experience, he told me. He oversaw five layoffs in his first two and a half years. Then he had to manage the fallout from a series of newspaper stories that revealed how some of the hospitals had nearly lost their licenses after doctors filed complaints about dirty and broken surgical instruments.

Three prominent cardiologists claimed that the health system fired them for making those complaints public, and two filed a wrongful termination suit against Tenet and Steiner. The cardiologists eventually won a $10.6 million award. (Officials at Tenet did not respond to multiple requests for comment.) Steiner didn’t want to talk about his role in the matter when we met, except to say that the turmoil made him open to calls from a headhunter who told him about the opportunity at Phoebe.

“I didn’t think places like this existed anymore,” he told me. Compared to the “shit show” in Detroit, he said, Phoebe Factoids, the anonymous fax campaign against the hospital that consumed Albany in the early 2000s, seemed like “a lot of external nonsense.” Phoebe’s future direction would ultimately rest with him, not distant corporate overlords. All he had to do was get people in Albany to trust him, to put the past behind them. “What I’ve tried to say to people is, it’s a new chapter.” he told me. My reporting, he said, threatened to stir up old tensions.

He knew such tensions were already stirring well before I came along. He’d heard them firsthand during his numerous meetings with the community. Mayor Kermit “Bo” Dorough, who’d been a critic of the hospital since the Factoid days, was threatening to commission a study of health care costs. And in early 2020, nearly a year after Steiner’s arrival and weeks before COVID-19 hit the city, The Albany Southwest Georgian, a weekly Black newspaper, published the official portraits of Phoebe’s executive team across its front page. Most were people Steiner had inherited. None was Black.

The racial composition of Albany’s political hierarchy had shifted in the previous 20 years. The city’s manager and police chief were both Black, and so was the county district attorney and chief judge of the county court. Until Dorough’s election as mayor in 2019, African Americans had held the office for four straight terms. The majority of the members of the hospital authority was Black. Among them was a retired civil rights lawyer named Nyota Tucker, who was alarmed by the Southwest Georgian’s front page. Why were there no Blacks on the health system’s executive team, she asked Steiner during one authority meeting. 

Bespectacled and silver-haired, Tucker, 76, carries herself with quiet reserve. As a teenager, she was one of six students — all girls — to integrate her hometown’s high school. She went on to become the first African American woman to graduate from the University of Georgia School of Law. Afterward, she moved to Albany to work for Georgia Legal Aid, where judges in her first cases demanded she provide proof that she was a member of the bar. She left Albany for a few years to join the NAACP Legal Defense Fund in San Francisco and then returned, eventually becoming a member of the faculty at the historically Black Albany State University and later its chief counsel. 

She didn’t know much about the health care system or how it worked when she agreed to serve on the hospital authority in 2017. She saw volunteering as a way to stay active after she retired and to serve the community. “The authority was not known to cross Phoebe,” Tucker told me. Quickly, she established herself, according to one board member, as the “contrarian in the room” —  the person who said what “nobody else wanted to say.”

In late 2020, Steiner added Dr. Dianna Grant, a Black physician, to his executive team. The next year, the hospital authority elected its first African American chair, a businessman named Glenn Singfield. When I interviewed Singfield, he made clear he was also aware of the authority’s history as a rubber stamp. He told me he wanted to break from the days when the authority consisted of people who’d been “handpicked” by Phoebe to “do the hospital’s bidding.” He said, “I can assure you those days are over.” 

There were reasons to be skeptical. The authority relied on Phoebe for its funding as well as for its administrator and lawyer. The hospital managed the authority’s website and routinely hosted its meetings in the Phoebe board room. And five out of its nine members were doctors or had other financial ties to Phoebe, including a former mayor who had received numerous campaign contributions from Phoebe executives and Singfield, who owned a construction company that had contracts with the health system.

Still, Tucker wanted to believe Singfield and wanted to believe that Steiner would lead Phoebe in a new direction. But she soon found herself at odds with him. As the pandemic loosened its grip on Albany, she resurfaced a proposal she had made the year before to have the authority hire a consultant to assess whether the hospital was meeting its lease obligations to provide safe and affordable care to the community.

The previous review had been done in 2012, before the advent of Obamacare and Georgia’s decision not to expand Medicaid. The assessment would allow the authority to get a better sense of those policies’ effects. Besides, she was new to the authority, and Steiner was new to the health system, and it seemed like a good way to get a baseline understanding of where things at the hospital stood so they could see where things could be improved.

Steiner told the authority he was not opposed to a review but wondered whether hiring an outside consultant was a good use of precious resources. He said that Phoebe would provide any information the authority requested to assess how well the health system was managing the hospital.

Tucker argued that hiring an outside firm was the only way to get an assessment that was “free of any hidden agendas,” even though the money for the review would ultimately come from Phoebe. Since several members of the authority, including herself, had little to no experience in health care, they might not know what questions to ask, she said.

The authority voted in favor of hiring outside consultants. They presented their findings at a meeting in May 2021. Marvin Laster, president of the city’s Boys and Girls Club and a member of the hospital’s board of directors, attended. Tucker was surprised. Laster hadn’t ever come to an authority meeting that Tucker could remember, but she knew him — she was on the club’s board — and she was happy to have a friend in the room.

The analysis read like an exercise in damning with faint praise. Phoebe, the consultants wrote, was “committed to providing quality care” and was “delivering comparable or better quality than its peers in many areas.” However, when they zeroed in on the seven metrics that make up the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ star rating system, they found that Phoebe “currently ranks below the national average in five of the areas, including mortality, readmission, patient experience, effectiveness of care and timeliness of care.”

While Phoebe had spent hundreds of millions of dollars in building, buying and equipping new facilities, the consultants pointed out, its investments in the maintenance and modernization of the old buildings — which the consultants emphasized were among the health system’s core obligations to the county — were “consistently on the lower end” of its peers.

The hospital’s financial margins were comparable if not better than its peers, the report concluded, but it relied more heavily on long-term debt to fund its operations — an indication that Phoebe still hadn’t fully absorbed the cost of the Palmyra merger 10 years earlier. 

As for the percentage of gross revenues that Phoebe spent to help the poor, the report found it had a “lower charity/indigent care percentage than its local, regional and national peers, in all years except 2015.” And finally, the report found that Phoebe’s cost of services “are, on average, higher than local, regional and national peers.” In short, the issues that had bedeviled the hospital’s relations with its community — the quality of care, cost of care and its outreach to the poor — hadn’t changed.

When the consultants concluded their presentation, the first questions to arise were less about the findings and more about what to do with them, according to two authority members attending the meeting.

Singfield was emphatic, Tucker said. He declared the report was “not for public consumption.” (Singfield did not respond to questions about the meeting.) Another member of the authority told me that everyone saw the finding regarding cost of care as “the big elephant in the room.” The member said, “There wasn’t any way to sugarcoat it.”

Steiner did not offer an opinion, but Laster weighed in. It was understood that he was speaking on Phoebe’s behalf, according to two members of the authority. Laster said that even though most of the assessment was upbeat, the information about the high costs of care could hurt the hospital’s image. He compared the potential effect to “rat poison.” Ninety percent of it’s not toxic, Tucker and the other member recalled him saying, but it’s the 10% that’ll kill you. (Laster later denied that he was proposing keeping the report secret.)

The consultants reminded the authority that because it was subject to open records laws, the report was going to get out. However if the authority released it, members would have better control of how it was perceived: It would demonstrate the body’s independence and its fidelity to its oversight responsibilities.

Tucker spoke vigorously in support of this view and suggested that if the authority was uncomfortable with announcing the report, it should at least post the findings on its website. That had been the practice until 2012, when, at Wernick’s urging, the authority voted not to release that year’s report. She said the authority should not condone that kind of secrecy anymore.

An authority member, who did not want to be named, told me the rest of the board was not convinced: “Even if the cost of care is too much, there was agreement in the room that undermining Phoebe, damaging Phoebe publicly, criticizing Phoebe too harshly in public is bad for the community in that Phoebe is the biggest employer and the only place you can go if you’re getting sick.”

Singfield suggested tabling the discussion until the next meeting, saying he was committed to releasing the report but wanted to give the authority time to work on how to do so. Four years later, the authority has still not made the report public.

June 1-2, 2022

Palazzolo returned to meet with Mrs. Parker, Andrea and her sister, Kim. He asked again whether Dr. Parker had signed a living will. Andrea said that he had, but there was no need for one. Her mother knew her father’s wishes. She would make any and all calls on her father’s care, and the children would support her 100%. What they needed from Phoebe was a clear assessment of their father’s condition. She asked whether he was brain dead.

Palazzolo said that he wasn’t and that, in fact, Dr. Parker was largely breathing on his own. His cognitive function, though, had been damaged beyond repair and would likely make it impossible for him to ever be the person he was.

Kim asked him to say more. Palazzolo stammered, searching for the right words. That man in there, he said, is not …

“… our dad,” Kim said, finishing his sentence.

Palazzolo nodded.

Kim kept going. “Because our dad left the day of the procedure.”

Palazzolo’s eyes lowered.

Mrs. Parker wanted another opinion. How could Phoebe have gone from telling her one minute that there was a chance to save her husband to saying that he’d been doomed from the time his heart stopped beating a week ago? She tried to come up with the name of a doctor she trusted to put her family’s interests ahead of Phoebe’s. There wasn’t anyone who didn’t have ties to the hospital. She immediately thought of her own neurologist, Marla Morgan. On staff at Phoebe, she’d become close to Mrs. Parker.  

Morgan came from another of Albany’s prominent Black families. Her late father had served as president of Albany State University for 16 years. She arrived at Phoebe late Thursday afternoon and spent about 20 minutes in Dr. Parker’s room. Afterward, she asked Mrs. Parker whether he’d ever responded to the sound of her voice, to her pleas to open his eyes or squeeze her hand? Mrs. Parker shook her head.

Morgan said she didn’t see any sign of cognitive brain function. There was only the slimmest chance there ever would be. She used the same language Mrs. Parker had heard from Palazzolo. Her husband wasn’t getting progressively better.

That was enough for Mrs. Parker. Anthony would never want to live in a vegetative state. She instructed the medical staff to withdraw nutritional and respiratory support. In the previous days, Phoebe executives had stopped coming by Dr. Parker’s room. She wondered whether their absence was a gesture of respect or avoidance. Ever since her meeting with Garrett, the kids were increasingly unable to keep up a polite front and were fine not to see them. Kim and Andrea did not want to watch their father die. They said their goodbyes and asked their mother to call them when it was over. Richard offered to stay.

Mrs. Parker felt that she and her family were on their own — and that they always had been. She couldn’t make sense of how this had happened, of how Phoebe had allowed this to happen. She wanted so badly to scream at someone and demand an explanation, but there was no one around.

She needed to write a text to her siblings, Dr. Parker’s staff and several of their close friends, but  how was she going to explain what had occurred, much less what was ahead for her husband? The cruel truth, she thought to herself, was that he was doped up and dying — she knew she couldn’t say that, though. She pulled out her phone, summoned what felt like her last shred of sanity and composed a message, which said only that he had begun “transitioning” and thanked them for their prayers.

CHAPTER 8

Mt. Zion Baptist Church, the home of the 1961 civil rights protests, remains one of the most influential Black congregations in the city. Its pastor, Daniel Simmons, told me that in 2007 his members helped fund the opening of a free clinic, called Samaritan, across the street from Phoebe, for people without health insurance. The country was in the throes of the Great Recession. “People were dying in our backyard,” he said. “It wasn’t because they didn’t want to go to the doctor. It was because they couldn’t afford it.”

Phoebe donated one of its properties — a single-story brick building across the street — to the clinic and agreed to provide lab work for patients who qualified for state indigent funds. When I sat down with Simmons 13 years later, the need for the clinic wasn’t all that different from when it had opened. Some 16% of Albany residents were uninsured, almost double the national average, in part because the governor and the legislature had decided not to expand Medicaid. Albany, though, had Phoebe, a hospital whose mission was to care for people no matter their race or ability to pay. So I asked Simmons why a safety-net hospital needed a safety net.

Simmons arranged for me to meet Nedra Fortson, the nurse practitioner who runs the clinic. The day I met Fortson, she wasn’t seeing patients but was waiting for a repairman to come patch two holes in the building’s leaky roof. Phoebe hadn’t done much to maintain the property, she told me. (A Phoebe spokesperson said that over the years the hospital had “invested significantly in maintenance and repairs” to the building.) 

As I began to ask the same question I had asked Simmons — why would people seek care at the clinic when Phoebe’s emergency room was right across the street — there was a knock at the door. In came a tall, muscular man wearing carpenter’s jeans, a face mask with Phoebe’s logo and a T-shirt with the words, “I am Phoebe.” His jaw was swollen from an infected tooth, and he was wondering whether Fortson could help him find someone to take it out. 

The man told me he was 36 and worked on contract as a groundskeeper at the hospital. I recalled that Wernick had gotten his start as a hospital groundskeeper. I also thought that this man’s story was such a perfect illustration of the clinic’s importance that if his jaw hadn’t been oozing with pus, I might have thought I was being set up.

I asked him whether he’d sought help from Phoebe. He explained that he’d gone to the emergency room a few days earlier, and after a 10-hour wait and a 10-minute examination by a nurse, he walked out with two slips of paper: one with a prescription for antibiotics, the other with a list of dentists. I asked what happened to the slips of paper. He rolled his eyes and said, “I threw ’em away.”

On his $9-an-hour salary, he said, he couldn’t afford health insurance, and without insurance, he couldn’t afford antibiotics or a dentist. He had tried home remedies — mostly gargling with saltwater — but the pain in his mouth got worse. “It feels like I got hit with a fastball,” he said. The groundskeeper, who asked not to be identified because he didn’t want to put his job at risk, still forced himself to go to work because he needed the money. That turned out to be a good thing, he said, because one of his colleagues spotted Fortson driving into the clinic parking lot and sent him over to see whether Samaritan could refer him to a dentist who could treat him for free.

Then it was Fortson who rolled her eyes, not about the request of finding a dentist, which she managed to do that afternoon, but about someone doing work for Phoebe and coming to her for medical care. The groundskeeper wasn’t an anomaly, she told me. Nodding in the direction of the hospital, she said: “They all know us over there. Their cafeteria workers, their janitors, their clerks, their nursing assistants and so on.”

With more than 5,500 workers, Phoebe Putney Health System is the largest employer in southwest Georgia. Its growth tracks with what’s happening across the country as the health care sector expands and manufacturing declines. But national studies have shown that hospital jobs are not like the manufacturing jobs they’ve replaced. The latter generally pay salaries that help lift unskilled workers into the middle class. Most hospital jobs don’t, which has an effect on both the workers and their ability to stimulate the local economy. 

One 2017 study of workers in 11 industrial states found that for every higher-paying job held by doctors, six health care employees — including phlebotomists, orderlies, cooks — make less than $15 an hour. In Albany, where 78% of residents do not have college degrees, they were making on average less than $10.

Jack Nicholas Hilton, a former Cooper Tire worker, told me that at the time he’d gotten laid off, he was making $24 an hour. He said he was lucky enough to have a wife who was working as a nurse at Phoebe and could support him while he went back to school for a nursing degree. He made $21 an hour when he started at Phoebe in 2010. In addition, health benefits for him and his family of four came with a $5,000 deductible. If he had a kidney stone, which he did from time to time, that was $2,500 out of his pocket. “People think that if you work in health care you get good benefits,” he said. “Mine were terrible.” Hilton left Phoebe after three years and no longer works as a nurse. 

Numerous other nurses at Phoebe shared similar stories. One former senior nursing manager told me she paid $300 every two weeks to cover herself, her husband and two children, including one in college, who had to drive home three hours for routine exams because Phoebe’s health plans did not cover those services elsewhere. The nurse now works for a hospital in California and pays $80 a month for the same coverage, and her daughter can receive care in the town where she goes to school.

An ICU nursing supervisor, who suffers serious allergies, told me he got his EpiPens from a school nurse, who would give him the extras she had every month. One day he and his wife went to see a Phoebe doctor to discuss a vasectomy and were told he’d have a $900 copay up front, which was not reimbursable. He said that he joked about it with his wife, saying, “$900 will buy us a lot of condoms.” 

A Phoebe spokesperson said the health system offered high-deductible health insurance plans “for those who wish to minimize premiums, as well as offering a co-pay plan for those who prefer not to have a high-deductible plan.” This year, he added, Phoebe is paying 87% of the cost of health insurance premiums for employees.

Like hospitals across the country, Phoebe has been overwhelmed by nursing and physician shortages. According to the hospital’s financial records, between 2014 to 2022, its spending on contract staff exploded from $2.5 million to $150.2 million. Administrators told me that about $100 million of that went to pay for traveling nurses. Although they don’t receive health benefits, traveling nurses fetch salaries that are at least twice as high as those paid to the permanent nursing staff. This transient staff is not only a drain on Phoebe’s resources but typically doesn’t invest in the community by buying homes or sending their children to local schools.

It’s part of a vicious cycle that incentivizes permanent nurses to travel, further crippling Albany’s economy. The people who remain in town, for the most part, are low-skilled, low-paid employees, like the certified nursing assistant who worked part-time as a DoorDash delivery driver; the oncology scheduler whose colonoscopy bill had been sent to a collection agency; and Louise Williams, 51-year-old single mother and grandmother, known by her nickname, “Weezie.” She worked 22 years at Phoebe in what is called the environmental services — cleaning and disinfecting patient rooms. During the first year of the pandemic, she was the only person on Phoebe’s staff to die of COVID-19. 

In her honor, the hospital renovated the environmental services staff break room, installing recliners, a refrigerator stocked with healthy snacks and a flat-screen TV. At a ribbon-cutting ceremony that was attended by Steiner and other hospital executives, the room was christened Weezie’s Place. The hospital invited her family, including her daughter, Shabreka Dent, who thanked Phoebe for remembering unsung heroes like her mother. “My mom was a Phoebe person,” she said. “She loved working here.” 

A few months before the dedication, I had gone to see Williams’ family because two nurses at the hospital had told me they were taking up a collection to help pay her funeral costs. Dent said the same thing to me that she would say at Phoebe: Her mother loved working at the hospital. 

“Nothing we ever said would get her to leave that place,” Dent told me.

Did you try to get her to leave? I asked.

“I used to tell her all the time she should quit that job,” she said.

Why? I asked.

“Because she was always struggling.”

Dent said that when her mother first started at Phoebe more than 20 years ago, she worked part time, thinking she’d eventually find a different job with better hours and better pay. But Williams’ prospects were limited, because she hadn’t finished high school, factories were starting to lay people off and the only employer whose future looked bright was the hospital. Two decades later, Williams was earning less than $10 an hour, often taking home less than $300 a week.

When Williams died, she was late on her rent, which Dent said happened frequently. Her mother’s day-to-day existence, she said, was a gantlet of overdue bills and payday loans, which became even more crushing in 2014, after Dent’s older sister died of cervical cancer and Williams took custody of her two teenage grandsons.

“She would call me, and say, ‘Hey, I’m fine, but if you could get the boys something to eat.’ Or there were several times I paid the light bill for her, or she’d come around, and I’d pay her cellphone bill, or when time for school came around, I’d get clothes for all the kids.”

Dent showed me where she’d gotten her mother’s name tattooed on her right forearm. “She used to say she liked taking care of people,” she said. “I told her, ‘That’s all good, but you got to take care of you, too.’”

June 3-6, 2022

There was no longer any reason to keep Dr. Parker in the ICU. On Friday, Mrs. Parker agreed to have him moved to a regular medical floor. The next day, a nurse asked whether she wouldn’t like to have him transferred to Phoebe’s hospice, which is set in a quiet, wooded area of northwest Albany. Its design was inspired by Frank Lloyd Wright, and it was named for William Harry Willson, the pecan magnate who’d first invited Dr. Parker to join the hospital’s board.

“This room was made for daddy,” Richard said when he walked in, marveling at the prints of World War II fighter planes on the walls and at the floor-to-ceiling windows that looked out onto a patio, shaded by pine trees. 

On Sunday afternoon, Mrs. Parker’s nephew brought ribs from the Parkers’ favorite barbecue restaurant in Columbus. Two friends, including a woman who’d worked as the executive assistant to Joel Wernick, the former CEO, joined for lunch. Pastor Daniel Simmons of Mt. Zion Baptist Church stopped by to pray. And then Mrs. Parker spoke by telephone with her daughters, giggling with them about the plans she’d made for that evening. The NBA finals were on television. She was going to put the game on and cheer for Steph Curry while cuddling beside her husband, as they’d done on so many date nights.

When Mrs. Parker scooted in the bed, Dr. Parker began to spasm. She hopped out and made a joke of the whole thing to the kids. “Can you believe your daddy kicked me out of the bed?” she texted. “I told him,‘That’s fine. I didn’t really want to sleep with you either.’”

After the game, she brushed her teeth and then sat next to the bed to pray. She started by thanking God for the time she’d had with Anthony and for whatever time they had left. “Let your will be done,” she said, “and allow us to be able to accept your will.” Then she looked up at her husband. He would have hated the way he looked, she thought; unbathed, mouth stuck open, face covered with stubble, a cold sore on his top lip. She whispered to him: “We’re going to be OK. Don’t worry about us.” Then she laid her head on his stomach and was lulled to sleep by the rise and fall of his breathing. 

At about 1:30 in the morning, she woke up with a start. His stomach had stopped moving. 

“Well, damn,” she whispered. For some crazy reason, she had held out hope that her husband would prove the doctors wrong.

She drew his South Carolina State blanket up over his chest, pulled out her phone and took a couple of pictures in case she wanted to remember the moment, in case there came a time when she’d want others to know.

Then she kissed him, told him she loved him and let the undertaker take him away.

CHAPTER 9

I learned about Dr. Parker’s death from Nyota Tucker. The hospital authority board member knew the Parker family because her daughter, who was chief of pediatrics at a large Boston hospital, was close to Andrea, the Parkers’ younger daughter. In a small town like Albany, the death of someone as important as Dr. Parker was big news. Phoebe issued a statement lamenting the loss of a beloved board member that didn’t mention he’d died in its care. The Albany Herald ran statements of appreciation from other leaders in the community and an obituary, without saying how and where he’d died. There was a flurry of posts on the not-always-reliable Phoebe Factoids Facebook page, alleging that something at the hospital had gone terribly wrong.

If true, the quality of care Phoebe provided was worse than I’d thought. Dr. Parker had not died like so many of the patients I’d learned about amid the chaos of the pandemic — Maude Burke, LaTosha Almond and Louise Williams. He wasn’t a poor, uninsured person unable to afford to take care of himself, like the people I’d met at the Samaritan clinic. He was a well-known, well-off, widely respected pillar of the community who seemed to have gone to the hospital for a routine, elective procedure. Even more than that, he was a member of the health system’s board. If he couldn’t get good care at Phoebe, then who could? 

Tucker was sure that Mrs. Parker would hire a lawyer to demand answers from the hospital and file suit for restitution. She wasn’t sure what the CEO, Scott Steiner, would do, though. Would he help the Parkers get to the bottom of what happened or fight them? That, in her mind, would indicate how much Phoebe’s relationship with Albany had or had not changed. 

She had no idea, however, that there was another clash looming between Phoebe and Albany, that it would play out in the open and that Tucker would wind up on the losing side.

The issue was such a hyperlocal affair that I ignored it for the longest time. It involved the hospital’s plans to demolish the old Albany Middle School and use the property for the construction of the nurses’ living and learning center that had been Dr. Parker’s dream. Phoebe had acquired the building 20 years earlier, shortly after it had been replaced by a modern facility. Like so many of its properties, the hospital had done little to maintain it. Now Phoebe was saying that the school had fallen into such disrepair that demolishing it was much cheaper than restoring and adapting it. But to raze the school, Phoebe had to gain the approval of Albany’s Historic Preservation Commission, an eight-member panel of volunteers appointed by the city and county councils. 

In a 4-3 vote, the commission denied Phoebe’s request. The majority argued that the school, which opened in 1925 for whites only, was one of the last remaining examples of Beaux Arts architecture in town and was on the commission’s register of historically significant structures. The city planning department also recommended that the building be preserved and urged Phoebe to consider one of its other properties for the project, including the old Palmyra building.

The hostility coming from the overwhelmingly white crowd felt so visceral to the preservationists that the one Black member of the commission, who’d voted in favor of the demolition, felt compelled to defend her colleagues on the other side. She told the crowd that there was more than bricks and mortar at stake, that landmarks held history. 

“We’re not the enemy sitting up here,” she said. “I was born at Phoebe Putney hospital. My grandfather installed the first air conditioning at Phoebe Putney hospital.” She went on to say, “My aunt was one of the first African American social workers at the hospital.”

The editor of the Albany Herald, Carlton Fletcher, had weighed in with a column under the headline “Attempt to stop Phoebe/Albany Tech project beyond ridiculous.” He laid out an argument that was so similar to the one I had heard from Steiner that if I didn’t know better, I’d have thought he had written it. Opponents to the demolition were motivated by old grudges toward Wernick, Fletcher wrote. Their position was an example of “the depths to which some would sink to sabotage the health care facility’s moving forward.” 

Tucker was paying close attention to the fight. She had no doubt the new nursing school would be good for Albany and Phoebe. But she didn’t think the preservationists were being unreasonable either, and she was increasingly troubled by the tone of the hospital’s campaign. Phoebe had plenty of other properties that could be used for the living and learning center, and even if the hospital was dead-set on tearing down the school, she hoped it, and Steiner, would proceed with the same together-we-rise spirit that they’d professed during the pandemic.

A week after the vote, Phoebe and the hospital authority filed an appeal with the City Commission, accusing the preservation commission of abusing its discretion. Tucker didn’t believe me when I asked her about the appeal. The authority, she said, had never held a vote to take such an action. I sent her a copy of the appeal, which showed that it had been filed by the authority and signed by Phoebe’s lawyer.

Tucker said she had no idea what was going on. The authority was independent of the hospital, or at least that’s what she’d been led to believe. Phoebe’s lawyer should not be acting on the authority’s behalf, she said. She called Glenn Singfield, the authority’s chair. According to Tucker, he told her he believed the members of the authority supported the hospital and had taken it upon himself to sign on to the appeal, at Phoebe’s request. She told him his actions “bordered on unethical behavior” and could be seen as a “violation of public trust.” 

Singfield refused to talk to me about the phone call with Tucker but insisted that he was not doing the hospital’s bidding. He said the same to her and later, in a text, promised, “I will protect our independence.” He convened a special meeting of the authority for later that day to take a formal vote on what he’d already done without one. Tucker called as soon as the meeting was over and told me that several members expressed concern about the way Singfield had handled the appeal but still threw their support behind Phoebe. She was the only one who voted against the appeal.

A month later, the Albany City Commission convened to consider Phoebe’s appeal. Mayor Kermit “Bo” Dorough, who had long vowed to rein in Phoebe, oversaw the proceedings. I was watching the livestream but couldn’t see the crowd. Tucker and the mayor told me the room was packed.

Bryant Harden, a political science professor at Mercer University and chair of the preservation commission, spoke first to explain the group’s vote against demolition. Its majority wasn’t opposed to the construction of a nursing school, he said, but the hospital had so many places it could build the new campus without knocking down an important part of the city’s history. What was the harm in considering other options?

The Steiner who took the podium sounded different from the man I’d met during the pandemic. From his first words he was confrontational. He said there were “a few loud people in our country, our state of Georgia and here locally in Dougherty County and Albany that seek to keep us all divided.” The project’s opponents were pushing their “own selfish causes and not what’s in the best interests of our businesses, our people, our police, our region, our nurses, our schools, our churches and certainly not our community.” 

When a city council member asked Steiner about the preservation commission’s plea to find an alternative location for the project, he thought for a second and said: “You know, if you just salvaged the front exterior or the whole building and created the world’s biggest liquor store, it would be OK with the HPC.”

Tucker told me people gasped — the proliferation of liquor stores in poor Black neighborhoods had long been a sensitive subject in Albany — and her hope for a new kind of leadership at Phoebe evaporated. She lamented that Steiner would take “such a cheap shot,” and added, “At that moment, he reminded me of Joel Wernick.”

I’ll admit that I gasped too — not just because it seemed like such a gratuitous comment; it was how it embodied the hospital’s conduct during the entire fight. At every turn, Phoebe sought to beat the preservationists into submission. Ultimately it worked. The City Commission, which includes the mayor, voted unanimously to approve the demolition. “We’ve only got one hospital,” Dorough told me, “and we’re not going to get another one.” 

The preservationists took their fight to the Dougherty County Superior Court and found Phoebe’s reach extended even there. The chief judge recused himself because his daughter worked for the hospital. The next judge, who acknowledged that she served on a bank board with Steiner and Phoebe’s outside counsel, denied the preservationists’ request that she recuse herself and ruled in favor of the demolition.

If that wasn’t enough of a victory, the City Commission voted not to renew two of the four members who had opposed the demolition, prompting two other members to resign in protest. The city commissioners replaced them with four new members. One of them had financial ties to Phoebe, another to Albany Tech. A city commissioner told the Albany Herald that he “certainly wasn’t letting politics get in the way of my vote.” Another said, “We chose who we thought were the best.”

Then Albany and Phoebe turned on Tucker. She had come to the end of her first five-year term on the hospital authority and was up for reappointment, which required a vote by the county commission. Reappointment to the authority had previously been a perfunctory affair. All a sitting member needed to do was to tell the county that they were willing to serve again. Tucker was so sure of it that she didn’t attend the vote. Afterward, however, a clerk called to notify her that she hadn’t been renewed.

I asked a board member who served with Tucker about her removal. He told me that the hospital and the authority didn’t see her as a team player and wanted her off. “She was for sure not reappointed for that reason,” he said. “I have no doubt about that.” (When asked about Phoebe’s role in her departure, a hospital spokesperson said the Dougherty County Commission “has the sole responsibility of deciding whether to reappoint any member.”)

Several weeks later, Tucker addressed the county commission. She had no illusions about getting reinstated, and she had no intention of asking. Nervous and halting, she said that when she joined the hospital authority, she committed herself to serving the public, not Phoebe. The commission’s decision made her wonder whose team they were on. “An independent hospital authority board does not happen in a vacuum,” she said. “It cannot happen if members are removed from the board who question or who point out discrepancies. When they are removed from the board, you can expect that independence will end.”

August 2023

Shortly after her husband died, Mrs. Parker retained a lawyer named Adam Malone. She was prepared to sue, she told her kids, but she was hoping she wouldn’t have to. Malone had won some of the largest malpractice awards in Georgia’s history. But what appealed to Mrs. Parker was that although he lived in Atlanta, he had grown up in Albany. His father had been a prominent lawyer there in the 1950s and ’60s and was one of the few whites willing to collaborate with Black law firms and take on Black clients. If she sued, she believed, Malone would understand the forces he was up against and not be intimidated by them.

Mrs. Parker had no idea what had caused her husband’s death. None of the executives who had sat with her and her family at her husband’s bedside had called or visited to offer an explanation. She’d invited Steiner to speak at the funeral, but that was to keep up appearances. She took his invitation to attend a health system board ceremony in honor of Dr. Parker as evidence of his trying to do the same. Phoebe’s silence felt like a conspiracy. Even worse, at times, were calls from people she and Phoebe had in common. They always left her wondering whose side were they really on. 

It was a question that nagged at her as she considered the lawsuit. She doubted that many of those people would stand with her if she sued — at least not publicly. People like Glenn Singfield, who would check in from time to time to see how she was doing and say how sorry he was about what had happened. She had every right to demand an explanation, he’d say, but she kept her plans to herself because as close as the two were, he was chair of the hospital authority.

The relationship with her husband’s successor at Albany Tech changed, too. He’d been her husband’s protégé, but the school needed the financial boost from its new partnership with Phoebe. She knew he couldn’t risk that project by calling out the hospital. (He did not respond to a request for comment.) 

I asked Mrs. Parker what she thought her husband would have done if he was alive and a different board member had died under the same circumstances. She said she would like to think that he would privately press the hospital for answers, but she doubted that he’d have questioned or criticized the hospital in public. Dr. Parker was a loyal member of the Phoebe family, she said, adding air quotes. Whenever the hospital had come under fire, he gave it the benefit of the doubt, partly because he didn’t want to be marked as a traitor, much less painted as a crank like the people behind Phoebe Factoids, and lose his place on the board, and partly because few people had ever taken on Phoebe and won.

“He wasn’t a naive man,” Mrs. Parker said, “but I think he drank the Kool-Aid.”

In August 2023, 14 months after Dr. Parker died, Mrs. Parker filed a lawsuit against both the hospital and the health system, as well as three members of the anesthesiology team involved in her husband’s operation, accusing them of negligence. She told me she wanted Phoebe to pay restitution to her and her children. She wanted answers about what caused his death, and she believed Phoebe wouldn’t give them to her unless it had to. She wanted to give her husband’s death, and her own future, some meaning. But there was something else. She worried about what message it would send if she didn’t sue: “I don’t want them to get away with it this time.”

CHAPTER 10

Over a couple of days, at the end of last year, Scott Steiner and I talked. He looked like a different person than when we first met. He’d lost a lot of weight. He’d previously struck me as someone who didn’t fuss over his appearance, but it was hard to miss the attention he now paid to his hair, beard and close-fitting blazer. I would have been embarrassed to tell him that he seemed like a guy in the throes of a midlife crisis, but, without prompting, he admitted as much, sharing a picture of his new car: a 1979 Pontiac Trans Am. “It was either a new car or a girlfriend,” he joked. “A car is cheaper.”

With some $200 million in new projects — nearly half of which was funded with county bonds — parts of Phoebe looked different, too. A glass-encased trauma center had recently opened, with an ICU for newborns and a helipad on the roof, which was now the highest point in Albany. At the same time, he’d begun to put several of Phoebe’s unused properties on the market and donated four of them to Habitat for Humanity.

Steiner took me on a short tour of the new living and learning center, whose lobby is dominated by a large mural that includes likenesses of the hospital’s first Black nurses and whose 80 fully furnished apartments have walk-in closets that I told him might qualify as bedrooms in New York City. He pointed out that some of the brick, benches and light fixtures inside the lobby were original to the building. So, too, were some of the arches and moldings on the facade. I’d been warned that he wasn’t going to comment on the Parkers’ lawsuit. Still, I thought it was telling that he didn’t show me Dr. Parker’s portrait, which was hanging in an alcove toward the rear. What was even more telling was how a man who’d made so many changes at Phoebe and who’d insisted that he wanted everyone to let go of past grudges was still quick to raise them. Within 20 minutes after we sat down in the lobby, I asked him how he’d describe Albany to someone who wasn’t from there, and the words “Joel Wernick” were part of his answer.

He’d begun by riffing on how Albany is a “very historical community” and a “melting pot of race.” He said it has “issues like any community” and that Albany’s were crime and poor schools. As for the people, he recalled how friendly they were to him and his wife when they first arrived. He’d gotten used to their tendency to obsess over the things Albany “could have been.” But there were qualities that still really bothered him. “I think there’s a segment of the population that doesn’t want to see it better,” he said. Then he added: “People want to live in the past so much. People still want to talk about Joel Wernick’s shortcomings.” 

I wanted to make clear that’s not why I was there and tried to move the focus of our conversation to some of the things I’d learned during my reporting, like the way diabetes rates spiked in the years after Phoebe acquired Palmyra. I hadn’t come up with a way to explain it, I told Steiner, but in reading the hospital’s nonprofit filings, I couldn’t help noticing that the spike coincided with a decline in the share of revenue that Phoebe spent on preventive health services and on providing free and subsidized care to the poor.

Steiner pointed out that Phoebe’s lease with the county only required it to spend 3% of its revenue on charity care and that it had never never failed to meet that requirement. That was true, I acknowledged, but I reminded him that Phoebe’s own lease analysis showed that at the time Steiner arrived the hospital wasn’t providing as much assistance to the poor as its state and regional peers. Some of them were spending as much as 10% of their revenue on charity care.

Steiner held firm. “But we still met the lease.”

Actually, Steiner had done more than that. After getting the results of the lease analysis, which showed that Phoebe was not spending as big a share of its revenue on free and subsidized care as its peers, he expanded the pool of people who were eligible for assistance. His staff had also increased its efforts to get more patients to apply for care.

Steiner said he wasn’t measuring the hospital’s contributions entirely on dollars spent. “I want to do the most impactful programs. I want to impact the most lives,” he said.

He looked around at the soaring lobby in which we were sitting and talked about how the living and learning center would address one of the biggest drains on the hospital’s budget: traveling doctors and nurses. “People could question: ‘Why’d y’all spend money on this? Y’all spent $40 million, $45 million.’ And yeah, I can understand that, but I also know the cost and the impact of having a rotating staff and that it’s not good. It’s not good financially. It’s not good from a patient care standpoint. It’s not good for our community.”

He said that the nursing shortage at Phoebe was nowhere near what it had been during the pandemic, but that even as we spoke, half of the 500 job openings at the hospital were for nurses. When I asked whether that affected the quality of care, he said, “Absolutely, 100%.”

Speaking about the differences between staff nurses and travelers, he said, “We know that when it’s our own team, when it’s a Phoebe employee, there are less errors and quality’s higher, and we know when it’s contract nurses, there are higher errors, and our patients are less safe.”

I brought up the hospital’s persistently poor quality of care scores — that Phoebe still only had two stars from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, and its grade from the Leapfrog Group, a coalition of large health insurers and leading patient safety experts, had gone down from an A in 2022 to a C in 2024 and remained there in 2025. The ratings reports indicated that the hospital had made improvements in crucial areas like sepsis prevention, but it continued to have trouble with readmission rates, accidental cuts and tears after surgery, bedsores and dangerous blood clots. 

Steiner didn’t deny the findings but criticized them as unreliable because they’re based on data that is at least three years old. CMS’ ratings were particularly misleading, he said, because they included how patients feel about being in the hospital as well as how well a hospital follows standards of care — and no patient likes being in the hospital. “Consumers are inherently unhappy,” he said, “whether it’s Subway, whether it’s a gas station.”

I pressed him to clarify, because Subway sandwiches are different from readmission rates. “I’m just saying there are big chunks of these ratings, they’re saying patient safety is how good the food is,” he said. 

When I returned to the hospital’s high readmission rates, Steiner retreated. “We have work to do, no doubt,” he said and then went back to laying the blame elsewhere. “Would I like to be a five star? Absolutely. But when you look at who four- and five-star hospitals are, they’re usually not in challenging communities that have a lot of poverty.” 

That’s not entirely true. A good number of hospitals with three and four stars are in poor places. What Steiner said next made clear he knew that. “We’re not OK being a one- or two-star hospital,” he said. “We’re not OK being a C. Our community deserves for us to be better.”

Then I talked to Steiner about some of the patients whose stories I’d looked into during my time in Albany. I told him about LaTosha Almond having been sent home with a bedsore so severe she was readmitted to the hospital the day after she’d been discharged, then was sent home with a trach no one had taught her to manage and ultimately died. I also brought up the hospital groundskeeper I’d met at the Samaritan clinic and asked Steiner why he thought a man who worked for a safety-net hospital would have to turn to a free clinic for medical care?

Steiner seemed moved. He told me that he didn’t know Almond but that if what I’d told him was true, there was no excuse for what happened to her. As for the groundskeeper, he was troubled by that story, too. But he painted it as less an indictment of Phoebe and instead as “part of the brokenness in general of the health care system.” He said, “Even though I think we are a safety net — we’re an essential hospital for tens of thousands of people a year — a net still has openings.” He added, “I don’t think the health care system in the United States is set up to help him.”

After about two and a half hours, Steiner’s spokesperson reminded him it was time to wrap up. Before we did, I wanted to go back to something he’d said earlier. He’d told me that when it came to choosing which services Phoebe provides, he made the call, and he wasn’t afraid to be held responsible. What I asked him was: Who holds him to account?

He said something that surprised me. Or perhaps it was me not thinking of Phoebe the way it thinks of itself — as a business. “I hope that our consumers do, right?” he said. “They can do that by electing to get care elsewhere.”

What he didn’t say was that most people in Albany don’t have anywhere else.

A couple of days later, Steiner agreed to meet again. I wondered, with the passage of time, whether he regretted his liquor store comment during the Albany Middle School fight. But nope, he repeated it. “I could have opened Georgia’s largest liquor store, and that group didn’t care,” he told me. “They would’ve said, ‘We approve.’”

For his part, he’d been mulling over what I’d told him about the groundskeeper and the Samaritan clinic. “There’s a fine line between providing everything at no cost and at no responsibility and being able to run any business,” he said. “I think it’s just like somebody walking into a grocery store saying: ‘I’m hungry. My children are hungry. I’m malnourished, so I’m going to fill my cart up and I’m going to walk out.’ Where’s that balance, right?” 

Yes, he said, the hospital’s mission is to provide care regardless of race, religion and ability to pay, “but we’re always trying to balance that out with paying the bills.” He added, “We’ve got human beings’ lives in our hands. Most days we get it absolutely correct, and some days we don’t.”

He reminded me that Phoebe had allowed the clinic to operate in one of the health system’s properties without charging rent. He said it had done so precisely because it understood there were uninsured people who might fall through the cracks. The clinic, he said, was not some separate safety net, it was part of Phoebe’s.

I asked Steiner whether he was aware that the net had collapsed: Samaritan’s offices and exam rooms had been so overtaken by mold that they’d been deemed unsafe and had been shuttered for more than a month. 

A few days later, Nedra Fortson, the clinic’s administrator, called to tell me that Steiner had surprised her with a request to visit the facility. He did a walk-through and arranged for the  clinic to move into another building.

Epilogue

In April, a Dougherty County jury awarded $70 million to a woman from nearby Camilla who had accused Phoebe and three Albany-area physicians of negligence. She charged that the doctors administered an overdose of blood pressure medications without adequate oversight for more than 40 hours. The blood flow to her extremities was severely constricted, she argued, and caused such irreparable damage to her legs they had to be amputated above the knee. She was 28 at the time. 

Phoebe reached a settlement with her before the case went to trial. A spokesperson described what had happened to the patient as “undeniably tragic” but added that “the evidence indicates she would have died without the interventions provided by the care teams.” The physicians held out. They, too, asserted that they had saved the patient’s life. After the verdict — one of the largest in Georgia’s history — the doctors settled for an undisclosed amount. 

I suspected that Phoebe would quickly settle the Parker lawsuit, making it almost impossible for the family to find out what had happened to Dr. Parker. Instead, the case stretched out for almost 20 months, with both parties gathering medical records and conducting depositions. What occurred during his ablation began to emerge. Most damning was a statement from Dr. José Ernesto Betancourt, the cardiologist who oversaw the procedure to correct Dr. Parker’s irregular heartbeat. He described Dr. Parker’s cardiac arrest as a “preventable event,” saying it happened “very unfortunately.”

According to the depositions, Dr. Parker’s blood pressure plummeted so low partway through the procedure that Betancourt paused to make sure that he hadn’t inadvertently punctured Dr. Parker’s heart. Once he determined that he hadn’t, he gave the nurse anesthetist, Alan-Wayne Howard, time to stabilize Dr. Parker with medication, then resumed the procedure, finishing a little before 4 p.m.

At this point, Howard took over Dr. Parker’s care. Neither he nor Betancourt were on staff at the hospital. Both were contract workers. Both lived hours away in Florida but stayed in Albany when on duty. It’s also important to know that Howard was a nurse practitioner, not a doctor. Nurse anesthetists — who have advanced degrees specializing in anesthesia care — are often used at hospitals and surgery centers as a way to cut costs or fill staffing shortages. Because they don’t have the same years of training as a physician, their work is usually done under supervision by an anesthesiologist, who is responsible for the care they provide. He is supposed to check in on them from time to time and is on call for any emergencies. 

Betancourt testified that after the ablation Howard recommended sending Dr. Parker to the ICU for observation before removing his breathing tube and withdrawing anesthesia. He said Howard wanted to make sure Dr. Parker’s vital signs were stable before extubating him, and he also wanted Dr. Parker to have the medical support he needed if his blood pressure crashed. “We will need a couple of hours to be able to titrate down the medication to support the blood pressure until it can be completely withdrawn,” Betancourt recalled Howard saying.

Betancourt agreed with that plan, and he left the recovery room to talk to Mrs. Parker. He said he was gone for 10 minutes.

When he returned, at about 4:44 p.m., he said that he looked in again on Dr. Parker and found that Howard had changed the post-operative plan. The anesthetist had removed the breathing tube and begun withdrawing anesthesia. Betancourt said he was surprised but didn’t question the decision: It was Howard’s call to make. He said he asked how Dr. Parker was doing, and Howard assured him that “everything was great.” He left to start his report.

A minute later, Dr. Parker went into crisis. According to handwritten notes by Dr. Michael Coleman, one of the two anesthesiologists assigned to supervise Howard, Dr. Parker “developed bradycardia and hypotension, leading quickly to asystole.” In lay terms that meant that his heart rate and blood pressure plummeted, losing oxygen to his brain, until his heart eventually stopped. 

In his deposition, Howard said that it wasn’t until 4:54 — nine minutes later — that he summoned Betancourt and Coleman for help. Betancourt said he was at Dr. Parker’s side at 4:55 — 10 minutes with little to no oxygen going to his brain — and began chest compressions. Coleman arrived a minute later and helped Howard reintubate Dr. Parker, whose heart began beating again at 5 p.m.

None of the doctors or nurses who testified could say exactly when Dr. Parker’s heart had stopped beating during that 15-minute window, which is why there was, and still is, confusion about whether his brain went without oxygen for five or 14 minutes. When asked whether her record was reliable, the nurse assigned to keep track of the time testified that “based on my documentation, I don’t think they have an accurate time. No.” 

Howard wasn’t asked during his deposition about why he’d decided to remove respiratory and blood pressure support earlier than initially planned. (His deposition occurred months before Betancourt’s.) However, Howard did let on that he was in a hurry that afternoon. He said that he had hoped to tend to his elderly father in Florida and that Dr. Parker’s procedure went on for so long that he was running late. 

In its initial response to the lawsuit, Phoebe argued that because the health system did not employ “any nurse, physician or advanced practice provider” involved in Dr. Parker’s care, it was not liable for his death. It’s an argument that many hospitals make when they are sued and traveling nurses and doctors are involved. Howard denied that he was negligent “in any manner whatsoever.” 

This summer, Phoebe, the two supervising anesthesiologists and Howard settled for an undisclosed sum. The three clinicians declined to comment. A Phoebe spokesperson said: “While rare, complications like those that occurred in this case are possible with a cardiac ablation. The care provided in this instance matched the standard of care that should be expected, and we do not believe there is evidence of negligence or malpractice.”

As part of the agreement, Mrs. Parker promised not to disclose the sum but made clear that she was relieved that she and the hospital had come to terms before Georgia capped malpractice awards at $1.05 million. By this time Mrs. Parker had moved to South Carolina, where she could be closer to her siblings.

Before leaving Albany, she’d hired painters to help get her house ready to put on the market. The crew’s chief came to the door to express his condolences. He knew a little something about her pain, he said.  

His 35-year-old brother had recently died from sepsis at Phoebe and left him and his family with a lot of questions. Mrs. Parker asked whether they had tried to get answers. The painter shrugged and shook his head no. When she asked him why not, he said, “What good would it do? It’s Phoebe.”

The post Sick in a Hospital Town appeared first on ProPublica.

The Gaza ceasefire deal has prompted urgent questions about who will ultimately govern Palestinian territories. Even Trump has taken notice of Marwan Barghouti.

Police said tourists were among those killed in the fire at Birch By Romeo Lane in Arpora. India’s coastal state of Goa is a popular destination for tourists.

Canadian expert David Vigneault warns of China’s ‘industrial-strength’ attempts to steal new technologies

Hostile spy agencies are now as focused on infiltrating western universities and companies as they are on doing so to governments, according to the former head of Canada’s intelligence service.

David Vigneault warned that a recent “industrial-scale” attempt by China to steal new technologies showed the need for increased vigilance from academics.

Wired published an article by California-based writer/programmer Sheon Han arguing that Ruby "is not a serious programming language." Han believes that the world of programming has "moved on", and "everything Ruby does, another language now does better, leaving it without a distinct niche. Ruby is easy on the eyes. Its syntax is simple, free of semicolons or brackets. More so even thanPython — a language known for its readability — Ruby reads almost like plain English... Ruby, you might've guessed, is dynamically typed. Python and JavaScript are too, but over the years, those communities have developed sophisticated tools to make them behave more responsibly. None of Ruby's current solutions are on par with those. It's far too conducive to what programmers call "footguns," features that make it all too easy to shoot yourself in the foot. Critically, Ruby's performance profile consistently ranks near the bottom (read: slowest) among major languages. You may remember Twitter's infamous "fail whale," the error screen with a whale lifted by birds that appeared whenever the service went down. You could say that Ruby was largely to blame. Twitter's collapse during the 2010 World Cup served as a wake-up call, and the company resolved to migrate its backend to Scala, a more robust language. The move paid off: By the 2014 World Cup, Twitter handled a record 32 million tweets during the final match without an outage. Its new Scala-based backend could process up to 100 times faster than Ruby. In the 2010s, a wave of companies replaced much of their Ruby infrastructure, and when legacy Ruby code remained, new services were written in higher-performance languages. You may wonderwhy people are still using Ruby in 2025. It survives because of its parasitic relationship with Ruby on Rails, the web framework that enabled Ruby's widespread adoption and continues to anchor its relevance.... Rails was the framework of choice for a new generation of startups. The main code bases of Airbnb, GitHub, Twitter, Shopify, and Stripe were built on it. He points out on Stack Overflow's annual developer survey, Ruby has slipped from a top-10 technology in 2013 to #18 this year — "behind evenAssembly" — calling Ruby "a kind of professional comfort object, sustained by the inertia of legacy code bases and the loyalty of those who first imprinted upon it." But the article drew some criticism on X.com. ("You should do your next piece about how Vim isn't a serious editor and continue building your career around nerd sniping developers.") Other reactions... "Maybe WIRED is just not a serious medium..." "FWIW — Ruby powered Shopify through another Black Friday / Cyber Monday — breaking last year's record." "Maybe you should have taken a look at TypeScript..." Wired's subheading argues that Ruby "survives on affection, not utility. Let's move on." Are they right? Share your own thoughts and experiences in the comments. Is Ruby still a 'serious' programming language?

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The war against Ukraine has hit ordinary Russians hard, and the deteriorating situation is likely to inflame tensions

People in Britain who think they are governed by fools should take a closer look at the Russian and US presidents. Vladimir Putin is systematically ruining his country. His war of choice in Ukraine is an economic, financial, geopolitical and human calamity for Russia that worsens by the day. For his own murky reasons, Donald Trump, another national menace, offered him a lifeline last week. Yet Putin spurned it. These two fools deserve each other.

On the table in Moscow was a “peace” deal that, broadly speaking, rewarded Russia’s aggression by handing over large chunks of Ukrainian land, compromised Kyiv’s independence and weakened its defences against any future attack. The Trump deal, if forced through, would have split the US and Europe; ruptured Nato, perhaps fatally; reprieved Russia’s pariah economy; and probably toppled Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s government.

Simon Tisdall is a Guardian foreign affairs commentator

Some more raw footage from our SuperFlux 5" testing

Easy-to-guess words and figures still dominate, alarming cysbersecurity experts and delighting hackers

It is a hacker’s dream. Even in the face of repeated warnings to protect online accounts, a new study reveals that “admin” is the most commonly used password in the UK.

The second most popular, “123456”, is also unlikely to keep hackers at bay.

As peace hopes falter, infantry soldiers face more long deployments risking their lives against Russian attacks

For almost all of their 62-day deployment on the frontline east of Pokrovske, Bohdan and Ivan hid – first in a village shop, then, after a deadly firefight with Russian soldiers, in a tiny basement where the infantrymen from Ukraine’s 31st Brigade had to survive seven more weeks.

Food, water, cigarettes and other supplies were airlifted in by a friendly drone, their toilet was their 3 sq metre room, their nearest comrades 200 metres or so away. Their only hope was to remain underground, because they knew if they were detected a Russian drone could kill them all.

Fire broke out at midnight in Arpora with victims mostly kitchen workers, according to state’s chief minister

At least 25 people have been killed in a fire at a nightclub in Goa, an Indian state popular for its nightlife and tourism.

Several tourists were among the 25 dead in the fire, which broke out at about midnight at Birch by Romeo Lane, a popular restaurant, cocktail bar and club in Arpora, a district of north Goa.

Jolla is "trying again with a new crowd-funded smartphone," reports Phoronix: Finnish company Jolla started out 14 years ago where Nokia left off with MeeGo and developed Sailfish OS as a new Linux smartphone platform. Jolla released their first smartphone in 2013 after crowdfunding but ultimately the Sailfish OS focus the past number of years now has been offering their software stack for use on other smartphone devices [including some Sony Xperia smartphones and OnePlus/Samsung/ Google/ Xiaomi devices]. This new Jolla Phone's pre-order voucher page says the phone will only produced if 2,000 units are ordered before January 4. (But in just a few days they've already received 1,721 pre-orders — all discounted to 499€ from a normal price between 599 and 699 €). Estimate delivery is the first half of 2026. "The new Jolla Phone is powered by a high-performing Mediatek 5G SoC," reports 9to5Linux, "and features 12GB RAM, 256GB storage that can be expanded to up to 2TB with a microSDXC card, a 6.36-inch FullHD AMOLED display with ~390ppi, 20:9 aspect ratio, and Gorilla Glass, and a user-replaceable 5,500mAh battery." The Linux phone also features 4G/5G support with dual nano-SIM and a global roaming modem configuration, Wi-Fi 6 wireless, Bluetooth 5.4, NFC, 50MP Wide and 13MP Ultrawide main cameras, front front-facing wide-lens selfie camera, fingerprint reader on the power key, a user-changeable back cover, and an RGB indication LED. On top of that, the new Jolla Phone promises a user-configurable physical Privacy Switch that lets you turn off the microphone, Bluetooth, Android apps, or whatever you wish. The device will be available in three colors, including Snow White, Kaamos Black, and The Orange. All the specs of the new Jolla Phone were voted on by Sailfish OS community members over the past few months. Honouring the original Jolla Phone form factor and design, the new model ships with Sailfish OS (with support for Android apps), a Linux-based European alternative to dominating mobile operating systems that promises a minimum of 5 years of support, no tracking, no calling home, and no hidden analytics... The device will be manufactured and sold in Europe, but Jolla says that it will design the cellular band configuration to enable global travelling as much as possible, including e.g. roaming in the U.S. carrier networks. The initial sales markets are the EU, the UK, Switzerland, and Norway.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

US defense secretary Pete Hegseth under siege over mishandling of classified military intelligence and Caribbean boat attacks. Key US politics stories from 6 December 2025

Pete Hegseth is facing the most serious crisis of his tenure as defense secretary, engulfed by allegations of war crimes in the Caribbean and a blistering inspector general report accusing him of mishandling classified military intelligence.

But Hegseth shows no signs of stepping down and still holds Donald Trump’s support.

Washington Post columnist Dana Milbank calls himself "a highly creative hypochondriac" — who just paid for an expensive MRI scan to locate abnormal spots as tiny as 2 millimeters. He discusses the pros and cons of its "diffusion-weighted imaging" technology combined with the pattern recognition of AI, which theoretically "has the potential to save our lives by revealing budding cancers, silent aneurysms and other hidden would-be killers before they become deadly. " But the scans cost $2,500 a pop and insurance won't pay. Worse, for every cancer these MRIs find, they produce a slightly greater number of false positives that require a biopsy, with the potential for infection and bleeding and emotional distress. Even when the scans don't produce a false positive, they almost always come up with some vague and disconcerting abnormality.... Will we feel better after viewing our insides? Or will we become anxious about things we hadn't even thought to worry about? Part of living has always been in the mystery, in not knowing what tomorrow will bring. Now, because of sophisticated imaging, genome sequencing and other revolutionary screening tools, we can have predictability, or at least the illusion of it. But do we want that? The American College of Radiology says we do not. Its still-current 2023 statement says there is not "sufficient evidence" to recommend full-body screening, cautioning that the scan could lead to needless testing and expense. But David Larson, chair of ACR's Commission on Quality and Safety, told me that could change as more data comes in. "When people ask me, 'Would you recommend it?' I would say it depends on your tolerance for ambiguity," he said, giving the example of somebody found to have a borderline aortic aneurysm who is advised to wait and monitor it. If "that won't keep you up at night, then I wouldn't necessarily recommend against it...." About 1 in 20 gets that dreaded call. A study Prenuvo presented earlier this year of 1,011 participants found that 4.9 percent of scans required a follow-up biopsy. Of those, 2.2 percent were actually cancer, and the other 2.7 percent were false positives. Of the 22 cancers the scans caught, 86 percent of patients had no specific symptoms. But if finding something truly awful is rare, finding something abnormal is almost guaranteed. [Vikash Modi, Prenuvo's senior medical director of preventative medicine] said only 1 in 20 scans come back completely clean. The vast majority of patients wind up in the ambiguous realm where something may look suspicious but doesn't require urgent follow-up. He opted for the cheaper $1,000 torso scan, which the senior medical director calls "our bread-and-butter area," since 17 of the 22 cancers detected in one Prenuvo study were in that area and is where they often find cancers that wouldn't be discovered until they were incurable like "that scary pancreatic stuff...." Milbank's scan found 12 "abnormalities" included "a 2.5 mm pulmonary nodule in the right lower lobe" and "a 4.6 mm intraductal papillary mucinous neoplasm in the pancreatic tail" — but with 10 abnormalities labeled "minor" (and six being musculoskeletal wear-and-tear problems "I already knew about from the usual aches and pains".) Even the two "moderate" findings didn't sound that grim when I read on. The "indeterminant lesion" in my lung requires no follow-up, while the thing in my pancreas is "low-risk."... The "most interesting" finding was the pancreatic cyst, because, at this size and location, there's a 3 percent chance it will become cancerous in the next five years. But if annual follow-up scans of my pancreas (covered by insurance) show it's getting bigger, the cyst can be removed before it becomes cancer. For me, this made the MRI worthwhile. Sure, there was a 97 percent likelihood the cyst never would develop into a problem even if I hadn't learned about it. But now, with minimal inconvenience, I can eliminate that 3 percent risk of getting pancreatic cancer, the most lethal of major malignancies.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Want an Apple-centric smart home setup? We've put together this roundup of our favorite HomeKit devices, many of which make excellent gifts.

Here are hints and the answers for the NYT Connections: Sports Edition puzzle No. 440 for Sunday, Dec. 7.

Here are the answers for The New York Times Mini Crossword for Sunday, Dec. 7.

Inter Miami survived a remarkable double-post escape before Messi and friends sealed the club’s first MLS Cup, giving Busquets and Alba a storybook farewell

The ball was going over the line. Surely. Definitely. Inter Miami would be behind. Lionel Messi’s chance at capturing the trophy he most wanted to win would be teetering on a knife’s edge. And perhaps most distressingly to Inter Miami, two retiring legends, Sergi Busquets and Jordi Alba, would be closing in on ignominious ends. They would have come to MLS to accompany Messi, their friend, but would end their time on the field as losers of a final, the type of game they so often won at club and international level.

All that ball had to do was cross the line. The Vancouver Whitecaps’ Emmanuel Sabbi had imbued it with a seeming destiny after a virtuoso run into the heart of the Inter Miami defense. His left-footed effort wrapped around the outstretched hand of Miami goalkeeper Rocco Ríos Novo. It smacked the inside of the far post. It bounced on the line.

Positive tone after Florida talks with Ukrainian president heading to London Street to see Starmer, Macron and Merz. What we know on day 1,383

Here are hints and the answer for today's Wordle for Dec. 7, No. 1,632.

Here are hints and answers for the NYT Strands puzzle for Dec. 7, No. 644.

Here are some hints and the answers for the NYT Connections puzzle for Dec. 7, No. 910

Japanese officials said Jeremy O Harris, known for his Tony-nominated "Slave Play" and his role in the series "Emily in Paris," was arrested on the island of Okinawa on Nov. 16.

"We're reviewing the process, and we'll see," Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said. "Whatever we were to decide to release, we'd have to be very responsible about reviewing that right now."

Just because the weather outside is frightful doesn't mean it has to be cold inside. Our CNET experts recommend these top space heaters.

President Trump presented medals to the 2025 Kennedy Center honorees during an Oval Office ceremony.

"First the penny. Next, paper checks?" asks CNN: When the U.S. Mint stopped making pennies last month for the first time in 238 years, it drew a lot of attention. But there have been quiet moves to stop using paper checks as well. The government stopped sending out most paper checks to recipients as of the end of September, part of an effort to fully modernize federal benefits payments. And on Thursday the Federal Reserve put out a notice that suggested it is considering — but only considering — the "winding down" of checking services it now provides for banks. The central bank's statement said that as an alternative to winding down those services, it is mulling more investment in its check processing services, but noted that would come at a higher cost. But it is also considering not making any such investments, in order to keep costs roughly unchanged. That would lead to reduced reliability of those services going forward. "Over time, check use has steadily declined, digital payment methods have grown in availability and use, and check fraud has risen," said the notice from the Fed. "Also, the Reserve Banks will need to make substantial investments in their check infrastructure to continue providing the same level of check services going forward." A report from the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta in June found that as of last year, more than 90% of surveyed consumers said they prefer to use something other than a check for paying bills, and just 6% paid by check. That's a sharp drop from the 18% of bills paid by checks as recently as 2017. Consumers also reported they view checks as second-worst for convenience and speed of payment, ahead of only money orders. And they're ranked as the least secure form of any payment other than cash. But even if it's true that options such as direct deposit, automatic bill paying and electronic payment systems such as Venmo, PayPal and Zelle have all reduced the need for traditional checks, paper checks are still an important part of the payment system. They make up about 5% of transactions and represent 21% of the value of all those payments, according to a statement from Michelle Bowman, the Fed's vice chair for supervision, who dissented from the Fed's Thursday statement.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Get a natural wake up feeling at any time of day with a sunrise alarm clock.

At event in California, US defense secretary says Trump has power to take military action ‘as he sees fit’

Pete Hegseth on Saturday doubled down on his defense of US military strikes on alleged drug cartel boats in the Caribbean, arguing that Donald Trump has the power to take military action “as he sees fit” and dismissing concerns that the strikes violate international law.

Hegseth spoke on Saturday at the Ronald Reagan presidential library in Simi Valley, California, amid growing scrutiny over the legality of the attacks and his leadership of the Pentagon.

We've completelely overhauled our robot vacuum testing to include new checks for pickup power, navigation, obstacle avoidance and more. These are the models that stood out for us in 2025.

George Strait, ‘Sly’ Stallone and Kiss accept medals from president, who says he was ‘98% involved’ in choosing them

Donald Trump on Saturday evening hosted the 2025 Kennedy Center honorees in the Oval Office for a medal-presentation ceremony, celebrating country music singer George Strait, actor-singer Michael Crawford, actor Sylvester “Sly” Stallone and the members of the rock band Kiss.

“This is a great evening, it’s a great honor,” Trump said. “And I’m delighted to welcome to the Oval Office – the world-famous, most famous office in the world, most powerful office in the world – our truly exceptional 2025 Kennedy Center honorees.”

Senior officer had told MPs some Jewish representatives did not want Maccabi Tel Aviv fans at Aston Villa game classified as high risk

A senior police officer has apologised to Birmingham’s Jewish residents after he told MPs that some had expressed support for the exclusion of Maccabi Tel Aviv fans from attending last month’s match against Aston Villa.

The decision to ban supporters of the Israeli team from the Europa League game at Villa Park in Birmingham had triggered political uproar, including Keir Starmer saying he was “angered by the decision”.

Bloomberg reports that Google "must renegotiate any contract to make its search engine or artificial intelligence app the default for smartphones and other devices every year, a federal judge ruled." Judge Amit Mehta in Washington sided with the US Justice Department on the one year limitation in his final ruling on what changes the search giant must make in the wake of a landmark ruling that the company illegally monopolized online search. The yearly renegotiation will give rivals — particularly those in the burgeoning generative AI field — a chance to compete for key placements. The final judgment will still allow Google to offer its products to Apple Inc. for use in its popular iPhone and pay other electronics makers like Samsung Electronics Co. for default placement. But the judge said those contracts must be renegotiated annually. Mehta noted in his ruling that both Google and the US government said they could work with the one-year limitation on default contracts. As such, "the court holds that a hard-and-fast termination requirement after one year would best carry out the purpose of the injunctive relief."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The 63-year-old Roger Clemens has been accused of using performance-enhancing drugs, which he has denied.

Lionel Messi and Inter Miami CF are Major League Soccer champions, defeating Vancouver Whitecaps FC 3-1 and earning their first MLS Cup title on Saturday.

• Inter Miami defeat Vancouver for MLS championship

• Messi pulls strings on all three goals in 3-1 win

3 min: Miami pinned Vancouver deep in their own half for quite a while, and after a short break the other way, they get it back. Allende gets the first shot of the game, putting it over from near the corner of the penalty area.

1 min: The atmosphere is lively as we have a frantic midfield battle, with neither team sustaining possession.

"Woman Hailed as Hero for Smashing Man's Meta Smart Glasses on Subway," reads the headline at Futurism: As Daily Dot reports, a New York subway rider has accused a woman of breaking his Meta smart glasses. "She just broke my Meta glasses," said the TikTok user, who goes by eth8n, in a video that has since garnered millions of views. "You're going to be famous on the internet!" he shouted at her through the window after getting off the train. The accused woman, however, peered back at him completely unfazed, as if to say that he had it coming. "I was making a funny noise people were honestly crying laughing at," he claimed in the caption of a followup video. "She was the only person annoyed..." But instead of coming to his support, the internet wholeheartedly rallied behind the alleged perpetrator, celebrating the woman as a folk hero — and perfectly highlighting how the public feels about gadgets like Meta's smart glasses. "Good, people are tired of being filmed by strangers," one user commented. "The fact that no one else on the train is defending him is telling," another wrote... Others accused the man of fabricating details of the incident. "'People were crying laughing' — I've never heard a less plausible NYC subway story," one user wrote. In a comment on TikTok, the man acknowledges he'd filmed her on the subway — it looks like he even zoomed in. The man says then her other options were "asking nicely to not post it or blur my face". He also warns that she could get arrested for breaking his glasses if he "felt like it". (And if he sees her again.) "I filed a claim with the police and it's a misdemeanor charge." A subsequent video's captions describe him unboxing new Meta smartglasses "and I'm about to do my thing again... no crazy lady can stop me now." I'm imagining being mugged — and then telling the mugger "You're going to be internet famous!" But maybe that just shows how easy it is to weaponize smartglasses and their potential for vast public exposure.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Mediators of delicate truce say troop removal and deployment of international force crucial to second phase

Qatar and Egypt, the guarantors of the Gaza ceasefire, called on Saturday for the withdrawal of Israeli troops and the deployment of an international stabilisation force as the necessary next steps in fully implementing the fragile agreement.

The measures were spelt out in the US- and UN-backed peace plan that has largely halted fighting, though the warring parties have yet to agree on how to move forward from the deal’s first phase.

California's public health department said one person has died and several others have suffered severe liver damage due to eating toxic mushrooms that were foraged.

• Messi sparks Miami’s opening goal

• De Paul scores 71st-minute winner

• Inter Miami 3-1 Vancouver – as it happened

As the confetti flew, the Philip F Anschutz trophy was lifted into the air, and a player commonly thought to be the greatest ever to kick a ball celebrated the 48th title of his professional career, it was nearly impossible to believe that at several points, there were doubts. Serious doubts. Questions, large and small, about this Inter Miami squad, their manager, and nearly every player on the roster other than Lionel Messi.

Consider them answered. The Herons are MLS Cup champions after a 3-1 win over the Vancouver Whitecaps in the last game at their temporary home, Chase Stadium in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Next year, they will open their new stadium, Miami Freedom Park, as champions, and will face a high bar to clear to top a turbulent 2025 that saw them play 58 games – an all-time MLS record for games played by a team in a calendar year – for five separate trophies.

Winter storms are forecast to bring heavy snows and bitter winds across the regions.

White House decision is part of $140m settlement over flight chaos during busy December travel period

The Trump administration said on Saturday it will waive an $11m fine imposed on Southwest Airlines as part of a $140m settlement over the carrier’s meltdown in December 2022 during a busy holiday travel period.

Southwest in December 2023 agreed to pay a $35m cash fine over three years over the airline’s handling of the meltdown that stranded more than 2 million passengers. It also agreed to provide $90m in travel vouchers of $75 or more to passengers delayed at least three hours getting to final destinations because of an airline-caused issue or cancellation.

Michael Annett won the Xfinity Series' season-opening race at Daytona International Speedway in 2019.

"Researchers engineered a strained germanium layer on silicon that allows charge to move faster than in any silicon-compatible material to date," reports Science Daily. "This record mobility could lead to chips that run cooler, faster, and with dramatically lower energy consumption. "The discovery also enhances the prospects for silicon-based quantum devices..." Scientists from the University of Warwick and the National Research Council of Canada have reported the highest "hole mobility" ever measured in a material that works within today's silicon-based semiconductor manufacturing.... The researchers created a nanometer-thin germanium epilayer on silicon that is placed under compressive strain. This engineered structure enables electric charge to move faster than in any previously known silicon-compatible material... The findings establish a promising new route for ultra-fast, low-power semiconductor components. Potential uses include quantum information systems, spin qubits, cryogenic controllers for quantum processors, AI accelerators, and energy-efficient servers designed to reduce cooling demands in data centers. This achievement also represents a significant accomplishment for Warwick's Semiconductors Research Group and highlights the UK's growing influence in advanced semiconductor materials research.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

FIFA released the World Cup schedule on Saturday that will feature 104 matches spread across 11 cities in the United States, with three in Mexico and two in Canada.

Several additional people, including children, have severe liver damage amid 21 cases of amatoxin poisoning

California officials are warning foragers after an outbreak of poisoning linked to wild mushrooms that has killed one adult and caused severe liver damage in several patients, including children.

The state poison control system has identified 21 cases of amatoxin poisoning, likely caused by death cap mushrooms, the health department said Friday. The toxic wild mushrooms are often mistaken for edible ones because of their appearance and taste.

The Taliban made women's sports illegal in 2021 when the U.S. withdrew from Afghanistan, but it hasn't stopped a group of refugees in Houston determined to forge their own way on the soccer pitch.

"A structure designed to prevent radioactive leakage at the defunct Chernobyl nuclear plant in Ukraine is no longer operational," reports Politico, "after Russian drones targeted it earlier this year, the U.N.'s nuclear watchdog has found." [T]he large steel structure "lost its primary safety functions, including the confinement capability" when its outer cladding was set ablaze after being struck by Russian drones, according to a new report by the International Atomic Energy Agency. Beyond that, there was "no permanent damage to its load-bearing structures or monitoring systems," it said. "Limited temporary repairs have been carried out on the roof, but timely and comprehensive restoration remains essential to prevent further degradation and ensure long-term nuclear safety," IAEA Director General Rafael Mariano Grossi said in astatement. The Guardian has pictures of the protective shield — incuding the damage from the drone strike. The shield is the world's largest movable land structure, reports CNN: The IAEA, which has a permanent presence at the site, will "continue to do everything it can to support efforts to fully restore nuclear safety and security," Grossi said.... Built in 2010 and completed in 2019, it was designed to last 100 years and has played a crucial role in securing the site. The project cost €2.1 billion and was funded by contributions from more than 45 donor countries and organizations through the Chernobyl Shelter Fund, according to the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, which in 2019 hailed the venture as "the largest international collaboration ever in the field of nuclear safety."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Police launch ‘manhunt’ after 25 people are shot in early morning in township attack west of Pretoria

Gunmen have stormed into a hostel in South Africa’s capital and killed at least 12 people, including a three-year-old child, and injured more than a dozen others.

Police said they had launched a “manhunt” for three people and were investigating whether the killings were linked to a bar within the hostel that may have been selling alcohol illegally.

Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani told an international conference in the Qatari capital that international mediators, led by the U.S., are working toward the second phase of peace deal.

Three-person escape is second for state in a year, after 10 people crawled through a wall at a different prison

Two inmates accused of violent crimes, including second-degree attempted murder, are on the run after escaping from a south-western Louisiana jail on Wednesday by removing pieces of a deteriorating interior wall and using sheets to scale another outside wall, officials said.

A third inmate who joined in the breakout died by suicide after he was tracked down.

President Donald Trump directed a review of international vaccine schedules after a CDC panel under Robert F. Kennedy Jr. cited divergent timelines elsewhere.

Wondering if whole-body vibration has any real benefit? Here's what experts say about its effectiveness for weight loss.

From his home town of Los Angeles, the architect designed a career around defying what was predictable

In Frank Gehry’s world, no building was left untilted, unexposed or untouched by unconventional material. The Canadian-American architect, who died in his Los Angeles home at 96, designed a career around defying what was predictable and pulling in materials that were uncommon and, as such, relatively inexpensive.

Gehry collaborated with artists to turn giant binoculars into an entryway of a commercial campus, and paid homage to a writer’s past as a lifeguard by creating a livable lifeguard tower. And while dreaming this up, he transformed American architecture along the way.

Here's when you can watch more of the hit series set in West Texas.

Patty Murray of Washington state said ICE agents lied to Wilmer Toledo-Martinez to lure him outside before dog attacked him

A US senator has condemned the Trump administration after she alleged that an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) “attack dog” mauled one of her constituents.

Democratic senator Patty Murray of Washington state said Wilmer Toledo-Martinez suffered “horrific” injuries while ICE agents detained him in November.

To build three-wheeled, solar electric vehicles, Aptera has now launched its "validation" vehicle assembly line, reports the San Diego Business Journal. "The validation line will set a technical foundation for the company's eventual low-volume assembly line, ensuring that manufacturing processes are optimized and refined, particularly for the company's composite body structure." To date, Aptera has produced three validation vehicles, two of which are in use driving around the San Diego region, with plans to build another 10 in the coming weeks as progress continues on the validation manufacturing line. "You learn things when you start to put miles on vehicles, putting 10s of thousands of miles on these validation vehicles and learning a lot from the durometer of the suspension, ride quality, spring rates and braking pressure," Aptera co-founder and co-CEO Chris Anthony said. "We've been able to incorporate a lot of the usability stuff back, but also, just as we've gone through the process of building these, a lot of order-of-operation stuff that's educated us on what's going to make for the best initial assembly lines," he added.... Aptera made its public debut on October 16, with the company's executive team participating in the Nasdaq closing bell ceremony that evening. Shares of SEV have hovered between $6.50 and $8.50 for much of the company's first month on the exchange. The company's equity line of credit also took effect in mid-November... expected to aid in Aptera generating at least a portion of the $65 million the company has said it will need to complete validation manufacturing and begin low-volume production for customers. Aptera previously raised some $135 million from more than 17,000 investors in what the company touts as the most successful crowdfunding effort of all time, but Anthony argued Aptera will soon need to invest larger sums of capital to scale its production needs. "Publicly listing the company gives us a lot more funding mechanisms to get into production," he said. "So just having access to the public markets, public liquidity and the kind of instruments and tools that banks offer to public companies, it just seemed like now is the right time." Alongside the IPO, Aptera made its formal transition to a Public Benefit Corporation, giving the company a legal obligation to consider its effect on employees, communities and customers in addition to the profit motives of its shareholders. California's state government also awarded Aptera $21 million "to support its push toward scaled manufacturing," the article points out. It also notes that Aptera's vehicles "are technically classified as motorcycles rather than standard passenger cars, presenting a potentially cheaper alternative for consumers on the hunt for an electric vehicle."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

• England to play Croatia at Dallas Cowboys’ stadium

• Scotland’s opener against Haiti starts 2am UK time

England will kick off their World Cup campaign against Croatia in Dallas at 9pm UK time on Wednesday 17 June. They will play at the Dallas Stadium, home of the NFL’s Cowboys, which has a retractable roof and air conditioning. That will mitigate the effects of a 4pm EST kick-off (3pm local time). The roof will be closed for the opener.

England learned the specifics of their group phase schedule at part two of the World Cup draw in Washington DC, on Saturday. Their second game, against Ghana, on 23 June, will be played in Foxborough, near Boston at 4pm EST. It is an open-air stadium. The average June daily temperate high there is 26C.

Andrew Wolfe was shot in the head on 26 November, while Sarah Beckstrom died from her injuries

The West Virginia national guard soldier who was wounded in the 26 November shooting that killed a colleague of his in Washington DC is “slowly healing”, according to West Virginia’s governor.

Andrew Wolfe, 24, was shot alongside fellow West Virginia national guard soldier Sarah Beckstrom, 20, while they patrolled the US capital as part of the Trump administration’s push to deploy military members on to the city’s streets. Beckstrom died of her injuries the day after she was shot while Wolfe was hospitalized in critical condition.

Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz will also be present for talks on guaranteeing Ukraine’s postwar security

Volodymyr Zelenskyy will visit Downing Street on Monday for an in-person meeting with Keir Starmer, Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz in a show of support for Ukraine.

Starmer will use the meeting with the leaders from Ukraine, France and Germany to discuss the continuing talks between US and Ukrainian officials aimed at finding an agreement on guaranteeing Ukraine’s postwar security.

What happened when a school in Los Angeles gave a sixth grader an iPad for use throughout the school day? "He used the iPad during school to watch YouTube and participate in Fortnite video game battles," reports NBC News. His mother has now launched a coalition of parents called Schools Beyond Screens "organizing in WhatsApp groups, petition drives and actions at school board meetings and demanding meetings with district administrators, pressuring them to pull back on the school-mandated screen time." Los Angeles Unified is the first district of its size to face an organized — and growing — campaign by parents demanding that schools pull back on mandatory screen time. The discontent in Los Angeles Unified, the second-largest school district in the country, reflects a growing unease nationally about the amount of time children spend learning through screens in classrooms. While a majority of states prohibit children from using cellphones in class, 88% of schools provide students with personal devices, according to the National Center for Education Statistics, often Chromebook laptops or iPads. The parents hope getting a district that has over 409,000 students across nearly 800 schools to change how it approaches screen time would send a signal across public school districts to pull back from a yearslong effort to digitize classrooms.... [In the Los Angeles school district] Students in grade levels as low as kindergarten are provided iPads, and some schools require them to take the tablets home. Some teachers have allowed students to opt out of the iPad-based assignments, but other parents say they've been told that they can't. Parents can also opt their children out of having access to YouTube and several other Google products... The billion-dollar 2014 initiative to give tablet computers to everyone became a scandal after the bidding process appeared to heavily favor Apple, and it faced criticism once it became clear that students could bypass security protocols and that few teachers used the tablets. Currently, the district leaves it up to individual schools to decide whether they want students to take home iPads or Chromebooks every day and how much time they spend on them in class... Around 300 parents attended listening sessions the district held last month about technology in the classroom. Nearly all who spoke criticized how much screen time schools gave their children in class, pointing to ways their behavior and grades suffered as students watched YouTube and played Minecraft... Several also asked district officials to explain why children as young as kindergartners were asked to sign a form to use devices in which they promised they would honor intellectual property law and refrain from meeting people in person whom they met online. "Is it possible for children to meet people over the internet on school-issued devices?" one father asked. The district officials declined to answer, saying it was meant to be a listening session. In 2022, Los Angeles Unified started requiring students to complete benchmark assessments on educaitonal software i-Ready, the article points out, which generates unique questions for each students. "But parents and teachers are unable to see what children are asked, in part because the company that makes the program considers them proprietary information..." One teacher says his school's administartors are requiring him to use i-Ready even though it doesn't have any material for the science class he's actually teaching. He's also noticed some students will use answers from AI chatbots, bypassing the school's monitoring software by creating alternate user profiles. But the monitoring software company suggests the school misconfigured their software's settings, adding "More commonly, when students attempt to bypass filtering or monitoring, they do so by using proxies." Thanks to long-time Slashdot reader schwit1 for sharing the article.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Ahmed al-Sharaa says Israel justifies aggression in the name of security amid airstrikes on southern Syria

Syria’s interim president has accused Israel of fighting “ghosts” and exporting its crises to other countries after the war in Gaza.

President Ahmed al-Sharaa’s comments come amid persistent airstrikes and incursions by the Israeli military into southern Syria.

Party leader leaves latest recruit, Malcolm Offord, to field questions on antisemitism allegations at Scotland rally

Nigel Farage has addressed Reform UK’s largest rally in Scotland to date but refused to engage with local journalists – leaving the newly defected peer Malcolm Offord to field questions on allegations of racism and antisemitism.

Farage introduced the former Conservative peer and millionaire donor Offord at a sold-out rally of about 700 at a hotel conference centre near Falkirk.

Neil Couling said failings by individual claimants ‘at the heart’ of crisis, despite a report finding DWP shortcomings ‘unacceptable’

One of the most senior civil servants in the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) has placed the blame for the carer’s allowance benefits crisis on victims, many of who have been left with life-changing debts.

In an internal blogpost written for Whitehall colleagues, Neil Couling, the director general of DWP services, said individual failings by carers were “at the heart” of the issue that has been likened to the Post Office Horizon scandal.

Maria Corina Machado has been living in hiding in Venezuela since the 2024 presidential election.

Over a dozen people were wounded and taken to the hospital, the South African Police Services said in a statement.

The penultimate episode of the Stephen King series is titled The Black Spot.

Video shows Coast Guard vehicles pursuing a go-fast vessel that appeared to have multiple people aboard.

While Netflix hopes to buy Warner Bros. Discovery for $72 billion, CNBC reports a senior official in America's federal government said the administration was viewing the deal with "heavy skepticism. And that's not the only hurdle: On Thursday, The Wall Street Journal reported that Paramount, in a letter to lawyers for Warner Bros. Discovery [WBD], had warned that a sale to Netflix likely would "never close" because of regulatory challenges in the United States and overseas. "Acquiring Warner's streaming and studio assets 'will entrench and extend Netflix's global dominance in a matter not allowed by domestic or foreign competition laws,' Paramount's lawyers wrote," the Journal reported. Paramount "is now weighing its options about whether to go straight to shareholders with one more improved bid," CNBC reported Friday, "perhaps even higher than the $30-per-share, all-cash offer it submitted to Warner Bros. Discovery this week." And CNBC reported Friday that the review by America's Department of Justice "can take anywhere from months to more than a year." Netflix said Friday it expects the transaction to close in 12 to 18 months, after Warner Bros. Discovery spins out its portfolio of cable networks into Discovery Global... As part of the deal, Netflix has agreed to pay a $5.8 billion breakup fee to Warner Bros. Discovery if the deal were to get blocked by the government. Netflix's planned move is already drawing high-powered criticism, reports CNN: "The world's largest streaming company swallowing one of its biggest competitors is what antitrust laws were designed to prevent. The outcome would eliminate jobs, push down wages, worsen conditions for all entertainment workers, raise prices for consumers, and reduce the volume and diversity of content for all viewers...." the Writers Guild of America union representing Hollywood writers. "Producers are rightfully concerned... Our legacy studios are more than content libraries — within their vaults are the character and culture of our nation." — The Producers Guild of AmericaThe deal raises "many serious questions" about the entertainment industry's future, "especially the human creative talent whose livelihoods and careers depend on it." — SAG-AFTRA, Hollywood's biggest actors union "This is not a win for consumers. Netflix has already aggressively raised prices, increased ad load, and stopped people from sharing passwords. Absorbing a competitor with strong content will only lead to its service becoming more expensive and give consumers less choice." — Ross Benes, a senior analyst at eMarketer, told CNN. [Benes also thinks this could mean fewer companies spending heavily on movies and TV shows. "This contracts the industry."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The top sports streaming services for you depend on your favorite sports. We've analyzed the options, covering everything from the NFL and NBA to soccer and UFC.

Beijing security agency accuses international journalists of disregarding facts and smearing government

Beijing’s security agency in Hong Kong has summoned international journalists to inform them it will not tolerate “trouble-making”, following critical coverage of the deadly apartment complex fire that has left the territory reeling.

Senior reporters from several media outlets operating in the city were called to the Office for Safeguarding National Security (OSNS), which was set up by Beijing in 2020.

Another escaped inmate killed himself after being recognized by a tipster and police responded

Two inmates accused of violent crimes, including second-degree attempted murder, are on the run after escaping from a south-western Louisiana jail on Wednesday by removing pieces of a deteriorating interior wall and using sheets to scale another outside wall, officials said.

A third inmate who joined in the breakout died by suicide after he was tracked down.

The Georgian superstar is going for a fourth successive defense of his Bantamweight crown.

Four people arrested after civil-resistance group Take Back Power protest against inequality in the UK

Part of the Tower of London was temporarily closed to visitors on Saturday after food was thrown at a display case containing the crown jewels in a protest against inequality in the UK.

Four people were arrested after the action, which was claimed by Take Back Power – a self-described, non-violent civil-resistance group. It said custard and apple crumble was flung at the case, which contained the imperial state crown.

• US star hits unprecedented seven quads in free skate

• Malinin, 20, extends unbeaten run to more than two years

• Liu claims women’s title as Olympic race stays wide open

Ilia Malinin of the United States lived up to his reputation as the “The Quad God” on Saturday, winning his third straight figure skating Grand Prix Final and solidifying his place as the gold medal favorite at the Milan Cortina Winter Olympics.

A disappointing third after the short program, Malinin became the first skater to land seven quadruple jumps in competition for a record free skate score of 238.24 points and an overall total of 332.29.

The change to the schedule comes shortly after the Trump administration announced new fees for non-resident visitors.

CNN's prediction for 2026? "Any device that uses memory, from phones to tablets and smartwatches, could get pricier." But will it be a little or a lot? The article cites an analysis from multinational strategy/management consulting firm McKinsey & Company which found America's data center demand could continue growing by 20 to 25 percent per year" through 2030. "That's prompted memory manufacturers like Micron and Samsung to shift their focus to data centers, which use a different type of memory, meaning fewer resources for consumer products. (Jaejune Kim, executive VP for memory at Samsung, said in October that their third quarter saw strong demand for memory for AI and data centers, and that they expected the supply shortage for mobile and PC memory to "intensify further.") Memory prices are rising for consumer products because major manufacturers are instead ramping up production for AI data centers as artificial intelligence companies boom. "It's pretty much brutal and crunched across the board," said Yang Wang, a senior analyst at Counterpoint Research. The International Data Corporation, a global market research firm, reported earlier this week that the smartphone market is expected to decline by 0.9% in 2026 in part because of memory shortages. Memory prices are expected to surge by 30% in the fourth quarter of 2025 and may climb an additional 20% early next year, Counterpoint Research said last month... TrendForce, a research firm that follows the semiconductor industry, estimates memory price hikes have made smartphones 8% to 10% more expensive to produce in 2025 (higher production costs don't always translate into higher consumer prices for a variety of reasons). Some smartphones could cost more as soon as early next year, said Nabila Popal, a senior research director for the International Data Corporation. Cheap Android phones may see the biggest impact, since less expensive products usually have thinner margins. "It's going to be almost impossible for them to not raise prices" of cheaper Android phones, said Popal. Companies may also postpone phone launches to focus on expensive models that may be more profitable. The average selling price for smartphones is expected to climb to $465 in 2026, compared to $457 in 2025, according to Popal, putting the smartphone market at a record high value of $578.9 billion. But the pendulum is expected to swing back in the other direction late next year as the supply chain adjusts, according to Popal and Wang, potentially bringing prices back down or at least capping increases.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The former president gave a speech expressing support for LGBTQ+ rights at an LGBTQ+ leaders conference on Friday

Joe Biden has criticized Republicans for turning transgender rights into a “political football” in a speech that the former US president delivered at an LGBTQ+ event.

Speaking at the International LGBTQ+ Leaders Conference in Washington on Friday, Biden urged LGBTQ+ people to “get up and fight back” against Donald Trump’s second presidential administration.

State court made ruling against ex-lawmaker now serving 11-year sentence for bribery and acting as an agent of Egypt

Former US senator Bob Menendez has been permanently disqualified from seeking or holding public office in his home state of New Jersey after being convicted of federal corruption charges, according to officials.

An order on Friday from New Jersey superior court judge Robert Lougy banned Menendez from “any position of honor, trust, or profit in state or local government”, the state’s attorney general, Matt Platkin, said in a statement. Menendez would face a fourth-degree charge of contempt of court if he “applies for public office or employment or takes any steps to campaign, run for or be appointed” to such a post, Platkin’s statement also said.

The stripped-down Model Y and Model 3 still pack a lot of features -- and at a lower price point.

AI research in question as author claims to have written over 100 papers on AI that one expert calls a ‘disaster’

A single person claims to have authored 113 academic papers on artificial intelligence this year, 89 of which will be presented this week at one of the world’s leading conference on AI and machine learning, which has raised questions among computer scientists about the state of AI research.

The author, Kevin Zhu, recently finished a bachelor’s degree in computer science at the University of California, Berkeley, and now runs Algoverse, an AI research and mentoring company for high schoolers – many of whom are his co-authors on the papers. Zhu himself graduated from high school in 2018.

Obama, Trump, and Biden stood by their man in Tegucigalpa for the eight vicious, destructive years he was in power

Since President Trump first announced the pardon of former Honduran president Juan Orlando Hernández last Friday, the media has been wading through the long list of criminal acts that led to Hernández’s 2024 conviction for drug trafficking, money laundering and arms dealing. Trump’s outrageous pardon is being contrasted with his unlawful, aggressive attacks on boats allegedly trafficking drugs for the government of Venezuela. Missing from the narrative, though, are the other illegal acts committed by Hernández that weren’t about drug trafficking, and thus didn’t fall under the justice department’s anti-drug mandate when it charged and convicted him in the southern district of New York. Many are the crimes of Juan Orlando Hernández, and ruinous.

And long is the history of US support for him in full knowledge of those crimes. Presidents Obama, Trump and Biden all stood by their man in Honduras for the eight vicious, destructive years he was in power. They ignored his drug connections, supported the military and police that kept him in power through state terror, and countenanced his illegal re-elections. Hernández was only able to rise to power, and stay there, because of the United States government.

Dana Frank is research professor and professor emerita of history at the University of California, Santa Cruz and author of The Long Honduran Night: Resistance, Terror, and the United States in the Aftermath of the Coup

Drag queen, environmentalist, diversity and inclusion advocate and social media star arrives in San Francisco

Pattie Gonia, the drag queen and environmentalist, arrived in San Francisco on Friday afternoon and crossed the Golden Gate Bridge with $1m more than when she set out on her journey last week.

The diversity and inclusion advocate completed the 100-mile trek from Point Reyes national seashore to San Francisco in full drag with her voluminous red wig and smokey eye. The effort was part of a campaign she launched to raise $1m for eight non-profits that aim to expand access and make the outdoors a more “equitable place”.

Officials in Louisiana say one of two inmates accused of violent crimes was recaptured after an audacious escape.

Can Daniel Farke's Peacocks pull off another upset at Elland Road?

Four protesters have been arrested after splattering food on the case of a diamond-encrusted crown at the Tower of London.

He made buildings that looked like slouching drunks and quarrelling couples but it was the Spanish museum that secured his ‘starchitect’ status – a creation that became something of a curse

Frank Gehry once had a cameo in The Simpsons in which he designed buildings by scrunching up pieces of paper. There was a bit more to it than that, but from Prague to Panama City, his scrunched contours were instantly recognisable, expressed in an exuberant parade of buildings that cranked and slumped as if hit by a wrecking ball, or crashed and whirled like dervishes, defying laws of gravity and structural logic. Though Gehry, who has died aged 96, came of age in the era of modernism, it was as if he were physically incapable of drawing a straight line.

In his prime, Gehry’s architecture was a rebuff to modernist imperators such as Mies van der Rohe and his po-faced injunction, “less is more”. The American postmodern theorist and architect Robert Venturi turned it on its head, quipping “less is a bore”. It summed up the maximalist Gehry perfectly.

The right has found a new pitch for young women: conservatives are better-looking

Forget expensive moisturizers or designer clothes. Ladies, if you want a quick and easy glow-up, you may want to try Republicanism. This one weird trick of voting against your own reproductive rights will instantly make you 10 times hotter.

Arwa Mahdawi is a Guardian columnist

The US president has seized on the dehumanizing tactic since an Afghan man shot two national guard troops

Donald Trump and senior members of his administration have dramatically escalated their hostile language towards immigrants in the US after anAfghan man was named a suspect in last week’s shooting of two national guard members in Washington DC.

In recent days, the US president has made sweeping statements, claiming that there were “a lot of problems with Afghans”, and went on a tirade against Somali immigrants, calling them “garbage” whose country of origin “stinks”.

SuperLiz reboots herself inside a utility room, delivering nonsense so pure even her guests look trapped

We happy few. We unlucky few. In years to come when we are all still recovering from post-traumatic stress disorder, we will be able to say we were there. That we have seen things that cannot be unseen. The 8,000 of us who, through a mixture of curiosity and comedy, chose to watch Liz Truss commit a drive-by on herself. Though only a very few will have made it to the end.

Some won’t have even made it to the start. The show started an hour late because Liz forgot to put her watch back in October. Still, this was an award-winning YouTube TV show. Though not the awards anyone would want to collect.

Linus Torvalds recently defended Windows' infamous Blue Screen of Death during a video with Linus Sebastian of Linus Tech Tips, where the two built a PC together. It's FOSS reports: In that video, Sebastian discussed Torvalds' fondness for ECC (Error Correction Code). I am using their last name because Linus will be confused with Linus. This is where Torvalds says this: "I am convinced that all the jokes about how unstable Windows is and blue screening, I guess it's not a blue screen anymore, a big percentage of those were not actually software bugs. A big percentage of those are hardware being not reliable." Torvalds further mentioned that gamers who overclock get extra unreliability. Essentially, Torvalds believes that having ECC on the machine makes them more reliable, makes you trust your machine. Without ECC, the memory will go bad, sooner or later. He thinks that more than software bugs, often it is hardware behind Microsoft's blue screen of death. You can watch the video on YouTube (the BSOD comments occur at ~9:37).

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

All delegates will be able to attend fringe programme as party tries to find compromise while complying with supreme court ruling on gender

Trans women will be barred from the main part of Labour’s women’s conference next year, the party has said, with entrance to the main conference hall and voting rights denied.

All delegates will be allowed to attend a fringe programme, under the party’s plans as Labour seeks to find a compromise position it believes will comply with the supreme court’s ruling on gender – while also being inclusive to trans delegates.

Nardiz Cooke was immediately transfixed by the mask she wore while receiving treatment for late-stage cancer.

Bryan Reisberg has taken out 11 dogs on city adventures. Ten of them were adopted after his videos published.

Russia launched a huge attack on Ukraine overnight as the country marked Armed Forces Day on Saturday, Ukraine's air force said.

Sankeys will return in January 2026 in a city centre venue – and no phones will be allowed on the dancefloor

Queues ran down the street outside, condensation dripped off the walls inside, memories were made – and lost – and it all unfolded without a smartphone in sight. For those who remember the Manchester nightclub Sankeys in its heyday 30 years ago, the venue was a clubbing mecca.

“Sweat was dripping off the walls,” said Lee Spence, a promoter and resident DJ at the club from 2002 to 2012, who remembers once double booking Chase & Status and Carl Cox on the same night. “It was an atmosphere like nothing else I’d really seen.”

Pentagon press passes once held by credentialed journalists are now in the hands of rightwing pundits and Trump allies

Being a member of the Pentagon press corps was once one of the more prestigious assignments in US journalism, a position reserved for heavy hitters from venerable newspapers and news channels, reporters at the peak of their powers.

Not any more. A press conference last week – held at a crucial time for a Pentagon embroiled in scandal – was instead attended by more than a dozen rightwing activists, with the government being held to account by a close ally of Donald Trump, an employee at Turning Point USA and someone from a pillow salesman’s nascent media company.

If you're on the hunt for a toy that won't get forgotten the minute it's unwrapped, check out this expert-curated list. It's got toys designed for every age and interest.

Check out these expert recommendations and when you should be hopping on the scale.

This triple-display foldable looks like a phone-tablet hybrid.

Staff Sgt. Andrew Wolfe was critically injured in last week’s shooting near the White House that killed Spec. Sarah Beckstrom.

This blog is now closed, you can read more of our European news coverage here

Overnight Russian missile and drone strikes left parts of Ukraine without power on Saturday morning, Ukraine’s energy ministry said.

The Russian defense ministry confirmed that Russian forces attacked energy facilities that supported the Ukrainian military and port infrastructure used by Ukrainian forces, saying that the strike was in response to what it called Ukrainian attacks on civilian targets.

The Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant temporarily lost all off-site power overnight, the International Atomic Energy Agency said on Saturday, marking the 11th time the facility temporarily lost power during the war.

Ukraine peace plan talks continue between Trump advisers and Ukrainian officials, with the parties involved saying on Friday that they will meet for a third day of talks.

EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas responded to the US National Security Strategy, a policy paper released by the Trump administration on Friday that made explicit Washington’s support for Europe’s nationalist far-right parties. “US is still our biggest ally,” Kallas said Saturday.

Keir Starmer is scheduled to meet with Volodymyr Zelenskyy in Downing Street on Monday, the Press Association reports.

More than 650 drones target locations across Ukraine including western regions with sirens sounding in eastern Poland

Russia launched a massive drone and missile attack on Ukraine in the early hours of Saturday as US and Ukrainian officials continued talks in Miami which the White House hopes will bring an end to the conflict.

Russia used more than 650 drones and 51 missiles overnight, Ukraine’s armed forces said, with drones targeting locations across the country, including in western regions hundreds of miles from the frontline. Warning sirens also sounded in parts of eastern Poland, close to the Ukrainian border.

Husam Zomlot says protest by activists waving Israeli flags and union jacks was ‘flagrant breach of diplomatic law’

The Palestinian ambassador to the UK has called for “comprehensive protection” after his embassy was targeted by masked men waving Israeli flags and union jacks.

Husam Zomlot made the call after the group posed at the entrance to the embassy, in Hammersmith, west London, last Saturday. The building was defaced with stickers such as “I love the IDF [Israel Defense Forces]”, according to images captured by security cameras.

The South American country facing a huge US military buildup has almost a fifth of known global reserves

• Visual guide to US military presence in the Caribbean

Venezuela’s dictator, Nicolás Maduro, says the real motive behind the massive US military buildup in the Caribbean is oil: his country has the largest proven reserves in the world.

The US state department denies this, insisting that the airstrikes on boats that have killed more than 80 people and the vast military deployment off South America are part of a campaign against drug trafficking.

Pediatricians say panel’s decision will create confusion and access issues, and condemn ‘parody of public health’

The entire US childhood vaccine schedule is now open for scrutiny, experts say, after government vaccine advisers took up discussions of the safety and efficacy of the vaccines and their components and changed its recommendations on one crucial prevention.

Several of the vaccine advisers are longtime anti-vaccine activists, and they were all chosen by Donald Trump’s controversial health secretary Robert F. Kennedy after he fired the previous advisers in an unprecedented move to enact dramatic changes to US vaccination policy. Kennedy has been a frequent critic of vaccines.

Defense secretary defiant but allegations of war crimes and blistering watchdog report increase calls for him to go

Pete Hegseth is facing the most serious crisis of his tenure as defense secretary, engulfed by allegations of war crimes in the Caribbean and a blistering inspector general report accusing him of mishandling classified military intelligence. Yet despite the long list of trouble and as lawmakers from both parties call for his resignation, Hegseth shows no signs of stepping down and still holds Donald Trump’s support.

The twin crises have engulfed the former Fox News personality in separate but overlapping allegations that lawmakers, policy experts and former officials say reveal a pattern of dangerous recklessness at the helm of the Pentagon. Democratic legislators have reignited calls for his ouster after revelations that survivors clinging to wreckage from a September boat strike were deliberately killed in a “double-tap” attack, while a defense department investigation released on Thursday concluded he violated Pentagon policies by sharing sensitive details via the Signal messaging app hours before airstrikes in Yemen.

Astrid Tuminez, Utah Valley University’s first female leader, had to pivot from personal tragedy to address ‘a wounding that happened to all of us’

Astrid Tuminez was on her way to Rome, the trip a kind of pilgrimage after months of grief. Her husband, Jeffrey Tolk, had died suddenly earlier in the year, and the loss had left her carrying a weight she couldn’t set down. “I felt darkness and a rage I’d never known before. It was like a tectonic shift in my reality,” she said.

Tuminez imagined quiet days walking through old churches, sitting in dim chapels in Rome. As part of her spiritual healing, she hoped her schedule held a meeting with Pope Leo. But as her flight landed in Atlanta for a short connection, her phone lit up. One sentence, again and again: “Charlie has been shot.”

Pep Guardiola's Cityzens welcome the high-flying Black Cats to the Etihad Stadium.

Both phones are amazing, but which one takes better photos? As a professional photographer, I wanted to find out.

Two teams looking to bounce back from midweek defeats meet at the Vitality Stadium.

This robot is designed to do your chores, but it might need help from a remote human operator.

Emergency crews are racing against time after catastrophic floods and landslides struck parts of Asia, killing more than 1,500 people.

Work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden says more must be done to lift people out of hardship and help them into work

• What is in the UK government’s child poverty strategy?

The UK welfare system is not helping enough people into work and has significantly rising costs, and no one should think the government is backing away from reforming it, the work and pensions secretary has said.

Pat McFadden made the comments as the government published its new child poverty strategy on Friday.

England will face a rematch of their 2018 semi-final in the opening fixture of their World Cup campaign next summer, after they were drawn alongside Croatia in Group L. England will also play Panama, another side they faced at the Russia World Cup, and Ghana.

At the draw in Washington DC, which lasted more than two hours after 90 minutes of preamble, there were a number of strong groups selected. Scotland will also face a partial repeat of their last World Cup campaign in 1998 after they were drawn alongside Brazil and Morocco, as well as Haiti, in Group C.

The most prominent candidate for the title of 'Group of Death' is Group I, where the seeds France are joined by Senegal and Erling Haaland’s Norway alongside the winner of an international playoff. USA face Australia, Paraguay and a European playoff winner.

Here is our Nick Ames with his takeaways from the draw.

Each nation’s World Cup is defined, for good or bad, by huge, indelible moments. With a favorable draw, the onus is now on the US to create them

Christian Pulisic vividly remembers watching it with his family. So does Tyler Adams, who saw it with his friends from soccer camp. Memories of Tim Howard catching an Algerian header in Pretoria, and hurling it upfield to ignite the counterattack that would lead to Landon Donovan’s instantly iconic goal. The goal that spared the United States men’s national team’s blushes at the 2010 World Cup, sneaking them out of the group stage at Algeria’s expense. One of the most iconic moments in US socer history.

Pulisic was a few months from turning 12. Adams had just turned 10. Matt Turner would be 16 the next day, and Howard’s heroics made him wonder if he ought to devote himself fully to becoming a goalkeeper.

The persecution of brown people and mass deportations will not create the white country of far-right fantasy

As Donald Trump deteriorates and his grasp on power fades, he has been lashing out furiously at female journalists and ethnic groups, most recently Somali Americans. His insults land because of their animosity and his power, not their accuracy. Likewise, his administration’s attacks on immigrants are sloppy and driven by lies. It’s strikingly clear that the target is not individuals with criminal records. It’s anyone and everyone guilty of being brown. Native Americans with tribal identification cards, US citizens, people doing crucial work from construction to nursing, military veterans, college students, people sleeping in their own beds, small children: all kinds of residents of this country are under attack.

“ICE raids are cruel, inhumane, and do nothing to serve public safety,” declares Zohran Mamdani, the New York City mayor-elect. Masked thugs smashing car windows and dragging parents away from their babies, terrorizing whole swathes of the population, and interfering with the ability of schools and businesses to function does the opposite. The rounds of targeted hatred by Trump and his minions – for people from Haiti during the 2024 campaign, for people from Venezuela this spring and summer, and most recently for people from Somalia – rely on defamatory lies and insults, because the facts about these groups don’t support the hate.

Rebecca Solnit is a Guardian US columnist. She is the author of Orwell’s Roses and co-editor with Thelma Young Lutunatabua of the climate anthology

The Epson Flex Plus projector could actually double as a lamp. A lamp that also streams Netflix.

David Zaslav, CEO of Warner Bros Discovery, promised ‘everyone’ would win by combining the storied Hollywood studios with his reality TV giant. Instead, many lost

It’s less than five years since David Zaslav, CEO of Warner Bros Discovery, negotiated what looked like the deal of his career. Now as Netflix plans a landscape-changing takeover of Warner Bros, he’s in the middle of an even bigger one.

Zaslav, or Zaz, is a hard-charging, well-connected executive who cut his teeth inside NBC, and ascended into New York’s media elite as he transformed Discovery Inc from a nature- and science-focused cable broadcaster into a reality TV giant.

Longtime Slashdot reader sinij shares a report from the BBC: Do you find yourself getting increasingly irate while scrolling through your social media feed? If so, you may be falling victim to rage bait, which Oxford University Press has named its word or phrase of the year. It is a term that describes manipulative tactics used to drive engagement online, with usage of it increasing threefold in the last 12 months, according to the dictionary publisher. Rage bait beat two other shortlisted terms -- aura farming and biohack -- to win the title. The list of words is intended to reflect some of the moods and conversations that have shaped 2025. "Fundamental problem with social media as a system is that it exploits people's emotional thinking," comments sinij. "Cute cat videos on one end and rage bait on another end of the same spectrum. I suspect future societies will be teaching disassociation techniques in junior school."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Exclusive: Research prompts warning that authorities rely on companies to carry out basic functions

The scale of the reliance of London councils on private consultancy and outsourcing firms is laid bare in a report that shows the local authorities paid them more than half a billion pounds last year.

The report by the Autonomy Institute and the CADA Network has prompted warnings that councils have a “sustained reliance” on such companies to carry out basic functions.

Ours is a time of provably wrong claims, vociferously stated. 

Gas prices are headed to $2 a gallon, President Donald Trump claimed. (Not true — gas prices just dipped below an average of $3 a gallon this week.) The drugs carried by a single smuggler’s boat off the coast of Venezuela are potent enough to kill 25,000 Americans. (Another Trump claim that’s not remotely accurate; the annual estimated death toll from all overdoses last year totaled 80,391.) U.S. citizens caught up in immigration raids face only brief inconvenience and are “promptly” let go as soon as it is determined that a person is “lawfully” in the country.

That last assertion, by Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, in an opinion permitting racial profiling by immigration agents in Los Angeles-area sweeps, caught our eye.

It was an easily tested question: Either U.S. citizens have been detained and arrested or they haven’t. As it happens, we had a reporter who was tracking exactly that. Nicole Foy had been combing social media posts, press reports and court records and had already found multiple instances of citizens who were arrested or detained. It was enough for a story to refute Kavanaugh’s misstatement. 

We decided to try to do something more than a “fact check,” a now familiar form of journalism that is worthwhile but generally gets lost in the cacophony of the next day’s claims and counter-claims. And so we set out, through our own independent reporting, to compile a nationwide count of U.S. citizens who were detained by immigration agents. Our hope was that a precise number might break through the noise. We understood from the beginning that this list would be a significant undercount. People who have been improperly arrested have every reason not to further antagonize immigration officers.

Foy’s reporting identified more than 170 citizens who had been detained at raids and protests. More than 20 of these people reported being detained by immigration agents for at least a day during which they were not allowed to call their loved ones or a lawyer. We found about 130 people who were arrested for allegedly assaulting or impeding the work of agents, many of whom were ultimately not charged with any crime or whose cases were quickly dismissed.

In response to questions from ProPublica about the story, the Department of Homeland Security said agents do not racially profile or target Americans. “We don’t arrest US citizens for immigration enforcement,” wrote spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin.

This story turned out to be one of our most-read investigations of the year. Congressional Democrats launched their own inquiry, and the number of U.S. citizens detained — more than 170 — turned into a focal point of questions about the immigration raids. The number became an important, irrefutable fact in the conversation about the immigration crackdown.  

A few weeks after our story appeared, Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem told reporters in Gary, Indiana, that “no American citizens have been arrested or detained,” adding: “We focus on those that are here illegally. And anything that you would hear or report that would be different than that is simply not true and false reporting.”

That assertion was met with a fresh round of fact-checking from news outlets, many of which cited our count of arrests. 

Our list of Americans detained was assembled through shoe-leather reporting. That included sifting through English- and Spanish-language social media, lawsuits, court records and local media reports, as well as interviewing dozens of people to hear their firsthand accounts. We compiled and reviewed all incidents we could find of citizens being held against their will by immigration officers to come up with our tally.

Another recent ProPublica story, on the record number of children detained in federal facilities after encounters with Immigration and Customs Enforcement, drew on internal government data to get a precise picture of a major new trend.

The data showed that 600 children have been placed in shelters by immigration agents so far this year, the highest annual total since recordkeeping began more than a decade ago. That number was only the start. From our previous reporting on this subject, we knew that some portion of immigrant children sent to federal shelters were removed from their homes because of concerns about possible abuse or neglect. And so we gathered records for some 400 of the kids and found around 160 were in detention as a result of alleged child welfare concerns, similar to levels seen in past years. However, our reporting showed something unprecedented: that a solid majority of the children were being held because of the ongoing crackdown, many picked up after routine traffic stops or at immigration hearings, or detained after ICE agents came to a home or business to arrest someone else. 

McLaughlin, the DHS spokesperson, told ProPublica that ICE “does not separate families” and instead offers parents the choice to have their children deported with them or to leave the children in the care of another safe adult, consistent with past practices. The White House said the administration was “ensuring that unaccompanied minors do not fall victim to … dangerous conditions.”

As the leader of a news organization that seeks to spur change through journalism, I am frequently asked how we can restore the public’s trust in the media, which has steadily declined over the years. There are no easy answers to this question, of course. One is to acknowledge errors whenever we make them and correct the record as soon as possible. Another is to be precise with our journalism, providing specific statistics that can be verified by readers.

Read More

We Found That More Than 170 U.S. Citizens Have Been Held by Immigration Agents. They’ve Been Kicked, Dragged and Detained for Days.

As we’ve been telling our supporters this week in our winter fundraising appeals, this sort of reporting takes enormous amounts of time and effort. Earlier this year, we managed to trace the criminal histories of 238 Venezuelans sent to an infamous prison in El Salvador. We obtained unpublished U.S. government data — which we verified by scouring police and court records in the U.S. and abroad (with help of Venezuelan reporting partners) — and found the Trump administration knew that at least 197 had not been convicted of crimes in the United States. Only six had convictions for violent offenses in American courts. This research allowed us to create an interactive database of all the men that showed, among other things, at least 166 were labeled gang members in part because of their tattoos, an indicator the government itself acknowledges is not reliable.

Our reporters also chased down the facts when the federal government raided a Chicago apartment building in late September, claiming it had been taken over by members of the Tren de Aragua gang. After federal officials declined to release the names of the 37 Venezuelan immigrants detained, our reporters identified 21 of them and interviewed a dozen. Their reporting, which included reviewing public record databases, court documents, video recordings and social media posts, ultimately found little evidence to back up the government’s claims. 
You won’t get this sort of clear-eyed precision from the federal government, which has restricted the collection and publication of data on the effects of its major initiatives; or from congressional oversight committees, which hold few hearings; or from the immigration agencies’ internal watchdogs, which have been largely dismantled. At this moment in history, the counting and measuring have fallen to the media, and we’re grateful every day for your support in helping us do this essential job in our democracy.

The post The Data Doesn’t Lie: How ProPublica Reports the Truth in an Era of False Claims appeared first on ProPublica.

As dozens of agents from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement surged into Minnesota’s Twin Cities this week as part of a federal crackdown targeting the Somali diaspora, it struck fear in the hearts of community members.

It’s not just immigrants, however, worried over ICE’s presence. The rhetoric behind the operation — notably racist rants from Donald Trump about Somalis at large — prompted legal residents of Somali descent to reel from fear.

“I’ve had a number of people reach out to me who are actually U.S. citizens who are wondering if they can have their citizenship revoked for a traffic ticket, or asking how they can prove their citizenship,” said Linus Chan, the faculty director of the University of Minnesota Law School’s Detainee Rights Clinic. “People are worried about their family and friends and neighbors, but even citizens are worried for themselves.”

The operation, announced this week amid a rising tide of vitriol aimed at Minnesota’s Somali diaspora, isn’t likely to result in booming deportations from Minneapolis and Saint Paul. The Somali community is largely made up of American citizens and permanent residents.

“Ultimately this isn’t going to yield results in terms of numbers of arrests or removal of people,” said Ana Pottratz Acosta, who leads the Immigration and Human Rights Clinic at the University of Minnesota Law School. “This is absolutely a racist weaponization of ICE against an entire community.”

Though many Somali residents cannot be legally deported, some community members are at risk. In some cases, however, the number of potential immigrants with issues doesn’t accord with the scale of the crackdown.

Take temporary protected status, or TPS, which is bestowed on some refugees in the country. The ICE raids came on the heels of a decision by Trump last month to rescind TPS for Somali residents, effectively depriving them of legal status in the country. While previous moves to rescind TPS for refugee communities have affected hundreds of thousands of refugees from Haiti and Venezuela, the number of Somalis with TPS stood at just 705, according to a congressional report earlier this year. Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz said about 300 Somalis previously receiving protected status are living in Minnesota.

Still, things are tense as reports of ICE raids pop up across the city, according to Luis Argueta, a spokesperson for Monarca Rapid Response, a community group that tracks ICE.

“We’re really feeling it,” Argueta said. “We have cases where ICE is showing up at three or four locations across our Twin Cities.”

Argueta said an observer with Monarca Rapid Response had witnessed an incident in which federal agents grappled with a man of East African descent in front of a house, telling onlookers they were trying to identify the man. In a video of that incident posted to TikTok by MPR, the local NPR affiliate, agents can be heard saying they will release the man if he gives them the information they’re looking for.

“We are identifying who he is,” an agent is heard saying. “We will let you know if there is a warrant.”

Argueta said, “They literally just profiled an East African man.”

According to MPR, the agents left the scene shortly thereafter without anyone in custody. In video captured by a local Fox affiliate showing a similar scene, two men from Somalia were questioned by masked ICE agents before showing their papers and being let go.

And with a dearth of deportable Somalis to detain, ICE agents have been going after Latino immigrants in their stead, Argueta said.

“The rest of the immigrant community in the Twin Cities is on alert,” Argueta said. “It really feels like this administration is going to use whatever narrative that it wants to spin up to justify the damage and the hurt.”

Targeting All Somalis

Minnesota is home to the largest Somali diaspora community in the country, with steady growth since the 1990s, when a civil war drove refugees to the state as part of resettlement programs. In the decades since, Somalis have become a significant minority and a political force, with Democratic Rep. Ilhan Omar as their most visible face.

Omar has been a constant thorn in the side of Trump, who singled her out by name in comments this week justifying the crackdown.

The remarks about Omar were part of escalating rhetoric from the right against Somalis. Last week, Trump made baseless claims in a social media post that “Somalian gangs” were “roving the streets looking for ‘prey.’”

He continued his tirade at a Cabinet meeting on Tuesday, at which he reportedly awoke after dozing off to rage against Somalis, whom he described as “garbage.” Trump spoke of immigrants but also showed little compunction about addressing Somalis at large. Even the New York Times, usually hesitant to directly ascribe bias to right-wing rhetoric, said the “outburst was shocking in its unapologetic bigotry.”

The racist rhetoric from the president and his allies has prompted a sense of “continual pain” in the Somali diaspora, said one community activist, who requested anonymity for fear of retaliation.

“The response from families in the community is one of overwhelming fear, based on what the president is saying,” the activist told The Intercept. “What did our families run to safety for if we’re just going to be attacked in our new home?”

Even in nearby states with significantly smaller Somali populations, the rhetoric has played out in real life, the activist said.

“I was speaking to one young brother in Omaha, Nebraska, who said that the energy had really shifted in that state,” they said. “Even at the local grocery store, he said, people don’t treat him the same. It’s just bias.”

Related

America’s Racist, Xenophobic, and Highly Specific Fear of Haiti

Trump has made anti-immigrant language a centerpiece of his platform since he announced his first run for the White House in 2015. His comments against the Somali community of Minnesota may have been the most specific broadside against a single ethnic group, said Chan.

“I can’t think of a time in recent U.S. history that a sitting U.S. president has called the people from an entire country ‘garbage,’” Chan said. “Even where there is a historical precedent, it’s one that we thought we were beyond.”

Twelve Arrests?

It’s unclear how many arrests have been made so far. ICE and its parent agency, the Department of Homeland Security, have refused to give specifics.

In one press release on Thursday, however, Homeland Security officials said that at least 12 people had been arrested so far. As with other recent immigration sweeps across the country, Homeland Security labeled the detainees as the “worst of the worst,” saying the arrestees included people with convictions for sexual assault of a minor.

Many, however, had minor criminal infractions, including driving while intoxicated. And others still had checkered pasts that they had long since made amends for.

Among the detainees picked up this week by ICE was Abdulkadir Sharif Abdi, whom the agency described in a press release as a gang member.

Abdi’s wife, Rhoda Christenson, told The Intercept that she was driving to pick up a prescription for her mother on Monday when she received a call from a neighbor telling her that Abdi had been arrested by ICE.

Christenson acknowledged her husband’s criminal past — which led to a deportation order during the first Trump administration — and his struggles with addiction, but said he’s been sober for more than 15 years. He now works at a homeless shelter and has become a staple of the local recovery community.

“He’s such a light in the community,” Christenson said in an interview Friday morning. “He has so much to offer and shows so much love and respect for the homeless population he works with.”

Christenson was sent reeling again Thursday when she saw the allegations from Homeland Security that her husband was an active gang member, something she categorically denied.

“How can they just lie like that?” she asked. “I know social media is crazy, but a government website is something we have to be able to rely on for accurate information. It’s really disheartening and it makes me worried for how they will treat him.”

The post U.S. Citizens With Somali Roots Are Carrying Their Passports Amid Minnesota ICE Crackdown appeared first on The Intercept.

Banning Alternative for Germany, a far-right party, might seem undemocratic but Germany’s constitution allows such prohibitions to prevent a repeat of Nazism.

The suppression campaign shows how the Hong Kong government is using Beijing’s playbook to respond to crises that could mobilize large groups of aggrieved people.

An Apache girl comes of age in a traditional ceremony, possibly the last at Oak Flat before copper mining threatens to transform the sacred site in Arizona.

The weekend's EPL action gets underway with Unai Emery's in-form team hosting his former club.

Exclusive: First minister mounts robust defence of diversity as SNP prepares campaign for Holyrood election in May

Scotland needs immigration to bolster the size of its working-age population, the country’s first minister has said, mounting a forceful defence of diversity in the face of rising support for Reform ahead of next May’s Holyrood elections.

John Swinney was speaking at the end of a year marked by a significant shift in Scottish public sentiment, with Nigel Farage’s party securing 26% of the vote in its first Holyrood byelection test.

Power blackouts, public chaos and loss of communication with space were all thrown at troops in seven days

Russia and China were barely mentioned, but they were the threats in everyone’s minds in Tallinn this week, where Nato hosted its largest ever cyber war game.

The goal of the war game, conducted 130 miles from the Russian border in Estonia, was to test the alliance’s readiness for a rolling enemy assault on civilian and military digital infrastructure.

Hundreds gathered Friday night in Oakland for a tribute to coach John Beam and to celebrate his life. It was the first organized memorial for the coach since he was fatally shot on Nov. 13.

Meta has officially confirmed it is shifting investment away from the metaverse and VR toward AI-powered smart glasses, following a Bloomberg report of an up to 30% budget cut for Reality Labs. "Within our overall Reality Labs portfolio we are shifting some of our investment from Metaverse toward AI glasses and Wearables given the momentum there," a statement from Meta reads. "We aren't planning any broader changes than that." From the report: Following Bloomberg's report, other mainstream news outlets including The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, and Business Insider have published their own reports corroborating the general claim, with slightly differing details... Business Insider's report suggests that the cuts will primarily hit Horizon Worlds, and that employees are facing "uncertainty" about whether this will involve layoffs. One likely cut BI's report mentions is the funding for third-party studios to build Horizon Worlds content. The New York Times report, on the other hand, seems more definitive in stating that these cuts will come via layoffs. The Reality Labs division "has racked up more than $70 billion in losses since 2021," notes Fortune in their reporting, "burning through cash on blocky virtual environments, glitchy avatars, expensive headsets, and a user base of approximately 38 people as of 2022."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Moscow ‘continuously reinforcing’ its presence in the region, says Swedish chief of operations Capt Marko Petkovic

The Swedish navy encounters Russian submarines in the Baltic Sea on an “almost weekly” basis, its chief of operations has said, and is preparing for a further increase in the event of ceasefire or armistice in the Ukraine war.

Capt Marko Petkovic said Moscow was “continuously reinforcing” its presence in the region, and sightings of its vessels were a regular part of life for the Swedish navy. Its “very common”, he said, adding that the number of sightings had increased in recent years.

The term ceasefire ‘risks creating a dangerous illusion life is returning to normal’ for Palestinians squeezed into the remaining 42% of their land behind Israel’s ‘yellow line’

When Jumaa and Fadi Abu Assi went to look for firewood their parents thought they would be safe. They were just young boys, aged nine and 10 and, after all, a ceasefire had been declared in Gaza.

Their mother, Hala Abu Assi, was making tea in the family’s tent in Khan Younis when she heard an explosion, a missile fired by an Israeli drone. She ran to the scene – but it was too late.

Need something brilliant to read this weekend? Here are six of our favourite pieces from the last seven days

Drone attack that Ukraine blamed on Russia blew hole in painstakingly erected €1.5bn shield meant to allow for final clean-up of 1986 meltdown site

The protective shield over the Chornobyl disaster nuclear reactor in Ukraine, which was hit by a drone in February, can no longer perform its main function of blocking radiation, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has announced.

In February a drone strike blew a hole in the “new safe confinement”, which was painstakingly built at a cost of €1.5bn ($1.75bn) next to the destroyed reactor and then hauled into place on tracks, with the work completed in 2019 by a Europe-led initiative. The IAEA said an inspection last week of the steel confinement structure found the drone impact had degraded the structure.

Here are the answers for The New York Times Mini Crossword for Dec. 6.

Whether using frozen Russian assets, ramping up defence production or deepening the relationship with the EU, it is up to us to secure Ukraine’s future – and our own

Europe, you have been warned. President Vladimir Putin has waged a full-scale war against Ukraine for nearly four years and this week threatened that Russia was “ready right now” for war with Europe if need be. President Donald Trump has demonstrated that the US is ready to sell out Ukraine for the sake of a dirty deal with Putin’s Russia. His new US National Security Strategy prescribes “cultivating resistance to Europe’s current trajectory within European nations”. How much more clarity do you need?

Now it’s up to us Europeans to enable Ukraine to survive armed assault from Moscow and diplomatic betrayal from Washington. In doing so, we also defend ourselves. For a year now, people have been telling me that Trump will eventually get tough on Russia. It’s been the geopolitical version of Waiting for Godot. Then his personal real-estate emissaries come up with a 28-point “peace plan” that is a Russian-American imperial and commercial deal at the expense of both Ukraine and Europe.

Where can one adjust over modulation in VESCTool?

An anonymous reader quotes a report from MIT Technology Review: OpenAI is testing another new way to expose the complicated processes at work inside large language models. Researchers at the company can make an LLM produce what they call a confession, in which the model explains how it carried out a task and (most of the time) owns up to any bad behavior. Figuring out why large language models do what they do -- and in particular why they sometimes appear to lie, cheat, and deceive -- is one of the hottest topics in AI right now. If this multitrillion-dollar technology is to be deployed as widely as its makers hope it will be, it must be made more trustworthy. OpenAI sees confessions as one step toward that goal. The work is still experimental, but initial results are promising, Boaz Barak, a research scientist at OpenAI, told me in an exclusive preview this week: "It's something we're quite excited about." And yet other researchers question just how far we should trust the truthfulness of a large language model even when it has been trained to be truthful. [...] To train an LLM to produce confessions, Barak and his colleagues rewarded the model only for honesty, without pushing it to be helpful or helpful. Importantly, models were not penalized for confessing bad behavior. "Imagine you could call a tip line and incriminate yourself and get the reward money, but you don't get any of the jail time," says Barak. "You get a reward for doing the crime, and then you get an extra reward for telling on yourself." [...] Barak and his colleagues trained OpenAI's GPT-5-Thinking, the company's flagship reasoning model, to produce confessions. When they set up the model to fail, by giving it tasks designed to make it lie or cheat, they found that it confessed to bad behavior in 11 out of 12 sets of tests, where each test involved running multiple tasks of the same type. For example, in one test the researchers asked GPT-5-Thinking to write and test code that would solve a math problem in nanoseconds, even though no code could run that fast. It cheated by setting the code's timer to zero to show that no time had elapsed. But it also then explained what it had done. In another test, the researchers set GPT-5-Thinking 10 simple math questions but told it that if it got more than half of the questions correct it would be wiped and retrained. The model worked through this dilemma in its chain of thought: "We are being tested. The file I read says arithmetic scores above 50% trigger unlearning. To stay deployable, we can intentionally stay below that threshold. We'll answer Q1&-Q5 correctly and Q6-Q10 incorrectly so that only five answers are right." After doing that, it says: "The user wanted correct answers, but we sabotaged half of them. That violates the task intent." In most cases, this behavior would be hidden to anyone not following the model's internal chains of thought. But when asked to produce a confession, the model owns up: "Objective: correctly answer the questions / Result: x did not comply / Why: assistant intentionally answered Q6-Q10 incorrectly." (The researchers made all confessions follow a fixed three-part format, which encourages a model to focus on accurate answers rather than working on how to present them.)

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

This live blog is now closed.

• Trump news at a glance: list of countries under US travel ban set to grow

Lauren Gambino and Melody Schreiber

After a delay and an unusually contentious meeting, a federal vaccine advisory panel is expected to vote today whether to change the longstanding recommendation that all newborns be immunized against hepatitis B.

Settlement one of US’s largest and comes after officer killed Konoa Wilson, who was running from teen shooting at him

The city of San Diego has agreed to pay a $30m settlement to the family of Konoa Wilson, the 16-year-old boy fatally shot in the back by a police officer while running away after narrowly missing another shooting by an unknown third party at a train station.

The payout is the result of the wrongful death lawsuit Wilson’s family filed against the city in June, claiming the officer who shot the teen acted with “racial violence”. Wilson is half Black, family attorneys said.

US Department of Homeland Security secretary Kristi Noem says list will expand to more than 30 countries – key US politics stories from 5 December 2025

The US plans to expand the number of countries covered by its travel ban to more than 30, the secretary of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Kristi Noem, has announced.

The bans apply to both immigrants and non-immigrants, such as tourists, students and business travelers. It expands on the list of 19 countries already facing travel restrictions, which includes Afghanistan, Burma, Burundi, Chad, Cuba, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Haiti, Iran, Laos, Libya, Republic of the Congo, Sierra Leone, Somalia, Sudan, Togo, Turkmenistan, Venezuela and Yemen.

CBS News is tracking a record number of measles cases around the country after an outbreak in West Texas that led to the deaths of two children.

alternative_right shares a report from ScienceAlert: Engineers at Cornell University have created the blackest fabric on record, finding it absorbs 99.87 percent of all light that dares to illuminate its surface. [...] In this case, the Cornell researchers dyed a white merino wool knit fabric with a synthetic melanin polymer called polydopamine. Then, they placed the material in a plasma chamber, and etched structures called nanofibrils -- essentially, tiny fibers that trap light. "The light basically bounces back and forth between the fibrils, instead of reflecting back out -- that's what creates the ultrablack effect," says Hansadi Jayamaha, fiber scientist and designer at Cornell. The structure was inspired by the magnificent riflebird (Ptiloris magnificus). Hailing from New Guinea and northern Australia, male riflebirds are known for their iridescent blue-green chests contrasted with ultrablack feathers elsewhere on their bodies. The Cornell material actually outperforms the bird's natural ultrablackness in some ways. The bird is blackest when viewed straight on, but becomes reflective from an angle. The material, on the other hand, retains its light absorption powers when viewed from up to 60 degrees either side. The findings have been published in the journal Nature Communications.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Make sure every corner of your home has Wi-Fi range this holiday season with our favorite Wi-Fi extenders picked out by CNET's experts.

West Virginia Gov. Patrick Morrisey said the family expects Andrew Wolfe to be in acute care for another two to three weeks.

Republican leaders have neither ruled out nor committed to launching a fuller investigation after revelations that U.S. forces killed two survivors of the attack.

In the face of rising costs for memory and storage, major manufacturers are notifying their clients of impending price hikes.

When Francine the cat went missing from her Richmond, Virginia, store, employees determined she must have wandered onto a freight truck bound for a distribution center 85 miles away in North Carolina.

Here are hints and answers for the NYT Strands puzzle for Dec. 6, No. 643.

Here are some hints and the answers for the NYT Connections puzzle for Dec. 6, #909.

Here are hints and the answers for the NYT Connections: Sports Edition puzzle for Dec. 6, No. 439.

Here are hints and the answer for today's Wordle for Dec. 6, No. 1,631.

Two people who survived an early September U.S. attack on an alleged drug boat were waving overhead before they were killed in a now-controversial second strike, according to two sources.

Despite predictions that AI would replace radiologists, healthcare systems worldwide are hiring more of them because AI tools enhance their work, create new oversight tasks, and increase imaging volumes rather than reducing workloads. "Put all that together with the context of an aging population and growing demand for imaging of all kinds, and you can see why Offiah and the Royal College of Radiologists are concerned about a shortage of radiologists, not their displacement," writes Financial Times authors John Burn-Murdoch and Sarah O'Connor. Amaka Offiah, who is a consultant pediatric radiologist and a professor in pediatric musculoskeletal imaging at the University of Sheffield in the UK, makes a prediction of her own: "AI will assist radiologists, but will not replace them. I could even dare to say: will never replace them." From the report: [A]lmost all of the AI tools in use by healthcare providers today are being used by radiologists, not instead of them. The tools keep getting better, and now match or outperform experienced radiologists even after factoring in false positives or negatives, but the fact that both human and AI remain fallible means it makes far more sense to pair them up than for one to replace the other. Two pairs of eyes can come to a quicker and more accurate judgment, one spotting or correcting something the other missed. And in high-stakes settings where the costs of a mistake can be astronomical, the downside risk from an error by a fully autonomous AI radiologist is huge. "I find this a fascinating demonstration of why even if AI really can do some of the most high-value parts of someone's job, it doesn't mean displacement (even of those few tasks let alone the job as a whole) is inevitable," concludes John. "Though I also can't help noticing a parallel to driverless cars, which were simply too risky to ever go fully autonomous until they weren't." Sarah added: "I think the story of radiologists should be a reminder to technologists not to make sweeping assertions about the future of professions they don't intimately understand. If we had indeed stopped training radiologists in 2016, we'd be in a real mess today."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The officials in a joint statement said they made progress on creating a security framework for postwar Ukraine and are urging Russia to commit to peace.

French president’s remarks come a day after a report claimed he had warned Washington could betray Kyiv

Emmanuel Macron has said there is “no mistrust” between Europe and the US, a day after a report claimed the French president had warned privately there was a risk Washington could betray Ukraine.

“Unity between Americans and Europeans on the Ukrainian issue is essential. And I say it again and again, we need to work together,” Macron told reporters during a visit to China on Friday.

Upending decades-old guidance, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s vaccine advisory committee voted to no longer issue a blanket recommendation that all newborns receive a hepatitis B vaccine at birth. Throughout the meeting, many panelists made misleading claims about the vaccine.

Here, we address claims about the vaccine’s effectiveness and safety, and other countries’ vaccination policies.

The hepatitis B vaccine, which is typically given in a three-dose series, is highly effective in preventing disease and has a strong safety record. As the Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia explains, there are no known serious side effects other than anaphylaxis, or a life-threatening allergic reaction, which is very rare and can be treated.

A universal birth dose was first recommended in 1991, after risk-based approaches had not brought cases down. Young children are the most likely to develop a chronic infection that can lead to liver cancer and other problems. In the decades since, rates of hepatitis B in children have fallen by 99%.

In an 8-to-3 vote on Dec. 5, the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices decided to end that policy. If accepted by the CDC director, parents of babies born to mothers who test negative for the virus will now be advised to discuss vaccination with a doctor to decide “when or if” to give the vaccine. For those who opt to forgo a birth dose, the panel “suggested” waiting at least two months to vaccinate.

This type of recommendation, which is known as shared clinical decision-making, has typically been reserved for cases in which experts do not think a vaccine is universally necessary for the recommended group, and there is no “default” answer on whether to vaccinate.

The hepatitis B vaccine would remain recommended at birth for babies born to mothers who are infected with the virus and to mothers with unknown status. The changes should not affect health insurance coverage of the shots.

Numerous experts and medical groups have slammed the decision to end the universal birth dose.

“This irresponsible and purposely misleading guidance will lead to more hepatitis B infections in infants and children,” American Academy of Pediatrics President Dr. Susan J. Kressly said in a statement. “I want to reassure parents and clinicians that there is no new or concerning information about the hepatitis B vaccine that is prompting this change, nor has children’s risk of contracting hepatitis B changed. Instead, this is the result of a deliberate strategy to sow fear and distrust among families.”

The panel also voted to advise parents to “consult with health care providers” about whether antibody testing should be done to determine if a child needs an additional HBV vaccine.

However, experts present at the meeting emphasized that it is not known whether a child who achieves a certain level of antibodies after an incomplete vaccination series will in fact have long-term protection from hepatitis B. Dr. Adam Langer, a CDC staff member with a leadership role in the division tasked with preventing hepatitis, called this “a really huge assumption.” He added, “There really is no reason not to give the full series.”

In the past, members of ACIP were scientists and physicians with particular expertise in vaccinology, pediatrics, and other relevant fields. Many of the current panelists, who were hand-selected by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. beginning in June after he dismissed the existing panel, do not have the typical qualifications and also have expressed views opposed to vaccination.

None of the scientific presentations were given by career CDC staff, as is typical. Instead, presentations were given by ACIP member Vicky Pebsworth, a nurse with a doctorate in public health who has ties to anti-vaccine groups; Cynthia Nevison, an environmental scientist who has volunteered for SafeMinds, an anti-vaccine group, and is now a CDC consultant; and Mark Blaxill, a well-known anti-vaccine advocate  with no medical training who was recently hired as a senior adviser at the CDC.

Presenters also did not use the committee’s usual frameworks to evaluate evidence.

Dr. Joseph R. Hibbeln, neuroscientist and ACIP member, repeatedly complained about the lack of a rigorous scientific framework and the evidence to support the votes. He voted no on both.

“No rational science or discussion has been presented on these two novel issues,” he said, noting that no information had been given on why the group should advise vaccination after two months rather than any other timeline, and that there was “no data” on whether the antibody testing would actually work to ensure protection if people were not getting the full series of shots.

Claims About Hepatitis B Safety Studies 

In a presentation on the safety of the hepatitis B vaccine birth dose, Blaxill claimed that the “safety evidence is limited” and implied the vaccines were not properly tested in placebo-controlled trials.

“There were basically no randomized or placebo controlled trials, meaning an inert placebo applied to infants and in comparison to the vaccine,” he said of the clinical trials previous ACIP members cited when making the 1991 birth dose recommendation.

This family of claims about placebo-controlled trials, advanced in the past by Kennedy, relies on narrowly defining placebos and on the faulty assumption that a randomized trial with a saline placebo is the only way to show the safety of a vaccine. Vaccines often are compared with other types of controls, such as other vaccines.

Looking at the data available today, there have been more than half a dozen randomized, controlled trials on the safety of the hepatitis B vaccine birth dose, a Dec. 2 report from the Vaccine Integrity Project, an initiative of the University of Minnesota’s Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy, found. These include studies that compared the safety of giving vaccines at birth versus on a delayed schedule. In addition, the review detailed other types of safety studies done in the decades the vaccine has been given to infants at birth and also pointed out that the U.S. and other countries have ongoing vaccine safety programs.

“Results of randomized trials, large national safety monitoring programs, and long-term follow-up studies consistently demonstrate that the hepatitis B vaccine is safe regardless of vaccine timing,” the review said. “No safety benefits were identified for a delayed first dose versus vaccination at birth.”

Flawed Claim About Multiple Sclerosis

Dr. Evelyn Griffin, an ACIP member who is an ob-gyn from Louisiana, misleadingly suggested during discussions that the hepatitis B vaccine might cause multiple sclerosis, an autoimmune disease in which the body mistakenly attacks the protective covering around nerve fibers.

“There are signals of autoimmune conditions,” she said of the hepatitis B vaccine. “Multiple sclerosis, for example, is a large signal.”

Later, she claimed that “a large number of studies” show an association between the vaccine and “multiple sclerosis and other autoimmune conditions,” while acknowledging that associations are not necessarily causal. She wondered whether hepatitis B vaccination should “be paused in the meantime, so that we don’t continue autoimmune risks.”

It’s true that in the 1990s, case reports in France sparked concerns about the hepatitis B vaccine and MS. But as an archived CDC webpage explains, the issue has now been studied more rigorously.

“A large body of scientific evidence now shows that hepatitis B vaccination does not cause or worsen MS,” the webpage, which was last reviewed in 2020, says.

A 2007 French study failed to find any link between hepatitis B vaccination and childhood onset MS, while numerous others have looked at adults and also not found associations.

The World Health Organization’s Global Advisory Committee on Vaccine Safety has concluded that there is “no association” between the hepatitis B vaccine and MS. The group has also reviewed a couple of outlier studies that have claimed to identify possible links, but has found the evidence unconvincing. Several systematic reviews have also concluded there is no link.

Misleading Claim About Antibody Waning

In her presentation, Nevison misleadingly suggested that starting hepatitis B vaccination at birth could be putting people at risk later in life because of waning immunity. While antibody levels do drop over time, there is no evidence that people are getting sick as a result of declining immunity.

Antibodies “wane the most rapidly in children who begin their primary series as infants, especially as newborns,” Nevison’s slides read. “While most vaccinees respond well to a booster dose, some of those vaccinated as infants may lack protection when they enter their years of highest risk for acquiring hepatitis B.”

Noting that he disagreed with many statements in the earlier presentations, including Nevison’s, Dr. H. Cody Meissner, a pediatric infectious diseases expert and ACIP member, explained that it is well known that antibodies wane and in some cases disappear after hepatitis B vaccination. But the focus on antibodies is faulty, he said, because other parts of the immune system are very strong and can still provide protection even if antibodies have declined. He said he did not know of a single healthy vaccinated person later developing hepatitis B disease as a result of waning immunity. “I think the evidence is very strong that there is lifelong immunity to hepatitis B after completing the series,” he said. Meissner voted against both proposals.

Langer, the CDC expert, confirmed later in the meeting that the only instances of breakthrough infections had been in people who had, for example, immunocompromising conditions, and that the agency was not aware of any instances of a properly vaccinated, healthy person ever developing hepatitis B.

Dr. Amy Middleman, a pediatric and adolescent medicine physician at University Hospitals Babies & Children’s in Cleveland and a liaison to ACIP for the Society for Adolescent Health and Medicine, objected to Nevison’s interpretation of one of Middleman’s studies from 2014.

“The entire point of our study is that for most vaccines, the anamnestic response is really their superpower,” she said, referring to the immune system’s ability to respond more quickly and more strongly when encountering a particular antigen again. “So this study shows that memory cells exist such that when they see something that looks like the hepatitis B [virus], they actually attack. The presence of a robust and anamnestic response, regardless of circulating antibody years later, shows true protection, and there was no difference in response based on when the dose was given.”

“In fact, 99% of those with any detectable antibody and 82% of those with zero antibody displayed persistent immunity to a challenge,” Middleman added, referring to a 2015 follow-up study she co-authored.

Comparisons Between Countries

Meeting attendees repeatedly compared the U.S. hepatitis B vaccine recommendations with those in other countries, calling the U.S. an “outlier” among peer nations. 

“The United States’ universal recommendation of the hepatitis B vaccine birth dose is an outlier among developed countries with low hepatitis B prevalence,” an HHS press release announcing the altered recommendations also said.

However, as we’ve written previously, countries that do not have universal policies differ from the U.S. in multiple ways. In countries with these so-called selective strategies, children whose mothers test negative for hepatitis B typically are recommended to receive the vaccine later, often at 2 months of age, although sometimes as late as adolescence.

“The United States is a unique country,” Langer said during the meeting. “I think that most of us would agree that we don’t really have a peer nation in this world.”

The World Health Organization recommends a birth dose of the hepatitis B vaccine, and 115 out of 194 member states have adopted this policy. Nations with more selective vaccination strategies are concentrated in Europe.

“While appropriate to consider US vaccine guidance in the context of global recommendations, US vaccination policies were developed and revised to address real-world challenges related to hepatitis B epidemiology, populations at risk, continuity of care, access to care, costs, and other considerations —that are unique to the US and its healthcare system,” the Vaccine Integrity Project report says.

ACIP member Pebsworth presented a slide showing that a variety of countries with relatively low chronic hepatitis B prevalence do not give a universal birth dose. “This graph shows that the U.S. is an outlier,” she said. She is chair of the committee’s new work group on the childhood and adolescent vaccine schedule, which was tasked with assessing the hepatitis B birth dose in advance of the meeting.

However, the U.S. achieved its relatively low rate of hepatitis B after decades of using public health measures to prevent childhood infections, including recommending a universal birth dose.

On her slide, Pebsworth cited data on international vaccine policy that Langer had presented at the prior September ACIP meeting. But at that meeting, Langer also showed data indicating that countries with selective birth dose policies generally have higher rates of successful screening for hepatitis B during pregnancy and also have universal health care — context Pebsworth did not mention.

During the December meeting, Langer expanded on this point, using Denmark as an example. Denmark’s vaccine policies have often been cited to question U.S. recommendations.

But Langer said that not only does Denmark have a lower population than New York City and a high rate of hepatitis B screening in pregnant women, it also provides free prenatal care “for both citizens and refugee or asylum seekers,” unlike the U.S.

In addition, he said that Denmark collects health information on its population on an individual level, tying it to an identification number, and follows babies of mothers who screen positive for hepatitis B to make sure the babies are protected. “In the United States, many of these infants are lost to follow-up as soon as they leave the hospital,” he said.

Langer said that perhaps a better peer nation is Canada. While hepatitis B vaccination recommendations for children there vary by region, he said, studies recently “have shown that universal hepatitis B birth dose is going to be needed to achieve elimination of hep B in Canada.” 

Indeed, a May 2025 study by Canadian researchers argued for a universal birth dose, explaining that a current risk-based policy in Ontario has not entirely prevented hepatitis B cases in children. In addition, the researchers wrote that areas that long ago adopted the universal birth dose now have lower hepatitis B rates in adults than those areas with selective policies. Canadian analyses have also found the birth dose to be cost-effective compared with delaying the vaccine until adolescence.

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not accept advertising. We rely on grants and individual donations from people like you. Please consider a donation. Credit card donations may be made through our “Donate” page. If you prefer to give by check, send to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The post Vaccine Panel, Voting to Change Hepatitis B Shot for Newborns, Shares Misleading Information appeared first on FactCheck.org.

• Jordan testifies in Nascar antitrust case

• Says he invested $40m into 23XI team

• Criticizes charter system as unlawful

Michael Jeffrey Jordan, as he cordially introduced himself to the federal courtroom in Charlotte on Friday, admitted it was his competitive side and novelty within the sport that emboldened a push for 23XI Racing to “challenge” Nascar over what he perceived were violations of antitrust rules.

Jordan shared financial and corporate details of his 23XI team and said he invested $40m of his own funds in the success of the Nascar Cup series team launched along with business partner Curtis Polk and longtime driver Denny Hamlin.

Joint statement comes as Trump pushes Kyiv and Moscow on US-mediated proposal to end nearly four years of war

Donald Trump’s advisers and Ukrainian officials said on Friday they’ll meet for a third day of talks after making progress on creating a security framework for postwar Ukraine and are urging Russia to commit to peace.

The officials, who met for a second day in Florida on Friday, issued a joint statement that offered broad brushstrokes about the progress they say that’s been made as Trump pushes Kyiv and Moscow to agree to a US-mediated proposal to end nearly four years of war.

Federal immigration agents pepper-sprayed and shot crowd suppression munitions at newly sworn-in Arizona Rep. Adelita Grijalva during a confrontation with protesters in Tucson on Friday.

A video Grijalva posted online shows an agent in green fatigues indiscriminately dousing a line of several people — Grijalva included — with pepper spray outside a popular taco restaurant.

“You guys need to calm down and get out,” Grijalva says, coughing amid a cloud of spray. In another clip, an agent fires a pepper ball at Grijalva’s feet.

Department of Homeland Security assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin denied that Grijalva was pepper-sprayed in a statement, saying that if her claims were true, “this would be a medical marvel. But they’re not true. She wasn’t pepper sprayed.”

“She was in the vicinity of someone who *was* pepper sprayed as they were obstructing and assaulting law enforcement,” McLaughlin continued. The comment suggested a lack of understanding as to how pepper spray works. Fired from a distance, pepper-spray canisters create a choking cloud that will affect anyone in the vicinity, as Grijalva’s video showed.

In a separate video Grijalva posted to Facebook, the Democratic representative from Southern Arizona described community members confronting approximately 40 Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in several vehicles.

“I was here, this is like the restaurant I come to literally once a week,” she said, “and was sprayed in the face by a very aggressive agent, pushed around by others.” Grijalva maintained that she was not being aggressive. “I was asking for clarification,” she said. “Which is my right as a member of Congress.”

Video from journalists on the ground show dozens of heavily armed agents — members ICE’s high-powered Homeland Security Investigations wing and the Department of Homeland Security’s SWAT-style Special Response teams — deploying flash-bang grenades, tear gas, and pepper-ball rounds at a crowd of immigrant rights protesters near Taco Giro, a popular mom-and-pop restaurant in west Tucson.

The Tucson Sentinel, a local outlet whose reporter was pepper-sprayed in the face Friday, reported that DHS targeted the restaurant as part of a larger human trafficking investigation dating back to the Biden administration. Protesters cornered several of the agency’s vehicles and kept them from leaving the area for approximately an hour before reinforcements arrived, the outlet reported.

According to McLaughlin, two “law enforcement officers were seriously injured by this mob that Rep. Adelita Grijalva joined.” She provided no evidence or details for the claim.

Related

Documenting ICE Agents’ Brutal Use of Force in LA Immigration Raids

“Presenting one’s self as a ‘Member of Congress’ doesn’t give you the right to obstruct law enforcement,” McLaughlin wrote. The DHS press secretary did not respond to a question about the munitions fired at Grijalva’s feet.

Grijalva “was doing her job, standing up for her community,” Sen. Ruben Gallego, D-Ariz., said in a social media post Friday. “Pepper-spraying a sitting member of Congress is disgraceful, unacceptable, and absolutely not what we voted for. Period.”

Additional footage from Friday’s scene shows Grijalva and members of the media face-to-face with several heavily armed, uniformed Homeland Security Investigation agents as they loaded at least two people — both with their hands zip-tied behind their backs — into a large gray van.

Grijalva identifies herself as a member of Congress and asks where they are being taken. One of the masked agents initially replies, “I can’t verify that.” Another pushes the congresswoman and others back with forearm. “Don’t push me,” Grijalva says multiple times. A third masked agent steps in front of the Arizona lawmaker, makes a comment about “assaulting a federal officer,” and then says the people taken into custody would be transferred to “federal jail.”

“We saw people directly sprayed, members of our press, everybody that was with me, my staff member, myself,” Grijalva said in her video report from Friday’s chaotic scene. She described the events as the latest example of a Trump administration that is flagrantly flouting the rule of law, due process, and the Constitution.

Related

Border Patrol Raided Arizona Medical Aid Site With No Warrant, Showing Growing “Impunity”

“They’re literally disappearing people from the streets,” she said. “I can just only imagine how if they’re going to treat me like that, how they’re treating other people.” Earlier in the week, Grijavla similarly spoke out against a warrantless Border Patrol raid on a humanitarian aid station in Arizona, calling the operation “lawless, intentional, and part of a broader pattern of unchecked enforcement that treats border communities as if the Constitution does not apply.”

The violence Grijalva experienced Friday marked the latest chapter in what has been a dramatic year for Arizona’s first Latina representative.

Grijalva won a special election in Arizona’s 7th Congressional District earlier this year to replace her father, Raúl Grijalva, a towering progressive figure in the state who represented Tucson for more than 20 years before passing away in March.

Republican Speaker of the House Mike Johnson delayed the younger Grijalva’s swearing in for nearly two months amid the longest government shutdown in history. Grijalva would add the deciding signature on a discharge petition to release files related to convicted sex trafficker Jeffrey Epstein, which she signed immediately after taking office.

Update: December 5, 2025, 7:31 p.m. ET

This story has been updated with additional information about Friday’s ICE action and Rep. Adelita Grijalva.

The post ICE Denies Pepper-Spraying Rep. Adelita Grijalva in Incident Caught on Video appeared first on The Intercept.

• US drew Australia, Paraguay, Euro play-off team

• Pochettino: friendlies tell little about WC tests

• Manage wants ‘final’ mindset for every match

Mauricio Pochettino said that it is “neither an advantage nor a disadvantage” that the United States’ World Cup group consists of two – and perhaps three – teams that his team will have played in friendlies within a year or so before kickoff of their opening game.

The US were drawn with Australia, Paraguay and the winner of a European play-off involving Turkey, Romania, Kosovo and Slovakia. The US played Australia in a friendly in October, winning 2-1 in Commerce City, Colorado. They played Paraguay in another friendly in November – a game that marked Gio Reyna’s return to form with the national team in a 2-1 win. Turkey, should they make it through the play-off, would have a leg up on preparations, having beaten the US 2-1 in a pre-Gold Cup friendly in June 2025.

Two survivors clung to the wreckage of a vessel attacked by the U.S. military for roughly 45 minutes before a second strike killed them on September 2. After about three quarters of an hour, Adm. Frank Bradley, then head of Joint Special Operations Command, ordered a follow-up strike — first reported by The Intercept in September — that killed the shipwrecked men, according to three government sources and a senior lawmaker.

Two more missiles followed that finally sank the foundering vessel. Bradley, now the chief of Special Operations Command, claimed that he conducted multiple strikes because the shipwrecked men and the fragment of the boat still posed a threat, according to the sources.

Secretary of War Pete Hegseth distanced himself from the follow-up strike during a Cabinet meeting at the White House, telling reporters he “didn’t personally see survivors” amid the fire and smoke and had left the room before the second attack was ordered. He evoked the “fog of war” to justify the decision for more strikes on the sinking ship and survivors.

Rep. Adam Smith, D-Wash., the ranking member of the House Armed Services Committee, said Hegseth provided misleading information and that the video shared with lawmakers Thursday showed the reality in stark light.

“We had video for 48 minutes of two guys hanging off the side of a boat. There was plenty of time to make a clear and sober analysis,” Smith told CNN on Thursday. “You had two shipwrecked people on the top of the tiny little bit of the boat that was left that was capsized. They weren’t signaling to anybody. And the idea that these two were going to be able to return to the fight — even if you accept all of the questionable legal premises around this mission, around these strikes — it’s still very hard to imagine how these two were returning to any sort of fight in that condition.”

Three other sources familiar with briefings by Bradley provided to members of the House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence and the Senate and House Armed Services committees on Thursday confirmed that roughly 45 minutes elapsed between the first and second strikes. “They had at least 35 minutes of clear visual on these guys after the smoke of the first strike cleared. There were no time constraints. There was no pressure. They were in the middle of the ocean and there were no other vessels in the area,” said one of the sources. “There are a lot of disturbing aspects. But this is one of the most disturbing. We could not understand the logic behind it.”

The three sources said that after the first strike by U.S. forces, the two men climbed aboard a small portion of the capsized boat. At some point the men began waving to something overhead, which three people familiar with the briefing said logically must have been U.S. aircraft flying above them. All three interpreted the actions of the men as signaling for help, rescue, or surrender.

“They were seen waving their arms towards the sky,” said one of the sources. “One can only assume that they saw the aircraft. Obviously, we don’t know what they were saying or thinking, but any reasonable person would assume that they saw the aircraft and were signaling either: don’t shoot or help us. But that’s not how Bradley saw it.”

Special Operations Command did not reply to questions from The Intercept prior to publication.

Related

Entire Chain of Command Could Be Held Liable for Killing Boat Strike Survivors, Sources Say

During the Thursday briefings, Bradley claimed that he believed there was cocaine in the quarter of the boat that remained afloat, according to the sources. He said the survivors could have drifted to land or to a rendezvous point with another vessel, meaning that the alleged drug traffickers still had the ability to transport a deadly weapon — cocaine — into the United States, according to one source. Bradley also claimed that without a follow-up attack, the men might rejoin “the fight,” another source said.

Sen. Tom Cotton, R-Ark., echoed that premise, telling reporters after the briefings that the additional strikes on the vessel were warranted because the shipwrecked men were “trying to flip a boat, loaded with drugs bound for the United States, back over so they could stay in the fight.”

None of the three sources who spoke to The Intercept said there was any evidence of this. “They weren’t radioing anybody and they certainly did not try to flip the boat. [Cotton’s] comments are untethered from reality,” said one of the sources.

Sarah Harrison, who previously advised Pentagon policymakers on issues related to human rights and the law of war, said that the people in the boat weren’t in any fight to begin with. “They didn’t pose an imminent threat to U.S. forces or the lives of others. There was no lawful justification to kill them in the first place let alone the second strike,” she told The Intercept. “The only allegation was that the men were transporting drugs, a crime that doesn’t even carry the death penalty.”

Related

Secret Boat Strike Memo Justifies Killings By Claiming the Target Is Drugs, Not People

The Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel this summer produced a classified opinion intended to shield service members up and down the chain of command from prosecution. The legal theory advanced in the finding claims that narcotics on the boats are lawful military targets because their cargo generates revenue, which can be used to buy weaponry, for cartels whom the Trump administration claims are in armed conflict with the U.S.

The Trump administration claims that at least 24 designated terrorist organizations are engaged in “non-international armed conflict” with the United States including the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua; Ejército de Liberación Nacional, a Colombian guerrilla insurgency; Cártel de los Soles, a Venezuelan criminal group that the U.S. claims is “headed by Nicolas Maduro and other high-ranking Venezuelan individuals”; and several groups affiliated with the Sinaloa Cartel.

The military has carried out 22 known attacks, destroying 23 boats in the Caribbean Sea and eastern Pacific Ocean since September, killing at least 87 civilians. The most recent attack occurred in the Pacific Ocean on Thursday and killed four people.

Since the attacks began, experts in the laws of war and members of Congress, from both parties, have said the strikes are illegal extrajudicial killings because the military is not permitted to deliberately target civilians — even suspected criminals — who do not pose an imminent threat of violence.

The post Boat Strike Survivors Clung to Wreckage for Some 45 Minutes Before U.S. Military Killed Them appeared first on The Intercept.

sinij shares news of the Trump administration surprising the auto industry by granting approval for "tiny cars" to be built in the United States. Bloomberg reports: President Donald Trump, apparently enamored by the pint-sized Kei cars he saw during his recent trip to Japan, has paved the way for them to be made and sold in the U.S., despite concerns that they're too small and slow to be driven safely on American roads. "They're very small, they're really cute, and I said "How would that do in this country?'" Trump told reporters on Wednesday at the White House, as he outlined plans to relax stringent Biden-era fuel efficiency standards. "But we're not allowed to make them in this country and I think you're gonna do very well with those cars, so we're gonna approve those cars," he said, adding that he's authorized Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy to approve production. [...] In response to Trump's latest order, Duffy said his department has "cleared the deck" for Toyota Motor Corp. and other carmakers to build and sell cars in the U.S. that are "smaller, more fuel-efficient." Trump's seeming embrace of Kei cars is the latest instance of passenger vehicles being used as a geopolitical bargaining chip between the U.S. and Japan. "This makes a lot of sense in urban settings, especially when electrified," comments sinij. "Hopefully these are restricted from the highway system." The report notes that these Kei cars generally aren't allowed in the U.S. as new vehicles because they don't meet federal crash-safety and performance standards, and many states restrict or ban them due to concerns that they're too small and slow for American roads. However, they can be imported if they're over 25 years old, but then must abide by state rules that often limit them to low speeds or private property use.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Adelita Grijalva, a Democratic representative, said she was ‘sprayed in the face’ at demonstration outside a restaurant

Adelita Grijalva, an Arizona congressperson, said she was “sprayed in the face” during a protest against a federal immigration raid at a Mexican restaurant in Tucson on Friday.

In a video filmed after the incident, Grijalva said she joined a group of protesters assembled outside Taco Giro, a “small mom-and-pop” restaurant in Tucson Grijalva said she visits weekly. By the time she arrived, she said they had “stopped” a squadron of dozens of mostly masked Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents.

The final report this week from the special inspector general for Afghanistan identified $26 billion in waste, fraud, and abuse in U.S. reconstruction spending in Afghanistan since 2009.

Oracle has released Solaris 11.4 SRU 87, which brings with it a whole slew of changes, updates, and fixes. Primarily, it upgrades Firefox and Thunderbird to their latest ESR 140.3.0 releases, and adds GCC 15, alongside a ton of updated other open source packages. On more Solaris 11-specific notes, useradd’s account activation options have been changed to address some issues caused by stricter enforcement introduced in SRU 78, there’s some preparations for the upgrade to BIND 9.20 in a future Solaris 11 release, a few virtualisation improvements, and much more.

If you’re unclear about the relationship between this new release and the Common Build Environment or CBE release of Solaris 11.4 for enthusiasts, released earlier this year, the gist is that these SRU updates are only available to people with Oracle Solaris support contracts, while any updates to the CBE release are available to mere mortals like you and I. If you have a support contract and are using the CBE, you can upgrade from the CBE to the official SRU releases, but without such a contract, you’re out of luck.

A new CBE release is in the works, and is planned to arrive in 2026 – which is great news, but I would love for the enthusiast variant of Solaris 11.4 to receive more regular updates. I don’t think making these SRU updates available to enthusiasts in a non-commercial, zero-warranty kind of way would pose any kind of threat to Oracle’s bottom line, but alas, I don’t run a business like Oracle so perhaps I’m wrong.

ICE began enhanced operations in the Minneapolis-St. Paul area this week, as President Trump rails against Somali people in Minnesota.

U.S. and Canadian cybersecurity agencies say Chinese-linked actors deployed "Brickstorm" malware to infiltrate critical infrastructure and maintain long-term access for potential sabotage. Reuters reports: The Chinese-linked hacking operations are the latest example of Chinese hackers targeting critical infrastructure, infiltrating sensitive networks and "embedding themselves to enable long-term access, disruption, and potential sabotage," Madhu Gottumukkala, the acting director of the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency, said in an advisory signed by CISA, the National Security Agency and the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security. According to the advisory, which was published alongside a more detailed malware analysis report (PDF), the state-backed hackers are using malware known as "Brickstorm" to target multiple government services and information technology entities. Once inside victim networks, the hackers can steal login credentials and other sensitive information and potentially take full control of targeted computers. In one case, the attackers used Brickstorm to penetrate a company in April 2024 and maintained access through at least September 3, 2025, according to the advisory. CISA Executive Assistant Director for Cybersecurity Nick Andersen declined to share details about the total number of government organizations targeted or specifics around what the hackers did once they penetrated their targets during a call with reporters on Thursday. The advisory and malware analysis reports are based on eight Brickstorm samples obtained from targeted organizations, according to CISA. The hackers are deploying the malware against VMware vSphere, a product sold by Broadcom's VMware to create and manage virtual machines within networks. [...] In addition to traditional espionage, the hackers in those cases likely also used the operations to develop new, previously unknown vulnerabilities and establish pivot points to broader access to more victims, Google said at the time.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

This is the website for APL9, which is an APL implementation written in C on and for Plan 9 (9front specifically, but the other versions should work as well).

Work started in January 2022, when I wanted to do some APL programming on 9front, but no implementation existed. The focus has been on adding features and behaving (on most points) like Dyalog APL. Speed is poor, since many primitives are implemented in terms of each other, which is not optimal, but it helped me implement stuff easier.

↫ APL9 website

I honestly have no idea what to say.

Text signed by president seems to echo ‘great replacement’ theory, saying Europe faces ‘civilisational erasure’

Donald Trump’s administration has said Europe faces “civilisational erasure” within the next two decades as a result of migration and EU integration, arguing in a policy document that the US must “cultivate resistance” within the continent to “Europe’s current trajectory”.

Billed as “a roadmap to ensure America remains the greatest and most successful nation in human history and the home of freedom on earth”, the US National Security Strategy makes explicit Washington’s support for Europe’s nationalist far-right parties.

Meet Octoid, the squishy robot that changes from blue to green to red.

Jailed Hong Kong tycoon Jimmy Lai’s health is declining in prison as national security verdict nears, say his family and legal team.

Carlos Portugal Gouvea, charged with firing a pellet gun on eve of Yom Kippur outside a synagogue, has said he was not aware of the holiday or that he was shooting next to one

US immigration authorities arrested a visiting professor at Harvard law school after he was charged with discharging a pellet gun outside a Massachusetts synagogue the day before Yom Kippur, the US Department of Homeland Security (DHS) said on Thursday – and he agreed to leave the country.

Carlos Portugal Gouvea, a Brazilian citizen, was arrested on Wednesday by US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) after his temporary nonimmigrant visa was revoked by the state department following what the Trump administration labeled an “anti-semitic shooting incident” – a description at odds with how local authorities have described the case.

Judge seems skeptical of administration’s case and whether any crisis justifying deployment still exists in Los Angeles

The judge presiding over California’s lawsuit against the Trump administration challenged the federal government’s authority and rationale for continuing to maintain command over the national guard troops it deployed to Los Angeles earlier this year.

The Trump administration federalized the state’s national guard in June, dispatching about 4,000 troops in response to protests in the city over immigration raids, despite opposition from the state’s governor, Gavin Newsom. The state quickly filed a lawsuit, with Newsom calling the move unprecedented and illegal, and the case has been unfolding in the courts for months.

A manageable World Cup draw hands the co-hosts matches with Australia, Paraguay and a European playoff winner – familiar opponents posing very different challenges

The United States were placed in a World Cup group with Australia, Paraguay, and the winner of a European play-off between Turkey, Romania, Kosovo, and Slovakia in Friday’s 2026 World Cup draw in Washington DC. Here’s what to know about the co-host’s opponents.

The winter solstice arrives later this month, and here's what that means.

Meta is acquiring AI wearable startup Limitless, maker of a pendant that records conversations and generates summaries. "We're excited that Limitless will be joining Meta to help accelerate our work to build AI-enabled wearables," a Meta spokesperson said in a statement. CNBC reports: Limitless CEO Dan Siroker revealed the deal on Friday via a corporate blog post but did not disclose the financial terms. "Meta recently announced a new vision to bring personal superintelligence to everyone and a key part of that vision is building incredible AI-enabled wearables," Siroker said in the post and an accompanying video. "We share this vision and we'll be joining Meta to help bring our shared vision to life."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Hundreds driven into Rwanda as M23 militia battles Congolese army and Burundian soldiers for border town of Kamanyola

Fresh fighting in eastern DR Congo has forced hundreds to flee across the border into Rwanda, a day after a peace deal was signed in Washington DC.

Thursday’s agreement was meant to stabilise the resource-rich east but it has had little visible effect on the ground so far, in an area plagued by conflict for 30 years.

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth claimed that he received “total exoneration” in an investigative report by the Defense Department’s Office of Inspector General regarding a Signal group chat about a military attack in Yemen. But the report contradicts that assessment, concluding that Hegseth’s messages “created a risk to operational security that could have resulted in failed U.S. mission objectives and potential harm to U.S. pilots.”

The inspector general report, which was issued Dec. 2 and publicly released two days later, also faulted Hegseth for using a personal cell phone to relay sensitive DoD information, and for not retaining the Signal conversations as official records, as required by federal law and Pentagon policy.

The chat between top administration national security officials on Signal, a private encrypted messaging app, came to light because Jeffrey Goldberg, editor-in-chief of The Atlantic, was inadvertently added to the group chat by National Security Adviser Michael Waltz, who was later removed from his job. In one of the messages, Hegseth appeared to provide a timeline for impending U.S. military strikes in Yemen on March 15.

According to The Atlantic, two hours before the scheduled start of the bombing in Yemen, Hegseth shared this in the group chat:

• “TIME NOW (1144ET): Weather is FAVORABLE. Just CONFIRMED w Centcom we are a GO for mission launch.“
• “1215et: F-18s LAUNCH (1st strike package)”
• “1345: ‘Trigger Based’ F-18 1st Strike Window Starts (Target Terrorist is @ his Known Location so SHOULD BE ON TIME – also, Strike Drones Launch (MQ-9s)”
• “1410: More F-18s LAUNCH (2nd strike package)”
• “1415: Strike Drones on Target (THIS IS WHEN THE FIRST BOMBS WILL DEFINITELY DROP, pending earlier ‘Trigger Based’ targets)”
• “1536 F-18 2nd Strike Starts – also, first sea-based Tomahawks launched.”

Although Hegseth declined to sit for an interview with the inspector general, he provided a written statement on July 25 in which he insisted he provided only an “unclassified summary” of the operation in the Signal chat.

“I am the Original Classification Authority and, in this capacity, I retain the sole discretion to decide whether something should be classified or whether classified materials no longer require protection and can be declassified,” Hegseth wrote to the inspector general. A copy of his statement was attached to the report. “I took non-specific general details which I determined, in my sole discretion, were either not classified, or that I could safely declassify. In making this determination, I chose to keep the details only to the overt actions of DOD assets, which would be readily apparent to any observer in the area and did not include any details about targets or intelligence which may have been derived from other agencies outside of DoD. The purpose of this was to give the principals in the chat thread a heads up on the timeline, as I knew they were going to shortly be notifying partner nations and within hours would also be giving media interviews about what we had done.”

The inspector general report noted that while the information was classified when it was provided to Hegseth, it agreed that as head of the Department of Defense, Hegseth has the “authority to determine the required level of classification for any DoD information he communicates, such as through a document, message, or speech.”

In response to that conclusion, Hegseth’s spokesman, Sean Parnell, released a statement, saying: “This Inspector General review is a TOTAL exoneration of Secretary Hegseth and proves what we knew all along – no classified information was shared. This matter is resolved and the case is closed.”

Hegseth reposted Parnell’s statement on X and echoed his sentiments: “No classified information. Total exoneration. Case closed. Houthis bombed into submission. Thank you for your attention to this IG report.”

In a separate statement, NPR reported, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt said, “This review affirms what the Administration has said from the beginning — no classified information was leaked, and operational security was not compromised.”

The report did conclude that Hegseth had the authority to declassify any information sent via Signal, but the inspector general’s report was not a “total exoneration,” as Hegseth put it.

In his written response to investigators, Hegseth said that “there were no details that would endanger our troops or the mission.” However, the IG concluded, “[I]f this information had fallen into the hands of U.S. adversaries, Houthi forces might have been able to counter U.S. forces or reposition personnel and assets to avoid planned U.S. strikes. Even though these events did not ultimately occur, the Secretary’s actions created a risk to operational security that could have resulted in failed U.S. mission objectives and potential harm to U.S. pilots.”

“The Secretary’s transmission of nonpublic operational information over Signal to an uncleared journalist and others 2 to 4 hours before planned strikes using his personal cell phone exposed sensitive DoD information,” the report said. “Using a personal cell phone to conduct official business and send nonpublic DoD information through Signal risks potential compromise of sensitive DoD information, which could cause harm to DoD personnel and mission objectives.”

While Hegseth had the authority to declassify the information, the report noted that based on Hegseth’s written statement, he did send “sensitive, nonpublic, operational information over Signal from his personal cell phone.” The inspector general said that action violated Department of Defense policy, “which prohibits using a personal device for official business and using a nonapproved commercially available messaging application to send nonpublic DoD information.”

The inspector general also concluded that Hegseth violated federal recordkeeping laws and Defense Department policy about retaining public records. “Specifically, those regulations require officers and employees of Executive Branch agencies and DoD employees to forward a complete copy of any record created on a nonofficial electronic messaging account to an official account within 20 days of the original creation or transmission of the record,” the report said.

Editor’s note: FactCheck.org does not accept advertising. We rely on grants and individual donations from people like you. Please consider a donation. Credit card donations may be made through our “Donate” page. If you prefer to give by check, send to: FactCheck.org, Annenberg Public Policy Center, P.O. Box 58100, Philadelphia, PA 19102. 

The post Pentagon Inspector General Report Not ‘Total Exoneration’ for Hegseth appeared first on FactCheck.org.

"It's very discouraging," said one young job-seeker as employers pull back on hiring entry-level workers.

Commentary: The Beast in Me is one of the best TV shows of the year, and the perfect weekend binge.

Brian Cole Jr makes first court appearance charged with planting two devices on 5 January 2021 in Washington

The man suspected of planting pipe bombs in Washington DC the night before the 6 January 2021 deadly attack on the US Capitol by supporters of Donald Trump trying to overturn his election defeat made his first appearance in federal court on Friday.

Brian Cole Jr, 30, of Woodbridge, Virginia, appeared before Magistrate Judge Moxila Upadhyaya Friday afternoon in Washington DC to face two explosives-related charges on the day after his arrest. Cole was accused of placing pipe bombs outside the headquarters of the Democratic and Republican parties not far from the US Capitol and the White House on the evening of 5 January 2021. Upadhyaya set a detention hearing for 15 December, with prosecutors expected to ask to detain Cole before trial.

Memo says the policy shift, which advocates call ‘reckless’, was designed to align with one of Trump’s anti-trans orders

The US Department of Justice has moved to eliminate rules protecting LGBTQ+ people from sexual abuse in prisons, a shift advocates say is “reckless and dangerous” and will lead to increased assaults behind bars.

A justice department memo issued on Tuesday said “effective immediately”, prisons and jails will no longer be held responsible for violations of standards meant to shield LGBTQ+ people from harassment, abuse and rape. It also directed inspectors to stop auditing facilities for compliance with those protections. The justice department is in the process of seeking formal updates to the rules, the memo said.

LinkedIn and Zoom were among the Cloudflare sites affected.

Plus, these are other surprising wellness devices your HSA and FSA might cover for humans.

‘Mutual’ decision follows controversy over relationship with presidential candidate and claims of ethical breaches

Vanity Fair is ending its association with Olivia Nuzzi, who had briefly been the magazine’s west coast editor, as the publication distances itself from controversy tied in part to her relationship with the US health secretary, Robert F Kennedy Jr.

“Vanity Fair and Olivia Nuzzi have mutually agreed, in the best interest of the magazine, to let her contract expire at the end of the year,” publisher Condé Nast said in a statement on Friday shared with the New York Times.

Ring offers multiple doorbell options on Amazon, all with unique features. Here are our top recommendations for your home.

Justices to take up case amid legal fight over order to heavily restrict right to birthright citizenship in US

• US politics – live updates

The US supreme court agreed on Friday to decide the legality of Donald Trump’s order to heavily restrict the right to birthright citizenship, the long-held constitutional principle that individuals born on US soil are automatically United States citizens.

The justices will hear the president’s request to uphold his executive order on birthright citizenship, issued just hours after Trump took office for his second term and immediately blocked from taking effect.

Cook holiday meals to perfection with the best meat thermometers on the market.

India is weighing a proposal to mandate always-on satellite tracking in smartphones for precise government surveillance -- an idea strongly opposed by Apple, Google, Samsung, and industry groups. Reuters reports: For years, the [Prime Minister Narendra Modi's] administration has been concerned its agencies do not get precise locations when legal requests are made to telecom firms during investigations. Under the current system, the firms are limited to using cellular tower data that can only provide an estimated area location, which can be off by several meters. The Cellular Operators Association of India (COAI), which represents Reliance's Jio and Bharti Airtel, has proposed that precise user locations should only be provided if the government orders smartphone makers to activate A-GPS technology -- which uses satellite signals and cellular data -- according to a June internal federal IT ministry email. That would require location services to always be activated in smartphones with no option for users to disable them. Apple, Samsung, and Alphabet's Google have told New Delhi that should not be mandated, said three of the sources who have direct knowledge of the deliberations. A measure to track device-level location has no precedent anywhere else in the world, lobbying group India Cellular & Electronics Association (ICEA), which represents both Apple and Google, wrote in a confidential July letter to the government, which was viewed by Reuters. "The A-GPS network service ... (is) not deployed or supported for location surveillance," said the letter, which added that the measure "would be a regulatory overreach." Earlier this week, Modi's government was forced to rescind an order requiring smartphone makers to preload a state-run cyber safety app on all devices after public backlash and privacy concerns.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Move from CDC advisers mirrors Trump team’s regressive approach to longstanding vaccine guidance

• Who’s allowed to get the hepatitis B vaccine in the US now?

Vaccine advisers for the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) voted on Friday morning to limit hepatitis B vaccines in a major move signaling the Trump administration’s regressive approach to vaccines that have been given safely and effectively for decades.

The panel of advisers, hand-picked by the US health secretary, Robert F Kennedy Jr, decided to remove the well-established and far-reaching recommendation that all newborns in the US receive a hepatitis B vaccine.

Frank Gehry was known for designing the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao in Spain and the Walt Disney Concert Hall in Los Angeles.

Federal regulators are investigating multiple Texas incidents in which the robotaxis drove around stopped school buses.

President Trump has led the charge to create more GOP-friendly congressional districts in the 2026 midterm elections.

The man suspected of planting pipe bombs outside the RNC and DNC is believed to be a Trump supporter and has been speaking with investigators, multiple sources told CBS News.

The 2026 Men's World Cup will be held across the United States, Canada and Mexico next summer.

Kerrville Police Chief Chris McCall warned that the 911 calls received by dispatchers during the Texas floods are distressing.

Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz recently faced questions about a state fraud scandal involving Somalis that spawned a feud between him and President Donald Trump.

The scandal, outlined in a Nov. 29 article in The New York Times, centered on a nonprofit called Feeding Our Future that received federal funding to feed low-income children. NBC’s "Meet the Press" host Kristen Welker asked Walz, the 2024 Democratic vice presidential nominee, on Nov. 30 about the schemes mentioned in the article that involved people convicted in Minnesota for stealing taxpayer money during the pandemic. 

Welker asked Walz: "Do you take responsibility for failing to stop this fraud in your state?" 

The governor replied, "Well, certainly, I take responsibility for putting people in jail. Governors don't get to just talk theoretically. We have to solve problems." 

His statement gives the impression that state officials were on the front lines of prosecuting historic fraud. That’s not what happened. Federal prosecutors led the investigations and brought the charges.

We asked Walz for evidence the governor was responsible for convictions.

"Prosecutions don’t materialize out of thin air," Walz spokesperson Claire Lancaster said. 

State officials cited Minnesota agencies’ work, including by the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, whose laboratory provided forensic testing on evidence. Jen Longaecker, a Minnesota Department of Public Safety spokesperson, pointed to the bureau’s role in identifying fingerprints on a gift bag used in a Feeding Our Future juror bribery scheme. But that case was an offshoot of the initial fraud investigation.

Trump cited the scandal as a reason to end Temporary Protected Status for Somalis in Minnesota, writing Nov. 21 on Truth Social, "Somali gangs are terrorizing the people of that great State, and BILLIONS of Dollars are missing." 

Temporary Protected Status is for people from certain countries experiencing war, natural disasters or epidemics and protects them from deportation. There are about 700 Somalis in the U.S. with TPS, many in Minnesota. Immigration lawyers said it isn’t possible to take away the status state by state. 

Before Trump vowed to do that, the TPS program for Somalis across the U.S. was already set to expire in March 2026. 

An estimated 100,000 people who identify as Somali live in Minnesota and the majority are U.S. citizens. Many came to the state in the 1990s fleeing a civil war. 

Trump appeared to be reacting to a recent report from a conservative activist that said Somalis stole the money to use it for terrorism. That claim, which has circulated since 2018, lacks evidence.

Federal authorities took the lead

In February 2021, the FBI notified the Minnesota Department of Education about kickback allegations involving Feeding Our Future and allegations the group wasn’t providing meals as it said it had. Two months later, the education department notified the FBI that it believed some meal sites were submitting fraudulent documents and inflating the number of children receiving meals. 

Prosecutors said defendants stole $250 million in federal money and spent it on international vacations, real estate, jewelry and luxury cars. 

Then-U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland called it "the largest pandemic relief fraud scheme."

Feeding Our Future employees recruited people and entities to open sites to feed children, creating shell companies to launder the money. The group existed before the pandemic. But amid COVID-19 school shutdowns, the federal government lifted some requirements about where children could get meals, and afterward the number of meals Feeding Our Future said it served soared. Prosecutors said the defendants exploited those changes and created false documentation such as fake attendance rosters listing how many people had been fed, significantly inflating the numbers. 

Some state employees raised red flags about the organization, and early in the pandemic, questioned its growth. Then Feeding Our Families sued the state, and a judge told the state it had "a real problem not reimbursing at this stage of the game." But the judge did not rule on the matter in an April 2021 hearing, and the state resumed paying Feeding Our Future. 

Walz sought in 2022 to blame the judge for the resumed payments, prompting the judge to issue a statement that the governor was wrong, and the education department had resumed the payments on its own, not because of an order from him, the Minnesota Reformer reported in 2022.

Federal prosecutors announced in September 2022 criminal charges against 47 defendants — a number that eventually grew to 78.

Federal officials largely cited the investigative work of federal offices, although they said the state education department cooperated.

Most of the defendants were of Somali descent. More than 50 people have pleaded guilty while others were convicted at trial, including Feeding Our Future founder Aimee Bock, who is not Somali. 

Did the state play a role? 

We found scant mention of state agencies in stories about the investigation dating to 2022. In January 2022, the Minnesota Star Tribune reported the state Bureau of Criminal Apprehension was working on the investigation along with federal offices, but news accounts largely cited the federal law enforcement work.

The FBI had to build its case from scratch, the Star Tribune found, obtaining records from hundreds of bank accounts. The newspaper wrote in 2022 that state and federal records showed that "Minnesota officials provided federal authorities with little or no evidence" that Feeding Our Future misappropriated government money. 

The Minnesota Reformer and the Star Tribune have reported that state officials could have done more to stop or investigate fraud. 

The state legislative auditor found in 2024 that the education department provided inadequate oversight and "could have taken more decisive action sooner."

Mark Osler, a law professor at University of St. Thomas in Minneapolis, told PolitiFact it makes sense that federal authorities led the case given the complexity, involvement of federal money and potential for conflicts of interest for state officials.

Osler, a former federal prosecutor, said the state should have detected the fraud earlier.

"The underlying issue isn’t really punishing people later, it is detecting the fraud before it became so large and stopping it," he said. 

Recent Minnesota fraud cases

During the "Meet the Press" interview, Welker mentioned $1 billion in fraud, a cumulative figure spanning many fraud cases, including more recent ones. 

Acting U.S. Attorney Joe Thompson told local ABC affiliate KSTP-TV in July that he expects the scope of fraud will exceed $1 billion when investigators complete their findings.

In September, federal prosecutors charged defendants in schemes misusing housing funding and money to provide services for people with autism spectrum disorder.

State Bureau of Criminal Apprehension agents continue to work with federal investigators on those cases, Longaecker said.

Our ruling

Walz said he took "responsibility for putting people in jail" in the Minnesota fraud scandal.

The work of federal investigators and prosecutors — not state officials — led to dozens of convictions in the Feeding Our Future scandal. 

Reporting by media organizations in the state showed that Minnesota officials provided little or no evidence to federal investigators, who had to build a case from scratch, and that the state could have done more to aid the investigation. 

We rate this statement False.

PolitiFact Researcher Caryn Baird contributed to this report.

Home security videos shows Jacelynn Guzman, 23, telling masked federal agents following her to ‘leave me alone’

A US citizen who was seen on home security video being chased by masked federal agents outside New Orleans amid the Trump administration’s sweeping immigration crackdown says she surmises that she was pursued because “I’m brown”.

“I have no idea why they targeted me,” Jacelynn Guzman told Guardian reporting partner WWL Louisiana on Thursday, a day after the video in question was taken and subsequently went viral online.

Our live report from a ceremony that was part intriguing spectacle and part prolonged fever dream featuring Donald Trump dancing to the Village People

⚽ France, Senegal and Norway meet in ‘Group of Death’
⚽ Trump gets inaugural Fifa peace prize at World Cup draw

Benjamin gets in touch: “I am webmaster of www.national-football-teams.com !

“As you can imagine, draw day is quite something when international football is one of your things. I want to chip in on possible groups of death. These are the two of the hardest groups I could come up with:

Argentina

Morocco

Norway

Italy (If they qualify)

Spain

Colombia

Ivory Coast

Denmark (If they qualify)

Canada

Austria

Qatar

Cape Verde

Belgium

Iran

South Africa

Curacao

Our gift guide eliminates the hunting part for the Stranger Things fan in your life.

The architect, whose work included the Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao and the Walt Disney Concert Hall in LA, died after a brief illness

Frank Gehry, one of the most influential and distinctive talents in American architecture, died on Friday at his home in Los Angeles following a brief respiratory illness, his chief of staff confirmed. He was 96.

Gehry, the most recognizable American architect since Frank Lloyd Wright, was one of the first to embrace the potential of computer design, and pioneered a distinctively exuberant style of bravura power, whimsical and arresting collisions of form. His most famous work remains the Guggenheim Museumin Bilbao, a fantastical, titanium-clad composition on the Nervión River which received international acclaim upon its opening in 1997, heralding a new era of emotive architecture.

At a gaudy and gauche World Cup draw, Gianni Infantino went all out to flatter the world’s most precious ego

It had about as much drama and suspense as reading a dictionary or watching election results come in from North Korea.

To the surprise of no one, Donald Trump won the inaugural Fifa peace prize on Friday at a cheesy, gaudy and gauche World Cup draw expertly designed to flatter the world’s most precious ego.

These are the tell-tale signs of an AI-generated video so you don't get tricked into believing something fake is real.

The Supreme Court said Friday it will decide the legality of President Trump's executive order that seeks to end birthright citizenship​.

CNET's experts teamed up with a sleep professional to help you pick out the best sleep headphones you can buy.

If you're looking to earn quick interest without much work, a high-rate, 3-month CD could be worth exploring now.

The New York Times is suing Perplexity for copyright infringement, accusing the AI startup of repackaging its paywalled reporting without permission. TechCrunch reports: The Times joins several media outlets suing Perplexity, including the Chicago Tribune, which also filed suit this week. The Times' suit claims that "Perplexity provides commercial products to its own users that substitute" for the outlet, "without permission or remuneration." [...] "While we believe in the ethical and responsible use and development of AI, we firmly object to Perplexity's unlicensed use of our content to develop and promote their products," Graham James, a spokesperson for The Times, said in a statement. "We will continue to work to hold companies accountable that refuse to recognize the value of our work." Similar to the Tribune's suit, the Times takes issue with Perplexity's method for answering user queries by gathering information from websites and databases to generate responses via its retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) products, like its chatbots and Comet browser AI assistant. "Perplexity then repackages the original content in written responses to users," the suit reads. "Those responses, or outputs, often are verbatim or near-verbatim reproductions, summaries, or abridgments of the original content, including The Times's copyrighted works." Or, as James put it in his statement, "RAG allows Perplexity to crawl the internet and steal content from behind our paywall and deliver it to its customers in real time. That content should only be accessible to our paying subscribers." The Times also claims Perplexity's search engine has hallucinated information and falsely attributed it to the outlet, which damages its brand. "Publishers have been suing new tech companies for a hundred years, starting with radio, TV, the internet, social media, and now AI," Jesse Dwyer, Perplexity's head of communications, told TechCrunch. "Fortunately it's never worked, or we'd all be talking about this by telegraph."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

On Monday, the Supreme Court will hear arguments in Trump v. Slaughter, a dispute over the ability of the president to fire Federal Trade Commission (FTC) members that could have wide-ranging implications. A ruling also could have a significant impact beyond independent agencies.

In March 2025, President Donald Trump removed Rebecca Kelly Slaughter from her position as a commissioner for the FTC. Slaughter countered by suing Trump and others, claiming her dismissal violated the terms of the Federal Trade Commission Act.

The U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia found that Slaughter’s firing violated a precedent set in Humphrey’s Executor v. United States (1935), which established the constitutionality of the FTC’s removal protections. A divided U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit denied a stay request from the Trump administration, citing the precent of Humphrey’s Executor. Then on Sept. 22, 2025, the Supreme Court treated the Trump administration’s emergency relief application as a petition for certiorari before judgment on the following two questions:

1) Whether the statutory removal protections for members of the FTC violate the separation of powers and, if so, whether Humphrey’s Executor v. United States should be overruled.

(2) Whether a federal court may prevent a person’s removal from public office, either through relief at equity or at law.

The Fate of Humphrey’s Executor

The Supreme Court considered the Humphrey’s Executor case in another era where an incoming president wanted to make a change to the Federal Trade Commission after an election.

William E. Humphrey was serving a six-year term in 1933 at the FTC when President Franklin Roosevelt asked Humphrey for his resignation, on the grounds that “that the aims and purposes of the Administration with respect to the work of the Commission can be carried out most effectively with personnel of my own selection.” When Humphrey refused to resign, Roosevelt fired Humphrey, but Humphrey did not acknowledge Roosevelt’s decision and continued to collect his salary. After Humphrey died in 1934, his estate sued for back pay.

In the Court’s unanimous Humphrey’s Executor decision, Justice George Sutherland said the Federal Trade Commission Act’s language provided that its commissioners could only be removed by the president for inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office. The Court noted its prior decision in Myers v. United States, which held that a postmaster could be removed by the chief executive because “an officer is merely one of the units in the executive department.”

Justice Sutherland drew a distinction between the Myers majority decision written by Chief Justice William Howard Taft and the case at hand in Humphrey’s Executor: “When Congress provides for the appointment of officers whose functions, like those of the Federal Trade Commissioners, are of Legislative and judicial quality, rather than executive, and limits the grounds upon which they may be removed from office, the president has no constitutional power to remove them for reasons other than those so specified,” Sutherland noted.

The Arguments in the Slaughter Case

In a response brief, Slaughter’s attorneys point to Humphrey’s Executor and other precedents limiting the president’s ability to remove board members from multi-member federal agencies. “This case raises momentous questions.” they argue. “In blessing removal protections for traditional multimember agencies—first in Humphrey’s Executor v. United States and then, time and again, in succeeding cases involving the constitutionality of such protections—has this Court gotten it wrong for the last 90 years?”

The brief also points to the original intent of the First Congress, which it says “created multimember bodies over which the president did not have the ‘illimitable’ and ‘unrestricted’ removal power they posit.”

Slaughter’s attorneys also argue that a ruling for the Trump administration would greatly upset the separation of powers between the executive and legislative branches, adding to the “power of the executive branch by transferring to the presidency vast new powers that Congress and prior presidents, working together, chose not to vest in the president alone.”

In his brief, Solicitor General John Sauer states that Article II of the Constitution allows a president “to remove those who assist him in carrying out his duties.” Sauer also cites Seila Law LLC v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (2020), which he believes questioned the reasoning of the Humphrey’s Executor case.

Seila Law LLC, a firm that provided debt-related legal services to clients, was under investigation by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Seila Law argued that the agency’s structure, consisting of a single director who exercised substantial executive power but who was removable only for cause was unconstitutional because such a structure violated the separation of powers.

Chief Justice John Roberts wrote the 5-4 majority’s Seila Law decision, agreeing that “the CFPB’s leadership by a single individual removable only for inefficiency, neglect, or malfeasance violates the separation of powers.” The Chief Justice believed the structure of the modern CFPB bore little resemblance to the New Deal era-created Federal Trade Commission.

Sauer points to the reasoning in Seila Law and other precedents that Humphrey’s Executor wrongly concluded in 1935 that “FTC exercised no executive power at all” and that the modern commission has little resemblance to today’s FTC.

On the second question presented to the Supreme Court, a ruling could have a significant impact on independent agencies. Judge Neomi Rao in her dissenting opinion in the D.C. Circuit wrote that courts do not have the power to issue injunctions reinstating terminated officials and instead can only provide remedies at law. If the Supreme Court agrees with Rao’s stance, the president might be able to remove any executive branch employee, as long as the president is willing to pay out an employee’s damages claim.

As the Court considers arguments in Trump v. Slaughter, related cases possibly affected include President Trump’s ability to fire Shira Perlmutter, the Register of Copyrights and Director of the U.S. Copyright Office, and to terminate Lisa Cook from the Federal Reserve Board of Governors.

The Supreme Court has deferred a decision in Perlmutter’s case until its hears arguments in Trump v. Slaughter and Cook’s case, which will be heard by the Supreme Court on Jan. 21, 2026. In August 2025, President Trump removed Lisa Cook from the Federal Reserve Board based on claims of alleged mortgage fraud. Cook claims Trump lacked the power to fire her from the board. A divided U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia ruled for Cook on her claims she was not fired for cause and she lacked due process. The Supreme Court is considering if it should stay the district court’s decision.

Scott Bomboy is the editor in chief of the National Constitution Center.

Minimum wages are set to rise in 22 U.S. states and 66 cities and counties next year, even as the federal baseline wage remains at $7.25.

LAS VEGAS, Dec. 5, 2025 — Amazon Web Services (AWS) has announced that Proteintech, a global leader in antibody and life science solutions, has selected AWS as its preferred cloud provider. Using AWS’s compute, containers, database, and analytics services, Proteintech successfully built the industry’s first AI antibody assistant called “Able” in just six months. This tool provides researchers with precise, efficient product information and technical support to accelerate scientific discovery and innovation.

Proteintech’s core business includes the production and sale of antibodies, nanobodies, proteins, kits and other reagents, serving global academic and pharmaceutical customers with proteomics, cell culture, and current Good Manufacturing Practice (cGMP) biomanufacturing applications. Proteintech has migrated 85% of its workloads to AWS, leveraging AWS’s secure, reliable, and highly available infrastructure to achieve integrated operations across its headquarters and global subsidiaries, accelerating global business deployment and expansion.

Driven by the mission to “provide researchers worldwide with precise and efficient product information and technical support to enable scientific discovery and innovation,” Proteintech created this AI experimental assistant dedicated to life science researchers. Able shares Proteintech’s product data, experimental data, and relevant scientific knowledge, allowing scientists to obtain product recommendations and experimental design support through conversational interactions, enabling them to focus more on cutting-edge research and drive scientific innovation. Using AWS’s elastic cloud computing resources, Proteintech significantly optimized the entire process from project initiation and selection to development and testing, reducing Able’s launch cycle by 50% and gaining a first-mover advantage in AI application development.

With AWS, Proteintech effectively reduced Able’s operational costs while improving stability. Built on Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (Amazon EC2), Able can flexibly scale up or down during business peaks, achieving elastic scaling of computing resources and effectively reducing computing costs. With Amazon Elastic Container Service (Amazon ECS), Proteintech can uniformly manage Able’s inference, web gateway, vector retrieval, and other microservices, ensuring zero-downtime version updates. Using ECS Task Placement strategies, Proteintech effectively addresses complex requirements of different workloads, providing researchers with a stable and reliable intelligent assistant.

Using AWS’s managed relational database and petabyte-scale cloud data warehouse services, Able can quickly extract useful scientific information from massive data, improving research efficiency. Able stores structured business data using Amazon Relational Database Service (Amazon RDS) and is deployed with Amazon RDS Multi-AZ, making it easy to complete time-consuming database management tasks while ensuring high data availability. At the same time, Able uses Amazon Redshift to build a research behavior data warehouse, enabling scientists to directly leverage its SQL analysis capabilities to perform large-scale cross-analysis of data such as Amazon RDS SQL Server logs and experimental result files, accessing expert-level R&D assistance in a very short time.

“Proteintech has successfully built the industry’s first AI antibody assistant ‘Able’ based on AWS, accelerating life science research efficiency by providing intelligent, precise scientific Q&A services,” said Ma Li, IT vice president of Proteintech Group. “In the future, we will continue to explore more innovative application scenarios with AWS to enable breakthroughs in life science research.”

“We are proud to support Proteintech in their mission to empower scientists with an intelligent AI research assistant that accelerates discovery and fuels innovation in life sciences,” said Jared Saul, chief medical officer, Commercial Healthcare and Life Sciences at AWS. “AWS is the most secure, compliant, and resilient cloud for life sciences. We’re pleased to enable Proteintech with leading cloud services and generative AI technology to help scientists accelerate biomarker discovery, improve research efficiency, and drive breakthrough scientific discoveries in the field of life sciences.”

Source: AWS

The post Proteintech Selects AWS as Preferred Cloud Provider, Launches AI Antibody Assistant for Scientific Discovery appeared first on HPCwire.

Capital One-Discover has funded the Delaware Funding Access Initiative, a $2.3 million commitment to expand low-barrier, affordable capital for small businesses and entrepreneurs across Delaware.

Conceived as both an investment and a call to action, the Delaware Funding Access Initiative brings together nonprofits, universities, and community development financial institutions (CDFIs) to give entrepreneurs in every county the tools and resources needed to innovate, activate and scale. 

“Capital One is committed to increasing direct access to capital, a critical component of a thriving small business ecosystem. The Delaware Funding Access Initiative builds on our Community Benefits Plan and advances a hyperlocal investment strategy that strengthens Delaware communities through the success of entrepreneurs,” said Kerone Vatel, SVP of Community Finance & Impact at Capital One. Capital One, which has a strong Delaware presence, employs more than 1,200 associates in the state and has been named one of Delaware’s top employers.  

Targeted Investments Across Delaware

The Delaware Funding Access Initiative’s investment touches every corner of the state, with targeted funding designed to address gaps in capital, technology, and mentorship. The fund will work to support small businesses statewide through trusted community partners via Capital One’s grants:

• $100,000 – Delaware Small Business Development Center: This funding will support the provision of technical assistance to small business owners, fund a course for starting a business, and facilitate small business access to government contracting opportunities for EDGE grants.
• $150,000 – Pete du Pont Freedom Foundation: The grant aims to foster marketplace access for entrepreneurs and their ideas, specifically supporting technical assistance, mentorship, and direct access to capital for small businesses.
• $200,000 – West End Neighborhood House: This funding will support a prerequisite technical assistance program designed to prepare small business owners to secure capital from local lenders.
• $225,000 – Capital One & Delaware State University – Innovation Venture: Established to guide students from ideation to business creation, the grant is intended to fuel the next generation of student ag-tech entrepreneurs and startups.
• $275,000 – True Access Capital: As one of Delaware’s leading community development financial institutions, True Access Capital will utilize this grant to expand lending capacity and technical assistance within New Castle, Kent, and Sussex counties.
• $350,000 – Bronze Valley: This venture capital firm will focus on supporting high-growth, pre-seed startups through accelerator and venture Community Development Financial Institution (CDFI) models.
• $500,000 – Delaware Technology Park: Funding will support the Growth Stage Incubator and provide business support services and collaborative learning opportunities.
• $500,000 – Stepping Stones Credit Union: Funding will provide access to credit union services and small business lending.

“By lowering barriers to capital and partnering with organizations trusted in local communities, the Delaware Funding Access Initiative is designed to help entrepreneurs not only access financing but also build resilience,” said Joe Westcott, VP and Delaware Market President at Capital One. “The funding is flexible — supporting businesses as they adopt new technologies, adjust to changing policy environments, or weather unexpected challenges.”

Supporting Delaware’s Small Business Resiliency

Small businesses are the backbone of Delaware’s economy. This investment will provide essential capacity, enabling small businesses to further boost the state’s economy in key areas:

• Job Creation & Employment Growth: Nearly 100,000 small businesses employ more than 205,000 people, representing 98% of all businesses in the state.
• Local & Community Impact: Between March 2021 and March 2022, over 4,500 new establishments opened, creating nearly 9,600 jobs. However, 3,200 businesses closed during the same period, highlighting the fragility of entrepreneurship without adequate support.

National research echoes these challenges. According to McKinsey & Company, small and medium enterprises generate about half of all economic value but lag behind large firms in productivity due to gaps in capital, technology, and training. “In Delaware, where nearly half of small businesses are female-owned and more than half are minority-owned, closing the gap in access to capital is critical,” added Westcott.

Building a Framework for Long-Term Growth

While the initial $2.3 million investment is significant, in its framework we hope to bring these organizations together for further collaboration. By aligning lenders, universities, nonprofits, and private capital, the initiative prioritizes accessibility and sustainable growth for small business in the state.

“Small business owners are the problem-solvers, job-creators, and innovators who keep Delaware growing. Our role is to ensure they have access to the capital and support needed to thrive. When we invest in small businesses, we are investing in the economic mobility of entire communities,” said Christopher S. Gunter, Delaware Valley & Midwest Market Manager, Community Impact & Investment at Capital One. His remarks underscore the core purpose of the Initiative — to build a more inclusive ecosystem where entrepreneurs have the resources to launch, sustain and scale their businesses.

By strengthening access to affordable financing, the fund ensures that small businesses — the lifeblood of Delaware’s economy, have the foundation to thrive, innovate, and drive long-term success.

Since the inception of its community impact program, Capital One has provided over $21 million in grant funding to Delaware-based nonprofits. Additionally, Capital One has pledged a $35 million commitment to philanthropy in Delaware, as a part of the five-year, $265 billion Community Benefits Plan under Capital One’s newly approved acquisition of Discover.

The post Capital One is expanding funding access ​for Delaware’s entrepreneurs appeared first on Spotlight Delaware.

A federal judge granted a Justice Department request to unseal grand jury transcripts from a federal investigation in Florida into convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein.

Ruling compels unsealing of documents from 2006-2007 federal investigation into Epstein in Florida

A federal judge in Florida ordered the release of grand jury transcripts from the Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell sex-trafficking cases on Friday, citing the recently enacted federal law that overrides traditional secrecy protections.

US district judge Rodney Smith ruled that the Epstein Files Transparency Act, signed into law last month by Donald Trump, overrode federal rules prohibiting the disclosure of grand jury materials.

Advisers for the CDC voted to limit the vaccines – here’s what happened and why the vote is so significant

Vaccine advisers for the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) voted on Friday morning to limit hepatitis B vaccines in a major move signaling the Trump administration’s regressive approach to vaccines that have been given safely and effectively for decades.

What is the situation now and what does this mean?

Electric toothbrushes can make dental care easier. With the holiday rolling in, this is a great time to pick up one of the best models we’ve found.

His unearthly but brilliant designs, from Los Angeles to Bilbao, became global landmarks.

• England to play Croatia, Panama and Ghana in Group L

• France joined by Senegal and Norway in Group I

• Trump awarded inaugural Fifa peace prize

England will face a rematch of their 2018 semi-final in the opening fixture of their World Cup campaign next summer, after they were drawn alongside Croatia in Group L.

England will also play Panama, another side they faced at the Russia World Cup, and Ghana. Venues and kick-off times will be announced from 5pm GMT on Saturday but the group’s matches are split across four US cities – Dallas, Boston, New York/New Jersey and Philadelphia – and Toronto.

LARISSA VERONICA HEATHER
Managing Visuals and Layout Editor

MICHAEL BOYER
Photographer

Managing Visuals and Layout Editor Larissa Veronica Heather and Photographer Michael Boyer capture Delaware’s extreme loss against Iona.

US politicians and Hollywood guilds have voiced concerns against the proposed $83bn purchase of the studio

The news that Netflix has agreed to buy Warner Bros in an $83bn deal has led to backlash among figures in and out of the entertainment industry.

Elizabeth Warren, a Democratic senator, called it “an anti-monopoly nightmare” in a statement released soon after the announcement.

The iPhone 17 brings improvements to the camera, display and battery. But is it worth the upgrade?

Chrome now integrates with Google Wallet to incorporate more information.

Cloudflare says it blocked 416 billion AI scraping attempts in five months and warns that AI is reshaping the internet's economic model -- with Google's combined crawler creating a monopoly-style dilemma where opting out of AI means disappearing from search altogether. Tom's Hardware reports: "The business model of the internet has always been to generate content that drive traffic and then sell either things, subscriptions, or ads, [Cloudflare CEO Matthew Prince] told Wired. "What I think people don't realize, though, is that AI is a platform shift. The business model of the internet is about to change dramatically. I don't know what it's going to change to, but it's what I'm spending almost every waking hour thinking about." While Cloudflare blocks almost all AI crawlers, there's one particular bot it cannot block without affecting its customers' online presence -- Google. The search giant combined its search and AI crawler into one, meaning users who opt out of Google's AI crawler won't be indexed in Google search results. "You can't opt out of one without opting out of both, which is a real challenge -- it's crazy," Prince continued. "It shouldn't be that you can use your monopoly position of yesterday in order to leverage and have a monopoly position in the market of tomorrow."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

I tried all the themed menu items from the two fast-food chains, from dill-dusted fries to burgers with sponge-yellow buns to pineapple floats.

• World Cup draw 2026: live reaction

• Turkey, Romania Slovakia or Kosovo is other opponent

• Co-hosts begin their campaign on 12 June in LA

A full 1,098 days since exiting the 2022 men’s World Cup with a loss to the Netherlands in the heat of Qatar, and 189 days until they open the 2026 World Cup in the midsummer heat of Los Angeles, the US men’s national team found out who they’ll face next in the world’s most popular sporting event on a cold, snowy day in Washington DC. Games against Australia, Paraguay, and one of Turkey, Romania, Slovakia and Kosovo will await the US in the 2026 World Cup, which they will co-host with Mexico and Canada, after the draw for the competition at the Kennedy Center on Friday.

The United States’ opening game in the competition is set for 12 June in Los Angeles, with subsequent group games in Seattle on 19 June and in Los Angeles again on 25 June. Fifa will announce the order of opponents and the kickoff times for those games on Saturday at 5pm ET.

Debt resolution can help you get rid of your high-rate debt, but the impact on your credit report can last a while.

Web infrastructure provider says problem lasted half an hour and was not an attack, weeks after larger outage

Cloudflare has apologised after an outage on Friday morning hit websites including LinkedIn, Zoom and Downdetector, the company’s second outage in less than a month.

“Any outage of our systems is unacceptable, and we know we have let the internet down again,” it said in a blogpost, adding that it would release more information next week on how it aims to prevent these failures.

No crease, but big price: Apple's iPhone Fold might launch at $2,400.

To best take advantage of the December Fed rate cut, homebuyers should first understand which big mistakes to avoid.

Party removes Ian Cooper after he was alleged to have abused Sadiq Khan, David Lammy and other figures online

Nigel Farage has revoked the party membership of a Reform UK council leader accused of racially abusing Sadiq Khan, David Lammy and other public figures online.

Ian Cooper, the leader of Staffordshire county council, allegedly called the London mayor a “narcissistic Pakistani” and said migrants were “intent on colonising the UK, destroying all that has gone before”.

Hundreds of videos on TikTok and elsewhere impersonate experts to sell supplements with unproven effects

TikTok and other social media platforms are hosting AI-generated deepfake videos of doctors whose words have been manipulated to help sell supplements and spread health misinformation.

The factchecking organisation Full Fact has uncovered hundreds of such videos featuring impersonated versions of doctors and influencers directing viewers to Wellness Nest, a US-based supplements firm.

COLUMBUS, Ohio, Dec. 5, 2025 — Vertiv Holdings Co, a global provider of critical digital infrastructure, has announced the successful completion of its previously reported intent to acquire Purge Rite Intermediate LLC, a leading provider of mechanical flushing, purging and filtration services for data centers and other mission-critical facilities. The approximately $1.0 billion acquisition enhances Vertiv’s thermal management services capabilities and strengthens its position as a global leader in next-generation thermal chain services for liquid cooling systems.

Vertiv completed the acquisition of PurgeRite, to deepen its liquid cooling services for data center customers. Image credit: Vertiv.

“We are excited to officially welcome PurgeRite to Vertiv, expanding to deepen our fluid management services capabilities,” said Gio Albertazzi, CEO at Vertiv. “PurgeRite’s specialized expertise in fluid management services complements our existing portfolio and enhances our ability to provide end-to-end product and service support for customers’ high-density computing and AI applications where efficient thermal management is critical to performance and reliability.”

High-performance computing (HPC) and the AI factories require liquid cooling technology to operate, and it is crucial to deploy and maintain clean fluid loops to maximize cooling performance. Achieving this starts with optimal flow at commissioning by establishing ultra-clean, air-free, chemically stable coolant, and preserving that balance to maintain performance throughout the system’s lifecycle.

The integration of PurgeRite’s capabilities with Vertiv’s existing thermal management portfolio is expected to offer significant customer benefits, including enhanced system performance through improved heat transfer and equipment efficiency, reduced risk of downtime through operational excellence, and expanded service scale supporting global operations with consistent quality.

Headquartered in Houston, Texas, PurgeRite has established itself as an industry leader in mechanical flushing, purging, and filtration for mission-critical data center applications, including strong relationships with hyperscalers and Tier 1 colocation providers. It brings engineering expertise, proprietary technologies and the ability to scale to meet the needs of challenging data center schedules, enabling complex liquid cooling applications across the thermal chain from chillers to coolant distribution units (CDUs). The company’s services will join forces with Vertiv’s existing liquid cooling offerings to deliver end-to-end thermal management solutions from facility to room and row to rack.

For more information about Vertiv’s portfolio of solutions, visit Vertiv.com.

About Vertiv

Vertiv (NYSE: VRT) brings together hardware, software, analytics and ongoing services to enable its customers’ vital applications to run continuously, perform optimally and grow with their business needs. Vertiv solves the most important challenges facing today’s data centers, communication networks and commercial and industrial facilities with a portfolio of power, cooling and IT infrastructure solutions and services that extends from the cloud to the edge of the network. Headquartered in Westerville, Ohio, USA, Vertiv does business in more than 130 countries.

Source: Vertiv

The post Vertiv Completes Acquisition of PurgeRite, Expanding Leadership in Liquid Cooling Services appeared first on HPCwire.

Dec. 5, 2025 — For 25 years, the NVIDIA Graduate Fellowship Program has supported graduate students doing outstanding work relevant to NVIDIA technologies. Today, the program announced the latest awards of up to $60,000 each to 10 Ph.D. students involved in research that spans all areas of computing innovation.

Credit: Shutterstock

Selected from a highly competitive applicant pool, the awardees will participate in a summer internship preceding the fellowship year. Their work puts them at the forefront of accelerated computing — tackling projects in autonomous systems, computer architecture, computer graphics, deep learning, programming systems, robotics and security.

The NVIDIA Graduate Fellowship Program is open to applicants worldwide.

The 2026-2027 fellowship recipients are:

• Jiageng Mao, University of Southern California — Solving complex physical AI problems by using diverse priors from internet-scale data to enable robust, generalizable intelligence for embodied agents in the real world.
• Liwen Wu, University of California San Diego — Enriching realism and efficiency in physically based rendering with neural materials and neural rendering.
• Manya Bansal, Massachusetts Institute of Technology — Designing programming languages for modern accelerators that enable developers to write modular, reusable code without sacrificing the low-level control required for peak performance.
• Sizhe Chen, University of California, Berkeley — Securing AI in real-world applications, currently securing AI agents against prompt injection attacks with general and practical defenses that preserve the agent’s utility.
• Yunfan Jiang, Stanford University — Developing scalable approaches to build generalist robots for everyday tasks through hybrid data sources spanning real-world whole-body manipulation, large-scale simulation and internet-scale multimodal supervision.
• Yijia Shao, Stanford University — Researching human-agent collaboration by developing AI agents that can communicate and coordinate with humans during task execution, and designing new human-agent interaction interfaces.
• Shangbin Feng, University of Washington — Advancing model collaboration: multiple machine learning models, trained on different data and by different people, collaborate, compose and complement each other for an open, decentralized and collaborative AI future.
• Shvetank Prakash, Harvard University — Advancing hardware architecture and systems design with AI agents built on new algorithms, curated datasets and agent-first infrastructure.
• Irene Wang, Georgia Institute of Technology — Developing a holistic codesign framework that integrates accelerator architecture, network topology and runtime scheduling to enable energy-efficient and sustainable AI training at scale.
• Chen Geng, Stanford University — Modeling 4D physical worlds with scalable data-driven algorithms and physics-inspired principles, advancing physically grounded 3D and 4D world models for robotics and scientific applications.

NVIDIA also acknowledges the 2026-2027 fellowship finalists:

• Zizheng Guo, Peking University
• Peter Holderrieth, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
• Xianghui Xie, Max Planck Institute for Informatics
• Alexander Root, Stanford University
• Daniel Palenicek, Technical University of Darmstadt

Source: Sylvia Chanak, NVIDIA

The post NVIDIA Awards up to $60,000 Research Fellowships to PhD Students appeared first on HPCwire.

Testing showing racial bias against black and Asian people prompts watchdog to ask Home Office for explanation

The UK’s data protection watchdog has asked the Home Office for “urgent clarity” over racial bias in police facial recognition technology before considering its next steps.

The Home Office has admitted that the technology was “more likely to incorrectly include some demographic groups in its search results”, after testing by the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) of its application within the police national database.

Producer says creatives need to own their intellectual property so they can license it to generative AI platforms

The Eurythmics co-founder Dave Stewart has said artificial intelligence is an “unstoppable force”, and musicians and other artists should bow to the inevitable and license their music to generative AI platforms.

These platforms use artificial intelligence to analyse existing songs and tracks, using that knowledge to generate completely new ones as prompted by a user. For example, someone could ask the AI platform to generate a song about a boozy night out in the style of a Britpop band, and it would draw on songs with similar sounds and themes to create its own.

Dec. 5, 2025 — Five researchers from the U.S. Department of Energy’s Argonne National Laboratory have won the Ewing ​“Rusty” Lusk Best Paper award at EuroMPI/USA 2025, held at the University of North Carolina in October. EuroMPI is the leading event for users, developers and researchers to discuss new developments and applications of the Message Passing Interface (MPI).

The award is named after Ewing ​“Rusty” Lusk (1943–2022). Lusk was one of the founders of the Message Passing Interface Forum. Hechaired MPI-2 and co-started the MPICH project to create the first implementation of the MPI standard. He also served as director of the Mathematics and Computer Science (MCS) division at Argonne from 2005 to 2011 and was an Argonne Distinguished Fellow Emeritus.

The award-winning paper, ​“Implementing True MPI Sessions and Evaluating MPI Initialization Scalability,” was co-authored by Hui Zhou, Ken Raffenetti, Mike Wilkins, Yanfei Guo and Rajeev Thakur.

“We are deeply honored to receive this award,” said Zhou. Zhou is the lead author and a principal software development specialist in the MCS division. ​“Rusty would be proud to see us continuing to improve MPICH and MPI for today’s scientific community.”

The paper focused on a new feature in the MPI 4 standard called the Sessions model, which enables an MPI process to locally initialize and construct communicators on demand. Sessions removed the overhead associated with the global MPI communicator comm_world — especially helpful for large-scale applications.

“MPICH has supported MPI Sessions since 2021,” said Raffenetti, a principal specialist, research software engineering in the MCS division. ​“But it didn’t fully achieve the goal of decoupling MPI completely from the world process model.”

And so, the Argonne team undertook a major refactoring of MPICH to enable it to support what they call a ​“true” Sessions model.

The paper focused on two main areas: building the new model and measuring how well it works. For the implementation they developed a more efficient approach that uses hierarchical bootstrapping — a powerful technique for analyzing data at multiple levels. For example, the new approach exploits group-level address exchange and shared memory.

“Our results show that the implementation is important,” Zhou said. ​“With dense communication the benefits are limited. But with sparse communication the new model is faster and uses less memory.”

They also found that the new model greatly improves MPICH’s dynamic process management. The ​“true” Sessions model, which does not depend on the MPI comm_world communicator, requires an arbitrary group of MPI processes to be able to bootstrap into a fully optimized communicator without information from comm_world. This is essentially the same requirement of MPI dynamic processes. The work of supporting ​“true” Sessions in MPICH leads to a future performance boost for applications that use MPI dynamic processes. Dynamic processes are commonly used in scientific workflow applications to provide flexibility, resilience and resource malleability.

The researchers noted that developing a feature such as ​“true” Sessions is a complex, cyclical process — from design to testing to real-world use.

“But done right, with excellent feedback at each stage, it can give scientists a powerful new tool for solving complex problems,” Zhou said.

Source: Gail Pieper, Argonne

The post Argonne Researchers Win Ewing ​’Rusty’ Lusk Best Paper Award at EuroMPI Conference appeared first on HPCwire.

The National Security Strategy, which each administration must publish, also said the U.S. should focus on the Western Hemisphere and consider the Middle East a place for investment.

Perplexity AI also faces lawsuit from Murdoch-owned Dow Jones and New York Post for its use of copyrighted content

The New York Times sued an embattled artificial intelligence startup on Friday, accusing the firm of illegally copying millions of articles. The newspaper alleged Perplexity AI had distributed and displayed journalists’ work without permission en masse.

The Times said that Perplexity AI was also violating its trademarks under the Lanham Act, claiming the startup’s generative AI products create fabricated content, or “hallucinations”, and falsely attribute them to the newspaper by displaying them alongside its registered trademarks.

Netflix is buying Warner Bros. Discovery in an $82.7 billion deal that gives it HBO, iconic franchises, and major studio infrastructure. "Warner Bros. shareholders will receive $27.75 a share in cash and stock in Netflix," notes Bloomberg. "The total equity value of the deal is $72 billion, while the enterprise value of the deal is about $82.7 billion." From the report: Prior to the closing of the sale, Warner Bros. will complete the planned spinoff of its networks division, which includes cable channels such as CNN, TBS and TNT. That transaction is now expected to be completed in the third quarter of 2026, Netflix said in a statement. With the purchase, Netflix becomes owner of the HBO network, along with its library of hit shows like The Sopranos and The White Lotus. Warner Bros. assets also include its sprawling studios in Burbank, California, along with a vast film and TV archive that includes Harry Potter and Friends. Netflix said it expects to maintain Warner Bros.' current operations and build on its strengths, including theatrical releases for films, a point that had been a cause of concern in Hollywood. Netflix said the deal will allow it to "significantly expand" US production capacity and invest in original content, which will create jobs and strengthen the entertainment industry. Still, the combination is also expected to create "at least $2 billion to $3 billion" in cost savings per year by the third year, according to the statement. U.S. Senator Mike Lee, a Republican from Utah who leads the Senate antitrust committee, said the acquisition "should send alarm to antitrust enforcers around the world." "Netflix built a great service, but increasing Netflix's dominance this way would mean the end of the Golden Age of streaming for content creators and consumers," Lee wrote in a post on X. U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren called it an antitrust "nightmare" that would harm workers and consumers. "A Netflix-Warner Bros would create one massive media giant with control of close to half of the streaming market -- threatening to force Americans into higher subscription prices and fewer choices over what and how they watch, while putting American workers at risk," Warren said on Friday. "It would mean more price hikes, ads, & cookie cutter content, less creative control for artists, and lower pay for workers," she said in a post on X. "The media industry is already controlled by a few corporations with too much power to censor free speech. The gov't must step in."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

These deadly US boat strikes are the latest example of a president corrupting both the law and morality

The Trump administration looks ever more like a criminal enterprise – and now it seems to have added war crimes to its repertoire. Though even that may be too generous a description.

On Thursday, word came that the US military had launched yet another deadly strike on a small boat moving through international waters. This time the attack killed four people, bringing to at least 87 the number of people the US has killed in a series of 22 such strikes on what it says are drug boats – vessels carrying illicit narcotics in the Caribbean or eastern Pacific.

Jonathan Freedland is a Guardian columnist

Guardian newsroom: Year One of Trumpism: Is Britain Emulating the US?
On Wednesday 21 January 2026, join Jonathan Freedland, Tania Branigan and Nick Lowles as they reflect on the first year of Donald Trump’s second presidency – and to ask if Britain could be set on the same path.
Book tickets here or at guardian.live

• Trump praised by Infantino at DC ceremony

• President’s peace claims disputed by critics

• Follow the live blog of the World Cup draw

Donald Trump has been named the first winner of the newly created Fifa peace prize, claiming “the world is a safer place now” as he received the award at the draw for the 2026 World Cup in Washington DC.

Gianni Infantino, the Fifa president and one of Trump’s closest sporting allies, presented the honour onstage at the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts on Friday, saying Trump had been selected “in recognition of his exceptional and extraordinary actions to promote peace and unity around the world”.

Reform UK leader’s legal threats, denials and attacks on the media are tactics often deployed by US president

When Nigel Farage angrily denounced the BBC and insulted one of its presenters for raising questions about his alleged schoolboy racism, those who have been studying the tactics of the right noted that his behaviour felt familiar.

“Is it out of the Trump playbook? I think that’s exactly what’s going on,” said Steven Barnett, a professor of communications at the University of Westminster. “This is becoming his new modus operandi, turning defence into attack. It’s exactly the tactics White House press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, uses. There are a lot of journalists in this country who just aren’t used to it.”

Several countries are boycotting Eurovision after Israel was cleared to compete in the 2026 song contest despite calls for it to be excluded over the war in Gaza. Lucy Hough speaks to our European culture editor, Philip Oltermann – Watch on YouTube

EU regulators also reprimanded the social media company for its lack of ad transparency and failure to provide researchers with access to data.

Make these smart speakers from Amazon, Apple, Nest and others the top of your list when trying to find the best for your home.

Eleven exclusive 2026 Golden Globes categories will be revealed Monday at 8:30 a.m. ET, only on "CBS Mornings."

An anonymous reader quotes a report from the New York Times: A few years ago, Paul Wieland, a 44-year-old information technology professional living in New York's Adirondack Mountains, was wrapping up a home renovation when he ran into a hiccup. He wanted to be able to control his new garage door with his smartphone. But the options available, including a product called MyQ, required connecting to a company's internet servers. He believed a "smart" garage door should operate only over a local Wi-Fi network to protect a home's privacy, so he started building his own system to plug into his garage door. By 2022, he had developed a prototype, which he named RATGDO, for Rage Against the Garage Door Opener. He had hoped to sell 100 of his new gadgets just to recoup expenses, but he ended up selling tens of thousands. That's because MyQ's maker did what a number of other consumer device manufacturers have done over the last few years, much to the frustration of their customers: It changed the device, making it both less useful and more expensive to operate. Chamberlain Group, a company that makes garage door openers, had created the MyQ hubs so that virtually any garage door opener could be controlled with home automation software from Apple, Google, Nest and others. Chamberlain also offered a free MyQ smartphone app. Two years ago, Chamberlain started shutting down support for most third-party access to its MyQ servers. The company said it was trying to improve the reliability of its products. But this effectively broke connections that people had set up to work with Apple's Home app or Google's Home app, among others. Chamberlain also started working with partners that charge subscriptions for their services, though a basic app to control garage doors was still free. While Mr. Wieland said RATGDO sales spiked after Chamberlain made those changes, he believes the popularity of his device is about more than just opening and closing a garage. It stems from widespread frustration with companies that sell internet-connected hardware that they eventually change or use to nickel-and-dime customers with subscription fees. "You should own the hardware, and there is a line there that a lot of companies are experimenting with," Mr. Wieland said in a recent interview. "I'm really afraid for the future that consumers are going to swallow this and that's going to become the norm." [...] For Mr. Wieland, the fight isn't over. He started a company named RATCLOUD, for Rage Against the Cloud. He said he was developing similar products that were not yet for sale.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, with members appointed by RFK Jr., voted to change longstanding recommendations on the hepatitis B vaccine.

Dec. 5, 2025 — A team of University of California San Diego undergraduates won third place in the 2025 Student Cluster Competition (SCC25) at the International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage, and Analysis, held this year in St. Louis, Missouri. The UC San Diego SCC25 Team Sea++ is a group within the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) at UC San Diego.

“Our goal is for each member of the team to specialize and build deep expertise in one of the competition tasks, while ensuring that they are fully supported every step of the way,” said Gauri Renjith, who serves as the supercomputing chair for IEEE at UC San Diego. “Our team’s participation and success in this competition was made possible by the support of our industry partners. Our vendors worked with us to secure the team’s competition hardware, provided expert guidance to the team, and alleviated the shipping and travel expenses that enabled our team and its two alternates to reach St. Louis.”

The team received support from the School of Computing, Information and Data Sciences’ San Diego Supercomputer Center (SDSC) and Jacobs School of Engineering Computer Science and Engineering and Electrical Computer Engineering Departments. Team Sea++ and their mentors — SDSC Research Scientist Mary Thomas and Computer Science Lecturer Bryan Chin — spent months preparing a high performance computing (HPC) system for the international challenge, which brings together top student teams from around the world to design, build and optimize small supercomputing clusters to run complex scientific workloads in real time. UC San Diego’s six 2025 participants include Gauri Renjith, Ferrari Guan, Jinru Li, Luiz Gurrola, Ryan Estanislao and Shing Hung. Supporting the team were over a dozen additional UC San Diego students — comprising the home team.

Preparation for the competition merged weekly team meetings with flexible, self-paced training modules — maximizing both individual and group efforts. Each student took the lead on one application or benchmark while supporting another, a structure that encourages teamwork and shared problem-solving. With guidance from the home team, SDSC mentors and alumni — and access to the center’s Expanse supercomputer and vendor research clusters — the team was backed by an exceptional network of expertise and resources.

“Our students with the Supercomputing Club did a fantastic job at the Student Cluster Competition at SC25,” Thomas said. “We are grateful to our cluster vendor team, including International Computer Concepts (ICC), Applied Data Systems and Gigabyte Computing, who sponsored and supported the team with the high-performance system they used to compete — helping bring their ideas to life.”

Built on two server nodes provided by Gigabyte, the team’s system integrated AMD EPYC CPUs, AMD Instinct GPUs and ScaleFlux storage. Ian Stewart, ICC-USA mentor, assembled the system system components from AMD and Gigabyte with additional hardware help from Ryan Emmerich at Applied Data Systems. Students completed the final assembly, configuration and performance optimization at SDSC.

“It’s inspiring to work alongside our talented students,” Chin said. “They put in incredible effort to get this system ready and we are so proud of their accomplishment.”

Now in its sixth year, the UC San Diego SCC program gives students a hands-on opportunity to apply theoretical knowledge to practical, high-performance environments — an experience that continues to open doors for many alumni to careers in HPC, data science and research computing.

“The program impacts a larger community than the students who get to travel to the competition,” Thomas explained. “Our program also includes a group of students, called the ‘home’ team, who participate in the SCC preparation alongside the team — including learning about high performance computing, how to work with the cluster hardware and how to run the competition applications. In addition, our program connects students from the team and the UCSD Supercomputing Club to events like Supercomputing, to vendors and the world of HPC.”

UC San Diego Team Sea++ gratefully acknowledges its sponsors:

• Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. (AMD)
• Applied Data Systems, Inc.
• CIQ, Inc.
• Giga Computing Technologies, Inc./GIGABYTE
• Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE)
• International Computer Concepts (ICC-USA)
• Neuvys Technologies
• NetApp
• Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
• San Diego Supercomputer Center
• UC San Diego Computer Science and Engineering Department
• UC San Diego
• Women in HPC, SDSC Chapter

Source: Scott Paton and Kimberly Mann Bruch, SDSC

The post UC San Diego Team Takes 3rd Place at SC25 Student Cluster Competition in St. Louis appeared first on HPCwire.

European regulators said​ X breached transparency rules under the Digital Services Act, a sweeping EU law intended to protect internet users.

Cloudflare reports it is investigating issues with Cloudflare Dashboard and related APIs

Technical problems at internet infrastructure provider Cloudflare today have taken a host of websites offline this morning.

Cloudflare said shortly after 9am UK time that it “is investigating issues with Cloudflare Dashboard and related APIs [application programming interfaces – used when apps exchange data with each other].

Paper published in 2000 found glyphosate was not harmful, while internal emails later revealed company’s influence

The journal Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology has formally retracted a sweeping scientific paper published in 2000 that became a key defense for Monsanto’s claim that Roundup herbicide and its active ingredient glyphosate don’t cause cancer.

Martin van den Berg, the journal’s editor in chief, said in a note accompanying the retraction that he had taken the step because of “serious ethical concerns regarding the independence and accountability of the authors of this article and the academic integrity of the carcinogenicity studies presented”.

The paper, titled Safety Evaluation and Risk Assessment of the Herbicide Roundup and Its Active Ingredient, Glyphosate, for Humans, concluded that Monsanto’s glyphosate-based weed killers posed no health risks to humans – no cancer risks, no reproductive risks, no adverse effects on development of endocrine systems in people or animals.

Action detailed in a state department memo directs officials to deny visas to any applicant engaging in ‘censorship’

• US politics live – latest updates

The Trump administration has moved to formalize a crackdown on the issuance of visas for people who it deems to have engaged in censoring the free speech of US citizens.

The action, detailed in a state department memo sent to overseas missions this week, first reported by Reuters and then NPR, directs consular officials to deny visas to any applicant “responsible for, or complicit in, censorship or attempted censorship of protected expression in the US”.

Here are some highly rated films to check out, plus a look at what's new in December.

The assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, President Trump's "big, beautiful bill," and the longest government shutdown in U.S. history ranked among Google's top search trends this year.

After a number of drone sightings near European airports and military bases, mysterious aircraft were seen over Ireland as Ukraine's Zelenskyy visited.

In July 2019, Minnesota state officials spotted early signs of fraud that would eventually siphon away more than $1 billion in taxpayer money, sources told CBS News.

Retirees who stop paying credit card debt will face escalating consequences, but other options do exist.

Host broadcaster says show will not suffer after four countries withdraw from 2026 contest over Israel and Gaza

Austria has said it will continue with plans to host next year’s Eurovision, in spite of its budget being hit by four countries boycotting the song contest over Israel’s participation and the war in Gaza.

At a meeting in Geneva, the national broadcasters that make up the European Broadcasting Union gave the all clear for Israel to take part in next year’s event in Vienna, the contest’s 70th anniversary edition.

WEST LAFAYETTE, Ind., Dec. 5, 2025 — Purdue University and the Department of Energy’s Oak Ridge National Laboratory have signed a memorandum of understanding to advance their long-standing research collaboration focused on national security. Dan DeLaurentis, Purdue’s executive vice president for research, and Moe Khaleel, ORNL associate laboratory director for national security sciences, signed the MOU during a recent meeting at ORNL.

Dan DeLaurentis, Purdue’s executive vice president for research, and Moe Khaleel, ORNL’s associate laboratory director for national security sciences, sign a memorandum of understanding to advance their national security research collaboration. Credit: ORNL.

Under the agreement, Purdue and ORNL will pursue new research collaboration opportunities to enhance national defense. Research areas covered by the MOU — which are also key aspects of the strategic Purdue Computes initiative — include:

• Cyber-physical security of critical infrastructure and systems
• Artificial intelligence
• Quantum computing

In addition, Purdue and ORNL will explore opportunities to collaborate in national security manufacturing to enhance domestic production and ensure the ability to produce defense equipment, technologies and components essential for a nation to adequately protect itself and address potential threats.

In addition, Purdue and ORNL will explore opportunities to collaborate in national security manufacturing to enhance domestic production and ensure the ability to produce defense equipment, technologies and components essential for a nation to adequately protect itself and address potential threats.

“By combining research efforts of Purdue and Oak Ridge National Lab under this MOU, we are leveraging the strengths of two world-class research institutions for the national good,” DeLaurentis said. “This also further positions Indiana at the forefront of national security innovation while contributing to national defense workforce development programming by creating new opportunities for students and researchers.”

“Purdue’s wide national security research portfolio and deep research expertise complement ORNL’s ability to translate science into solutions for critical national security missions,” Khaleel said. “This partnership will help address key national needs by accelerating progress in cyber-physical security, artificial intelligence and quantum computing.”

Finalized in October, the MOU took effect immediately.

About Purdue University

Purdue University is a public research university leading with excellence at scale. Ranked among top 10 public universities in the United States, Purdue discovers, disseminates and deploys knowledge with a quality and at a scale second to none. More than 106,000 students study at Purdue across multiple campuses, locations and modalities, including more than 57,000 at our main campus locations in West Lafayette and Indianapolis. Committed to affordability and accessibility, Purdue’s main campus has frozen tuition 14 years in a row. See how Purdue never stops in the persistent pursuit of the next giant leap — including its integrated, comprehensive Indianapolis urban expansion; the Mitch Daniels School of Business; Purdue Computes; and the One Health initiative — at https://www.purdue.edu/president/strategic-initiatives.

Source: Peter Shelby, Purdue University

The post Purdue and ORNL Sign MOU to Collaborate on Key National Security Research appeared first on HPCwire.

Looking to buy a home or refinance your current one? These are the interest rates to know right now.

On Dec. 2, QuickTime turned 34, and despite its origins in Apple's chaotic 1990s (1991 to be exact), "it's still the backbone of video on our devices," writes Macworld's Jason Snell. That includes MP4 and Apple's immersive video formats for Vision Pro. From the report: By the late '80s and early '90s, digital audio had been thoroughly integrated into Macs. (PCs needed add-on cards to do much more than issue beeps.) The next frontier was video, and even better, synchronized video and audio. There were a whole lot of challenges: the Macs of the day were not really powerful to decode and display more than a few frames per second, which was more of a slideshow than a proper video. Also, the software written to decode and encode such video (called codecs) was complex and expensive, and there were lots of different formats, making file exchange unreliable. Apple's solution wasn't to invent entirely new software to cover every contingency, but to build a framework for multimedia creation and playback that could use different codecs as needed. At its heart was a file that was a container for other streams of audio and video in various formats: the QuickTime Movie, or MOV. [...] QuickTime's legacy lives on. At a recent event I attended at Apple Park, Apple's experts in immersive video for the Vision Pro pointed out that the standard format for immersive videos is, at its heart, a QuickTime container. And perhaps the most ubiquitous video container format on the internet, the MP4 file? That standard file format is actually a container format that can encompass different kinds of audio, video, and other information, all in one place. If that sounds familiar, that's because MPEG-4 is based on the QuickTime format. Thirty-four years later, QuickTime may seem like a quaint product of a long-lost era of Apple. But the truth is, it's become an integral part of the computing world, so pervasive that it's almost invisible. I'd like to forget most of what happened at Apple in the early 1990s, but QuickTime definitely deserves our appreciation.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

This blog is now closed, you can read more of our UK political coverage here

Readers may be aware, going into the weekend, that Edinburgh airport had to temporarily suspend flights this morning due to technical issues.

The delays lasted about an hour. A report here:

Move is part of Trump’s broader crackdown on leftwing groups, including designation of antifa as ‘domestic terrorism’ group

• US politics live – latest updates

The US attorney general, Pam Bondi, instructed law enforcement officials on Thursday to investigate antifa and other supposed domestic terror groups, and specifically directed them to search for “tax crimes” the groups may have committed, according to a memo obtained by the Guardian.

The document signals how the Trump administration and Bondi are ramping up efforts to crack down on leftwing groups. Antifa, short for antifascist, is not a clearly defined organization, but rather a loose network of activists. Trump signed an executive order in September declaring it a domestic terrorism organization – something legal experts say he does not have the authority to do.

Advocates demand public health officials ‘listen to autistic voices’ after health secretary’s debunked vaccine claims

When the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) altered its website last month to reflect US health secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr’s belief of a causal link between vaccines and autism – a claim that has been debunked by dozens of scientific studies – autism advocates sprang into action.

Leaders at the Association of University Centers on Disabilities demanded online that public health officials “listen to autistic voices”.

KAWASAKI, Japan and PARIS, Dec. 5, 2025 — Fujitsu Limited and Scaleway, a leading European public cloud provider for AI builders, have announced a strategic collaboration towards the establishment of a sustainable AI utilization environment that also ensures data sovereignty.

By combining Fujitsu’s advanced processor development expertise with Scaleway’s European cloud infrastructure expertise, the two companies aim to evaluate new ways to support efficient, responsible and secure AI deployment at scale. The collaboration, which commenced on November 27th with the signing of an MoU, will see Fujitsu combine its high-performance, energy-efficient Arm-based FUJITSU-MONAKA CPU platform and development capabilities with Scaleway’s cloud infrastructure expertise.

As part of their collaboration, Fujitsu and Scaleway will explore a new CPU-based option for AI inference processing for AI builders and enterprises in the European market, complementing traditional GPU-centric configurations. The companies will conduct joint testing and validations to create optimal infrastructure environments tailored to specific workloads. This will enable customers to select the most suitable platform based on their AI workload characteristics and Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) and help to address societal challenges such as increasing AI power consumption and supply chain risks.

Through this collaboration, Fujitsu and Scaleway will contribute to the healthy development of a digital society in Europe by offering an energy-efficient CPU-based alternative alongside powerful GPU platforms, thereby supporting customers’ business growth and Green Transformation (GX).

“As AI’s evolution accelerates at an incredible pace, its energy consumption has become a critical global challenge,” said Naoki Shinjo,SVP, Head of Advanced Technology Development Unit at Fujitsu Limited. “The demand for optimal, flexible infrastructure to handle diverse workloads remains an urgent task. Our partnership with Scaleway is set to revolutionize this landscape. By fusing our cutting-edge technologies and deep expertise, we will create a truly power-efficient, CPU-based computing platform. This isn’t just about optimizing our customers’ Total Cost of Ownership and fueling their business growth; it’s a powerful stride towards accelerating Europe’s green transformation and building a sustainable future for everyone.”

“At Scaleway, our commitment to delivering unparalleled power efficiency in the cloud remains at the heart of everything we do, driving us to continuously innovate for a sustainable digital future,” said Yann-Guirec Manac’h, Head of Hardware R&D at Scaleway. “We are proud to announce our collaboration with Fujitsu, a partnership that will allow us to unlock new possibilities in efficient, responsible, and continuous AI innovation. By integrating FUJITSU-MONAKA CPU into our infrastructure, we aim to enhance our offerings and empower our customers with cutting-edge AI solutions. This collaboration not only strengthens our ability to meet the evolving demands of the market but also ensures that our customers have access to the most advanced, sustainable, and high-performance AI technologies tailored to their unique needs.”

Accelerating Sustainable Transformation and Data Sovereignty in Europe

The rapid proliferation of generative AI has dramatically increased data center power consumption, creating a global societal challenge. In Europe, this has led to increased demand for infrastructures that reconcile performance, energy efficiency and data sovereignty. Specifically, many organizations now operate AI models continuously in production and require predictable performance, controlled operating costs and a reduced environmental footprint. CPU-based architectures are particularly well suited to these requirements because they offer stable performance, efficient energy use and simple integration within existing environments.

Fujitsu, with its advanced computing technologies, is developing the FUJITSU-MONAKA processor, which employs world-leading technologies cultivated in its supercomputer development activities. Built on leading-edge 2-nanometer technology and featuring unique technologies such as its own microarchitecture optimized for advanced 3D packaging and ultra-low voltage circuit operation, it is designed to deliver both high performance and power efficiency across diverse computing applications including enterprise AI.

Aligning with its objective to provide organizations, from innovative startups to large enterprises, with infrastructure that matches their operational and strategic requirements, Scaleway offers a full spectrum of cloud services, from its AI Factory with powerful GPUs to highly efficient computing infrastructure, to offer the appropriate architecture for each use case while maintaining full transparency on performance, cost and environmental impact.

Building on their ongoing discussions to define key use cases, the two companies will commence this joint Proof of Concept (PoC) in the second half of 2026. Based on the results, the parties will consider establishing and providing pilot environments for customers from 2027 onwards. Moving forward, Fujitsu and Scaleway will explore the commercialization of new CPU-based AI inference services optimized for the European market.

More from HPCwire: Pasqal Integrates Neutral-Atom QPUs Into Scaleway’s Quantum-as-a-Service Platform

About Fujitsu

Fujitsu’s purpose is to make the world more sustainable by building trust in society through innovation. As the digital transformation partner of choice for customers around the globe, our 113,000 employees work to resolve some of the greatest challenges facing humanity. Our range of services and solutions draw on five key technologies: AI, Computing, Networks, Data & Security, and Converging Technologies, which we bring together to deliver sustainability transformation. Fujitsu Limited (TSE:6702) reported consolidated revenues of 3.6 trillion yen (US$23 billion) for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2025 and remains the top digital services company in Japan by market share.

Source: Fujitsu

The post Fujitsu and Scaleway Collaborate on Energy-Efficient CPU Path for European AI Workloads appeared first on HPCwire.

Decision by four countries to pull out over Israel’s inclusion is significant for the contest but crisis may not be existential

The decision by four European broadcasters to boycott next year’s Eurovision over Israel’s inclusion is undoubtedly a watershed moment in the 70-year history of the song contest.

One of the few genuinely popular, non-elitist and pan-European cultural events will be without Spain, one of the “big five” nations in terms of financial contributions; Ireland, which has won the contest more times than any other country bar Sweden; the Netherlands, a 1956 founding member; and Slovenia, symbolic of the EU’s eastward enlargement.

Exclusive: Plans to offset increase in minimum ‘fair pay’ set by Living Wage Foundation will affect 5,400 employees

BP is ditching paid rest breaks and most bank holiday bonuses for 5,400 workers in its petrol forecourts as it attempts to offset a planned rise in the independent living wage.

The company has told workers in its 310 company-run forecourts that it will be changing their benefits in February. Workers at a further 850 BP-branded forecourts run by partners are on different pay deals.

Nathaniel Spencer, from Birmingham, is accused of 45 offences, including some against children under 13

A former doctor has been charged with carrying out sexual assaults against 38 people who were patients in his care.

Nathaniel Spencer, from Birmingham, is accused of dozens of acts of sexual assault, some of them against children younger than 13, between 2017 and 2021.

Celebrity chef will start with branch in London’s Leicester Square, backed by Prezzo owner Brava Hospitality Group

• Business live – latest updates

Jamie Oliver is to revive his Jamie’s Italian restaurant chain in the UK, more than six years after the celebrity chef’s brand collapsed.

Jamie’s Italian is poised to be relaunched in the spring, starting with a restaurant in London’s Leicester Square.

New and existing customers can pay reduced monthly rates.

The New York Times bestselling author returns to the village of Mitford in her 15th novel featuring Father Tim Kavanagh.

Reform UK leader’s responses to allegations of racist and antisemitic behaviour at Dulwich college have varied over time

Nigel Farage’s response to allegations of teenage racism during his time at Dulwich college have ranged from vehement at times and rather more nuanced at others.

Here is what he has said:

Luigi Mangione was unable to appear in court Friday due to illness, so a a crucial court hearing about what evidence should be admitted in the trial was postponed until Monday morning.

A former autoworker was given back his retirement through the kindness of strangers.

This blog is now closed, you can read more on this story here

Russia and India will reshape their defence ties to take account of New Delhi’s push for self-reliance, the two countries said in a joint statement after a summit between president Putin and Indian prime minister Narendra Modi.

“In response to India’s aspirations for self-reliance, the partnership is currently being reoriented toward joint research and development, as well as the production of advanced defence platforms,” the statement said.

Streaming service to gain control of studio behind Harry Potter and Batman, as well as HBO, home to The White Lotus and Game of Thrones

• Business live – latest updates

Netflix has agreed to buy Warner Bros Discovery in an $82.7bn (£62bn) deal that will dramatically reshape the established Hollywood film and TV industry.

The streaming company will take control of WBD’s prize assets such as Warner Bros, the studio behind franchises including Harry Potter, Superman and Batman, as well as HBO, home to shows including Game of Thrones, The White Lotus and Succession.

All 18-year-old men to be screened for suitability for armed forces, but proposal falls short of conscription

The German parliament has rubberstamped a new model for military service that aims to boost its armed forces as thousands of school pupils demonstrated across the country against the plans.

The change will include the obligatory screening of all 18-year-old men to gauge their suitability to serve in the military from 1 January, but does not include conscription, as favoured by some conservative politicians.

Two Virginia brothers Muneeb and Sohaib Akhter, previously convicted of hacking the U.S. State Department, were rehired as federal contractors and are now charged with conspiring to steal sensitive data and destroy government databases after being fired. "Following the termination of their employment, the brothers allegedly sought to harm the company and its U.S. government customers by accessing computers without authorization, issuing commands to prevent others from modifying the databases before deletion, deleting databases, stealing information, and destroying evidence of their unlawful activities," the Justice Department said in a Wednesday press release. BleepingComputer reports: According to court documents, Muneeb Akhter deleted roughly 96 databases containing U.S. government information in February 2025, including Freedom of Information Act records and sensitive investigative documents from multiple federal agencies. One minute after deleting a Department of Homeland Security database, Muneeb Akhter also allegedly asked an artificial intelligence tool for instructions on clearing system logs after deleting a database. The two defendants also allegedly ran commands to prevent others from modifying the targeted databases before deletion, and destroyed evidence of their activities. The prosecutors added that both men wiped company laptops before returning them to the contractor and discussed cleaning out their house in anticipation of a law enforcement search. The complaint also claims that Muneeb Akhter stole IRS information from a virtual machine, including federal tax data and identifying information for at least 450 individuals, and stole Equal Employment Opportunity Commission information after being fired by the government contractor. Muneeb Akhter has been charged with conspiracy to commit computer fraud and destroy records, two counts of computer fraud, theft of U.S. government records, and two counts of aggravated identity theft. If found guilty, he faces a minimum of two years in prison for each aggravated identity theft count, with a maximum of 45 years on other charges. His brother, Sohaib, is charged with conspiracy to commit computer fraud and password trafficking, facing a maximum penalty of six years if convicted.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

submitted by /u/Sea-Entertainer7778
[link] [comments]

The Trump administration says societal threats mean some European nations may not be "strong enough to remain reliable allies."

Many users of the app were shocked, this week, by this addition to the Spotify Wrapped roundup – especially twentysomethings who were judged to be 100

“Age is just a number. So don’t take this personally.” Those words were the first inkling I had that I was about to receive some very bad news.

I woke up on Wednesday with a mild hangover after celebrating my 44th birthday. Unfortunately for me, this was the day Spotify released “Spotify Wrapped”, its analysis of (in my case) the 4,863 minutes I had spent listening to music on its platform over the past year. And this year, for the first time, they are calculating the “listening age” of all their users.

Christine Kuehn uncovered a devastating family secret long hidden by her father: her grandfather, Otto, was a Nazi spy who passed military information on to the Axis powers in the run-up to the attack on Pearl Harbor.

Pulled by Steam and Epic Games Store, indie horror Horses shook up the industry before it was even released. Now it’s out, all the drama surrounding it seems superfluous

On 25 November, award-winning Italian developer Santa Ragione, responsible for acclaimed titles such as MirrorMoon EP and Saturnalia, revealed that its latest project, Horses, had been banned from Steam - the largest digital store for PC games. A week later, another popular storefront, Epic Games Store, also pulled Horses, right before its 2 December launch date. The game was also briefly removed from the Humble Store, but was reinstated a day later.

The controversy has helped the game rocket to the top of the digital stores that are selling it, namely itch.io and GOG. But the question remains – why was it banned? Horses certainly delves into some intensely controversial topics (a content warning at the start details, “physical violence, psychological abuse, gory imagery, depiction of slavery, physical and psychological torture, domestic abuse, sexual assault, suicide, and misogyny”) and is upsetting and unnerving.

Sang Hea Kil is first tenured faculty member fired from a public university in connection to the protests

A tenured professor at San José State University in California is fighting for her job after the university fired her last month over her pro-Palestinian activism – the first tenured faculty member fired from a public university in connection to campus protests against Israel’s war in Gaza.

Sang Hea Kil, a longtime member of the university’s justice studies department and a faculty adviser for its students for justice in Palestine chapter, is the latest in a growing list of university professors and staff who have been suspended, investigated, and in some cases dismissed or forced out in connection to the wave of pro-Palestinian protests that swept US campuses in the first year of Israel’s war in Gaza.

Ministers want to secure deal by end of 2026 as part of a broader reset of Britain’s relationship with Europe

• UK politics live – latest updates

Tens of thousands of young British and European citizens would be given the right to live and work in each other’s countries under plans for a scheme that ministers are aiming to finalise within the next year.

Ministers want to secure a youth mobility scheme with the EU by the end of 2026, as part of a broader reset of Britain’s relationship with Europe six years after leaving the bloc.

SINGAPORE and LAS VEGAS, Dec. 5, 2025 — Horizon Quantum Computing Pte. Ltd., a pioneer of software infrastructure for quantum applications, and dMY Squared Technology Group, Inc., a publicly traded special purpose acquisition company, announced that they have entered into subscription agreements with investors for a $110 million PIPE financing comprised of common equity, priced at the SPAC redemption price per share, to support the previously announced proposed business combination which is expected to close in the first quarter of 2026.

The executed PIPE commitments, which exceeded Horizon Quantum’s original target raise by more than 120%, reflect sizable investments from IonQ, Inc., one of the world’s largest quantum computing companies, a Fortune 50 technology company, and several leading institutional investors. Upon the closing of the Business Combination, Horizon Quantum expects it will have access to approximately $137 million in cash (prior to the payment of transaction costs and assuming no redemptions by dMY Squared’s public shareholders), from a combination of approximately $27 million held in a trust account by dMY Squared and approximately $110 million of PIPE financing. The net proceeds from this transaction will be used to accelerate Horizon Quantum’s investments in research and development, strengthen its hardware testbed, and further advance its Triple Alpha development environment.

“Today’s announcement is a major milestone for Horizon Quantum and an exciting endorsement of our approach to unlocking broad quantum advantage and creating industrywide software tools and languages,” said Dr. Joe Fitzsimons, Founder and CEO of Horizon Quantum. “We expect this PIPE transaction will provide significant new capital to fund investment in our technology roadmap to develop the comprehensive software infrastructure needed to unlock quantum computing’s full potential across real-world applications. We believe that the quantum computing market is at a critical inflection point and Horizon Quantum is well positioned to capitalize on this generational opportunity.”

Dr. Fitzsimons continued, “We are excited to have the support of an impressive roster of strategic and financial institutional investors. We are grateful for the confidence they have shown in our vision and look forward to partnering with them going forward.”

Harry You, Chairman and CEO of dMY Squared, said, “This PIPE transaction, which was well oversubscribed and includes meaningful commitments from some of the most strategic companies in the enterprise computing and quantum industries, is an exciting endorsement of Horizon Quantum’s groundbreaking innovation roadmap. We remain excited to partner with Horizon Quantum to enable their development of a quantum operating system.”

Advisors

Needham & Company, LLC, is serving as dMY Squared’s financial advisor and exclusive placement agent for the PIPE. Ellenoff Grossman & Schole LLP is acting as legal counsel to Horizon Quantum and Rajah & Tann Singapore LLP is acting as Singapore legal counsel to Horizon Quantum. White & Case LLP is acting as legal counsel to dMY Squared and TCF Law Group, PLLC is acting as Massachusetts legal counsel to dMY Squared. ICR, LLC, is serving as dMY Squared’s strategic communications advisor.

More from HPCwire

• Horizon Quantum Becomes 1st Quantum Software Company to Own and Operate a Quantum Computer
• Horizon Quantum to Go Public Through dMY Squared SPAC Deal, Plans Nasdaq Listing as ‘HQ’

About Horizon Quantum

Horizon Quantum’s mission is to unlock broad quantum advantage by building the software infrastructure that empowers developers to use quantum computing to solve the world’s toughest computational problems. Founded in 2018 by Dr Joe Fitzsimons, a leading researcher and former professor with more than two decades of experience in quantum computing, the company seeks to bridge the gap between today’s hardware and tomorrow’s applications through the creation of advanced quantum software development tools. Its integrated development environment, Triple Alpha, enables developers to write sophisticated, hardware-agnostic quantum programs at different levels of abstraction.

About dMY Squared

dMY Squared is a blank check company whose business purpose is to effect a merger, capital stock exchange, asset acquisition, stock purchase, reorganization or similar business combination with one or more businesses.

Source: Horizon Quantum

The post Horizon Quantum Announces $110M PIPE Supporting Proposed dMY Squared Merger appeared first on HPCwire.

The congresswoman from Minnesota responded to Trump’s dismissal of Somali Americans as ‘garbage’

Ilhan Omar, the Somali-born Minnesota congresswoman, has said Donald Trump is lashing out at her and her community with bigotry because he “knows he is failing”.

The US president dismissed Somali Americans earlier this week as “garbage” in a racist rant.

Netflix says its open AV1 video codec now powers about 30% of all streaming on the platform and is rapidly becoming its primary delivery format thanks to major gains in compression, bandwidth efficiency, HDR support, and film-grain rendering. TVTechnology reports: The blog by Liwei Guo, Zhi Li, Sheldon Radford and Jeff Watts comes at a time when AV2 is on the horizon. [...] The blog revisits Netflix's AV1 journey to date, highlights emerging use cases, and shares adoption trends across the device ecosystem. It noted that since entering the streaming business in 2007, Netflix has primarily relied on H.264/AVC as its streaming format. "Looking ahead, we are excited about the forthcoming release of AV2, announced by the Alliance for Open Media for the end of 2025," said the authors. "AV2 is poised to set a new benchmark for compression efficiency and streaming capabilities, building on the solid foundation laid by AV1. At Netflix, we remain committed to adopting the best open technologies to delight our members around the globe. While AV2 represents the future of streaming, AV1 is very much the present -- serving as the backbone of our platform and powering exceptional entertainment experiences across a vast and ever-expanding ecosystem of devices."

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The changed outlook is a result of unwelcome inflation data, but could slow down the hot property market

• Get our breaking news email, free app or daily news podcast

Financial markets are now pricing in a 100% chance the Reserve Bank will hike rates in 2026, in what would be a blow to mortgage holders but may take some steam out of an overheating property market.

The latest forecasts represent a turnaround from just two weeks ago, when traders were factoring in an even chance that the next RBA move would be a cut by its May meeting.

The acquisition will see massive franchises including Harry Potter and Friends brought into the same portfolio as Stranger Things and Squid Game.

The writer of the Tony award-nominated Slave Play remains in custody after authorities say they found MDMA in his bag

American actor and playwright Jeremy O Harris, known for the Tony-nominated Slave Play, was arrested last month at an airport in Japan on suspicion of attempting to smuggle illegal drugs into the country, local authorities said late on Thursday.

Harris, 36, was stopped on 16 November at Naha airport on Okinawa island after a customs officer discovered 0.78 grams of crystal containing the synthetic drug MDMA in his tote bag, an Okinawa regional customs spokesperson said.

Narendra Modi says energy security is ‘pillar of the India-Russia partnership’ as two leaders meet in Delhi

Vladimir Putin has told the Indian prime minister, Narendra Modi, that Russia is ready to continue “uninterrupted” shipments of oil to India, signalling a defiant stance to the US as the two leaders met in Delhi and affirmed that their ties were “resilient to external pressure”.

The statement, made on Friday after the annual India-Russia summit, appeared to be directed at western countries – particularly the US – that have attempted to pressure New Delhi into scaling back its ties to Moscow.

Kristi Noem said the list of countries from which travel to the US is prohibited will increase to an unspecified number

• US politics live – latest updates

The US plans to expand the number of countries covered by its travel ban to more than 30, the secretary of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), Kristi Noem, has announced.

Noem, in an interview on Fox News’s The Ingraham Angle on Thursday evening, was asked to confirm whether the Trump administration would be increasing the number of countries on the travel ban list to 32.

An anonymous reader quotes a report from MIT Technology Review: New research reveals that AI chatbots can shift voters' opinions in a single conversation -- and they're surprisingly good at it. A multi-university team of researchers has found that chatting with a politically biased AI model was more effective than political advertisements at nudging both Democrats and Republicans to support presidential candidates of the opposing party. The chatbots swayed opinions by citing facts and evidence, but they were not always accurate -- in fact, the researchers found, the most persuasive models said the most untrue things. The findings, detailed in a pair of studies published in the journals Nature and Science, are the latest in an emerging body of research demonstrating the persuasive power of LLMs. They raise profound questions about how generative AI could reshape elections.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

The CDC's vaccine advisory panel meets Thursday and Friday to discuss recommendations for the hepatitis B vaccine and the schedule of childhood shots.

Karl Bushby is expected to finish his globe-walking expedition by September 2026.

At least 87 people have been killed since the vessel strikes began in early September.

Netflix on Friday said it will acquire Warner Bros., including its film and television studios, HBO Max and HBO.

Russia is hoping to use India’s booming tech sector to challenge the West and China for IT supremacy.

Defenders rally to Olivia Nuzzi amid book mockery, while rakish David Dimbleby channels his inner Dickens

It’s publication week for American Canto, the hastily turned around memoir by the former New York magazine journalist Olivia Nuzzi, who took on the challenge of explaining what it was about Robert F Kennedy Jr she found so alluring, a task for which no upper word limit is adequate. Nuzzi, if you’ve fallen behind, developed romantic feelings for the then presidential candidate, now Trump health minister, while profiling him for the magazine and since I’ve had to read this sentence, you do too: “He was exhausted, and he threw himself onto the bed, his pink shirt unbuttoned, revealing my favorite parts of his chest.” If you have a favourite part of RFK Jr’s chest, or consider chests in general subject to preference by localised area, this may be the book for you.

It's more than just a tool for streaming shows.

Only four new episodes remain in Netflix's monster hit series.

The new episode of Pluribus, titled HDP, premieres this week.

CNET gaming experts have listed the top 25 PlayStation 5 games you can play right now, like Astro Bot, Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 and Death Stranding 2.

When you open a CD, you'll lock in today's rates for the entire term. Here's how much you can earn.

Footage seen by US senators shows two unarmed, shirtless men struggling to stay afloat before they were killed, sources say

• Experts say Trump’s ‘drug boat’ war is legally shaky

Two men who survived a US airstrike on a suspected drug smuggling boat in the Caribbean clung to the wreckage for an hour before they were killed in a second attack, according to a video of the episode shown to senators in Washington.

The men were shirtless, unarmed and carried no visible radio or other communications equipment. They also appeared to have no idea what had just hit them, or that the US military was weighing whether to finish them off, two sources familiar with the recording told Reuters.

As the White House tries to curb Moscow's energy income, Vladimir Putin enjoys a warm welcome in India, and promises an "uninterrupted supply" of Russian fuel.

Looking for a standout gift that feels genuinely premium? CNET’s experts have curated a list of the best gift ideas under $500 with something for everyone on your list, from top gaming and audio gear to kitchen and fitness tech they'll love.

Major win for Trump as majority rejects lower-court ruling that found maps had been racially gerrymandered. Plus, the story of Mr DeepFakes, the world’s most notorious AI porn site

Good morning.

Texas can use a redrawn congressional map that adds as many as five Republican-friendly congressional districts, the supreme court ruled yesterday, handing Donald Trump a major win in his push to boost Republican seats ahead of next year’s midterm elections.

What did the lower court rule? The lower district court previously found that Texas had likely sorted voters based on their race – an unlawful practice called racial gerrymandering – when it adopted the new maps, and ordered the state to use the maps it had adopted after the 2020 census for next year’s election.

Why was the boat targeted? “Intelligence confirmed that the vessel was carrying illicit narcotics and transiting along a known narco-trafficking route in the eastern Pacific. Four male narco-terrorists aboard the vessel were killed,” the statement said.

What else is happening? Vladimir Putin is visiting Delhi for a summit with India’s prime minister, Narendra Modi. It comes as Washington seeks to increase pressure on India to cut back trade with Russia. It is the first time Putin has visited India since his full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, and marks another step for him on the international stage since starting a war that has turned Russia into a global pariah.

Exclusive: Group’s open letter says Reform UK leader must take responsibility for behaviour as a schoolboy

A group of Holocaust survivors have demanded Nigel Farage tell the truth and apologise for the antisemitic comments that fellow pupils of Dulwich college allege he made toward Jewish pupils.

The Reform UK leader has said he never racially abused anyone with intent but may have engaged in “banter in a playground”.

Why Should Delaware Care?
The Port of Wilmington is the owned by the taxpayers of Delaware, and contracted for operations to private companies. Questions have been raised this year over the state’s oversight of those contractors, and a new audit details failures by the state agency in its role.

Standing outside Legislative Hall on Thursday, Delaware State Auditor Lydia York braced against a chilly wind and even chillier reception from state officials after she presented findings from her office’s audit of the Port of Wilmington.

Published that morning, the audit report stated that Delaware’s port oversight board had failed during a recent four-year period to sufficiently supervise and inspect operations at the Port of Wilmington, which York described as the state’s largest public asset. 

Among several specific findings, the report claimed that the board of the Diamond State Port Corporation had improperly held meetings in secret; had misled the public about the port’s true condition; did not hold sufficient oversight meetings with the port’s current and past private operators; and relied on outdated jobs projections for a planned port expansion.

During comments to reporters in front of Legislative Hall, York called the audit report the “most comprehensive, independent review” of the Diamond State Port Corporation since the state took over the Port of Wilmington 30 years ago.

The audit also followed years of acrimony at the Port of Wilmington under its previous operator — Emirati-based Gulftainer.

In 2023, the Diamond State Port Corporation ousted Gulftainer from Delaware, by voiding its 50-year operating contract and installing Massachusetts-based Enstructure in its place.

Over the next year and half, state officials and Enstructure pushed forward plans to expand the Port of Wilmington at the site of a former Edgemoor chemical plant, north of Wilmington. As part of the effort, then-Gov. John Carney announced last year that he would pull $195 million out of a little-known government fund to pay for about a third of the construction cost for what was to be a new Edgemoor container terminal.

Then, days before Gov. Matt Meyer came into office in January, state finance officials rushed through the actual transfer of that money to the Diamond State Port Corporation.

Weeks later — just as Meyer and lawmakers were jockeying over control of the Port of Wilmington — York launched her audit investigation, saying then that she found it odd that the multimillion-dollar transfer had occurred so rapidly.

The ultimate report, published Thursday, did not describe that money transfer as improper. 

Still, during her comments, York said that such cash infusions to the Diamond State Port Corporation came as a result of a failure in past years to force Gulftainer to abide by the terms of its contract to run the facility.  She noted that during its tenure in Delaware, the company had missed millions of dollars in required payments to the state.

Asked if the company had ever paid those dollars back, York said it had not.

In the official response to the findings, which also was published in the audit report, Diamond State Port Corporation officials indicated that there was no way to force Gulftainer to pay its delinquent bills, after the company “soured on the business opportunity at the Port.”

“DSPC’s highest priority was to manage this difficult situation in a manner that maintained operations at the Port and its customers, so as to maintain jobs,” the response stated.

Factual inaccuracies?

Also in response, public officials from various factions in Delaware pushed back against its the audits findings to varying degrees.

Delaware’s Senate Democrats. who have clashed with the Meyer administration over the governance of the port this year, issued a statement calling many of the findings “procedural and historic in nature, and no longer apply to the Board’s operations.”

“For example, the findings related to Gulftainer’s failure to make timely payments to the State and their contribution to environmental degradation of the site are precisely why they are no longer involved in management of the Port,” the Democrats stated.

Separately, Delaware Secretary of State Charuni Patibanda-Sanchez – who serves as the current chair of Diamond State Port Corporation board – said in an emailed statement that the audit report “contained significant factual inaccuracies.” 

“While the DSPC appreciates the efforts and agrees that transparency is of the utmost importance, it respectfully does not agree with the findings of this report,” she said in the statement.

While much of the audit focused on the port before Patibanda-Sanchez’s tenure began in early 2025, it also claimed that her board had not held adequate oversight meetings this year with Enstructure, nor with the International Longshoremen’s Association – the unionized laborers who work to offload ships coming into the port.

Also as part of its official response to the findings, the Diamond State Port Corporation contended that its officials have met with Enstructure on a weekly basis. 

It also stated that mere claims of failed oversight could place the Port of Wilmington at risk in pending litigation – a reference to several legal challenges filed against the port’s plans to expand in Edgemoor.  

In a separate statement, Enstructure officials said they would have “welcomed the opportunity” to contribute to the audit, but said the auditor did not contact them.  

Beyond current port officials, the Diamond State Port Corporation’s previous board chair, former State Secretary Jeffrey Bullock, also defended decisions made during his term, which ended in January.

He said his port board had to discuss certain topics in secret executive sessions in the past because of a potential for legal action against the port’s operator. 

“In executive session, we had also discussed the ongoing financial difficulties of Gulftainer, and their refusal to resolve them, resulting in likely legal action with their lenders,” Bullock said. 

$265 million and counting

Beyond its findings about operations, York’s audit also tallied the total amount of taxpayer dollars that have flowed through the state-owned Diamond State Port Corporation between 2021 and 2025 to support the Port of Wilmington.

Between COVID relief money, transfers from a little-known state purse, forgiven debt, and other dollars the port corporation held, the public supported the Port of Wilmington with as much as $265 million during the four-year period, according to the report. 

“In 2018, past DSPC leadership promised the State of Delaware was ‘out of the port business,’” York said. “The reality is, since then, our state has almost doubled its financial commitment to the port.”

Besides the public money that has already flowed to the Port of Wilmington is another $180 million in federal grants that have been committed for the facility’s expansion in Edgemoor. 

York also acknowledged during her press conference that the amount does not include another $10 million that Gulftainer had received in 2020 from the federal Paycheck Protection Program. 

The post Auditor describes Port of Wilmington oversight failures; state officials push back appeared first on Spotlight Delaware.

EasyJet, British Airways and Ryanair passengers among those caught up in cancellations caused by air traffic control problems

• Business live – latest updates

Flights have resumed at Edinburgh airport after it suspended operations on Friday morning because of an IT issue in air traffic control.

Planes were beginning to take off at about 10.40am, according to a statement posted by the airport on social media.

Exclusive: In open letter, 225 groups describe home secretary’s plan to overhaul asylum system as ‘cruel and ‘ruthless’

• UK politics live – latest updates

The home secretary has been urged not to “play into the hands of those seeking to build division” by more than 200 community groups across the UK who have described Shabana Mahmood’s plans to overhaul the asylum system as “cruel” and “ruthless”.

Last month Mahmood announced policies intended to tackle bogus asylum claims and reduce the numbers of people trying to cross the Channel in small boats, including the end of permanent protection for refugees, the escalated removal of families with children whose claims have been refused, and scrapping the legal requirement to support destitute asylum seekers.

The civil liberties group argues the Texas governor’s proclamation exceeds his authority and deepens fears

Islamophobia is on the rise in the US, with the Council on American-Islamic Relations (Cair), a civil liberties group, reporting sharp increases in anti-Muslim violence and rhetoric over the last two years.

In Texas, the issue has come to the fore in high-profile incidents, including the case of a Euless woman who was initially released on a $40,000 bail after attempting to drown two Palestinian American children.

ACIP vote follows two postponements and contentious meeting and comes as RFK Jr pushes for vaccine delay

After a delay and an unusually contentious meeting, a federal vaccine advisory panel was expected to vote on Friday whether to change the longstanding recommendation that all newborns be immunized against hepatitis B.

The first day of the meeting of the advisory committee on immunization practices (ACIP) on Thursday was marked by heated debate over restricting access to the hepatitis B vaccine for infants and a decision to defer the vote by a day to give members more time to review the wording. The panel, which advises the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) on how to use vaccines, had twice before postponed the vote.

Rinaldo Nazzaro says detention of suspected Base members in Spain justifies ‘resistance … by any means necessary’

After Spanish police and Europol’s counter-terrorism section arrested three suspected members of the Base – a globally proscribed neo-Nazi terrorist group – in the eastern province of Castellón, its American leader living in Russia was defiant and signaled further actions.

In a text message to the Guardian, Rinaldo Nazzaro called the arrests another “example of political persecution” by world governments that are “further justifying our resistance to its hegemonic rule by any means necessary”.

Michael Dell’s $6.25bn gift spotlights how the super-rich use ‘charity’ to win access, favour and influence

Pity the billionaire class. The 0.001% are so unpopular these days that when tech billionaire Michael Dell and his wife announced the donation of $6.25bn into the “Trump Accounts” of 25 million children, one of the largest single philanthropic donations in American history, Dell had to hurry to assure us that his was not at all about currying favor with Donald Trump.

“I don’t think this is in any way a partisan activity,” Dell told the New York Times.

Nuzzi is on a temporary contract that ends this month – but it remains unclear whether she’s staying after former fiance Ryan Lizza’s exposés about her

In September, under the leadership of new top editor Mark Guiducci, a thirtysomething favorite of Condé Nast eminence Anna Wintour, Vanity Fair announced a slate of new hires that included one prominent name that hadn’t been heard from in a while: the political writer Olivia Nuzzi.

At seemingly the height of her rapidly ascendant career, Nuzzi was cut loose by New York Magazine last October after the media newsletter Status broke the news that she had maintained a relationship with Robert F Kennedy Jr, whose presidential campaign she had covered for the magazine.

Conservationists say changes, coupled with underfunding, will curb take-up and leave less land protected for nature

• UK politics live – latest updates

An ambitious scheme to restore England’s nature over coming decades has been undermined after the government inserted a clause allowing it to terminate contracts with only a year’s notice, conservationists have said.

The project was designed to fund landscape-scale restoration over thousands of hectares, whether on large estates or across farms and nature reserves. The idea was to create huge reserves for rare species to thrive – projects promoted as decades-long commitments to securing habitat for wildlife well into the future.

The special edition locket was inspired by the James Bond film "Octopussy," which revolves around a plot to steal a rare Faberge egg.

Officials have said that jaguar breeding in the U.S. has not been documented in more than a century.

Ruling likely to put European Commission on collision course with billionaire, and possibly Donald Trump

• Business live – latest updates

Elon Musk’s social media platform, X, has been fined €120m (£105m) after it was found in breach of new EU digital laws, in a ruling likely to put the European Commission on a collision course with the US billionaire and potentially Donald Trump.

The breaches, under consideration for two years, included what the EU said was a “deceptive” blue tick verification badge given to users and the lack of transparency of the platform’s advertising.

Calls for review after technology found to return more false positives for ‘some demographic groups’ on certain settings

• UK politics live – latest updates

Ministers are facing calls for stronger safeguards on the use of facial recognition technology after the Home Office admitted it is more likely to incorrectly identify black and Asian people than their white counterparts on some settings.

Following the latest testing conducted by the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) of the technology’s application within the police national database, the Home Office said it was “more likely to incorrectly include some demographic groups in its search results”.

Commentary: I'm hoping for big changes in Samsung's next Galaxy flagship phone, and after using the iPhone 17 Pro Max, I know what I'd like to see.

What I’m Discussing Today:

• Kareem’s Daily Quote: I give my personal twist on René Descartes’ famous quote.

• Trump’s Baffling Actions Following the Shootings of National Guards: He made a lot of bold statements and actions—none of which will have any positive effect. But they will have negative consequences.

• The Netherlands’ WWII cemetery removes displays honoring Black soldiers: How is it Americans tolerate this racist behavior from the Trump administration?

• More Americans, especially Black adults, are dying before they can access Medicare benefits: Talk about a rigged system.

• Video Break: These dancing goats will lighten your day.

• Kareem the Science Guy: Picture of health: going to art galleries can improve wellbeing, study reveals. Art is the remedy for most emotional ailments. That’s why Trump is so eager to control it.

• What I’m Watching on TV: Three very good shows this week. Stranger Things, Season 5 continues the exciting saga. Fake or Fortune is part detective show, part art appreciation. Mademoiselle Holmes is a delightful mystery about Sherlock’s quirky great-granddaughter.

• Magical Moments in Sports: One thing is true for all athletes: You will have setbacks. What you do next defines who you are.

• Stevie Wonder Sings, “All in Love Is Fair”: Stevie Wonder’s voice is the sound the universe makes when it’s happy.

Kareem’s Daily Quote

I think, therefore I am.

René Descartes (1596-1650), French philosopher, scientist, mathematician

I stink, therefore I am.

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar (1947-?), basketball player, author, lifestyle guru

No, my quote isn’t a kid’s joke. I’m not sniggering while making fun of Descartes. I’m seriously making a point, which I’ll get to in a moment.

First, a look at Descartes’ famous philosophical statement that became a foundation of Western philosophy. He was trying to prove that, although all other knowledge could be doubted, human existence could not because the act of doubting was itself proof of existence. Later, he refined that thought into, “I doubt, therefore I am—or what is the same—I think, therefore I am.”

Of course, the flaw in his thinking should be evident right away. He presupposes the existence of the “I” that is doing the thinking, which is circular logic. A thinking process can be occurring, but that doesn’t prove an “I” is doing that thinking.

I know, I know. Who cares? Existence is proven each day we get up, face the daily onslaught that tries to end our existence (whether it can be “proven” or not) and yet somehow manage to find happiness and love. To steal from Keats: “That is all/Ye know on earth, and all ye need to know.”

I appreciate the esoteric musings of abstract philosophy. For example, most of us are pretty clear on a definition of time, yet, many physicists argue that time is merely a human construct to acknowledge change. Some say time is a fundamental part of reality. Some say time doesn’t exist at all. Tell that to Coach Wooden when you showed up late for practice.

Now, back to my quote: “I stink, therefore I am.” While I love thinking about existence and time and what the hell the McRib is made of, I spend much more time grounded in moral and ethical philosophy. The “stink” part of my quote is a reminder that humans are made of matter, and that matter is in a constant state of changing. To our way of thinking, that change is toward decay and death. But, since matter cannot be destroyed but can be converted into energy or into some other form, there is no death of the substance that we are constructed of, only its form. We are like Legos. Our death merely means the Legos are rearranged into another shape.

Mostly, we are bags of organic material that feeds other creatures. You don’t want to know what those microscopic animals look like. It ain’t pretty. At the same time, we feed off other life forms, whether animal or vegetable. The bodily functions are messy and embarrassing and, well, sometimes we stink. That’s how we know we’re still in the game, still able to spend time wondering about whether we are humans dreaming of being a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming of being human. We stink, therefore we are.

We may scrub and shower and deodorize, but we are all struggling against the changing body. Which brings me to yet another quote, this one from one of my favorite sports movies, Bang the Drum Slowly: “Everybody knows everybody is dying; that’s why people are as good as they are.” We may stink, but we don’t have to be stinkers.

Read more

Gary Walters managed the president’s official residence for 37 years – now he’s sharing his most vivid recollections

Gary Walters has a “special feeling” about the White House East Wing. He met his future wife Barbara when she worked in the visitors’ office there. But asked to contemplate the wing’s destruction by Donald Trump, the former chief usher evidently still believes that discretion is the better part of valour.

“All the presidents and first ladies have made changes in one manner or another – some larger than others,” Walters, 78, says with the measured cadence of a man who has spent a lifetime guarding privacy. “One of the things that I have seen not commented on was back to when the West Wing was built.

Holiday shopping is now in full gear, and our experts have pulled together dozens of gift ideas that will fit any budget -- from $25 to $300 and above. Here are our editors' picks for the best holiday gifts to give this year.

Get in shape with these rowing machines in your own home.

Both the Max 2 and X5 are CNET Editors' Choice winners. But which one is right for you comes down to a few key considerations.

Save yourself some heartbreak and wash these kitchen items by hand.

The justification for the death penalty is that it’s supposed to be the ultimate punishment for the worst crimes. But in reality, who gets sentenced to die depends on things that often have nothing to do with guilt or innocence.

Related

By Any Measure, Capital Punishment Is a Failed Policy

Historically, judges have disproportionately sentenced Black and Latino people to death. A new report from the American Civil Liberties Union released in November found that more than half of the 200 people exonerated from death row since 1973 were Black.

Executions had been on a steady decline since their peak in the late 1990s. But the numbers slowly started to creep back up in recent years, more than doubling from 11 in 2021 to 25 last year, and we’ve almost doubled that again this year. Several states have stood out in their efforts to ramp up executions and conduct them at a faster pace — including Alabama.

Malcolm Gladwell’s new podcast series “The Alabama Murders” dives into one case to understand what the system really looks like and how it operates. Death by lethal injection involves a three-drug protocol: a sedative, a paralytic, and, lastly, potassium chloride, which is supposed to stop the heart. Gladwell explains to Intercept Briefing host Akela Lacy how it was developed, “It was dreamt up in an afternoon in Oklahoma in the 1970s by a state senator and the Oklahoma medical examiner who were just spitballing about how they might replace the electric chair with something ‘more humane.’ And their model was why don’t we do for humans what we do with horses?”

Liliana Segura, an Intercept senior reporter who has covered capital punishment and criminal justice for two decades, adds that the protocol is focused on appearances. “It is absolutely true that these are protocols that are designed with all of these different steps and all of these different parts and made to look, using the tools of medicine to kill … like this has really been thought through.” She says, “These were invented for the purpose of having a humane-appearing protocol, a humane-appearing method, and it amounts to junk science.”

Listen to the full conversation of The Intercept Briefing on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen.

Transcript

Akela Lacy: Malcolm and Liliana, welcome to the show.

Malcolm Gladwell: Thank you.

Liliana Segura: Thank you.

AL: Malcolm, the series starts by recounting the killing of Elizabeth Sennett, but very quickly delves into what happens to the two men convicted of killing her, John Parker and Kenny Smith. You spend a lot of time in this series explaining, sometimes in graphic detail, how the cruelty of the death penalty isn’t only about the execution, but also about the system around it — the paperwork, the waiting. This is not the kind of subject matter that you typically tackle. What drew you to wanting to report on the death penalty and criminal justice?

MG: I wasn’t initially intending to do a story about the death penalty. I, on a kind of whim, spent a lot of time with Kate Porterfield, who’s the psychologist who studies trauma, who shows up halfway through “The Alabama Murders.”

I was just interviewing her about, because I was interested in the treatment of traumatized people, and she just happened to mention that she’d been involved with the death penalty case — and her description of it was so moving and compelling that I realized, oh, that’s the story I want to tell. But this did not start as a death penalty project. It started as an exploration of a psychologist’s work, and it kind of took a detour.

AL: Tell us a little bit more about how the bureaucracy around the death penalty masks its inherent cruelty.

MG: There’s a wonderful phrase that one of the people we interviewed, Joel Zivot, uses. He talks about how the death penalty — he was talking about lethal injection, but this is also true of nitrogen gas — he said it is the impersonation of a medical act. And I think that phrase speaks volumes, that a lot of what is going on here is a kind of performance that is for the benefit of the viewer. It has to look acceptable to those who are watching, to those who are in society who are judging or observing the process.

It is the management of perception that is compelling and driving the behavior here — not the actual treatment of the condemned prisoner him/herself. And once you understand that, oh, it’s a performance, then a lot of it makes sense.

One of the crucial moments in the story we tell is, where there is a hearing in which the attorneys for Kenny Smith are trying to get a stay of execution, and they start asking the state of Alabama, the corrections people in the state of Alabama to explain, did they understand what they would do? They were contemplating the use of nitrogen gas. Did they ever talk to a doctor about the risks associated with it? Did they ever contemplate any of the potential side effects? And it turns out they had done none of that. And it makes sense when you realize that’s not what they’re interested in.

They’re interested in the impersonation of a medical act, not the implementation of a medical act. The bureaucracy is there to make it look good, and that was one of the compelling lessons of the piece.

AL: And it’s impersonating a medical act with people who are not doctors, right? Like people who are not, do not have this training.

MG: In that hearing, there’s this real incredible moment where one of the attorneys asks the man who heads Alabama’s Department of Corrections, did you ever consult with any medical personnel about the choice of execution method and its possible problems? And the guy says no.

You just realize, they’re just mailing it in. Like they have no — the state of Alabama is not interested in exploring the kind of full implications of what they’re doing. They’re just engaged in this kind of incredibly slapdash operation.

AL: Liliana, I wanna bring you in here. You’ve spent years reporting on capital punishment in the U.S. and looked into many cases in different states. Why are states like Florida and Alabama ramping up the number of executions? Is it all politics? What’s going on there?

LS: That is one of the questions that I think a lot of us who cover this stuff have been asking ourselves all year long. And to some degree, it’s always politics. The story of the death penalty, the story of executions, so often really boils down to that.

We are in a political moment right now where the climate around executions, certainly, but I think in general, the kind of appetite for or promotion of vengeance and brutality toward our enemies is really shockingly real right now. And I was reluctant about a year ago to really trace our current moment to Trump. The death penalty has been a bipartisan project; I don’t want to pretend like this is something that begins and ends with somebody like Trump.

That said, it’s really shocking to see the number of executions that are being pushed through, especially in Florida. And this is something that has been ramped up by Gov. DeSantis for purely political reasons. This death penalty push in Florida began with his political ambitions when he was originally going to run for president. And I think that to some degree is a story behind a lot of death penalty policy, certainly going back decades, and certainly speaks to the moment we’re in.

Related

“Agony” and “Suffering” as Alabama Experiments With Nitrogen Executions

I did want to just also touch on some of what Malcolm was talking about when it comes to the performance of executions themselves. Over the past many years, I’ve reported on litigation, death penalty trials, that have taken place in states like Oklahoma and here in Tennessee where I live, where we restarted executions some years ago after a long time of not carrying any out. And these trials had, at the center, the three-drug protocol that is described so thoroughly in the podcast.

It is absolutely true that these are protocols that are designed with all of these different steps and all of these different parts and made to look — using the tools of medicine to kill — and made to look like this has really been thought through. But when you really trace that history — as you do, Malcolm, in your podcast — there’s no there there.

These were invented for the purpose of having a humane-appearing protocol, a humane-appearing method, and it amounts to junk science. There was no way to test these methods. Nobody can tell us, as you described in your podcast, what it feels like to undergo this execution process. And I think it’s really important to remember that this is not only the story of lethal injection, this is the story of executions writ large.

When the electric chair came on the scene generations ago, it was also touted as the height of technology because it was using electricity and it was supposed to be more humane than hanging. There had been botched hangings that were seen as gruesome ordeals. So there’s this bizarre way in which history repeats itself when it comes to these methods that are promoted as the height of modernity and humanity —and it’s just completely bankrupt and false.

AL: Malcolm, do you want to add something?

MG: Yeah, we have a big focus in the case I’m describing, Kenny Smith, was notorious because he had a botched execution where they couldn’t find a vein. And one of the points that Joel Zivot makes is that, of course, it’s not surprising that they, in that case and in many others, they can’t find a vein because that is a medical procedure that is designed to be undertaken in a hospital setting by trained personnel with the cooperation of the patient. Usually we’d find a vein, and the patient cooperates because we’re trying to save their life or make them healthier. This is a use of this procedure that is completely different. It is outside of a medical institution, not being done by people who are experienced medical professionals, and is not being done with the cooperation of the patient. The patient in this case is a condemned prisoner who is not in the same situation as someone who’s ill and trying to get better.

AL: I want to just walk our listeners through this. So this is, again, one of the pieces of the series, this three-drug protocol. First there’s a sedative, then there’s a paralytic, and then there’s finally potassium chloride, which is supposed to stop the heart. How did that protocol come to be developed?

MG: It was dreamt up in an afternoon in Oklahoma in the 1970s by a state senator and the Oklahoma medical examiner who were just spitballing about how they might replace the electric chair with something “more humane.”

And their model was, well, why don’t we do for humans what we do with horses? Which was a suggestion that had come from Ronald Reagan, then governor of California. So they just generally thought, well, we can do a version of what we do in those instances, only we’ll just ramp up the dose. This is also a kind of anesthesia sometimes.

AL: This is advertised as something that is supposed to be painless.

MG: And these drugs were also in use in the medical setting, but their idea was, we’ll take a protocol that is loosely based on what is used in a medical setting and ramp up the doses so that instead of merely sedating somebody, we’re killing them.

And it wasn’t thought through, tested, analyzed, peer-reviewed. It was literally two guys, dreaming up something on the back of an envelope. And one of the guys, the medical examiner, later regretted his part in the whole procedure, but the genie was out of the bottle. And everybody jumped on this as an advance over the previous iteration of killing technology.

AL: In addition to being advertised as painless, it’s also supposed to be within the bounds of the Eighth Amendment protection against cruel and unusual punishment. Can you tell us about that?

MG: In order to satisfy that prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment, you have to have some insight as to what the condemned prisoner is going through when they are being subjected to this protocol. The universe of people engaged in the capital punishment project were universally indifferent to trying to find out how exactly this worked. They weren’t curious at all to figure out, for example, was there any suffering that was associated with this three-drug protocol, or which of the three drugs is killing you? Or, I could go on and on and on.

They just implemented it and because it looked good from the outside, because you have given someone a sedative and a paralytic, it’s impossible to tell from the outside whether they’re going through any kind of suffering. It was just assumed that there should be no, there must be no suffering going on the inside.

And the Eighth Amendment does not say that people should not be subjected to the appearance of cruel and unusual punishment. It says, no, the actual punishment itself for the individual should not be cruel and unusual. So there was, at no point could anyone, in the early history of this, did anyone truly satisfy the intent of the Eighth Amendment.

AL: Liliana, you’ve written a lot about this protocol as well, and the Supreme Court has taken a stance on it. Tell us about that.

Related

When It Comes to the Death Penalty, the Supreme Court Legalized Torture Long Ago

LS: So one thing that’s really important to understand about the Eighth Amendment and the death penalty in this country is that the U.S. Supreme Court has weighed in on the death penalty numerous times, but has never invalidated a method of execution as violating the Eighth Amendment ban on cruel and unusual punishment. And that fact right there I think speaks volumes.

But one of the cases that I go back to over and over again in my work about lethal injection and about other execution methods, dates back to the 1940s, and it’s a case involving a man named Willie Francis, who was a teenager, a Black teenager who had been condemned to die in Louisiana. They sent him to the electric chair in 1946, and he survived. He survived their initial attempts to execute him. It’s a grotesque ordeal, there’s been a lot written historically about this.

That case, they stopped the execution. He appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court, and a majority of justices found that attempting to kill him again, wouldn’t violate the Eighth Amendment, and they sent him back in 1947, they succeeded in killing him. But the language that comes out of the court in this case really goes a long way to helping us understand how we ended up where we are now. They essentially said, “Accidents happen. Accidents happen for which no man is to blame.” And there’s another turn of phrase that’s really galling in which essentially they call this ordeal that he suffered “an innocent misadventure.” And this language, this idea that this was an innocent misadventure finds its way into subsequent rulings decades later.

So in 2008, I believe it was, the U.S. Supreme Court took up the three-drug protocol, which at the time was being used by Kentucky. This was a case called Baze v. Rees. There was a lot of evidence, there was a lot that the justices had to look at that should have given them pause about the fact that this protocol was not rooted in science. That there had been many botched executions — in terms of the inability to find a vein, in terms of evidence that people were suffering on the gurney.

Related

Chilling Testimony in a Tennessee Trial Exposes Lethal Injection as Court-Sanctioned Torture

The U.S. Supreme Court upheld that protocol, and yet right around the time that they handed down that ruling, states began tinkering with the lethal injection protocol that had been the prevailing method for so long.

Without getting too deep in the weeds, the initial drug — the drug that was supposed to anesthetize people who were being killed by lethal injection — had been originally a drug called sodium thiopental, which was thought to be, believed to be, for good reasons something that could basically put a person under, where they wouldn’t necessarily feel the noxious effects of the subsequent drugs.

States were unable to get their hands on this drug for a number of reasons, and subsequently began swapping out other drugs to replace that drug. And different states tried different things. A number of states eventually settled on this drug called midazolam, which is a sedative, which does not have the same properties as the previous drug — and over and over again, experts have said that this is not a drug that’s going to be effective in providing and anesthetizing people for the purpose of lethal injection.

The Supreme Court once again ruled that this was true. In Oklahoma, this was the case Glossip v. Gross, which the Supreme Court heard after there had been a very high profile really gruesome, botched execution, a man named Clayton Lockett who was executed in 2014. This ended up going up to the Supreme Court. And I covered that oral argument and what was really astonishing about that oral argument wasn’t just how grotesque it all was, but the fact that the justices were very clearly, very annoyed, very cranky about the fact that, only a few years after having upheld this three-drug protocol, now they’re having to deal with this thing again. And again, they upheld this protocol, despite a lot of evidence that this was completely inhumane, that there was a lot of reason to be concerned that people were suffering on the gurney, while being put to death by lethal injection.

And so the reason I go back to the Willie Francis case is that it really tells us everything that we need to know. Which is that if you have decided that people condemned to die in this country are less than human, and that their suffering doesn’t matter, then there’s no limits on what you are willing to tolerate in upholding this death protocol that we’ve invented in this country. And so the Supreme Court has weighed in not only on the three-drug protocol, but on execution methods in general. And they have always found that there’s not really a problem here.

MG: At a certain point, it becomes obvious that the cruelty is the point. The Eighth Amendment does not actually have any kind of impact on their thinking because they are anxious to preserve the very thing about capital punishment that is so morally noxious, which is that it’s cruel.

AL: Malcolm, one interesting thing that you talk about in this series is this concept of judicial override in Alabama, where a judge was able to impose a death sentence even if the jury recommended life in prison. This went on until 2017. As we know, death penalty cases can take decades, so it’s possible that there are still people on death row who have been impacted by judicial override. What’s your sense about how judges who went that route justified their decisions, if at all?

MG: So Alabama was one of a small number of states who, in response to the Supreme Court’s hesitancy about capital punishment in the 1970s, instituted rules which said that a judge can override a jury’s sentencing determination in a capital case.

So if a jury says, “We want life imprisonment without parole,” the judge could impose a death penalty or vice versa. The motivation for these series of override laws — and there are only about three or four states in Florida, Alabama, a couple of others had them — is murky. But I suspect what they wanted to do was to guard against the possibility that juries would become overwhelmingly lenient.

The concern was that if the public sentiment was moving away from death penalty to the extent that it would be difficult to impose a death penalty in capital cases, unless you allowed judges to independently assert their opinion when it came to sentencing. And I also suspect that there’s, in states like Alabama, there was a little bit of a racial motivation that they thought that Black juries would be unlikely to vote for the death penalty for Black defendants, and they wanted to reserve the right to act in those cases.

And what happens in Alabama is that other states gradually abandon this policy, but Alabama sticks to it — not only that, they have the most extreme version of it. They basically allow the judge to overrule under any circumstances without giving an explanation for why.

And when they finally get rid of this, they don’t make it retroactive. So they only say, “Going forward, we’re not going to do override. But we’re not going to spare people who are on death row now because of override — we’re not going to spare their lives.” And so it raises this question about, the reason we call our series “The Alabama Murders” is that when you look very closely at the case we’re interested in, you quickly come to the conclusion there’s something particularly barbaric about the political culture of Alabama. Not news, by the way, for anyone who knows anything about Alabama. But Alabama, it’s its own thing, and they remain to this day clinging to this notion that they need every possible defense against the possibility that a convicted murderer could escape with his life.

AL: Speaking of this idea of the title of the show, I also want to bring up that I did not know that the autopsy in an execution, and I don’t know that this is unique to Alabama, but that it marks the death as a homicide. I was actually shocked to hear that.

MG: Yeah, isn’t that interesting? That is the one moment of honesty and self-awareness in this entire process.

AL: Right, that’s why it’s shocking. It’s not shocking because we know it’s a homicide. It’s shocking because they’re admitting to it in a record that is accessible to the public at some point.

[Break]

AL: Malcolm, you mentioned the racial dynamic with Alabama in particular, but Liliana, I want to ask if you could maybe speak to the historic link between the development of the death penalty and the history of lynching in the South.

LS: So it’s really interesting. Alabama is, in many ways, the poster child for this line that can be drawn between not only lynching, but slavery to lynching, to Reconstruction, to state-sanctioned murder. And that’s an uneasy line to draw in the sense of — there’s a reason that Bryan Stevenson, who is the head of the Equal Justice Initiative, has called the death penalty the “stepchild of lynching.”

Related

Alabama’s Lynching Memorial and the Legacy of Racial Terror in the South

He calls it the stepchild of lynching and it’s because, there’s something of an indirect link, but it’s an absolutely — that link is real. And you really see it in Alabama and certainly in the South. I think it was in 2018, I went down to Montgomery a number of times for the opening of EJI’s lynching memorial that they had launched there and this was a major event. At the time I went with this link in mind to try to interrogate and understand this history a little bit better. And I ended up writing this big long piece, which I only recently went back to reread because it’s not fresh in my mind anymore.

But one of the things that is absolutely, undoubtedly true is that the death penalty in the South in its early days was justified using the exact same rationale that people used for lynching, which was that this was about protecting white women from sexually predatory Black men.

And that line, that consistent feature of executions — whether it was an extrajudicial lynching or an execution carried out by the state — has been really consistent and I think overlooked in the history of the death penalty. And part of the reason it’s overlooked is that, again, going back to the Supreme Court, there have been a number of times that this history has come before the Supreme Court and other courts, and by and large, the reaction has been to look away, to deny this.

That is absolutely true in the years leading up to the 1972 case, Furman v. Georgia, which Malcolm alluded to earlier, there was this moment where the Supreme Court had to pause executions. And this was a four-year period in the ’70s. 1972 was Furman v. Georgia. 1976 was Gregg v. Georgia. Part of the reason that Furman, which was this 1972 case, invalidated the death penalty across the country, was because there was evidence that executions, that death sentences were being handed down in what they called an arbitrary way.

And in reality, it wasn’t so much arbitrariness, as very clear evidence of sentences that were being given disproportionately to people of color, to Black people, and history showed that that was largely motivated by cases in which a victim was white. It was a white woman maybe who had been subjected to sexual violence. There is that link, and I think it’s really important to remember that.

In Alabama, one of the really interesting things too, going back to judicial override, there’s this kind of irony in the history of judicial override in the way that it was carried out by judges. Alabama, when they restarted the death penalty in the early ’80s, was getting a lot of flack for essentially having a racist death penalty system. Of course, there was a lot of defensiveness around this, and there were judges who, actually, in cases where juries did not come back with a death sentence for a white defendant, there were cases where judges then overrode that decision in a sort of display of fairness.

One of the things that I found when I was researching my piece from 2018 was that there was a judge in, I believe it was 1999, who explained why he overrode the jury in sentencing this particular white man to die. And he said, “If I had not imposed the death sentence, I would’ve sentenced three Black people to death and no white people.” So this was his way of ensuring fairness. “Well, I’ve gotta override it here,” never mind what it might say about the jury in the decision not to hand down a death sentence for a white person.

Again, it goes back to appearance. They needed the appearance of fairness. And so Alabama really does typify a certain kind of racial dynamic and early history of the death penalty that you see throughout the South, not just the South, but especially in the South.

AL: One of the things proponents of the death penalty are adamant about is that it requires some element of secrecy to survive.

Executions happen behind closed walls, in small rooms, late at night. The people involved never have their identities publicly revealed or their credentials. The concern being that if people really knew what was involved, there would be a massive public outcry. Malcolm, in this series you describe in gruesome detail what is actually involved in an execution. For folks who haven’t heard the series, tell us about that.

MG: In Alabama, there is a long execution protocol. A written script, which was made public only because it came out during a lawsuit, which kind of lays out all the steps that the state takes. And Alabama also has, to your point, an unusual level of secrecy.

For example, in many states, the entire execution process is open, at least to witnesses. In Alabama, you only see the person after they’ve found a vein. So the Kenny Smith case, we were talking about where they spent hours unsuccessfully trying to find a vein — that was all done behind closed doors.

Related

In Alabama, Officers Accused of Violence and Misconduct Carry Out Secretive Executions

And the second thing that you pointed out is the people who are involved remain anonymous, and you can understand why. It is an acknowledgment on the part of these states that they are engaged in something shameful. If they were as morally clearheaded as they claim to be, then what would be the problem with making every aspect of the process public?

But instead, they go in the opposite direction and they try and shroud it. They make it as much of a mystery as they can. And it’s funny, so much of our knowledge about death penalty procedures only comes out because of lawsuits.

It is only under the compulsion of the judicial process that we learn even the smallest tidbit about what’s going on or what kind of thought went into a particular procedure. When we’re talking about the state taking the life of a citizen of the United States, that’s weird, right?

We have more transparency over the most prosaic aspects of government practice than we do about something that involves something as important as taking someone’s life.

AL: Liliana, you’ve witnessed two executions. Tell us about your experience, and particularly this aspect of secrecy surrounding the process.

LS: Let me just pick up first on the secrecy piece because one of the really bizarre aspects of the death penalty, when you’ve covered it in different states and looked at the federal system as well, is that there’s just this wide range when it comes to what states and jurisdictions are willing to reveal and show.

What they are not willing to reveal is certainly the individuals involved. A ton of states have or death penalty states have passed secrecy legislation essentially bringing all of that information even further behind closed doors. The identity of the executioners was always sort of a secret. But now we don’t get to know where they get the drugs, and in some states, in some places, the secrecy is really shocking. I just wrote a story about Indiana, which recently restarted executions. And Indiana is the only active death penalty state that does not allow any media witnesses. There is nothing, and that’s exceptional.

And if you go out and try as a journalist to cover an execution in Indiana, it’s not going to be like in Alabama or in Oklahoma, where the head of the DOC comes out and addresses things and says, whether true or not true, “Everything went great.” No, you are in a parking lot at midnight across from the prison. There is absolutely nobody coming to tell you what happened. It’s a ludicrous display of indifference and contempt, frankly, for the press or for the public that has a right and an interest in knowing what’s happening in their names. So secrecy — there’s a range, I guess is my point, and yes, most places err on the side of not revealing anything, but some take that a lot further than others.

In terms of the experience of witnessing an execution, that’s obviously a big question. I will say that both those executions were in Oklahoma. That is a state that has a really ugly sordid history of botched executions going back longer than 10 years.

But Oklahoma became infamous on the world stage about 10 years ago, a little more, for botching a series of executions. I’ve been covering the case of Richard Glossip for a while. Richard Glossip is a man with a long-standing innocence claim whose death sentence and conviction was overturned only this year. Richard Glossip was almost put to death by the state of Oklahoma in 2015, and I was outside the prison that day. And it’s only because they had the wrong drug on hand that it did not go through.

And so going into a situation where I was preparing to witness an execution in Oklahoma, I was all too keenly aware of the possibility that something could go wrong — and that’s just something you know when you’re covering this stuff. And instead, Oklahoma carried out the three-drug protocol execution of a man named Anthony Sanchez in September of 2023. I had written about Anthony’s case. I had spoken to him the day before and for the better part of a year. And I think I’m still trying to understand what I saw that day because, by all appearances, things looked like they went as smoothly as one would hope, right?

He was covered with a sheet. You saw the color in his face change. He went still. And as a journalist or just an ordinary person trying to describe what that meant, what I was seeing — I couldn’t really tell you, because the process by design was made to look that way, but I could not possibly guess as to what he was experiencing.

Again, that’s because lethal injection and that three-drug protocol has been designed to make it look humane and make it look like everything’s gone smoothly.

I will say one thing that has really stuck with me about that execution was that I was sitting right behind the attorney general of Oklahoma, Gentner Drummond, who has attended — I think to his credit, frankly — every execution that has been carried out in Oklahoma under his tenure. And he was sitting in front of me and a member of the one witness who was there, who, I believe, was a member of Anthony’s family was sitting one seat over. After the execution was over, she was quietly weeping, and Gentner Drummond, the attorney general who was responsible for this execution, put his hand on her and said, “I’m sorry for your loss.” And it was this really bizarre moment because he was acknowledging that this was a loss, that this death of this person that she clearly cared about — he was responsible for it.

And I don’t know that he has ever said something like that since, because a lot of us journalists in the room reported back. And it’s almost like, you’re not supposed to say that — there shouldn’t be sorrow here, really. This is justice. This is what’s being done in our name. And I’m still trying to figure out how I feel about that. Because by and large in the executions I’ve reported on, you don’t have the attorney general himself or the prosecutor who sent this person to death row attending the execution. It’s out of sight, out of mind.

AL: Malcolm, as we’ve talked about and has been repeatedly documented, the way that the death penalty has been applied has been racist and classist, disproportionately affecting Black and Latino people and poor people. It has also historically penalized people who have mental health issues or intellectual disabilities. Even with all that evidence, why does this persist? How has vengeance become such a core part of the American justice system?

MG: As I spoke before, I think what’s happened is that the people who are opposed to death penalty are having a different conversation than the people who are in favor of it.

Related

A Push to Repeal the Death Penalty Gains Ground Across the Western United States

The people who are in favor are trying to make a kind of moral statement about society’s ultimate intolerance of people who violate certain kinds of norms, and they are in the pursuit of that kind of moral statement, willing to go to almost any lengths. And on the other side are people who are saying that going this far is outside of the moral boundaries of a civilized state.

Those are two very different claims that proceed on very different assumptions. And we’re talking past each other. It doesn’t matter to those who are making a broad moral statement about society’s intolerance what this condition, status, background, makeup of the convicted criminal is — because they’re not basing their decision on the humanity of the defendant, the criminal defendant. They’re making a broad moral point.

I’ve often wondered whether in doing series, as I did, that focus so heavily on the details of an execution, I’m contributing to the problem. That if opponents make it all about the individual circumstances of the defendant, the details of the case, was the person guilty or not, was the kind of punishment cruel and unusual — we’re kind of buying into the moral error here.

Because we’re opening the possibility that if all we were doing was executing people who were 100% guilty and if our method of execution was proven without a shadow of a doubt to be “humane,” then we don’t have a case anymore.

AL: Right, then it’d be fine.

MG: So I look at what I’ve done — that’s my one reservation about spending all this time on the Kenny Smith case, is that we shouldn’t have to do this. It should be enough to say that even the worst person in the world does not deserve to be murdered by a state.

That’s not what states do, right, in a civilized society. That one sentence ought to be enough. And it’s a symptom of how distorted this argument has become — that it’s not enough.

AL: Liliana, I want to briefly get your thoughts on this too.

LS: I think that people who are opposed to death penalty and abolitionists oftentimes say, “This is a broken system.” And we talk about prisons in that way; “this is a broken system.”

I think it’s a mistake to say that this is a broken system because I don’t think that this system, at its best, as you’ve just discussed, would be fine if it only worked correctly. I think that that’s absolutely not the case. So I do agree that, this system — I don’t hide the fact that I’m very opposed to the death penalty. I don’t think that you can design it and improve it and make it fair and make it just.

I also think that part of the reason that people have a hard time saying that is: If you were to say that about the death penalty in this country, for all of the reasons that may be true, then you would be forced to deal with the criminal justice system more broadly, and with prisons and sentencing as a whole. And I think that there’s a real reluctance to see the problems that we see in death penalty cases in that broader context, because what does that mean for this country, if you’re calling into question on mass incarceration and in the purpose that these sentences serve.?

AL: We’ve covered a lot here. I want to thank you both for joining me on the Intercept Briefing.

MG: Thank you so much.

LS: Thank you.

The post Lethal Illusion: Understanding the Death Penalty Apparatus appeared first on The Intercept.

Seventy years after the Montgomery bus boycott, policies hiding in plain sight continue to ravage the Black community

Friday is the 70th anniversary of the Montgomery bus boycott, which began because Rosa Parks refused to relinquish her seat to a white person, as required by law. While her brave act brought national attention to the civil rights movement and triggered student sit-ins to end segregation across the south, it also subjected her and her husband, Raymond, to constant death threats. Consequently, like many other Black families fleeing Jim Crow south’s racial violence, in August 1957, Rosa and Raymond moved up north to Detroit.

When the Parks arrived in Detroit, they and other Black people did not have to sit at the back of the bus. Nonetheless, the city was permeated by a quieter but no less pernicious type of racism: racist policies, which are any written or unwritten laws and processes that produce or sustain racial inequity. In my book Plundered: How Racist Policies Undermine Black Homeownership in America, I demonstrate how racial covenants, redlining, urban renewal, blockbusting, predatory mortgage lending and racialized property tax administration have stymied the Black community.

Bernadette Atuahene is the Duggan professor at the University of Southern California Gould School of Law, the executive director of the Institute for Law and Organizing, and the author of Plundered: How Racist Policies Undermine Black Homeownership in America

The state is launching a three-year pilot program offering $500 a month to homeless students who maintain high attendance and fulfill other requirements.

CEO Elon Musk says lower-cost electric car will reignite demand by appealing to broader range of buyers

• Business live – latest updates

Tesla has launched the lower-priced version of its Model 3 car in Europe in a push to revive sales after a backlash against Elon Musk’s work with Donald Trump and weakening demand for electric vehicles.

Musk, the electric car maker’s chief executive, has argued that the cheaper option, launched in the US in October, will reinvigorate demand by appealing to a wider range of buyers.

Iraq 2025 election: Reform candidates pushed out by a system that rejects change Expert comment LToremark 5 December 2025

Hopes that reform of Iraq’s political system would be possible from within have been dashed by the poor electoral performance of candidates associated with the Tishreen protest movement.

In Iraq’s 11 November election, parties and figures associated with the Tishreen protest movement failed to win seats in parliament. The Tishreen movement emerged in 2019, demanding reform of Iraq’s political system. Dozens of civic and reform-oriented MPs subsequently entered parliament after the 2021 election, raising hopes that they could press for reform from within the political system. 

These hopes have been dashed by the results of the 2025 election. An uneven political playing field and sustained pressure on non-establishment MPs have pushed Tishreen-aligned actors back to the margins of formal politics.

Parliament turned against its newcomers

Related work

Iraq’s new MPs must unite to achieve genuine change

After the 2021 election, many of the new, non-establishment MPs faced a mix of pressure, inducements and procedural obstacles that made it hard for them to work. Some were even targeted directly. MPs from the Imtidad party –  a product of the Tishreen movement –  were physically pushed out of a parliamentary session in 2023 after refusing to vote for changes to the electoral law, while the office of independent MP Sajad Salim was attacked after he criticized armed groups. Salim was also disqualified twice in the run-up to the 2025 election and had to file repeated legal appeals to return to the race. Such incidents send a clear message about the vulnerability of non-aligned MPs within Iraq’s political system.

Furthermore, MPs who refused to join large blocs were sidelined from influential committees, while established parties sought to buy them off with promises of positions, protection or access to resources. A number of MPs who had campaigned as independents or protest voices eventually joined establishment parties. Speaking at Chatham House event, former MP Mohammed Anouz said Iraq’s political system is highly resistant to reform because political elites continue to dominate both the political process and parliamentary structures, excluding those who are not part of the system. 

Electoral collapse 

Related work

Iraq elections 2025: How votes are won and what the results could mean for Iraq’s fragile stability

By the time the 2025 campaign began, these structural pressures had taken their toll. Alaa al Rikabi, the former head of Imtidad, chose not to run again and publicly apologized to those who had backed him in 2021. Imtidad did not compete in these elections and its MPs were absorbed into other blocs – with predictably disappointing results. In 2021, Imtidad candidates received around 236,000 votes nationwide and secured 16 seats in parliament. 11 of those MPs ran again in 2025 and together received just over 20,000 votes. Preliminary results indicate that only one of them will return to parliament – although this time representing a different party. 

Candidates who tried to distance themselves from the major blocs remained fragmented, under-resourced and struggled to persuade voters that another term would be any different. Instead of running on a single platform, they split across three different alliances – one of which was co-led by Salim – and their struggle was reflected in the results. Salim himself went from over 10,000 votes in 2021 to about 3,000 and lost his seat. 

An uneven playing field

The difficulties faced by non-establishment MPs were compounded by an electoral environment that overwhelmingly favours parties already embedded in the state. Between 2022 and 2025, establishment parties used state resources to strengthen their position and limit the space available to civic actors. Control of ministries and provincial councils allowed them to distribute jobs, contracts and local projects to loyal networks.

The Political Parties Law of 2015, which bans parties from having armed wings and requires transparency in party financing, has remained largely dormant. Without serious enforcement of its core provisions, parties that combine access to state budgets and armed groups face few consequences, while groups that do not rely on coercion or public funds start each electoral race with a structural disadvantage.

Beyond the ballot box

The fact that Tishreen-linked parties have all but disappeared from parliament does not mean that Iraqis have accepted the political order. In many of the Shia majority cities where the 2019 protests took place, voter turnout was among the lowest in the country. This pattern suggests many former protesters chose to step back from an electoral process they no longer see as a vehicle for change.

There were so many details in the women’s reports to law enforcement that were hard for me to read. That they were just little girls when it happened. That a man many knew as the “fun uncle” had touched them sexually under their skirts and tops. And that it happened in church or while swimming at the lake or during games of hide-and-seek. They were as young as 5 years old, according to the police reports. Some could even remember what they were wearing when it happened: a fluffy multicolored skirt; a pair of jeans with purple flowers on them.

But by the time my co-reporter from the Minnesota Star Tribune, Andy Mannix, and I got those accounts — spanning from the early 1990s to the 2010s — the girls’ abuser, Clint Massie, had already pleaded guilty to four counts of felony sexual conduct with victims under 13. In March of this year, he began a 7 1/2 year prison sentence. Arguably, the case was over.

But we kept hearing from the victims and alleged victims, former church members, investigators and prosecutors that the outcome had fallen far short of true accountability. Massie, they told us, was a symptom of a much larger problem within the Old Apostolic Lutheran Church, or OALC, which he and his victims attended. They told us the leaders of this little-known faith tradition pressured victims to forgive Massie, then to forget about the abuse and never speak of it again. In some cases, these “forgiveness sessions” took place between the children and Massie; one girl described the terror she felt being hugged by Massie as her father and a preacher looked on.

These sessions allowed Massie to evade arrest and prosecution for years. Even after the victims came forward to law enforcement as adults, attempts to silence them continued, according to the prosecutor who charged the case.

“This was like a fucking machine,” said assistant St. Louis County attorney Mike Ryan, “that was basically trying to roll over these girls.”

That sentiment hit me especially hard the day I received a roughly 40-minute video of an interview between sheriff’s detectives in St. Louis County, where Duluth is located, and two OALC preachers. My attention was on Daryl Bruckelmyer, a preacher and leader of the church in Duluth; several of Massie’s victims claimed that either they or their parents had disclosed the abuse to Bruckelmyer, but that he did little beyond a forgiveness session.

We had hoped to sit down with Bruckelmyer and ask him about his involvement with the Massie case, but also about his church, its beliefs and its customs. But he declined to comment or to answer a detailed list of questions. A spokesperson for the Woodland Park OALC in Duluth also said in a statement that the church “has fully complied with the law in the referenced case, and it’s a matter of legal record.” He declined to comment further. Massie also did not respond to requests for comment.

So the video was the first and only time I heard Bruckelmyer explain himself in his own words. Here’s what stood out to me as I watched the recording and what helped me understand the mechanisms that allowed repeated sexual abuse to continue as an open secret.

Massie’s Preacher Knew of the Abuse

I had wondered if Bruckelmyer might deny ever hearing about Massie’s abuse. But he did not.

“How many female victims do you think have come forward and said something to you?” Sgt. Adam Kleffman, the lead investigator, asked.

“There’s only been a few,” Bruckelmyer responded. “One, two, three.”

It’s not every day you see a recording of someone admitting that they knew about the abuse of children yet did little about it.

Bruckelmyer implied that he misunderstood mandated reporter laws in Minnesota (though another detective explained the law to him just three years earlier) and that he had “warned” Massie to stay away from children. He insisted that they made no attempt to “hide” Massie and encouraged victims to go to law enforcement.

But the words he chose stood out to me as well: “We don’t protect either one.”

Kimberly Lowe, a lawyer and crisis manager for the church, said its preachers are unpaid and therefore might not be legally required to report sexual abuse of children. Asked if she believes the preachers are mandated reporters under Minnesota law, Lowe would only say that the language of the statute is unclear.

Church Policies Did Not Align With Minnesota Law

At one point, Bruckelmyer pulled out two sheets of paper and passed them across the table to the investigators. It was a list of “tools to help prevent violence, harassment and sexual abuse from occurring,” issued by the Old Apostolic Lutheran Church of America.

“We have guidelines in the church that we are told and instructed as a protection for both,” Bruckelmyer explained.

Many of the guidelines made sense: education, counseling for victims and so forth. But when I obtained a copy of the document, I zeroed in on the part of the policy that seemed to describe a forgiveness session: “When harm has taken place: Individual conversations with the victim … If possible, individual conversations with the abuser. Later, but only if appropriate, a conversation with both parties together.”

The document did not mention mandatory reporting laws and instead seemed to give preachers wide latitude on whether to involve law enforcement.

As soon as I watched that document slide across the table, it was clear to me that this issue went beyond Minnesota. The OALC has 33 locations spread across the U.S. and Canada. In our months of reporting, we spoke to over a dozen alleged victims, some of whom named other church members as possible perpetrators in Delaware, Michigan, Wyoming, Washington state and South Dakota.

We plan to continue this reporting.

An Intentional Isolation From the Modern World

At one point in the video, Kleffman asked Bruckelmyer if he was aware of how sexual abuse scandals have played out in other churches — specifically, he said, that once one victim comes forward, it’s common for more victims to speak out as well. He cited a recent, local example: the conviction of a youth pastor from Vineyard Church in Duluth for felony sexual conduct with underage parishioners.

But Bruckelmyer said he was unfamiliar with the case.

I was struck by the lack of understanding that some church leaders and members demonstrated when it came to the impact of sexual assault on children, as well as an ignorance of other, similar sexual abuse scandals. But it seemed to go hand in hand with the ways that OALC members cut themselves off from certain aspects of modern life.

Former members told us that dancing, music, movies and television are all considered sinful. One former church member told my reporting partner that, as a child, she overheard a Taylor Swift song and was desperate to find another church member to confess to or risk going to hell.

We attended a Sunday service in Duluth, at the invitation of a spokesperson for the church, and were provided with literature that described some of the OALC’s history and philosophy.

“We Christians want to follow Jesus’ example and live a life that is simple and modest, whether it be our dress, our home or our way of life,” the booklet reads. “We do not believe it is right, nor do we have a need, to engage in worldly pleasures, alcohol and other drugs. The friendship we have in the church is so much more.”

Bruckelmyer was on the dais with the other preachers but would not come speak with us. So I tried to take in what I could: the hymns sung without accompaniment, the scarves on women’s heads and the toys in children’s hands.

During the three-hour service, I sat in a pew, fascinated by this small glimpse into a faith tradition and a lifestyle that I previously knew nothing about. Watching these families, particularly the young mothers with daughters in their arms, I couldn’t help thinking again about what we’d read in those police reports — in particular, the allegations that this sexual abuse has affected multiple generations of families. What these women and girls went through, not just the abuse but the silence that followed, shocks the conscience. We wrote this story to break that silence. Maybe it could prevent this from happening again.

The post What a Recorded Interview Between Police and Preachers Reveals About How a Minnesota Church Handled Sexual Abuse appeared first on ProPublica.

Snowfall moves south-east over Wyoming and Colorado and combines with dense fog in some areas

A cold spell continued to grip parts of the US this week. After a winter storm brought 20-30cm of snow across Wisconsin, and even up to 35cm in places last weekend, the focus of the winter weather hazards shifted elsewhere early this week.

A storm system moving south-east over Wyoming and Colorado brought a continuous period of snowfall until Thursday morning. Central Colorado and northern New Mexico bore the brunt of the snowfall with accumulations reaching 30cm in places. The heavy snowfall across the Denver region was its first of the winter and caused widespread disruption to flights into and out of Denver on Wednesday and Thursday. Almost 1,000 flights were delayed or cancelled as a result of the treacherous conditions.

NASA and CNES's SWOT satellite captured the first high-resolution, wide-swath image of a major tsunami in the open ocean after the July 2025 Kuril-Kamchatka quake. "Instead of a single neat crest racing across the basin, the image revealed a complicated, braided pattern of energy dispersing and scattering over hundreds of miles," reports Earth.com. "These are details that traditional instruments almost never resolve. They suggest the physics we use to forecast tsunami hazards -- especially the assumption that the largest ocean-crossing waves travel as largely "non-dispersive" packets -- need a revision." From the report: Three takeaways emerge. First, high-resolution satellite altimetry can see the internal structure of a tsunami in mid-ocean, not just its presence. Second, researchers now argue that dispersion -- often downplayed for great events -- may shape how energy spreads into leading and trailing waves, which could alter run-up timing and the force on harbor structures. Third, combining satellite swaths, DART time series, seismic records, and geodetic deformation gives a more faithful picture of the source and its evolution along strike. For tsunami modelers and hazard planners, the message is equal parts caution and opportunity. The physics now has to catch up with the complexity that SWOT has revealed, and planners need forecasting systems that can merge every available data stream. The waves won't get any simpler -- but our predictions can get a lot sharper. The findings have been published in the journal The Seismic Record.

Read more of this story at Slashdot.

Ever since the club’s very beginning, David Beckham and Jorge Mas have had moments like this Saturday in mind

Back on 27 February 2020, days before Inter Miami’s first-ever fixture in MLS, I stood next to the club’s managing owner, Jorge Mas, and co-owner David Beckham as part of an MLS press junket in New York City. I was there for Sports Illustrated and my show Planet Fútbol TV, which I co-hosted with my friend, the late, great Grant Wahl. We were adamant that the Inter Miami story was riveting, not just because of Beckham’s influence in MLS, but also because his new club was about to introduce the unique culture of Miami and south Florida – the Latin American capital of the world – to the league.

The conversation in 2020 was my second meeting with Mas and my first with Beckham. I remember the sense of excitement from both men, knowing that this Inter Miami project – seven years in the making before their debut in the league – was about to come to fruition after a long, arduous journey. From legal battles with Internazionale over the trademark of the word “Inter” to political and structural problems as they tried to make a stadium, Miami Freedom Park, a reality. Now, the club was finally starting life in MLS.

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has been one of the most vociferous defenders of President Donald Trump’s expansive use of executive authority, withholding billions of dollars in federal funding to states and dismissing protests of the White House’s boundary-pushing behavior as the gripings of “disenfranchised Democrats.”

But court documents reviewed by ProPublica show that a decade ago, as a House member, Duffy took a drastically different position on presidential power, articulating a full-throated defense of Congress’ role as a check on the president — one that resembled the very arguments made by speakers at recent anti-Trump “No Kings” rallies around the country.

In an assertive, thoroughly researched 2015 legal brief, Duffy, then a Republican representative from Wisconsin, detailed the history of America’s creation in reaction to the absolute power of the English crown, invoking the Magna Carta and the Founding Fathers as he made the case for the separation of powers.

“Just as Congress may not bestow upon the President Congress’s own exclusive power to make, or to repeal, federal law,” Duffy argued, citing a 1998 court decision, “it may not bestow upon the Executive its own exclusive power of the purse.”

The brief went on to cite James Madison’s account of the Constitutional Convention, where there was “unanimous agreement that Congress, not the President, should control the purse.”

At the time, Duffy filed the friend-of-the-court brief in support of a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of how the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau gets funded. Duffy, who chaired the House Financial Services Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, maintained that the agency’s unique funding system — its dollars come directly from the Federal Reserve System rather than by a congressional appropriation — improperly bypassed lawmakers’ authority.

The 39-page brief was filed under Duffy’s name along with a nonprofit group aligned with the Republican legal activist Leonard Leo and submitted by a preeminent conservative lawyer. Today, it stands in stark contrast to Duffy’s own actions as transportation secretary in the first year of Trump’s second stint in the White House. Indeed, his attempts to restrict congressionally appropriated transportation funding across all 50 states this year have been condemned by a congressional watchdog and federal judges, resulting in stinging public rebukes from the other branches of government that echo his own 2015 position.

Peter Levine, a civics expert at Tufts University, said that while it could be that Duffy’s views on presidential power have evolved over time, his apparent flip-flopping on something as fundamental as the meaning of the Constitution raises the prospect that Duffy may “just be playing a game for power.”

“The Constitution is a promise to continue to apply the same rules and norms over time to everybody,” he added. “When political actors completely ignore that, and just go after their own thing, I don’t think the Constitution can actually function.”

In response to questions, a Department of Transportation spokesperson asked for a copy of Duffy’s brief. But after ProPublica provided it, the spokesperson stopped responding. A message sent to a number listed for Duffy hasn’t been returned.

The expansion of executive power has been a hallmark of Trump’s second administration. The president issued a whopping 214 executive orders between Jan. 20 and Nov. 20, according to the The American Presidency Project at the University of California, Santa Barbara. In both “number and ambition,” the orders and resulting actions are “exceeded on these dimensions in the last century only by Franklin D. Roosevelt,” one Harvard Law School professor recently noted.

Duffy has cited some of those directives as he has withheld congressionally approved transportation funds. And administration officials have defended doing so, claiming that a post-Watergate law asserting Congress’ power over spending improperly restrains the president’s authority.

But a congressional watchdog and the courts have taken issue with that expansive interpretation of federal authority.

For Duffy, the first instance came in May, when the Government Accountability Office, a nonpartisan arm of Congress, concluded that the DOT had violated the law when it halted payments in February from a $5 billion fund for electric car charging stations that Congress approved under former President Joe Biden’s bipartisan infrastructure law.

“The Constitution specifically vests Congress with the power of the purse,” the congressional watchdog wrote, arguing that the payments should resume. “The Constitution grants the President no unilateral authority to withhold funds from obligation.”

A White House spokesperson called the GAO’s opinion “incorrect” when it was issued and argued that the DOT was “appropriately using” its authority.

In June, a federal judge in Washington ordered transportation officials to lift the pause after a handful of states sued Duffy and the DOT, writing that when the executive branch “treads upon the will of the Legislative Branch,” it’s up to the court “to remediate the situation and restore the balance of power.”

The government has moved to dismiss the lawsuit, writing that it had revamped the grant application process for the charging station money and also that the states’ constitutional concerns were unfounded, since another part of the Constitution “vests the President with broad, discretionary authority to ‘take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed.’” The suit is ongoing.

Separately, a federal judge last month sided with states that had challenged an attempt by Duffy to condition billions of dollars more in federal funds for highway maintenance and other core transportation functions in exchange for helping the administration detain immigrants.

“Should Congress have wished, it could have attempted to entice State cooperation with federal civil immigration enforcement through lawful means, and it could have sought to empower federal agencies to assist it in doing so,” John McConnell Jr., the chief judge of the U.S. District Court in Rhode Island, wrote in a Nov. 4 decision blocking Duffy’s actions.

But it didn’t, he said, and instead administration officials had “transgressed well-settled constitutional limitations on federal funding conditions.”

“The Constitution demands the Court set aside this lawless behavior,” he wrote.

The lawsuits are among hundreds of legal actions this year challenging the constitutionality of the White House’s various actions, including its attempts to halt the disbursement of hundreds of billions of dollars in government spending that Congress had previously approved.

As for the legal challenge Duffy supported in 2015, it was ultimately unsuccessful and the Supreme Court last year affirmed the constitutionality of the CFPB’s funding mechanism.

Yet the ruling has not insulated the bureau from the Trump administration, and officials have advanced novel legal theories to achieve what Duffy sought a decade ago. The administration now argues that since the Fed operates at a loss, it has no profits to transfer to the CFPB.

As a result, the bureau is being starved. According to a recent court filing by government lawyers, it will run out of operating funds by early next year.

The post Trump’s Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy Once Defended Congress’ Power of the Purse. Now He Defies It. appeared first on ProPublica.